2010-07-17, 09:33 | Link #3324 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
I would even go as far and say that he is somewhere in the mansion, where he was found during Episode 4...before his body could be put into the incinerator. They just said that they recognized Kinzo...even a corpse can be recognized if he has something (like his 6th toe) that makes him recognizable. I do not believe that anybody on the island is Kinzo at the moment of the game. To gain the persona of 'Goldsmith' isn't hard, but becoming Kinzo would be breaking too many rules for my taste. And Kanon=Battler would also be highly speculative. That would mean that scenes like Battler, helping Kanon in the rosegarden in Episode 1 would be entirely fabricated. It is heavily implied that Battler was able to help him, because he is bigger and stronger than Kanon. Bodily strength: Battler>Kanon. So making them into one person would require either, a huge suspension of disbelief regarding what the people on the island see and know or and that is even more farfetched, a 2nd Battler on the island.
__________________
|
|
2010-07-17, 09:41 | Link #3325 | |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Canada
|
Quote:
As for the letter, why couldn't have any of the adults or cousins dropped it on their way to the guest house? It doesn't have to be Battler that does it - the letter does not pose a closed room puzzle. Especially now that we have the advent of retroactive actions, that letter really could've been dropped by anyone. |
|
2010-07-17, 09:53 | Link #3326 | |
Philosopher of theories
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Portugal
Age: 32
|
Quote:
|
|
2010-07-17, 09:58 | Link #3328 |
Philosopher of theories
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Portugal
Age: 32
|
...Kinzo actually says lots of times for Beatrice to come and let the roullete spin the way it wants. He doesn't really care if he's the zero. Also Kinzo would never say "I'm not furniture anymore".
A quick check-up, why is Kinzo=Kanon? I don't see it. |
2010-07-17, 10:06 | Link #3329 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
|
Uh he always says how magic is the most impossible/profit ratio. that would be the zero.
I do not think he IS the 80year old something Kinzo. he is his sucessor. he might have found the gold or is his child. In EP4 someone clearly was aknowlaged as "Kinzo" but we did not see who because of the stupid magic scene. There was also some strange theory that "Kinzo" and "Beatrice" must exist on rokkenjima. that would be Kanon and Shannon, both "created" by Kinzo and given a hearth |
2010-07-17, 11:36 | Link #3332 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Age: 39
|
I just finished reading Episode 6 and some (but not all) of this thread, so excuse me repeating anything that has been discussed to death.
I thought the shkanon theory was viable, maybe even likely, ever since the third game. It conforms with all the red text and Knox's rules, and opens up possibilities to "solve" some of the harder mysteries in each game. Because of this, my perspective is probably a bit skewed. But to me, huge parts of Episode 6 seem to be outright designed to support that theory. That includes both red and normal text, and both mystery and fantasy scenes. Actually some of it goes one step further and allows that wonderful hodgepodge known as shkanontrice. At this point, the main reason I see to doubt shkanon is purely meta (talking about Umineko, maybe I should call it meta-meta): it's too blindingly obvious. |
2010-07-17, 11:40 | Link #3333 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
I don't remember that being the case, so we could deal with a misrepresentation based on what is said. The children acknowledge the presence of Ushiromiya Kinzo. Someone kills half of them and imprisons the others. As far as I remember it does not clearly state, that Ushiromiya Kinzo = Killer. They could as well have been presented with the corpse of Ushiromiya Kinzo, acknowledged it and went on to talk with the real culprit. The fact that we see it like Ushiromiya Kinzo = Culprit could just be a deliberate misinterpretation of Hachijô Tôya's book or just something that she spun around it.
__________________
|
|
2010-07-17, 12:01 | Link #3335 | |
do you know ベアトリーチェ様?
Join Date: Dec 2003
Age: 35
|
I don't believe that Kinzo being alive was stated, hence my thought that they were presented with Kinzo's will or something to that effect.
Quote:
Not to mention that in that context... Battler's "sin"? How about not getting into several romances and then blaming it on him? |
|
2010-07-17, 12:04 | Link #3336 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
|
Durante i would read this:
http://forums.animesuki.com/showthre...56#post3145156 It shows that Shkannontrice was not that far off but still to easy to see. chounokoe: i do not think you will find this in red. Kinzo is already dead at the starting time for all games! Kinzo needs to be dead or else Kanon could not heredity Kinzo's name. Beatrice stated that in the beginning of EP4 or else the appearence of "Kinzo" would be considered "strange, but normal" i think the Blue about the heredity did not get denied. |
2010-07-17, 12:19 | Link #3337 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Buffer overflow
|
That doesn't work out, time-wise. Erika killed them (or so we are led to believe) back when she first inspected the corpses. After that, she went to the guesthouse and confirmed that there was no letter by the front door. Then the letter appeared. So the five victims couldn't have placed the letter there.
__________________
|
2010-07-17, 12:34 | Link #3338 | |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Quote:
I don't recall Erika stating she immediately ran back to the mansion, killed everyone, then went to check the letter. That seems improbable and quite cheap. Are we allowing the declaration of retroactive moves regardless of the temporal and spatial sense they make now?
__________________
|
|
2010-07-17, 13:19 | Link #3339 |
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Can we exclude that the letter was placed by anyone among the people in the guesthouse?
Was Erika the last who crossed the door? Did Erika check that Krauss or someone else didn't put the letter while she was busy talking to Rudolf and Hideyoshi?
__________________
|
|
|