AnimeSuki Forums

fmafanatic · 2006-04-26, 02:37

i love al especially in the movie u know and the dubbed voices are all good i know cause ive seen the jap and eng

hikaru_masha · 2006-04-26, 08:53

Ed! No contest! I love him to peices!

Spectacular_Insanity · 2006-04-26, 16:37

fmafanatic: Your avatar is awesome. I remember that episode...

nessy · 2006-04-26, 23:28

Al's kind of boring to me.
Ed, on the other hand.. is extremely entertaining

and also, i can relate to him about being short </3

Orichi · 2006-04-27, 15:05

Ed is way more interesting, especially when someone says that he's short.
Then he flies off the handle, it's rather quite amusing.
Also, Ed seems to be more willing to break rules than Al.
Ed is also, one of the only ones who can do alchemy without a circle.
Except for his teacher and Wrath.

Soka-chan · 2006-04-28, 05:09

They're both interesting on their own.I choose Ed, but not cause he's "more interesting".I think that Al is a unique individual, but I like him IN RELATION to his brother.I like Al, I like thinking Al...he's got much to think about...I like loving Al, understanding Al and...I' like to see a bit more of jealous Al, seeing as he's a teenager and always shadowed by his brother.

His genius brother.his loud, bad-mouthed, bad-tempered and just plain special brother. It's difficult to have a perfect, interesting, special(and specially-treated)brother, more entertaining, powerful, charming and brash than you.Everyone looks to him, IT'S ALWAYS ABOUT ED.

That's why I like the both of them so much, but Ed more, cause he's the boy I'd want to meet and fight with if I could choose between them.Two things I like the most: he's strong(strong-minded, strong-willed and strong-hearted)and he's passionate.

fadingwind · 2006-04-30, 15:33

I like Ed more than Al, I guess. I find Al's politeness and kindness too annoying sometimes, although he can be quite cute. I like Ed more because he protests about his lack of height in such a interesting and entertaining way. And he's just so funny and rude and... Ed. That's all I can say, really.

nataliel · 2006-08-22, 07:34

Definitely, Al!
I think, he is more reasonable and calm then Ed (and more handsome

).
He is really strong and patient.
And loving little brother.
However, he turns to be annoying a little bit in "Conqueror of Shambala"...

Bladealchemist · 2006-08-22, 18:45

Ed is extremely funny and you have to admit that transmutation without a circle is awesome.

nataliel · 2006-08-23, 11:51

Can you agree with me?
Ed is really not surprising as "the mainest" character.
Almost everything he does, he does as expected from a main good guy.
I think, Al turns to be annoying in Shambala from the same reason...

So, in the FMA series - Al is better.
In the Shambala - Ed rules.

Gaara. · 2006-08-23, 14:53

Eh Ed without a question..

Al is more like a side person X.x
Whole movie he doesnt really talks...If he talks he talk about the past...(((

Ed is more active person...so probably this is why he is my fav

Yazakura · 2006-08-23, 15:01

I chose Al, hands down.

@ Gaara: Really? If I recall correctly, they spend half of the whole series trying to get his body back. If not all of it....you really think he's that insignificant of a charcter?

Gaara. · 2006-08-23, 15:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yazakura

I chose Al, hands down.

@ Gaara: Really? If I recall correctly, they spend half of the whole series trying to get his body back. If not all of it....you really think he's that insignificant of a charcter?

well yeah...hes too quiet and he usually doesnt take any action in fighting. I didnt meant to say it as a side character...but its more like that dunno how to explain it >.< i think u understand what im saying :P

i0td · 2006-09-05, 19:40

I haven't voted yet, but currently I'm leaning more towards Al only because he displays an aura of calm and is the more restrained of the two. Of course, Ed's whimsical nature does make him much more entertaining to watch. He is a magnet that draws in all sorts of excitement.

felix · 2006-09-06, 06:34

Quote:

Ed's whimsical nature does make him much more entertaining to watch. He is a magnet that draws in all sorts of excitement.

lol...
That's exactly why I voted ed

..::Hacker::.. · 2006-10-08, 12:50

I have to say that Al is my favorite out of the two because he is so sweet, he loves animals and someone has to stop Ed when he starts fuming

Kilala642 · 2006-10-08, 13:38

I agree with ..::Hacker::.. word for word with that one except I have to say I like both of them!

shimplicity · 2006-10-10, 07:05

I voted for Ed

Ed is HILARIOUS, a very good older brother, responsible and realistic.

Al is cute, sweet, innocent and slightly immature.

To get something powerful and dangerous aka philospher stone and not wanting anyone to get hurt is just naive. It's something like hoping for no casualties in a war when a war is not without casualties. but i totally understand Al being the softie while Ed is the rough and tough guy.

They complement each other which makes them equally lovable.

p.s Al's human face is better looking and cuter than Ed.. I guess that's the reason he was turned into a tinman so that he wouldn't steal the show from Ed. =p

Queen Izayoi · 2006-11-18, 23:46

Ed, no doubt ~_^

fullmetalMonkey · 2006-12-28, 16:01

edward cause he is like i little bomb make him angey and die

View Poll Results: Al or Ed who do you like the most?
Al	59	24.18%
Ed	185	75.82%
Voters: 244. You may not vote on this poll

2006-04-26, 16:37	Link #43
Spectacular_Insanity Ha ha ha ha ha... Graphic Designer Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Right behind you. Age: 35	fmafanatic: Your avatar is awesome. I remember that episode... __________________

2006-04-26, 02:37	Link #41
fmafanatic Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2006	i love al especially in the movie u know and the dubbed voices are all good i know cause ive seen the jap and eng

2006-04-26, 08:53	Link #42
hikaru_masha I want chocolate! Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Mississauga, Ontario, Canada Age: 36	Ed! No contest! I love him to peices!

2006-04-26, 23:28	Link #44
nessy Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2006	Al's kind of boring to me. Ed, on the other hand.. is extremely entertaining and also, i can relate to him about being short </3

2006-04-27, 15:05	Link #45
Orichi Member Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Canada Age: 39	Ed is way more interesting, especially when someone says that he's short. Then he flies off the handle, it's rather quite amusing. Also, Ed seems to be more willing to break rules than Al. Ed is also, one of the only ones who can do alchemy without a circle. Except for his teacher and Wrath.

2006-04-28, 05:09	Link #46
Soka-chan Member Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Madrid Age: 38	They're both interesting on their own.I choose Ed, but not cause he's "more interesting".I think that Al is a unique individual, but I like him IN RELATION to his brother.I like Al, I like thinking Al...he's got much to think about...I like loving Al, understanding Al and...I' like to see a bit more of jealous Al, seeing as he's a teenager and always shadowed by his brother. His genius brother.his loud, bad-mouthed, bad-tempered and just plain special brother. It's difficult to have a perfect, interesting, special(and specially-treated)brother, more entertaining, powerful, charming and brash than you.Everyone looks to him, IT'S ALWAYS ABOUT ED. That's why I like the both of them so much, but Ed more, cause he's the boy I'd want to meet and fight with if I could choose between them.Two things I like the most: he's strong(strong-minded, strong-willed and strong-hearted)and he's passionate.

2006-04-30, 15:33	Link #47
fadingwind Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: HK	I like Ed more than Al, I guess. I find Al's politeness and kindness too annoying sometimes, although he can be quite cute. I like Ed more because he protests about his lack of height in such a interesting and entertaining way. And he's just so funny and rude and... Ed. That's all I can say, really.

2006-08-22, 07:34	Link #48
nataliel Member Join Date: May 2006 Age: 40	Definitely, Al! I think, he is more reasonable and calm then Ed (and more handsome ). He is really strong and patient. And loving little brother. However, he turns to be annoying a little bit in "Conqueror of Shambala"...

2006-08-22, 18:45	Link #49
Bladealchemist Junior Member Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Wouldn't you like to know? Age: 33	Ed is extremely funny and you have to admit that transmutation without a circle is awesome.

2006-08-23, 11:51	Link #50
nataliel Member Join Date: May 2006 Age: 40	Can you agree with me? Ed is really not surprising as "the mainest" character. Almost everything he does, he does as expected from a main good guy. I think, Al turns to be annoying in Shambala from the same reason... So, in the FMA series - Al is better. In the Shambala - Ed rules.

2006-08-23, 14:53	Link #51
Gaara. Only God can Judge me Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: US	Eh Ed without a question.. Al is more like a side person X.x Whole movie he doesnt really talks...If he talks he talk about the past...((( Ed is more active person...so probably this is why he is my fav

2006-08-23, 15:01	Link #52
Yazakura Enigma of Nothing Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Seattle WA, USA	I chose Al, hands down. @ Gaara: Really? If I recall correctly, they spend half of the whole series trying to get his body back. If not all of it....you really think he's that insignificant of a charcter?

2006-09-05, 19:40	Link #54
i0td Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Desert, USA Age: 37	I haven't voted yet, but currently I'm leaning more towards Al only because he displays an aura of calm and is the more restrained of the two. Of course, Ed's whimsical nature does make him much more entertaining to watch. He is a magnet that draws in all sorts of excitement.

2006-10-08, 12:50	Link #56
..::Hacker::.. Alone, not Lonely Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Sitting by someone I'm in love with but can't have because he already shattered my heart	I have to say that Al is my favorite out of the two because he is so sweet, he loves animals and someone has to stop Ed when he starts fuming

2006-10-08, 13:38	Link #57
Kilala642 FMA Freak Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: In T.V. land	I agree with ..::Hacker::.. word for word with that one except I have to say I like both of them!

2006-10-10, 07:05	Link #58
shimplicity Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2006 Age: 35	I voted for Ed Ed is HILARIOUS, a very good older brother, responsible and realistic. Al is cute, sweet, innocent and slightly immature. To get something powerful and dangerous aka philospher stone and not wanting anyone to get hurt is just naive. It's something like hoping for no casualties in a war when a war is not without casualties. but i totally understand Al being the softie while Ed is the rough and tough guy. They complement each other which makes them equally lovable. p.s Al's human face is better looking and cuter than Ed.. I guess that's the reason he was turned into a tinman so that he wouldn't steal the show from Ed. =p

2006-11-18, 23:46	Link #59
Queen Izayoi Inutaisho's Kitten Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Wherever you want me to be ~_^	Ed, no doubt ~_^

2006-12-28, 16:01	Link #60
fullmetalMonkey fma obessed monkey Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: stuck to my chair bad prank some1 save me	edward cause he is like i little bomb make him angey and die