|
View Poll Results: Durarara!! - Overall Series Impressions & Total Series Rating | |||
Perfect 10 | 22 | 25.29% | |
9 out of 10 : Excellent | 35 | 40.23% | |
8 out of 10 : Very Good | 18 | 20.69% | |
7 out of 10 : Good | 5 | 5.75% | |
6 out of 10 : Average | 4 | 4.60% | |
5 out of 10 : Below Average | 1 | 1.15% | |
4 out of 10 : Poor | 0 | 0% | |
3 out of 10 : Bad | 0 | 0% | |
2 out of 10 : Very Bad | 0 | 0% | |
1 out of 10 : Painful | 2 | 2.30% | |
Voters: 87. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools |
2011-01-05, 04:05 | Link #21 | |
Pedites Extraordinarii
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Maryland
|
Quote:
I absolutely hated the 3 brats: Anri - She IS a parasite, she does absolutely nothing, and half her actions leads to problems for everyone else. (ie. when she spied on the yellow scarf gang, and then asks Celty to bail her out...causing everyone to think the Dollars gang teamed up with the slasher). She has a dangerous sword that curses people and she uses to go around possessing people? I see her as a menace to society...especially at the end when she was still using people to confront Izaya. I absolutely hated her character...she was bland, uninteresting, and her speech pattern made her seem retarded. Mikado - He does absolutely nothing...when the sh*t goes down, he hides under his blanket and it takes Celty to set him straight. I don't hate him, but I really don't like him either. Causes problems for everyone with his indecisiveness. Kiba - annoying middle schooler who starts a gang, but doesn't have the balls, intelligence, or responsibility to control it. Causes problems from his indecisiveness, as well as making bad decisions. Rawr!!! |
|
2011-01-05, 06:08 | Link #22 | ||||||
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Celty didn't set him straight about anything either, just to have him help her stop Anri and Kida from having a violent confrontation. Quote:
The only real bad decision he had made was to not confront Mikado about the Dollars earlier. For the most part he is the character most victimized by Izaya aside from Shizuo and Rio, thanks to bastard taking advantage of his guilt and love for Saki. In the end he manages to come to terms with both his past and settle things with the YS. Last edited by Iron Maw; 2011-01-05 at 06:18. |
||||||
2011-01-05, 17:01 | Link #23 | ||||||
Pedites Extraordinarii
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Maryland
|
Quote:
3 characters as totally lacking organizational, leadership, common sense, etc qualities. I don't mind the fictional portrayal of awesome middle schoolers - but they actually have to be awesome with talents and skills, not a bunch of inept brats who somehow formed their organizations out of sheer luck. All 3 of them are terrible terrible leaders. Quote:
What was the entire point of even going to the base then? And after that, she gets Celty to bail her our, pulls out her sword, and confuses the YS into starting the gang war. Quote:
Anri and her devil sword is a far bigger menace to society than Izaya. Quote:
That is the very portrayal of running away and cowardice. Quote:
Quote:
It was Kiba's decision to let random people from the Blue Scarves join. It was his decision to do NOTHING after finding out Mikado was a part of the Dollars. At that point, he could've easily stopped everything by having a little chit chat with his friends. What did he do? He decides to avoid Mikado every day after school. He is like Mikado and thinks if he runs away, everything will fix itself. It was his decision to not properly restrain the YS when they were still following him - yes they were former BS members, but they still followed his authority at that point. In short, he did absolutely NOTHING, and let the gang war go out of control. The blue scarf members were still following him to a degree, but his betrayal (yes he did betray them) by not doing anything about the Dollars (not even negotiating) even though he knew Mikado was the leader shows he is a piss poor excuse for a leader. |
||||||
2011-01-05, 20:59 | Link #24 | |||||||||||||||
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
Mikado managed thawt Namie and saved Anri in the second half, Anri put Saika into excellent use for info gathering and protecting Dollar members. Kida had earned the respect of his gang long ago for being a great fighter. Their didn't their places by luck, you know this if you're paying attention. Quote:
Quote:
Even she had gotten involved YS would have fought the Dollars regardless, as the Slasher was simply an excuse to do so. Quote:
Furthermore how is she self-righteous or, arrogant at the end? She knows Izaya is person behind everything and doesn't want her friends being manipulate by him anymore. Really what are you talking about here? Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
He was ignoring the calls because he did not want to speak to anyone. Quote:
Quote:
So who exactly isn't paying attention to plot again? Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||||||||||||||
2011-01-05, 22:35 | Link #25 | ||||||||||||||
Pedites Extraordinarii
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Maryland
|
Quote:
Quote:
First, Izaya helped Mikado put the organization together. If it wasn't for him, I'm sure the Dollars would still be a bunch of backwater nobodies. Also, all he did was call a meeting to thwart Namie...the result was still nothing happening. He showed zero leadership skills before and after this even. The only think Mikado did was basically call a meeting - he really did absolutely nothing to help put together the Dollars structure, foundation, organization, etc (which was all done by recruiters or people like Izaya)... Kida earned their respect through brute force, but he was obviously not cut out to be leader. If he was such a great fighter, why couldn't he save his girl? Cuz he was a little punk coward at that time who had no leadership qualities or courage. Anri uses her powers at inopportune times, and doesn't even follow through with it to solve problems in the long run. Quote:
And no, it's not understandable. The people already told her Kida was the leader. I don't see how it could be a shock if she already knew the leader's identity. What good would running away after seeing him do? She infiltrated their damn base...and of course, she leeches off of Celty to make a dramatic entrance, pulls out her slasher sword, etc...all that resulted was her causing more problems for everyone. Quote:
All she did was give them more suspicion that the slasher was with the dollars and the black rider. Quote:
Besides, did you forget the part where she slices off Celty's head? (the real Sakia/Anri and not Haruna I assume) That's attempted murder, and would've been murder if Celty wasn't a headless rider. And she had the slasher attack her bullies with a sword... yeah, they were bullies, but attacking them with a sword? Common... Anri is mentally unstable with a dangerous power. So yes, she is far more dangerous than Celty or Izaya. Celty has powers, but she isn't weak minded with a dangerous cursed sword that could implode any minute. Quote:
Quote:
That is way more dangerous than Izaya, who just likes to see people in chaotic situations. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Cowardice and stupidity. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Horoda didn't control the group until Kida betrayed them by doing NOTHING, and then ran away without giving them orders for a while. |
||||||||||||||
2011-01-06, 07:22 | Link #26 | ||||||||||||
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
As for the Dollars; it doesn't have a structure or much of foundation to begin(it suppose to be hoax for fun) with be he and his friends start the site and posted on other message boards and invited people long before Izaya showed up. The only Izaya did was invite more people causing the group to be somewhat more unruly(leading to all the original members aside from himself to quit) by vandalizing things and the like until Mikado convinced others in the group to use the Dollars for more positive things. Quote:
Quote:
She just continue close herself to anyone and everyone because you hate her. Quote:
Quote:
That's dumb, if you had a good who friend who had been nothing more than upstanding person turnout to be leading a notorious group you be shocked and not try verify it or not? Quote:
Maybe you miss it with Rio, Mikado and Shizuo but Celty is really nice who you know helps out her friends. But I guess their all leeches too. And Anri pulled out Saika to defend herself from a pipe that had been thrown at her not to showoff if anything Celty was one doing it that(to scare off YS.) Quote:
The only other things I'm going to address before I go are: Quote:
Quote:
Last edited by Iron Maw; 2011-01-06 at 09:48. |
||||||||||||
2011-01-10, 07:01 | Link #27 |
lost ronin
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: in the recesses of my convoluted mind...
|
i gave it a 9. i had some problems with the last part, i felt that it lacked resolution. but then again perhaps it was meant to end that way. maybe celty didn't need to find her head to be whole. maybe shinra was simply rewarded for his obsessive love for her by having her return his once unrequited feelings. maybe shizuo was meant to remain the abnormally strong and angsty bartender. maybe izaya was needed to stay on as the ever manipulative and scheming information broker, otherwise ikebukuro would be terribly boring. and perhaps mikado, kida and anri were simply supposed to carry on with their lives and learn from the circumstances that drew them to one another.
all in all, it was an enjoyable series with unique and flawed characters. i love that it was told through the eyes of different characters, making it more personal and interesting. even the musical score was good and distinctive. it has the feel of a movie made by quentin tarantino. easily one of the coolest anime series i've seen. |
2011-01-19, 08:15 | Link #28 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Jan 2011
|
6 out of 10.
Just finished watching the episodes and when I watched the finale I was like "meh...". The whole scenario feels dragged. The theme reminds me of those movies where 2 brothers/friends/lovers grow up together and then a war happens and they end up on the opposing sides. There are a LOT of movies like that. Here we replace the brothers with 3 friends ,and the "war" with 3 gangs fighting each other because... wait why were they fighting in the first place? Ah yes the old leader of one of the factions thought ,that a second factions (the Slashers) hurt on of his friends. Ignoring that ,his friend of his is the leader of that faction itself. And then the third faction(Dollars) comes for ... no reason at all. Just some rumors that there was a collaboration between the Slashers and the Dollars. Right... Well sorry ,but it's simply not convincing enough. That's why as I said the whole thing feels dragged. The writer was forcing things TOO much in order to get 3 groups to fight ,where in the beggining these groups had nothing in common and no reason to fight at all. It would be far more convincing to put 2 opposing gangs (like the blue and yellow scarfs) to fight with each other. THEY would have reasons to fight in the first place. But to put a gang(yellow scarfs) ,fight with a group of everyday people(dollars) and with a group of hypnotized people(Slashers) based on... a misundestanding? Come on you can come up with something better than that. Wait there WAS someone pulling the strings. Izaya. Hmmmm... He wanted to create a havoc so that he can awake the head of an irish demon so that he can go to Valhalla. We are talking about the same head that kept standing in a jar , on a bookself rthe WHOLE time right? What happened to that? I expected in the big fight scene in the finale Izaya to show up with the head in his arms so that he can awake it. But nothing like that happened.So what was his original plan again? What was the point of all that in the first place? Hmm.... Let's be honest thought. That was the sereis theme for the second hald of it. For the first half the main plot thread was about Celty getting her head back. And alas, in the end of episode 12 she does learn that her head, who has been searching for 20 years is in a lab of a pharmaceutical company nearby. And WHEN SHE LEARNS ABOUT IT WHAT DOES SHE DO?????Nothing... Excuse me???? So we've been watching 12 episodes for nothing? Right becaue the new main plot of the series was 3 friends finding themselves on opposing sides as I mentioned above. So in conclusion: -Main plot thread A= Celty finding her head = Unresolved. -Main plot thread B=Izaya awaking the head=Unresolved. -Finding the point of existance of the Russian character, the doctors father, the police officer with the motorbike ,Heiwajima's brother=Unresolved. No just one scene with them is not enough. -Finding the point of existance of Heiwajima besides being a deus ex machina for 1.235 times and being a good excuse to add some fighting scenes=Unresolved. -3 friends becoming friends again with each other: Done. So 6 out of 10. For the graphics ,sound ,Heiwajima and the Russian guy(true they don't really have a reason to exist but I kinda liked them ). Actually if I add to all that the fact that the 3 main characters were boring as hell , I guess the final score is 4 out of 10. Because I can't give above 5 to an anime that tells me that the scenario is of no importance and all that matters is friendship. I have One Piece for that. |
2011-09-17, 20:59 | Link #30 |
Senior Member
Author
Join Date: Dec 2007
|
Animation Quality: 9
Really great stuff from Brains Base (which i follow their works closely now on ), everything was above average and kept the quality going strong. Voice Actors: 9 Mikado - Japanese and Dub were equally great. Kida - Mamoru Miyano rocks yet again, Kida is truly the kind of character that you love or hate. Dub was okay, though i loved Kida's "Oh shiiit!" Celty - Miyuki Sawashiro = Win. enough said. Dub was also great too. Shizuo - Ono Daisuke??! Holy crap i didn't know it was him, i thought it was Keiji Fujiwara. Damn what a BAMF! Dub: Crispin Freeman, yeah even more BAMF here too. Izaya - Hiroshi Kamiya?? (Natsume and Tieria??!) Damn, again i was fooled! Dub: I didn't like Izaya's voice, i kept thinking "OMG LELOUCH" the entire time. Shinra - Irony: Voiced by Lelouch's seiyuu (in Japanese) and Suzaku's in english. Anri: The beginning of Kana Hanazawa's rise to stardom. Had no clue Michelle Ruff (Rukia!) dubbed her. Great overall. Characters: 10 Without DRRR's amazing range of characters, from the Russian sushi guy to Shizuo to Celty and everyone in between, it wouldn't have been as great. Though Mika and Seiji got annoying, Seiji in particular. Story: 7 The first half of the series was amazing to watch and see our main characters grow especially Mikado when he summons the Dollars and pwns Namie in the process. Shizuo and Izaya are the show stealers, though. Second half really slipped IMO and the ending was just...plain. Soundtrack: 8 Of Brains Base's three biggest successes (Baccano!, Durarara!! and Natsume Yuujinchou), DRRR ranks last but still great overall. Same musician for all three of the above series!! Dang, talented guy there! Enjoyment: 8 Despite the drop in the second half, i really enjoyed Durarara and the characters really do make the show enjoyable. Emotional Involvement: 8 Would be a 9, but as i said earlier: Second half really lost my interest a bit. Overall: 8.6/10 (rounded to a 9)
__________________
|
|
|