AnimeSuki Forums

***relentlessflame*** · 2013-09-08, 19:41

This is a thread for Railgun S anime viewers to discuss the details of the anime-original second arc and how the events and character portrayed may or may not deviate from novel/manga canon, and what impact (if any) this may have on future events (or ways this is inconsistent with novel/manga portrayals of characters in future events).

All manga content may be discussed here without spoiler tags. If you are discussing things from the Index Novels, please use properly-labelled spoiler tags.

Bakaizer · 2013-09-08, 19:44

will Febli appear in the novel/manga?

Ilidsor · 2013-09-08, 19:57

^My guess is that they'll mention her once or twice in the manga and maybe the LN illustrator (can't remember his name atm) will draw him a few cameos in the LNs like with Harue.

ACertainStark · 2013-09-08, 21:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ilidsor

^My guess is that they'll mention her once or twice in the manga and maybe the LN illustrator (can't remember his name atm) will draw him a few cameos in the LNs like with Harue.

Yeah, that's probably what will happen just to give anime-viewers a little Easter egg.

Miraluka · 2013-09-08, 21:54

I think the tittle should be' Impact of Anime Original Arcs on Novel/Manga Canon' you know, the current arc has Telesthina.

Karna · 2013-09-28, 14:08

Just here to say that considering the timeframe as to when this arc is supposed to happen (during the 3 stories arc in Index), that this arc can not really be considered canon. It completely conflcits with the part where Touma went on a fake date with Mikoto to stop Etzali from stalking her.

Primary Consult · 2013-09-29, 19:55

Did it actually conflict though? The last line of the last episode implies that it is September 2nd (mentioning Liberal Arts City tomorrow)... considering the stills included Accel+LO and Touma in class, I am guessing it sailed right past Volume 5 (the last day of summer break). It would have been better if Unabara were shown or even a passing mention of helping Touma with his homework, but I don't see how it directly contradicts the existing timeline. Mikoto just needed an hour or two to herself on August 31st.

(Note: I got my timeline info from the "A certain unified calendar" graphic available on Baka Tsuki's site... I would say that format is the best way to keep all the stuff straight without having to read through walls of text).

Shinhwa · 2013-09-29, 20:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Primary Consult

Did it actually conflict though? The last line of the last episode implies that it is September 2nd (mentioning Liberal Arts City tomorrow)... considering the stills included Accel+LO and Touma in class, I am guessing it sailed right past Volume 5 (the last day of summer break). It would have been better if Unabara were shown or even a passing mention of helping Touma with his homework, but I don't see how it directly contradicts the existing timeline. Mikoto just needed an hour or two to herself on August 31st.

(Note: I got my timeline info from the "A certain unified calendar" graphic available on Baka Tsuki's site... I would say that format is the best way to keep all the stuff straight without having to read through walls of text).

An organized timeline from when Febli arc began and ended was posted on 2ch, which was then posted on the Ep24 thread, but it got deleted. But Ep24 did indeed happen on Aug 31.

RPG_Fanatic · 2013-09-29, 20:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ilidsor

^My guess is that they'll mention her once or twice in the manga and maybe the LN illustrator (can't remember his name atm) will draw him a few cameos in the LNs like with Harue.

Pretty much. Just like the season 1 arc.

Primary Consult · 2013-09-29, 20:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shinhwa

An organized timeline from when Febli arc began and ended was posted on 2ch, which was then posted on the Ep24 thread, but it got deleted. But Ep24 did indeed happen on Aug 31.

I wish it hadn't been deleted (or maybe it somehow could be moved here?). I'd like to see how they arrived at that conclusion, because IMO September 2nd makes more sense... they wouldn't be worrying about "afternoon classes" on August 31st because it is still summer vacation.

Ilidsor · 2013-09-29, 21:01

^They started it directly after the sisters arc. Like the next day iirc.

ACertainStark · 2013-09-29, 21:06

Wait then this didn't go past the Three Stories arc? Because I was confused over Last Order and Accelerator

Ilidsor · 2013-09-29, 21:14

That's just them not caring about the timeline. Hell sometimes it feels like they don't care about canon in general.

Primary Consult · 2013-09-29, 21:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ilidsor

^They started it directly after the sisters arc. Like the next day iirc.

Yes that is when they started it... but time had passed several times. For example, from the beginning of Episode 22 they went from 72 hours worth of candy to "the last one".

The timeline may not be internally consistent with itself, but the more I think of it the more sure I am that the final episode is supposed to be September 1st or 2nd.

Shinhwa · 2013-09-29, 21:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by Primary Consult

I wish it hadn't been deleted (or maybe it somehow could be moved here?). I'd like to see how they arrived at that conclusion, because IMO September 2nd makes more sense... they wouldn't be worrying about "afternoon classes" on August 31st because it is still summer vacation.

It was listed by js06 too. I don't know where I can find it because I am not experienced with looking at 2ch nor 4chan.

Ilidsor · 2013-09-29, 21:41

They tracked the amount of days that passed and it ended on the 31st. Maybe Haigon still has the image saved. Frankly it ending on September 1st or 2nd doesn't make this any better because that would imply that Misaka decided it was more important to spend an entire day with Touma to shake off some ranom boy, then to deal with an issue this big.

All of this could have been avoided if they had just had it happen in a few days time. If they had just paid any attention at all this could have been avoided.

Shinhwa · 2013-09-29, 21:48

I seriously don't get why they chose to make an original arc over Liberal Art City arc... seriously....

ACertainStark · 2013-09-29, 21:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ilidsor

They tracked the amount of days that passed and it ended on the 31st. Maybe Haigon still has the image saved. Frankly it ending on September 1st or 2nd doesn't make this any better because that would imply that Misaka decided it was more important to spend an entire day with Touma to shake off some ranom boy, then to deal with an issue this big.

All of this could have been avoided if they had just had it happen in a few days time. If they had just paid any attention at all this could have been avoided.

Wait so, in the case it did go to Sept 1 or 2, it means she skipped the date and all?

Shinhwa · 2013-09-29, 21:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by ACertainStark

Wait so, in the case it did go to Sept 1 or 2, it means she skipped the date and all?

Pretty much yes.

dniv · 2013-09-29, 21:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shinhwa

I seriously don't get why they chose to make an original arc over Liberal Art City arc... seriously....

This is because it is supposed to mirror Index. We can't get what we first see in Liberal Arts City Arc until we get to see it in Index III Battle Royale arc...

This is also because this season was a minor intro to AC's darkness after Mikoto found out about them... It'd be kind of weird if Mikoto suddenly became naive after everything that has been going on.

In the end, even if Mikoto is naive about magic and other things, we don't actually know how naive she is in general. The railgun manga has shown her develop in terms of maturity arc by arc, so I'm not really sure she's supposed to be naive as people generally consider her to be...

2013-09-08, 19:41	Link #1
*relentlessflame* 　 Administrator Join Date: Dec 2003 Age: 41	To Aru Kagaku no Railgun - Impact of Anime Febli Arc on Novel/Manga Canon This is a thread for Railgun S anime viewers to discuss the details of the anime-original second arc and how the events and character portrayed may or may not deviate from novel/manga canon, and what impact (if any) this may have on future events (or ways this is inconsistent with novel/manga portrayals of characters in future events). All manga content may be discussed here without spoiler tags. If you are discussing things from the Index Novels, please use properly-labelled spoiler tags.

2013-09-08, 19:44	Link #2
Bakaizer Demon Hunter Join Date: May 2013 Location: Ente Isla	will Febli appear in the novel/manga? __________________ Friendship and Rivalry. These two have it

2013-09-08, 19:57	Link #3
Ilidsor Angelerator Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Canada	^My guess is that they'll mention her once or twice in the manga and maybe the LN illustrator (can't remember his name atm) will draw him a few cameos in the LNs like with Harue. __________________

2013-09-29, 21:01	Link #11
Ilidsor Angelerator Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Canada	^They started it directly after the sisters arc. Like the next day iirc. __________________

2013-09-29, 21:14	Link #13
Ilidsor Angelerator Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Canada	That's just them not caring about the timeline. Hell sometimes it feels like they don't care about canon in general. __________________

2013-09-08, 21:54	Link #5
Miraluka Banned Join Date: Jan 2009 Age: 34	I think the tittle should be' Impact of Anime Original Arcs on Novel/Manga Canon' you know, the current arc has Telesthina.

2013-09-28, 14:08	Link #6
Karna just some guy Join Date: Oct 2007	Just here to say that considering the timeframe as to when this arc is supposed to happen (during the 3 stories arc in Index), that this arc can not really be considered canon. It completely conflcits with the part where Touma went on a fake date with Mikoto to stop Etzali from stalking her.

2013-09-29, 19:55	Link #7
Primary Consult Senior Member Join Date: Jun 2008 Age: 39	Did it actually conflict though? The last line of the last episode implies that it is September 2nd (mentioning Liberal Arts City tomorrow)... considering the stills included Accel+LO and Touma in class, I am guessing it sailed right past Volume 5 (the last day of summer break). It would have been better if Unabara were shown or even a passing mention of helping Touma with his homework, but I don't see how it directly contradicts the existing timeline. Mikoto just needed an hour or two to herself on August 31st. (Note: I got my timeline info from the "A certain unified calendar" graphic available on Baka Tsuki's site... I would say that format is the best way to keep all the stuff straight without having to read through walls of text).

2013-09-29, 21:06	Link #12
ACertainStark お姉さん☆ Join Date: Jul 2013 Location: Toronto, ON Age: 31	Wait then this didn't go past the Three Stories arc? Because I was confused over Last Order and Accelerator

2013-09-29, 21:41	Link #16
Ilidsor Angelerator Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Canada	They tracked the amount of days that passed and it ended on the 31st. Maybe Haigon still has the image saved. Frankly it ending on September 1st or 2nd doesn't make this any better because that would imply that Misaka decided it was more important to spend an entire day with Touma to shake off some ranom boy, then to deal with an issue this big. All of this could have been avoided if they had just had it happen in a few days time. If they had just paid any attention at all this could have been avoided. __________________

2013-09-29, 21:48	Link #17
Shinhwa Banned Join Date: Mar 2013 Location: Toronto, ON, Canada Age: 33	I seriously don't get why they chose to make an original arc over Liberal Art City arc... seriously....