AnimeSuki Forums

OceanBlue · 2011-03-19, 02:12

I'm no artist, but aren't you guys exaggerating the problems?

I probably should've made the leg wider, and I don't know foreshortening enough to get the shoulder in exactly the right place, but the reason you can't put her shoulder out that far is because her shoulders are angled.

The only problem I thought was blatant [and this was after I went to inspect it] is her left wrist. Also, I personally like it the puffy cheeks. It's probably more of a style thing.

RRW · 2011-03-19, 02:34

still, her butt its freak me out

Tempester · 2011-03-19, 03:48

I thought the picture didn't look quite correct, but everyone's comments, especially Malkuth's and OceanBlue's, seriously made me laugh out loud.

Also,

Spoiler:

Oh well, at least it's just promo art.

Mizuno · 2011-03-19, 07:34

Looks like somebody can't draw limbs... would have been the perfect image.

felix · 2011-03-19, 17:14

It’s already been “debated” for a whole page, can we stop with this nonsense already.

Just accept it as a different art direction and move on; worse things have had less comments. What? you people never seen Konan, Clannad, etc. The recent wannabe art critic boom (or plague), originating in the fate/zero thread, is very much pointless—nothing is truly wrong—especially when you don't have anything better to offer alongside the words. I feel like we’re feeding a witch hunt, hardly anyone understands what actually is wrong, and most are just drawn into the hate as it gathers enough mass.

If it’s really that wrong (although few if any mention what exactly is wrong) then we can have rules where as no pictures that are not “realistic” may be posted; given the state of anime, I guess we can just ban all pictures since no style is even close. That way all of you won't be so offended by it; or make such a fuss over it.

RRW · 2011-03-19, 18:34

it is a opinion. people can express that. if majority people say it's bad, then that indication it is bad.

obviously people have different art taste

Mizuno · 2011-03-19, 19:01

heh somebody needs to take a chill pill. For a moment I thought you drew it to be so offended by even such mild criticism.

OceanBlue · 2011-03-19, 20:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tempester

I thought the picture didn't look quite correct, but everyone's comments, especially Malkuth's and OceanBlue's, seriously made me laugh out loud.

Is this an inside joke at the F/Z thread or something? I don't understand, since it looks acceptable to me...

Quote:

Originally Posted by rrw

it is a opinion. people can express that. if majority people say it's bad, then that indication it is bad.

obviously people have different art taste

Having an opinion on something based on [somewhat] subjective artistic merits isn't really the same as an opinion about the anatomical accuracy of something... But this is anime we're talking about, so what am I saying?

RRW · 2011-03-20, 02:15

oh about fate/zero. there is small complain of off model on few scan. like this. felix just exagerated it anyway

MisaoFan · 2011-03-20, 02:22

I wonder if Fate/zero is getting a manga adaptation ?

dark998 · 2011-03-20, 16:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by OceanBlue

Having an opinion on something based on [somewhat] subjective artistic merits isn't really the same as an opinion about the anatomical accuracy of something... But this is anime we're talking about, so what am I saying?

This. Looks pretty good within the boundaries of anime proportions, couldn't care less if a leg or an arm is slighty shorter. And the designs in those magazine spreads are not always faithful to the final ones.

Malkuth · 2011-03-20, 17:29

For my part, I said clearly, I loved the image, but could not help it but point out some stuff that seemed out of proportion.

Also to criticize, point errors, etc. does not require you to be able to to something better, where the hell did that come from

Anyway, I thought denpa onna was high-school and older, but seems they are going for loli

Midonin · 2011-03-22, 17:33

The ED theme will be performed by Shaft mainstay Etsuko Yakushimaru. The title is "Ruru". Or maybe it's "Lulu", I'm not totally sure how to romanize it. For all I know it could be "Rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrruru".

Kanon · 2011-03-22, 17:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by Malkuth

Anyway, I thought denpa onna was high-school and older, but seems they are going for loli

It wouldn't be the first time we got a loli-looking high schooler, and it won't be the last. She looks very loli on the novel covers as well (especially vol 4).

Miraluka · 2011-03-22, 18:50

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kanon

It wouldn't be the first time we got a loli-looking high schooler, and it won't be the last. She looks very loli on the novel covers as well (especially vol 4).

Thats because she used to be a kid

.

Marcus H. · 2011-03-22, 19:43

Quote:

Originally Posted by Midonin

The ED theme will be performed by Shaft mainstay Etsuko Yakushimaru. The title is "Ruru". Or maybe it's "Lulu", I'm not totally sure how to romanize it. For all I know it could be "Rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrruru".

It's reminds me of the stuttering demon in P&SG and "RURRRRRRLRLRLRRUSHU".
Might be "rule" written in katakana.

Cosmic Eagle · 2011-03-24, 08:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wilfriback

Thats because she used to be a kid

.

Even in the normal current stories, she still looks 14 at most.....

ahelo · 2011-03-24, 08:38

lol her butt's big

Patriot's Blade · 2011-03-24, 08:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by OceanBlue

I'm no artist, but aren't you guys exaggerating the problems?

I probably should've made the leg wider, and I don't know foreshortening enough to get the shoulder in exactly the right place, but the reason you can't put her shoulder out that far is because her shoulders are angled.

The only problem I thought was blatant [and this was after I went to inspect it] is her left wrist. Also, I personally like it the puffy cheeks. It's probably more of a style thing.

Malkuth · 2011-03-24, 09:00

Quote:

Originally Posted by ahelo

lol her butt's big

that's a feature... I guess

the bug is the missing genitalia

2011-03-19, 03:48	Link #143
Tempester Japanese Culture Fan Join Date: Nov 2008 Location: Planet Earth Age: 33	I thought the picture didn't look quite correct, but everyone's comments, especially Malkuth's and OceanBlue's, seriously made me laugh out loud. Also, Spoiler: butt cheeks don't work that way. Oh well, at least it's just promo art.

2011-03-19, 17:14	Link #145
felix sleepyhead Author Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: event horizon	It’s already been “debated” for a whole page, can we stop with this nonsense already. Just accept it as a different art direction and move on; worse things have had less comments. What? you people never seen Konan, Clannad, etc. The recent wannabe art critic boom (or plague), originating in the fate/zero thread, is very much pointless—nothing is truly wrong—especially when you don't have anything better to offer alongside the words. I feel like we’re feeding a witch hunt, hardly anyone understands what actually is wrong, and most are just drawn into the hate as it gathers enough mass. If it’s really that wrong (although few if any mention what exactly is wrong) then we can have rules where as no pictures that are not “realistic” may be posted; given the state of anime, I guess we can just ban all pictures since no style is even close. That way all of you won't be so offended by it; or make such a fuss over it. __________________

2011-03-24, 08:38	Link #158
ahelo Criminal Unrequitor Graphic Designer Join Date: Jul 2010	lol her butt's big __________________ Traveler on Revenge / Ahelo Sigs / Saimoe Report! Signature by ganbaru

2011-03-19, 02:12	Link #141
OceanBlue Not an expert on things Join Date: Jun 2007	I'm no artist, but aren't you guys exaggerating the problems? I probably should've made the leg wider, and I don't know foreshortening enough to get the shoulder in exactly the right place, but the reason you can't put her shoulder out that far is because her shoulders are angled. The only problem I thought was blatant [and this was after I went to inspect it] is her left wrist. Also, I personally like it the puffy cheeks. It's probably more of a style thing.

2011-03-19, 07:34	Link #144
Mizuno Undefined Join Date: May 2004 Location: With the gods Age: 40	Looks like somebody can't draw limbs... would have been the perfect image.

2011-03-19, 19:01	Link #147
Mizuno Undefined Join Date: May 2004 Location: With the gods Age: 40	heh somebody needs to take a chill pill. For a moment I thought you drew it to be so offended by even such mild criticism.

2011-03-20, 17:29	Link #152
Malkuth Banned Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: London Age: 43	For my part, I said clearly, I loved the image, but could not help it but point out some stuff that seemed out of proportion. Also to criticize, point errors, etc. does not require you to be able to to something better, where the hell did that come from Anyway, I thought denpa onna was high-school and older, but seems they are going for loli

2011-03-22, 17:33	Link #153
Midonin Last Engage Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Florida	The ED theme will be performed by Shaft mainstay Etsuko Yakushimaru. The title is "Ruru". Or maybe it's "Lulu", I'm not totally sure how to romanize it. For all I know it could be "Rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrruru".