High School DxD BorN - Episode 10 Discussion / Poll

[Chichiryuushintei]

Originally Posted by ImperialFlameGod8190

I've stayed away but now u got me involved big mistake.

So tell me first off what do u think vol 5 vol 6 and vol 7 tried to prove and tell me if you think the anime proved them

By the way nobody else get involved in this conversation its between me and this person

I ask right back at you, how any of the changes made any real difference of continuity from the source material.

This is the internet. If I want to get into a discussion, I can.

[ImperialFlameGod8190]

Originally Posted by moodie

here lemme clear things up so i dont make an ass of myself. i havent read the novels

"rearrange all u want as long as we get the point of what the 3 novels were trying to prove" this statement i made was a general statement. if this adaption gets the point of what the three novels are trying to prove them i feel like im not left out of the source material. i never said that "this adaption IS doing that."

please dont be intimidating i was just adding on to the statement Chichiryuushintei posted. im well aware u know more about the dxd series more than me so go easy on me.

I'm in a good mood so fine then we'll end this discussion and the topic however i will make a warning in the future.

by making the statement you did you already made an ass out of yourself. because here's the difference between you and Chichi

You only understand THAT we "source material fags" are complaining. What you fail to understand is WHY we are complaining. Without reading the material you have no right to give us grief about complaining because u dont understand the problem. Chichi understands why we are complaining he just disagrees with it though i get the sense Chichi is also the type who as long as he gets to see what he wants he doesnt really care about anything else.

[ImperialFlameGod8190]

Originally Posted by Chichiryuushintei

I ask right back at you, how any of the changes made any real difference of continuity from the source material.

This is the internet. If I want to get into a discussion, I can.

Chichi i'm going to send my response to you via PM.

[Relthenar]

Originally Posted by Chichiryuushintei

of course the source material is flawed. I'm a huge DxD fanboy who has been reading the LN for years, and there are flaws in it.

I think this is going to be a case of where we will just have to disagree. I Also have been reading DxD for years. And I don't think the material is "flawed" at all. I have been writing stories for years and it isn't flawed. Granted things don't always go as smoothly as the reader wants it to, but that is not a flaw, but rather how the author wants it or as he has put it out. (those kind of things are supposed to be caught and fixed by the editor).

Also, like I said it was never in your face, but the trauma caused by Reynare is always there in the story. It is subtle in most cases, but it is always there. I recognized it right from the start. It just was never blatant. And to be honest, subtle reminders make the final resolution that much stronger. To always have it in your face, when it comes time to resolve it, most people are so sick of it. The anime by putting so blatant in your face makes it more tiring and stupid then something that makes sense.

[Kirihara_R]

hahaha , Rias getting swayed by her emotions by seeing Asia and Isse getting along with each other , whats more what is that clone guy doing there? .. is that their way of fixing the flaws of the Ln .. ? .. ok fine lets just accept that..

[DOmus]

Will be honest, the autoNTR made the chapter for me(I remembered one doujin of DxD with the same plot of another Issei). It was good, wanna see how it goes from now on.
inb4, more Rias NTR doujins

[Rising Dragon]

God, this is going to be a miserable week in this forum.

[ImperialFlameGod8190]

Originally Posted by Rising Dragon

God, this is going to be a miserable week in this forum.

We have two more besides this one so its gonna be a fun last 3 weeks.

[Seafoam]

Originally Posted by DOmus

Will be honest, the autoNTR made the chapter for me(I remembered one doujin of DxD with the same plot of another Issei). It was good, wanna see how it goes from now on.
inb4, more Rias NTR doujins

This episode just basically made the idea of the MC ntr'ing himself.

[Chichiryuushintei]

Originally Posted by Relthenar

I think this is going to be a case of where we will just have to disagree. I Also have been reading DxD for years. And I don't think the material is "flawed" at all. I have been writing stories for years and it isn't flawed. Granted things don't always go as smoothly as the reader wants it to, but that is not a flaw, but rather how the author wants it or as he has put it out. (those kind of things are supposed to be caught and fixed by the editor).

Also, like I said it was never in your face, but the trauma caused by Reynare is always there in the story. It is subtle in most cases, but it is always there. I recognized it right from the start. It just was never blatant. And to be honest, subtle reminders make the final resolution that much stronger. To always have it in your face, when it comes time to resolve it, most people are so sick of it. The anime by putting so blatant in your face makes it more tiring and stupid then something that makes sense.

Yeah, sure, because Loki being retarded enough to retreat when he's winning in the LN version of the first fight is not a flaw. I can even say a few more if you want me to.

I repeat: There wasn't any hints of anything before v9 except for a fraction of a paragraph in v4. Whenever Ise was in a steamy situation, he never ever had any thoughts that hinted at Reynare or anything. Just how much he loved being in such situations.

[RawHunter]

Originally Posted by moodie

this is why i absolutely hate "source material fags" they want a carbon copy of the adaption rather than a ADAPTION that is able to fix up issues with the source material. this is one of the few rare cases where it actually is fixing things rather than fucking things up.

Indeed I agree with you maybe Some LN fans might Expect too much from "TNK" too pull off a near Perfection/Loyal to Source Materials But i do hope S3 events does not affect Vol~10 Epicness..(If its Animated)

[Om Nerabdator]

Originally Posted by moodie

this is why i absolutely hate "source material fags" they want a carbon copy of the adaption rather than a ADAPTION that is able to fix up issues with the source material. this is one of the few rare cases where it actually is fixing things rather than fucking things up. hey guys u still have ur novels so stop crying. this is a 12 episode adaption and its doing a good job at it.

only thing the anime "fixed" is Ise trauma, cause honestly im pretty sure the author just made that up for vol10.
Anyway i see the anime as just a bonus to the LN, i cant take it seriously at all, but its still nice to see some scenes animated if they didnt just skip right over them.

[Chichiryuushintei]

Originally Posted by Om Nerabdator

only thing the anime "fixed" is Ise trauma, cause honestly im pretty sure the author just made that up for vol10.
Anyway i see the anime as just a bonus to the LN, i cant take it seriously at all, but its still nice to see some scenes animated if they didnt just skip right over them.

Wait, you actually take the LN seriously? O_O

[Wandering Soul]

Originally Posted by Rising Dragon

God, this is going to be a miserable week in this forum.

Got that right, though that should be expected considering that there was going to be anime original content.

[Rising Dragon]

If it's something the LN's author worked on and approved of, I'm okay with that. In the meantime, I'm glad I started with the anime first, 'cause I'd rather not poison myself with LNs. Again.

[The Green One]

Ah man watching the people in these threads act like this is the high point of my Saturday.

[Archilla]

Boy, that escalated quickly.

[Malicre]

Originally Posted by Sacredus

Like they care about source material at all -.-



It was in novels? No? So it's a filler.

I will just finish series after it ends... if they dind't go to anime only ending that would kill any chances for next season (if it will ever happens, let's hope it would better adaptation).

You can't argue with fanboys, don't even bother trying.

[Chichiryuushintei]

Originally Posted by Malicre

You can't argue with fanboys, don't even bother trying.

Yeah, because the definition of filler has everything to do with personal opinion... oh wait it doesn't.

[DragoMuseveni]

Kinda backdown ...... i don`t know how to feel about this episode ..... it might get ise in jd a second time or not ..... average episode i guess