AnimeSuki Forums

NeutralZero · 2016-09-24, 01:53

It would be nice if we can often see Kaguya in her sick form/mode...

The One Above God · 2016-09-24, 02:03

How cute~. I await the day Miyuki gets to tell Kaguya just that

.

Pierre · 2016-09-24, 18:23

As much as I like this work, I feel like at this rate it will either end quickly or go the nisekoi route where basically nothing happens for a long time. I mean the author can only play these games for so many chapters, at some point you need to make them a couple and move on the story or end it. Its not a premise that really can stay interesting for too long. That was the problem in Nisekoi, author should have addressed the pendant and moved on.

Tenzen12 · 2016-09-25, 04:16

Nisekoi is popular harem, of course author will milk it as much as possible. Kaguya is vanilla gag manga so if you want make comparisons at least use Working! or Tomo-chan.

risingstar3110 · 2016-09-30, 19:33

On the latest chapter, shipping Miyuki and Fujiwara...
...because (pseudo) mom x son incest is hot

J/k aside. These chapters have increasingly crossed any chance of Miyuki x Fujiwara to ever happen. Good for you Kaguya!! I guess no choice but shipping Fujiwara and Hayasaka (Kaguya's maid) then.

Tenzen12 · 2016-10-01, 16:41

Nah, if Fujiwara x Miyuki was option these chapters could be taken as it's nterlude.

I am not trying say it is option, mind you (though being closed together in Small locker was pretty hot...).

Hoodspirit · 2016-10-10, 11:41

An entertaining series with good humour.

There is just one bigger problem for me.
The first chapter gave the impression that the two are equal in their efforts to win this 'war'.
After nearly 40 chapters though, it is pretty one-sided. Shirogane took the offensive just once in the chapter where he pretended to be asleep.
Everything else comes from Kaguya's traps and manipulations (sometimes from a third person) where he just defends.
While the title of the Manga might justifies this, the repeated setting given within the first chapters do not allow this imbalance.

As long as it keeps to be entertaining I will follow it, but I really hope that this gap in effort in this 'war' will get smaller soon.

risingstar3110 · 2016-10-21, 21:30

Kaguya bitterness over Fujiwara was the best! And her sudden switch too.

The sister is interesting in Kaguya... ahaha. Sibling has similar taste

Diluc · 2016-10-21, 22:26

Learning the sister is the treasurer make me think if the author will make a spin off in middle school council president with the imouto and her friends become the focus.
I definitely will read that!

Wandering Soul · 2016-10-22, 15:05

The little sister finally makes her appearance. Siblings really do have similar tastes.

The part where Kaguya spends a few panels hating Fujiwara only to change her attitude was hilarious.

Ulin · 2016-10-22, 17:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wandering Soul

The part where Kaguya spends a few panels hating Fujiwara only to change her attitude was hilarious.

Best part of the chapter by far. I'm really looking forward to all that happening and exploding in Kaguya's face

RRW · 2016-11-27, 01:49

T_T

Tenzen12 · 2016-11-27, 01:56

Where did my romcom went ?

Ulin · 2016-11-27, 03:52

Pretty depressing chapter... I guess the fireworks battle (or at least I hope) will be solved with a victory for both of them

The One Above God · 2016-11-27, 11:40

I didn't expect such a...heavy chapter. Miyuki better pull it off.

Wandering Soul · 2016-11-27, 15:05

That was depressing. Luckily Miyuki is on his way.

RRW · 2016-12-04, 23:45

Kaguya chapter 45 certainly become one of the best title drop in history of manga.

The chapter is prefect

Wandering Soul · 2016-12-05, 22:31

Excellent chapter. I cheered at the end and the way they used a title drop was cool.

OH&S · 2016-12-07, 04:32

I was promised Shirogane bad-assery and that's what I got. The drama from the previous chapter was completely washed out by the second half of this chapter.

I'm also in agreement with the awesome title drop at the end.

Hoodspirit · 2016-12-07, 08:57

It's one sided against Kaguya once more. After the drama from last week, at least give her an even ground with Shirogane for a conclusion. But no, he remains the superior unfazed shining white knight till the end. "I'll know you would think of hiding in this alley behind a staircase in this big town despite never seeing you hiding before, since the only time outside of school we met was a messed up cinema visit." Wasn't this seinen?

This Manga was supposed to be a war of love with the usage of logic by both sides, not an one-sided massacre. We're 45 chapters in and Shirogane's only plot was to fake sleep.

Our genius Kaguya, who would probably read the whole ToS before agreeing and most likely also the FAQ and Help section whenever she runs into troubles, still can't set up a protected Twitter account like she wanted? Even that is straying too far from the premise of the manga at the cost of cheap comedy.

I ranted more than I wanted too, sorry. But at least that made me realise that this is probably not a series for me anymore. I wish everyone who sticks with it an enjoyable journey.

2016-09-24, 02:03	Link #22
The One Above God Kamijou Join Date: May 2014 Location: I'm Everywhere	How cute~. I await the day Miyuki gets to tell Kaguya just that . __________________ *"I'll destroy that illusion!"*

2016-09-25, 04:16	Link #24
Tenzen12 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012	Nisekoi is popular harem, of course author will milk it as much as possible. Kaguya is vanilla gag manga so if you want make comparisons at least use Working! or Tomo-chan. __________________ "I am convinced that life is 10% what happens to me and 90% of how I react to it" (Charles R. Swindoll)

2016-09-30, 19:33	Link #25
risingstar3110 ✘˵╹◡╹˶✘ Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Australia	On the latest chapter, shipping Miyuki and Fujiwara... ...because (pseudo) mom x son incest is hot J/k aside. These chapters have increasingly crossed any chance of Miyuki x Fujiwara to ever happen. Good for you Kaguya!! I guess no choice but shipping Fujiwara and Hayasaka (Kaguya's maid) then. __________________

2016-10-01, 16:41	Link #26
Tenzen12 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012	Nah, if Fujiwara x Miyuki was option these chapters could be taken as it's nterlude. I am not trying say it is option, mind you (though being closed together in Small locker was pretty hot...). __________________ "I am convinced that life is 10% what happens to me and 90% of how I react to it" (Charles R. Swindoll)

2016-10-21, 21:30	Link #28
risingstar3110 ✘˵╹◡╹˶✘ Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Australia	Kaguya bitterness over Fujiwara was the best! And her sudden switch too. The sister is interesting in Kaguya... ahaha. Sibling has similar taste __________________

2016-09-24, 01:53	Link #21
NeutralZero Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: Earth	It would be nice if we can often see Kaguya in her sick form/mode...

2016-09-24, 18:23	Link #23
Pierre Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2014	As much as I like this work, I feel like at this rate it will either end quickly or go the nisekoi route where basically nothing happens for a long time. I mean the author can only play these games for so many chapters, at some point you need to make them a couple and move on the story or end it. Its not a premise that really can stay interesting for too long. That was the problem in Nisekoi, author should have addressed the pendant and moved on.

2016-10-10, 11:41	Link #27
Hoodspirit Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2009	An entertaining series with good humour. There is just one bigger problem for me. The first chapter gave the impression that the two are equal in their efforts to win this 'war'. After nearly 40 chapters though, it is pretty one-sided. Shirogane took the offensive just once in the chapter where he pretended to be asleep. Everything else comes from Kaguya's traps and manipulations (sometimes from a third person) where he just defends. While the title of the Manga might justifies this, the repeated setting given within the first chapters do not allow this imbalance. As long as it keeps to be entertaining I will follow it, but I really hope that this gap in effort in this 'war' will get smaller soon.

2016-10-21, 22:26	Link #29
Diluc Darkhero of Monstadt Join Date: May 2015 Location: rich mansion with maids	Learning the sister is the treasurer make me think if the author will make a spin off in middle school council president with the imouto and her friends become the focus. I definitely will read that!

2016-10-22, 15:05	Link #30
Wandering Soul Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2013 Location: America	The little sister finally makes her appearance. Siblings really do have similar tastes. The part where Kaguya spends a few panels hating Fujiwara only to change her attitude was hilarious. __________________

2016-11-27, 01:56	Link #33
Tenzen12 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2012	Where did my romcom went ? __________________ "I am convinced that life is 10% what happens to me and 90% of how I react to it" (Charles R. Swindoll)

2016-11-27, 03:52	Link #34
Ulin Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2015 Location: Spain	Pretty depressing chapter... I guess the fireworks battle (or at least I hope) will be solved with a victory for both of them

2016-11-27, 11:40	Link #35
The One Above God Kamijou Join Date: May 2014 Location: I'm Everywhere	I didn't expect such a...heavy chapter. Miyuki better pull it off. __________________ *"I'll destroy that illusion!"*

2016-11-27, 15:05	Link #36
Wandering Soul Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2013 Location: America	That was depressing. Luckily Miyuki is on his way. __________________

2016-12-05, 22:31	Link #38
Wandering Soul Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2013 Location: America	Excellent chapter. I cheered at the end and the way they used a title drop was cool. __________________

2016-12-07, 04:32	Link #39
OH&S Index III was a mistake Join Date: Jul 2013 Location: Sydney, Australia Age: 32	I was promised Shirogane bad-assery and that's what I got. The drama from the previous chapter was completely washed out by the second half of this chapter. I'm also in agreement with the awesome title drop at the end. __________________

2016-12-07, 08:57	Link #40
Hoodspirit Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2009	It's one sided against Kaguya once more. After the drama from last week, at least give her an even ground with Shirogane for a conclusion. But no, he remains the superior unfazed shining white knight till the end. "I'll know you would think of hiding in this alley behind a staircase in this big town despite never seeing you hiding before, since the only time outside of school we met was a messed up cinema visit." Wasn't this seinen? This Manga was supposed to be a war of love with the usage of logic by both sides, not an one-sided massacre. We're 45 chapters in and Shirogane's only plot was to fake sleep. Our genius Kaguya, who would probably read the whole ToS before agreeing and most likely also the FAQ and Help section whenever she runs into troubles, still can't set up a protected Twitter account like she wanted? Even that is straying too far from the premise of the manga at the cost of cheap comedy. I ranted more than I wanted too, sorry. But at least that made me realise that this is probably not a series for me anymore. I wish everyone who sticks with it an enjoyable journey.