Rate That Signature!

[Dist]

Originally Posted by TUndead

lv23 - pretty nice avatar but there is nothing much to say about avatars 9/10

lualdi - nice background and the cutting of the char is good and if it was made and not just a pic from an anime then 9.5/10

It's not a picture from anime. That's a crop of the official artwork on Marta Lualdi. Lualdi herself is a character from Tales of Symphonia game on Wii. No clue on backround or whatsoever since I stole this from another forum lol >.<

5/10 For you. Sorry, I don't like skeletons :P. Brook is an exception.

Edit : Now that I read what Malin said...And reading your message again.. Not quite sure if you rated my avatar instead ? And for your information, my avatar is hand drawn fan art, not a picture from anime.

[Rikimtasu]

Tried to tweak a bit of my sig,hence v2 i guess?
@Issac 9/10

[Yumi Chan]

Lv23-It is awesome! 9/10!

[ganbaru]

lv23 9.5/10 very impressive
Rikimtasu 8.2/10 it's improuved
issac 8/10 interesting

[Yumi Chan]

Risa chan 8/10 i see other faces in the backround as well as the other one's

[Drake]

Yuki Kyonko Cute image and nice subtle colours tho imo it could do with a boarder 7/10

[OutSmart]

I love your sig drake! ^^ 9/10

[Nikusu]

Drake - I really love your signature. It's creative, the text is suiting, and the render is awesome. 9.5/10

OutSmart - You always have pretty wonderful signatures with this being no exception. The transparent border is nice and I love the vibrant colors. I like the font for the text, but the layer setting (overlay?) throws a strange green into the equation. Still a solid 9.0/10.

[Rikimtasu]

@lv23 8.9/10
@OutSmart 8.5/10
@Yumi Chan 8.7/10
No repeating rating i guess.

[Spectacular_Insanity]

Issac: Pure win. Kamina forever. 10/10

[Katocchi]

Laice-san - 10/10 I like the Idea of Your Sig ..
Rikimtasu - 8/10 much better without white gradient ..

[TheZap]

Katocchi,8.5/10, The red text sticks out...

[ganbaru]

lv23 8.5/10 interesting but the actual picture is too small. There's not much to see.

@ It's my version 2. I can't deal with the quality issue yet ( Microsoft Paint compress not enough the png format, so I am stuck to jpeg) but I changed the fond of the text , made a larger border ( 2 pixels insted of only 1), and the image is less streched.

[Dist]

- TheZap. Eww.. Gorillaz :<. I don't like it, sorry. 3/10

- Ganbaru. How about post the original version of PNG or whatever it is, and see if me or anyone else can compress it better ?

[TheZap]

Originally Posted by Lualdi

- TheZap. Eww.. Gorillaz :<. I don't like it, sorry. 3/10

- Ganbaru. How about post the original version of PNG or whatever it is, and see if me or anyone else can compress it better ?

ARE YOU GOING TO SAY EW TO EVERYTHING I LIKE AND RATE IT LOW ALL BECAUSE YOU HATE WHERE IT CAME FROM!?
btw. when are you going to change yours..... 5/10

[Dist]

No, I said Eww and voted it low because I do not like Gorillaz, the art desih, the signature itself, or the backround. Or am I supposed to vote it high just because everyone else votes everything anyone has high ?

For my signature, how about... No ? I just changed my forum name and I like to have forum name corresponding to my signature. Sorry to say, there aren't that much of anything about Lualdi since it's a game character.

... I hope you will read this before it gets deleted due not having a rating.

[Mon Cheri]

How can you not like Gorillaz?
They're awesome! Haha. Everyone has their own taste, i guess

Lualdi: Looks good 8/10

[TheZap]

Originally Posted by Lualdi

No, I said Eww and voted it low because I do not like Gorillaz, the art desih, the signature itself, or the backround. Or am I supposed to vote it high just because everyone else votes everything anyone has high ?

For my signature, how about... No ? I just changed my forum name and I like to have forum name corresponding to my signature. Sorry to say, there aren't that much of anything about Lualdi since it's a game character.

... I hope you will read this before it gets deleted due not having a rating.

Ur just saying that because its the Gorillaz, I bet if it wasnt the Gorillaz you would of said something else
-------------------------------
Malin 8/10, nice

[Nikusu]

Now now. Let's get along. Lualdi, I believe you have your right to an opinion, but please don't dismiss a whole signature just because it's not something you favor. Also, besides your post without a rating you also gave negative remarks without one piece of constructive criticism. "Eww" doesn't count. And Zap, don't fight back. Malin and I still think it's a wonderful signature.

Zap - I'll go with an 8.7. The render is nice and while I like the border I personally think it stands out a little strong. Overall I think it's a great abstract signature.

Malin - 8.9 You and your quick siggies! You really know how to mass produce while still keeping quality. For this signature I'd say the composition and text are the strong points (way to do another D.gray-man siggy!). For a little bit of criticism I'd say that maybe the splatter should be smudged a little bit for the group that is around her. Did you use a star brush? Very nice finish. Black and despair really does suit her. lol

Lualdi - 8.8 I like the detail. I like the text. I love the render. It's a little on the simplistic side, but it still looks wonderful. By the way, you forgot to erase a little bit on the bottom. Try searching Danbooru or Akibakko for more Tales pictures. That's one of the most popular JRPG's... Ever. There's bound to be enough art if you keep searching.

No fighting plx plx.

[TheZap]

Laice, hmmm, 8.5/10
--------------------------
I give my sig a 3/10
I never did grunge for a while so I decided to make one again so I can get better, what I made, fails....
Too much grunge D:
Back to my fav style, vector