2022-01-08, 01:24 | Link #21 |
On a mission
Author
|
Hmm, well there was actually a plot to the series; the revues were just a stage. And as we've seen, the giraffe can be pretty arbitrary with the rules and decided to go with whatever seemed more entertaining for it and the audience.
Anyhow, the plot wasn't much until it was revealed that some blonde madwoman decided to keep everyone trapped in her ideal world because she was afraid of uncertainty. Honestly the show wouldn't even be half as interesting if Nana wasn't batshit insane and we are reminded that nobody fucks with Big Banana. At least to me, I thought the series really peaked at Hikari vs Nana. But at the least, you could say she lost to complacency but overall I think some other recent anime villains could have learned a lot from her. So it wouldn't be fair to say that Revue Starlight had no conflict within it, such an idealistic show is just not going to put anyone in a bad light. Well, maybe Mr. Giraffe. The only problem with this is that all kinda leaves Karen out of the interesting stuff and I will say that I thought that both Hikari and Karen's motivation was just pretty bleh and sometimes even cringey at worst. That being said I actually loved the ending to the show since I really didn't think that Homura Reina Mimori Hikari should have just took matters in her own hands like that to go dwell in her own misery. Sometimes it's okay to be naive? I'm getting too old, so yes. I mean yes you can say there was more style than substance, but it's pretty well built. I mean you could simplify Evangelion to "boy with severe attachment issues deals with arguably as dysfunctional adults through biblical allegories and big robots" but that isn't fair is it?
__________________
Last edited by Archon_Wing; 2022-01-08 at 01:37. |
2022-01-08, 22:38 | Link #22 | |||||
Senior Member
Author
|
Quote:
Also, I found the Nana-focused section of the TV series genuinely surprising and hence quite suspenseful. I truly did not expect the TV series to pull something like that right in the middle of the show. And since the TV series had successfully surprised me there, it left me feeling more suspenseful for the finale. Now, as for this movie, at no point did it surprise me or intrigue me to the extent that the Nana-focused section of the TV series did. Quote:
Now, if Karen wasn't likeable to you, then I get you disliking the TV show. Personally, I liked Karen. She wasn't my favorite character in this show, but I thought she was Ok and likeable. Quote:
Quote:
You care about realism in this show to this degree? We're talking about a show with a talking giraffe staging flashy Revue fights where teenage girls compete with dangerous weapons in order to be a top actress. There's nothing realistic about any of this! There's no need whatsoever for this show to be a realistic commentary on what it takes to be a top star in real life. No more than there's a need for a magical girl anime to be a realistic commentary on what it takes to effectively fight crime in real life. So for this franchise? I'd prefer the more feel-good option over the more realistic option. So I preferred how the TV series presented the Hikari/Karen relationship over how the Movie presented it. Quote:
And I agree with you on Nana. Nana is my favorite character in this franchise. And honestly, Nana's big scene fairly early in this movie left me hoping that she'd have a critically important role in the plot of the movie, but... she didn't, really. She ended up getting her one Revue with Juuna and that was that, pretty much.
__________________
Last edited by Triple_R; 2022-01-08 at 22:49. |
|||||
2022-01-08, 23:10 | Link #23 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||
2022-01-08, 23:40 | Link #24 | ||||
On a mission
Author
|
Quote:
Quote:
Spoiler:
Quote:
Nana's issue was her character was kinda done, so she was trying to lead the other girls out by not making the same mistakes with reliving the past constantly. So she was doing the big sister thing. The problem was more that Junna wasn't really conflicted to begin with (she was already certain with what she was) so it became a little pointless either than wanting them to see them fight, or people that really believed that Juuna should win something. Quote:
Like Banana forcefully keeping everyone there and always winning isn't really something that can be consistent with a more mundane explanation. Even if we just accept that she doesn't want to move on in her head, how does it really force other people in? And how would she have a conflict with Hikari, someone she can't even know without the time shenanigans? That I think is the game changer, and can't really be ignored. And I feel like you could say that to many stories to just "stuff happens". But of course most things in fiction are about human relationships and conflict that could be expressed in realistic terms. That.... doesn't mean all the fantasy parts are inherently superfluous even if it could be written that way. And finally, if we're really supposed to assume those fights aren't real, then winning and losing really shouldn't have any significance either would it? Granted, people were cutting off buttons left and right to no effect in the movie, sooo guess Nana was right. It wasn't a Revue.
__________________
|
||||
2022-01-08, 23:51 | Link #25 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
|
Maybe she didn't force anyone in. Maybe the whole thing was in her head. But the question is, does it even matter? No, it doesn't. What matters is that she was scared of moving on to the next stage of her life. How the show decided to portray that is a matter of aesthetic style, but it doesn't affect Nana's fundamental internal conflict. At the end of the day Nana's story is simply the story of a girl who was afraid to lose that moment of brilliance that she found in school with her friends, the story of a girl who was afraid of growing up. Whether there was any actual magic to it doesn't change anything in a fundamental way.
__________________
Last edited by Kazu-kun; 2022-03-15 at 14:34. |
2022-01-09, 00:03 | Link #26 | |
On a mission
Author
|
Quote:
It just isn't going to happen if it's in her head, and you can't just suddenly decide entire chunks of the show are irrelevant just because it doesn't contain details relevant to your conclusion. edit: I mean more that yes, you don't have to take everything literally. But I think the other extreme is something I can't settle with.
__________________
Last edited by Archon_Wing; 2022-01-09 at 00:14. |
|
2022-01-09, 13:09 | Link #27 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||
2022-01-09, 18:24 | Link #28 | |
Senior Member
Author
|
Quote:
Maybe the main difference between us here is that I grew up on unrealistic superhero stories that were nonetheless presented as really happening. So I tend to approach anime shows like Revue Starlight as just another superhero-like story where totally unrealistic things are nonetheless really happening. If my main fictional interests growing up had been more realistic works, maybe I'd share your take on this TV show and movie. Anyway, thanks for the good discussion, Kazu-kun and Archon_Wing!
__________________
|
|
2022-04-10, 00:08 | Link #29 |
Happy Sphere
Join Date: Mar 2021
Location: Texas
|
A listing on AMC Theater's website is listing the Revue Starlight Movie coming to the US in June. Hopefully this means someone (Sentai Filmworks?) has licensed it and this will also lead to a Blu Ray release eventually.
__________________
Last edited by Ragashingo; 2022-04-11 at 18:29. |
2022-04-21, 09:38 | Link #30 |
Happy Sphere
Join Date: Mar 2021
Location: Texas
|
Official Confirmation of US theatrical release!
Not in my city, of course, but maybe close enough I can see it if things line up right. I'm probably more excited since this probably means Sentai Filmworks will eventually release a box set, but I'd love to see it in theaters if I can.
__________________
|
|
|