2010-08-06, 10:09 | Link #4241 | ||
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Quote:
Quote:
Either way her apparent behavior is just not the truth. So no, even if you see Erika acting that way there, it means nothing. Or rather it means nothing more than seeing Erika talking to Dlanor and making her usual metagaming. You want to give an explanation that actually make sense? Then you'd better not pay attention to what Erika is shown saying or doing.
__________________
|
||
2010-08-06, 11:24 | Link #4242 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Buffer overflow
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2010-08-06, 12:10 | Link #4243 |
Senior Member
|
Why is everyone overlooking the fact that if Battler wanted to hide, he would just leave the room?
There is no way for him to know the room is "sealed" by magical duct tape. Seeing Erika through the window is ridiculous. The curtains and shutters are generally closed on every window in the house. The room is not closed. Battler has no reason not to leave. He would normally leave the room. The lock is broken. Nothing is keeping him there. If he wants his corpse to disappear, he would not hide in the closet. The best explanation is that the door has been literally sealed, most likely by master key lock that "Erika" stole. |
2010-08-06, 12:18 | Link #4244 |
Mystery buff
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Gone Fishin!
|
Again She sealed the frame of the door with duct tape and it was never broken. That's the whole reason the logic error happened. Because that proves he didn't leave when as a GM he had planned to have his piece self do that. That's how both ends of the story don't match.
You keep saying he has every reason to leave that room, but that only works from a meta perspective. If he's faking his death he has no reason to forcefully leave the room and give that away. I'll make it even clearer. If the reason Battler's not capable of hiding anywhere, but the closet is because he was never there in the first place then the logic error would have never happened. But the chain is set Erika repaired it, Erika reset it and Battler unset it and Kanon reset it. For all these reasons The chain was not broken at the time when Battler left. That's just a fact and you have to deal with it.
__________________
Last edited by Judoh; 2010-08-06 at 12:35. |
2010-08-06, 12:30 | Link #4245 | |
Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
|
Quote:
The only person whose behavior doesn't make sense from a non-meta-world perspective is Erika's, which doesn't matter because Erika doesn't exist anyways, so her behavior being reliant on the meta-world is irrelevant and everything makes sense if you suppose "What if it wasn't Erika that entered the room." |
|
2010-08-06, 12:30 | Link #4246 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Buffer overflow
|
Quote:
Also, we don't know when Erika repaired the chain lock, but it might have been when she first entered the room. So Battler might have noticed her doing that too.
__________________
|
|
2010-08-06, 12:34 | Link #4247 | |
Mystery buff
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Gone Fishin!
|
Quote:
She pretty much has to repair the chain when she entered to reset it.
__________________
|
|
2010-08-06, 12:34 | Link #4248 | |
Junior Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
|
Quote:
Of course, with all the meta-stuff going on in this episode, it wouldn't have stopped Erika at all, but it would have humiliated her quite a bit and it would have been awesome to see her struggling to figure out who killed her and when while Battler helpfully offers some bullshit mystery explanation: "Maybe they fed you some small bombs at dinner, who knows? Wouldn't put it past Gohda." |
|
2010-08-06, 12:35 | Link #4249 | |
Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
|
Quote:
Sealing the door by taping the chain at the very beginning leaves it subject to tampering(For example slowly extricating the chain from the tape and then reattaching it without damaging the tape). There wouldn't be enough time to do so if she'd tampered with it after entering the room, since Battler would be on a time limit due to her attention only being diverted by the shower for a short moment. |
|
2010-08-06, 13:30 | Link #4251 |
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
You guys need to understand the difference between "sealed room" and "closed room". There are a few sublte but important differences.
A sealed room is a room from which it is impossible to exit without breaking a seal A closed room is a room with all the possible exists shut and the methods of locking are only possible from inside. Before Erika broke the seal, the guestroom was a sealed room. But after she broke the seal it never became a sealed room again. It became a closed room. If it was a sealed room Kanon couldn't possibly enter, and Battler couldn't possibly exit without breaking some kind of seal. This is also important because Erika's plan was not to keep Battler inside, it was to make him fall for a logic error. If she simply sealed the room, Battler would have no moves left and he'd have no choice but to tell her that the seal was broken or let Erika find Battler in the closet. But by leaving that hole open for Battler to escape she managed to make him say the reds that ultimately cornered him into a logic error. Of course this is only explainable from a metaworld perspective. Otherwise Erika had absolutely no reason to make the room a closed room instead of a sealed room.
__________________
|
2010-08-06, 13:51 | Link #4252 |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Well, she'd have reasons, but they don't square with her apparent actions.
__________________
|
2010-08-06, 14:44 | Link #4253 |
Dribble.....SHOOTOH!
Join Date: Feb 2006
|
I don't think it's that hard to explain. Since there's obviously some kind of fake death plot going on, Battler wasn't supposed to exit the room for a certain period of time, so that they could be sure that everyone who wasn't in on the plot was no longer in the mansion. When Battler is about to leave, he hears someone in the hallway. He can't leave without risking them seeing him, and he knows that a note will have been left saying that his corpse has disappeared, so he can't let whoever it is see him in the room. He sets up the trap in the bathroom to distract them and hides with the plan of sneaking out while they're otherwise occupied. However, when he goes to leave while Erika is in the bathroom, he sees the chainlock is set, and he can't leave without giving up the fact that he was in the room when she entered it. To explain why he didn't just give up the plan, you could argue that he was being manipulated like Natsuhi was in game 5 or that he saw blood on Erika and realized that she'd done something to the others.
|
2010-08-06, 15:39 | Link #4254 |
Artist
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Yesterday!
|
Now saying that Erika's scenes aren't the exact truth is obvious, but deciding that we can discard every scene with her as fake is the same as saying "there is no detective in arc 6, so everything is fake".
I do not think this is how it goes. If Erika said she sealed the windows from outside, I do not see any reason to believe she sealed them from the inside, even if it makes no sense. You would also have to think that sealing windows from inside have the ridiculous flaw that the people inside actually sees it. That would then bring the point of why anyone let Erika duct-tape the windows. I feel much more confident into believing that Erika's actions are weird then assuming that everyone else's reactions is weird. The game tells us clearly that she put on her swimsuit to put the seals on windows outside. Arbitarily deciding which scenes contains some truth and which have no truth at all about it is simply ignoring scenes that you don't like. It's really anti-thematic to the recent attemps to consider every scenes of every game to be a hint toward something. So a last thing. In arc 5 Erika put on her swimsuit, and was the detective, and put seals on windows. This is evidence that these are actions possible to her. In arc 6 she claims to have put on her swimsuit, and put seals on windows. Because of the evidence from arc 5, her claim is not only believable, but there is no evidence denying it. Putting on tapes on a window from outside, no matter how long it takes, is nothing next to the time it takes to sever off five heads. @ Moogleking Yes, you keep saying he has every reason to leave. However that simply isn't true. It's just your conjecture. |
2010-08-06, 16:01 | Link #4255 |
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Did Erika actually say she sealed any window from the outside in this episode?
Certainly if she sealed Battler's window from inside at least you can explain how come Battler knows about the seals.
__________________
|
2010-08-06, 16:13 | Link #4256 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Buffer overflow
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2010-08-06, 16:14 | Link #4257 |
Artist
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Yesterday!
|
Erika's reason to kill
She killed everyone to ... find tape on one of them... |
2010-08-06, 16:41 | Link #4258 |
Artist
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Yesterday!
|
Strictly speaking Chronotrig is right.
She didn't say so, but why would they mention the weather, and especially why would she have put on her swimsuit, to put seals inside? Swimsuit These theories make a lot less sense then accepting what we're being told as true. |
2010-08-06, 16:53 | Link #4259 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: New Zealand
|
Quote:
Quote:
Alternatively, she hopes to let Battler leave the room by breaking the chain, so she can then blame all the murders on him. Remember, she has just killed five people. She needs a scapegoat, or else she'll be torn apart by everyone else. To this end, she gives him time to escape. Quote:
She doesn't fully seal the door again because sealing it with the chain is faster. I've got no doubt that the actions are being manipulated by Meta-Erika. However they can still make sense on the gameboard. While you can make an argument for why she'd fully seal the room, it's also possible to pose a reason to just seal the chain. So Meta-Erika has both options open to her, as both are valid. She then chooses the one best for trapping Battler. |
|||
|
|