AnimeSuki Forums

Wheeljack83 · 2020-03-18, 06:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ruki0089

But if this got anime, there is high possibility this will be like Arifureta anime or other garbage adaptations.

Just because Arifureta was a disappointment isn't a good reason not to do one.

Ruki0089 · 2020-03-18, 06:33

Dude, I said high possibility being bad if this got one, not about this shouldn't be get anime adaptation.

Wheeljack83 · 2020-03-20, 01:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ruki0089

Dude, I said high possibility being bad if this got one, not about this shouldn't be get anime adaptation.

I have hope it can be good.

Pierre · 2020-03-22, 19:55

^Arifutea. I dont think its the worst adaptation - cue Ragnarock and the Einjhars, but dam they took a pretty good work and ................. actually that might be the worst adaptation, because I still dont get the thought process of the order in the first few episodes, where they seem to speed up and then flash back.

Ruki0089 · 2020-03-22, 21:38

I also said others, so it doesn't apply only to Arifureta~
There were so many bad anime adaptation~
Campione, Anti magic academy, DxD Born and etc.

Rimbo99 · 2020-03-25, 08:42

1) One thing that bothers me about Claire is that in truth, Cid is actually training her during childhood, why can't she see that?

2) Why was Cid and Claire's father was being a scummy coward? Shouldn't he be more worried for his daughter's disappearance?

sierra117 · 2020-03-25, 09:00

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rimbo99

1) One thing that bothers me about Claire is that in truth, Cid is actually training her during childhood, why can't she see that?

2) Why was Cid and Claire's father was being a scummy coward? Shouldn't he be more worried for his daughter's disappearance?

1. She saw that, but it’s irritating her that Cid (look like)never actually and seriously try despite having talent and potential

bakato · 2020-03-25, 09:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rimbo99

1) One thing that bothers me about Claire is that in truth, Cid is actually training her during childhood, why can't she see that?

2) Why was Cid and Claire's father was being a scummy coward? Shouldn't he be more worried for his daughter's disappearance?

2. Stereotypical anime behavior.

Garn · 2020-03-28, 12:40

It really would be nice to see something like this novel but a more serious version
A version where the MC does and knows everything that everyone else thinks that this MC does and knows

Without misunderstandings and with a MC more related to what happened in the past
As if the MC wanted to revive Aurora because she was someone special to him in the past
Or that he was part of the initial test subjects in the past

Rimbo99 · 2020-03-29, 05:10

Spoiler for Spoiler Questions:

sierra117 · 2020-03-29, 06:37

1. He wasn’t exactly kill them, just beat them uo

Log · 2020-03-29, 21:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by Garn

It really would be nice to see something like this novel but a more serious version
A version where the MC does and knows everything that everyone else thinks that this MC does and knows

Without misunderstandings and with a MC more related to what happened in the past
As if the MC wanted to revive Aurora because she was someone special to him in the past
Or that he was part of the initial test subjects in the past

A serious version of this novel wouldn't work because Cid is just too OP, especially the version of Cid you're proposing where he's actually as smart as Shadow Garden thinks he is.

I also don't think the story you're proposing is all that enticing. A majority of this series appeal comes from Cid's humor, if Cid's personality was altered this story loses a lot of charm.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rimbo99

Spoiler for Spoiler Questions:

2. I'd assume no.

3. Probably not. Cid was wacky in his original work too.

4. Presumably having as many blood samples as possible would help with their research.

Pierre · 2020-04-03, 20:56

^ the one about the assasin who is reincarnated to kill the hero is kind of a serious version of this, someone actually mentioned this as a comedy version of that on another thread I saw.

Rimbo99 · 2020-04-11, 22:23

Exactly, why did Hyoro and Jaga felt the need to lie to Cid? Cid already saw these two were acting cowardly during the terrorist attack? That's pretty inappropriate behavior especially they did nothing when Cid almost died.

sierra117 · 2020-04-11, 22:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rimbo99

Exactly, why did Hyoro and Jaga felt the need to lie to Cid? Cid already saw these two were acting cowardly during the terrorist attack? That's pretty inappropriate behavior especially they did nothing when Cid almost died.

To save face, because technically they are still Cid’s “friends”

real123 · 2020-04-21, 16:48

Did Yukime fall for Cid, my impression was she simply felt gratitude toward him and wanted revenge against Diablos

sierra117 · 2020-04-21, 22:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by real123

Did Yukime fall for Cid, my impression was she simply felt gratitude toward him and wanted revenge against Diablos

She is both

real123 · 2020-04-24, 17:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by sierra117

She is both

Hmm. Good for her, I really liked her back story along with Rose's

Rimbo99 · 2020-04-29, 20:23

I don't know if this is answered but Cid should be a little more concerned about Claire's kidnapping? If not for her safety but if she was never found, then their parents would have poured all their workload onto him and will watch him 24/7.

I'm also suprised no one, not even Sherry noticed Ruslan wearing Shadow Garden clothes? Won't that arouse suspicion that something is definitely wrong?

Wheeljack83 · 2020-05-29, 06:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rimbo99

I don't know if this is answered but Cid should be a little more concerned about Claire's kidnapping? If not for her safety but if she was never found, then their parents would have poured all their workload onto him and will watch him 24/7.

I'm also suprised no one, not even Sherry noticed Ruslan wearing Shadow Garden clothes? Won't that arouse suspicion that something is definitely wrong?

Cid is a very dense idiot and rarely seems to have an actual grasp of what is going on.

View Poll Results: Who is your favorite girl?
Nu	5	4.31%
Gamma	12	10.34%
Alpha	46	39.66%
Delta	30	25.86%
Beta	23	19.83%
Voters: 116. You may not vote on this poll

2020-03-18, 06:33	Link #322
Ruki0089 Yandere Otoko Ruki-tan Join Date: Jan 2012 Location: Earth 616	Dude, I said high possibility being bad if this got one, not about this shouldn't be get anime adaptation. __________________

2020-03-22, 21:38	Link #325
Ruki0089 Yandere Otoko Ruki-tan Join Date: Jan 2012 Location: Earth 616	I also said others, so it doesn't apply only to Arifureta~ There were so many bad anime adaptation~ Campione, Anti magic academy, DxD Born and etc. __________________

2020-03-29, 05:10	Link #330
Rimbo99 Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2017	Spoiler for Spoiler Questions: 1. Back in his old world, how come no police officer ever discover that Cid is the psycho that kills bikers and rapists? 2. Does some of SG like Epsilon and Nu intend to murder their parents for discarding them? 3. Regarding Cid's original death, did he suffer from brain damage after hitting the tree? Combined with suffering from hypothermia? 4. If the Diabolos Cult's goal is immortality, why do they need Alexia, Rose, Claire and the little girl for new Heroes? Didn't they already have the Three Heroes?

2020-03-29, 06:37	Link #331
sierra117 Harem Seeker Join Date: Aug 2015	1. He wasn’t exactly kill them, just beat them uo __________________ “If you were a logical person with refinement then it was obvious to prefer matureness over immatureness, abundance over lacking. Lolita complex is a mental illness, everyone. I hope you are able to go to your nearest mental hospital and get a suicide check-up.” -Dantalian, Dungeon Defense-

2020-03-22, 19:55	Link #324
Pierre Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2014	^Arifutea. I dont think its the worst adaptation - cue Ragnarock and the Einjhars, but dam they took a pretty good work and ................. actually that might be the worst adaptation, because I still dont get the thought process of the order in the first few episodes, where they seem to speed up and then flash back.

2020-03-25, 08:42	Link #326
Rimbo99 Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2017	1) One thing that bothers me about Claire is that in truth, Cid is actually training her during childhood, why can't she see that? 2) Why was Cid and Claire's father was being a scummy coward? Shouldn't he be more worried for his daughter's disappearance?

2020-03-28, 12:40	Link #329
Garn Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2016	It really would be nice to see something like this novel but a more serious version A version where the MC does and knows everything that everyone else thinks that this MC does and knows Without misunderstandings and with a MC more related to what happened in the past As if the MC wanted to revive Aurora because she was someone special to him in the past Or that he was part of the initial test subjects in the past

2020-04-03, 20:56	Link #333
Pierre Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2014	^ the one about the assasin who is reincarnated to kill the hero is kind of a serious version of this, someone actually mentioned this as a comedy version of that on another thread I saw.

2020-04-11, 22:23	Link #334
Rimbo99 Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2017	Exactly, why did Hyoro and Jaga felt the need to lie to Cid? Cid already saw these two were acting cowardly during the terrorist attack? That's pretty inappropriate behavior especially they did nothing when Cid almost died.

2020-04-21, 16:48	Link #336
real123 Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2013	Did Yukime fall for Cid, my impression was she simply felt gratitude toward him and wanted revenge against Diablos

2020-04-29, 20:23	Link #339
Rimbo99 Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2017	I don't know if this is answered but Cid should be a little more concerned about Claire's kidnapping? If not for her safety but if she was never found, then their parents would have poured all their workload onto him and will watch him 24/7. I'm also suprised no one, not even Sherry noticed Ruslan wearing Shadow Garden clothes? Won't that arouse suspicion that something is definitely wrong?