2005-12-20, 05:46 | Link #1 |
Kissing...
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Cuteness Rating
Ok, so I thought this through for quite a while after talking about it in the favourite girl thread. I have some suspicion about the poll itself in that thread, so I'm not creating a poll for this one.
Rules are simple: 1) We're not canvassing for others to support the girl each of us loves, so try not to say things like, 'Asa is better than Kaede', that sort of thing. 2) Put down the girls' name and your own personal rating of how cute they are, on a scale of 1 to 10. No decimals by the way. Think seriously about this, I don't think Nerine is cuter than Primula, although I prefer Nerine. The list includes the 5 girls, Mayumi, Kareha, and Riker's favourite MILF, Ama. Nadesico doesn't really count as cute, she's more of a mature beauty, so I'm not including her. Example: Nerine - 8 Lisianthus - 9 Primula - 10. 3) Give some reasons, not too insane, try for something serious. You can say you're biased against Asa as a reason for giving her a low score. You don't have to put as much as me. 4) Have fun. Don't criticise other people's choices, this is a personal rating, I don't want to see anything that resembles bringing in things from other anime. e.g. Call Hollows to eat Asa. So, to start off: Lisianthus - 9 Nerine - 8 Primula - 10 Kaede - 7 Asa - 7 Mayumi - 6 Kareha - 8 Ama - 8 I rate this people high because of long hair, and other stuff, of course. Primula: Look in the wagging tail thread. That is enough reason. Sia: She's just got that face, Kikyou adds that special character that I think Sia herself doesn't have. Nerine: She's nice, there are a lot of things that make her cute. Kareha: That "my my my" annoys me slightly, but I think her long hair's nice. Ama: Neko hat. Nice voice. Asa & Kaede: Asa has more character than Kaede, but I don't like it that much, and psycho Kaede scared me too much.
__________________
|
2005-12-20, 05:49 | Link #2 |
I desire Tomorrow!
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: As far away from reality as possible
Age: 41
|
The idea is nice (although you shouldn't question the other poll just because we're in the lead for a change :P)
There is JUST ONE FLAW. You have to specify the number of girls, and then have as vote for each girl For instance, let's say they are five girls, A-E My vote would be like (5 being the highest grade - more points, and 1 being the lowest, and using every number per vote, once - no two 5s or 3 1s, etc) B - 5 E - 4 D - 3 C -2 A - 1 That way, you have standard numbers, not the whole 1-10 scale, and it's much easier to count, and more objectional - meaning I could vote 10 for primula and 1 for everyone else just to give her more votes, but with the above system, I can't resort to that kind of abuse. How's that?
__________________
|
2005-12-20, 05:51 | Link #3 |
Kissing...
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
That's assuming I wish to tally the overall thing. Right now I'm just gauging everyone's personal reaction. I'll leave your idea for later.
And I did state the list in my previous post. EDIT: And I also said that you could give Asa or Kaede a low score if you were biased against them. That sort of post wouldn't really be useful if I wanted a proper rating of their cuteness factor
__________________
Last edited by Wrath88; 2005-12-20 at 06:03. |
2005-12-20, 05:51 | Link #4 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Lisianthus - 10 (cmon? she was all "i can walk under the umbrella proudly". Tell me that WASNT worth a 10???)
Nerine - 9 Primula - 5 Kaede - 9 Asa - 10 (holding her like a princess <3) Mayumi - 4 Kareha - 3 (eww, blondeness >.<) Ama - i dont think shes big enuf to be on here <.<.. 6 |
2005-12-20, 06:04 | Link #5 | |
I desire Tomorrow!
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: As far away from reality as possible
Age: 41
|
Quote:
Then it goes like that Sia, Kaede, Primula, Nerine : 10 (what can I say, with girls like that, I'm easy ) Asa : I can't vote, I'm biased :P
__________________
|
|
2005-12-20, 06:40 | Link #6 |
Osana-Najimi Shipper
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mt. Ordeals
|
My ranking of cuteness from least to most cutest. Can't give 'ratings' though, as I can only compare the girls with each other. But if you insist, then just make my rank 1 a '10', my rank 2 a '9', and so on.
Primula (Not much of a roricon here) Mayumi Asa Ama Kaede (WTF? The girl I'm supporting is only rank 4? Blame my fixation on childhood friends :P) Sia Kareha Lafie... I mean Neri... I mean Licorice ^_^ |
2005-12-20, 06:54 | Link #7 |
rawr!
Join Date: Dec 2005
Age: 43
|
Lisianthus - 9 (in a "cutesy girlie" way)
Nerine - 6 (dunno, she just doesn't take a place as "cute" in my head... *shrugs*) Primula - 8 (didn't see ep 23 yet, but she is cute hugging her neko) Kaede - 6 (rather plain imo) Asa - 8 (doesn't have to be too cute, it's the behaviour ) Mayumi - 8 (ever since the bath scene, I can't help myself ) Kareha - 10 (my my my!) Ama - 12 (sorry, she just breaks the scale of measurement. Honestly!) Upon reflectig this, everything below 6 is useless to note, anyway, as all girls in Shuffle! are cute to a certain degree. But then again, where'd be the point of harem if they weren't all almost equally "interesting" or presented a viable alternative ^,^ Oh, on a sidenote, I would also like to ask if you'd mind a thread to measure the sexiness of the female character's voices. Asa does have a sexy voice, no matter how you put it, and Ama... my my my! Whereas Sia and Nerine totally blow as far as it concerns their voices. . . . . . Allright allright, it's a sidenote, stop kicking me already!
__________________
|
2005-12-20, 07:32 | Link #8 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Since we are talking about cuteness
Lisianthus - 9 1/2 (she's hawt more than cute though) Nerine - 8 1/2 (same here) Primula - 10 + (this is the only mark you can give to her) Kaede - 9 1/2 (among the humans, she's the cutest ....magical creatures are no match for humans though =/ ) Asa - 8 (since i had to give a mark, i give an eight...I'd be a liar if I'd say that asa isn't cute....all the girls are) Mayumi - 8+ (poor flat-chested mayumi o_O....btw i find her heterochromia iridis kinda cute ) Kareha - 7 (more than her appeareance, i don't like her behaviour, so meh) Ama - 7 (no comment) and since you have put an adult.... Nadeshiko-sensei - 9 (although she gets a 90 in a beauty contest ) |
2005-12-20, 07:48 | Link #10 |
Kira_Naruto, the ecchi
Graphic Designer
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: http://www.exciting-tits.com/
|
In terms of cute-ness (face, personality, voice .. etc) .. Ama-chan leads no doubt .. with Rim-chan going a close second. .. Sia's cute.. but her voice are annoying at least to me.. and Kikyou kills the overall cuteness (for me) when counted her personality as well. Kaede is an average.. yup, but still she woo me over despite having a low score in terms of cuteness ... Not surprising for me, mind you, since cuteness factor dont usually guides me in choosing an anime dreamgirl for a particular series .. Kareha is simply to beautiful .. shes a default goddess to me ... Nerine is NOT cute when it came to face value .. she's damn sexy .. I think she and Kaede alternate spots for my wallie .. Asa, well, I cant really say... she's cute in a way .. but like Luna, she just dont have it in for me.
So there you have it .. my personal preferences .. Would be to hard for me to throw a value for them .. Gomenneh.
__________________
|
2005-12-20, 08:14 | Link #14 |
Peek a boo
Graphic Designer
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
It's also hard to put a value, but this is my preference in terms of cuteness.
Ama, then Primula, then Kareha. [Off Topic] Angelsama, I totally approve of your choice of avatar. We should form a Cute Moms Appreciation Club. :x |
2005-12-20, 08:27 | Link #16 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
OFF TOPIC
Quote:
(If you read the manga, you'll end up loving her, guaranteed) |
|
2005-12-20, 08:38 | Link #17 | |
Beautiful fighter.
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: England, UK
Age: 37
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2005-12-20, 08:49 | Link #18 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Currently AFK
|
Giving them a scale of 1-5. My rating sare:
Ama 5. Neko hat, cute voice and face Sia 5. Cutest voice ever, overall cuteness and "walk under the umbrella with you" Nerine 5. I like the way she acts, its cute. And love her ears and hair Asa 5. Overall short hair and looks totaly cute in it. Cute way of showing her feelings Kaede 3. I dont like the hair... Shes got a really nice personality but thats it for me Primula 3. I dont find loli that cute... And no, I dont find it anything ells Riker! Mayumi 4. Really cute haircolour, and love the two different colored eyes Kareha 4. The my my my is sweet, but then the hair color drags her down for me... Thats about my rating. I kindof like all the girls looks, but my favorites are stil Ama and Sia |
Thread Tools | |
|
|