Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei Manga Discussion (Licensed)

[Awrya]

Well, it's from Miyuki point of view.
It depends on what you see as different from the LN, for example

Spoiler for LN comparison:

the scene at the cafeteria was only subtly mentioned in the LN, while the manga went into more detail.

[chancs]

Originally Posted by Awrya

Well, it's from Miyuki point of view.
It depends on what you see as different from the LN, for example

Spoiler for LN comparison:

the scene at the cafeteria was only subtly mentioned in the LN, while the manga went into more detail.

well...the art is not at all good

[FRS]

ch5 of the spinoff has been scanlated

[Renegade334]

Rettousei ch.11 + Shucchou-ban + Yuutousei Bangai-hen are up.

Spoiler:

Ch.11 deals with Tatsuya intervening in the Club dispute and using his CAD to confuse (read: make them feel sick) his opponents. Another heir of the Families is introduced.

EDIT: After Record Report extra up, too.

[FRS]

Lots of fanservice in the side series

[Syokool]

"I want you to look more at Miyuki..."

Lot... lots of Miyuki service!

Thanks Ren

[willx]

Originally Posted by Renegade334

Rettousei ch.11 + Shucchou-ban + Yuutousei Bangai-hen are up.

Spoiler:

Ch.11 deals with Tatsuya intervening in the Club dispute and using his CAD to confuse (read: make them feel sick) his opponents. Another heir of the Families is introduced.

EDIT: After Record Report extra up, too.

Wooo! Now if only I can find it.. anyways! Yay!

[Seitsuki]

What is this and where can I get it


Now

[Renegade334]

The two users who replied to my post should know where. Just PM them (nope, ain't gonna say it out loud - must keep AS' laws happy).

[willx]

Originally Posted by Renegade334

The two users who replied to my post should know where. Just PM them (nope, ain't gonna say it out loud - must keep AS' laws happy).

Aaah, that comment tells me everything I need to know. Thanks Renegade!

[Chirst]

Special cover of Mahouka Koukou no Yuutousei vol 1

Spoiler:

[willx]

New chapter out! Amazing as always! One thing nags on me though.. It seems unlikely that Miyuki would call her brother "Tatauya" repeatedly I front of their friends.. Wouldn't she say "onisama" ?

[EnigmaticAxiom]

Originally Posted by willx

New chapter out! Amazing as always! One thing nags on me though.. It seems unlikely that Miyuki would call her brother "Tatauya" repeatedly I front of their friends.. Wouldn't she say "onisama" ?

I was thinking the same thing. Seeing Miyuki call him Tatsuya is odd to me, since most people here are fine with the "Onii-sama" deal. If they were going to go that far, I wish they would do it completely (remove all honorifics), or, at the very least, use "Brother" instead of "Tatsuya." It may be a bit more unnatural for an english speaker, but something feels wrong about her calling him Tatsuya :P

Well, either way, it's out and I'm going to enjoy it

[willx]

Originally Posted by EnigmaticAxiom

I was thinking the same thing. Seeing Miyuki call him Tatsuya is odd to me, since most people here are fine with the "Onii-sama" deal. If they were going to go that far, I wish they would do it completely (remove all honorifics), or, at the very least, use "Brother" instead of "Tatsuya." It may be a bit more unnatural for an english speaker, but something feels wrong about her calling him Tatsuya :P

Well, either way, it's out and I'm going to enjoy it

Oh, I wasn't harping on the translation .. I just wasn't sure if it was the mangaka taking liberties or not..

[SoFarGone]

what chapter would this be covered in the LN?

[Mentar]

Well, the raws are clear: Miyuki is consistently staying with "oniisama".

Larethian: Could you please relay to Suarhnir that I most politely and respectfully ask to reconsider this editing decision, and maybe rerelease with Oniisama, should the decision go this way? This is something which _massively_ alters the tone of the story and feels very "off" for fans of the series. And not just me, the feedback threads on the manga sites are full of question marks.

Thanks in any case for your efforts!

[FRS]

As usual that was a nice chapter

[Awrya]

Originally Posted by SoFarGone

what chapter would this be covered in the LN?

It covers the end of Vol.1, Ch.5 and the beginning of Vol.2, Ch.6.

I liked the battle, it was well drawn, evading and letting your opponents crash into each other.
The only thing that somehow stood out was when he used Cast Jamming against the two fencing club members, the movement was exaggerated. For a second I thought he was going SSJ1

Tsukasa reminds me of some other character, but I can't seem to remember. The closest guess would be Sai from Gundam Seed, but that's not quite it.

[Richocet]

Nice chapter, seeing the way Tatsuya portrays Juumonji seems a bit...strange(?)

[blackwhite67]

Originally Posted by Richocet

Nice chapter, seeing the way Tatsuya portrays Juumonji seems a bit...strange(?)

For the sake of your sanity, just ignore it. I hope the manga isn't going to start dedicating a whole chapter to explanations. This is just like his battle with Hanzou.