Madoka Magica - General Discussion

[sa547]

Originally Posted by Da_Box

now it all makes sense

wikipedia only listed 10

so i wondered

The maintainer (or whoever authored the entry) forgot to update it.

As the 'Pedia there doesn't get updated properly, you can look up for more information here instead (this really is a clearinghouse of anything connected to Madoka): http://wiki.puella-magi.net/

[Suzuku]

More comparison pics of Mami's room:

Spoiler:

As expected of SHAFT, Mami's room is completely redrawn in the BDs in pretty much every scene.

[MaiNoKen]

I am sure some subbing group will re-sub the series with BD raws I am looking forward to it!

[Seihai]

I still can't get over the fact that Homura had to suffer this much, that Sayaka in the end disappeared, that Madoka is shut off somewhere, that there're no more "kuuka?" scenes from awesome Kyoko, and a cat that was run over by a truck. I'm so weak! There's still the BDs plus the different Magica mangas, I need to get a hold of myself.

[momobunny]

So the cat still dies each time? Is that actually told in the story or can I still imagine that Homura goes through the extra trouble of saving the poor thing from being hit? ^^;

[Seihai]

It wasn't mentioned but going by Homura's nature and epicness, I believe there's no trouble for her to save a cat or two. It wasn't that unimportant to her when she met it, and it was special enough for Madoka to make a wish for it once, plus they both love cats. And it's even got a sweet name, Amy!

[momobunny]

Originally Posted by Vanish

It wasn't mentioned but going by Homura's nature and epicness, I believe there's no trouble for her to save a cat or two. It wasn't that unimportant to her when she met it, and it was special enough for Madoka to make a wish for it once, plus they both love cats. And it's even got a sweet name, Amy!

Yeah, I really wanna just keep my image of Homura the way it is... her letting a poor kitty die like that would ruin it. So I'm just gonna imagine her saving cute little Amy in each loop. :3

[Shadow5YA]

I don't think Homura knew about the cat until Madoka mentioned it. Madoka originally made her wish when she went out on her own before Homura met her. Since Homura wasn't there at the scene, she didn't really directly prevent Madoka from saving the cat. It's just that Madoka didn't go out to ponder because of Kyubey, so she never met the cat.

[sa547]

That magnificent jackass... Butch Gen changed his Twitter avatar to one with shimapan.
http://twitter.com/intent/user?screen_name=Butch_Gen

Naughty, naughty!

[Sheba]

Originally Posted by MaiNoKen

I am sure some subbing group will re-sub the series with BD raws I am looking forward to it!

Can someone PLEASE tell them that .avi needs love too. I would love to watch the BD release on my TV but my decoder won't read mkv and mp4. And no, purchasing a new one that read them all is NOT an option in the immediate and short term future.

[Snork]

I'm really LESS than a fan of MKV myself, but it's popular now. I heard it's basically a container format, and releasing modern raws in pure AVI would make them weigh about 1 Gb each. All because nowadays you're not a real man if you don't watch anime in a resolution big enough to fill a house wall.

Yeah, I really wanna just keep my image of Homura the way it is... her letting a poor kitty die like that would ruin it. So I'm just gonna imagine her saving cute little Amy in each loop. :3

Provided that she KNEW when and where the accident took place.
But it seems to have happened after the day Homura's usually returned to - otherwise, Madoka would have appeared contract-bound every time.

[Shadow5YA]

Can anyone translate the 4koma that came in the booklet with the BD?

[kaigan]

Originally Posted by Shadow5YA

Can anyone translate the 4koma that came in the booklet with the BD?

someone made these:


http://forums.animesuki.com/showthre...94#post3590394

http://forums.animesuki.com/showthre...19#post3590519

[Kanon]

Originally Posted by Suzuku

More comparison pics of Mami's room:

Spoiler:

As expected of SHAFT, Mami's room is completely redrawn in the BDs in pretty much every scene.

I wish they had fixed what needed fixing the most too: the character animation.



Being meguca is suffering...

[sa547]

Oh, you beaten me to the punch! But here's some other news -- the BD sales figures and the defective disc recall:

http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news...nuary-anime-bd

[Xacual]

Originally Posted by sa547

Oh, you beaten me to the punch! But here's some other news -- the BD sales figures and the defective disc recall:

http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news...nuary-anime-bd

Defective disc is now a collector's item...

[Jimmy C]

They said the recall applies to the limited edition BD, does that mean the standard edition BD doesn't have the error? Is there even a standard edition BD?

[Snork]

First time I've heard of there being different editions, actually. Sony never stops being Sony.

I wish they had fixed what needed fixing the most too: the character animation.

In this particular case you screencapped, I don't mind at all. Sayaka's expression is priceless.

[applejuice]

Mado Magi vol 1 sold 22,000 in one day, regardless of defect.
http://animapple.blogspot.com/2011/0...les-22000.html

I repeat, it is 'A SINGLE DAY' sales.

Edited: Awwww.... I was late.

Originally Posted by sa547

Oh, you beaten me to the punch! But here's some other news -- the BD sales figures and the defective disc recall:

http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news...nuary-anime-bd

[mols]

Nothing to do with the BD sales and such, but I read something about entropy and time travel... I couldn't stop from sharing

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/n...space-science/

Sorry from bringing real life subjects into anime forums lol