2010-04-10, 22:40 | Link #7901 | |
Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Classified
|
Quote:
Out of curiosity, where is Kanon supposedly while this is going on? |
|
2010-04-10, 22:40 | Link #7902 | |
The Great Dine
Join Date: Feb 2009
|
Quote:
Actually it makes me wonder if the small theory I'm trying to get evidence for may hold some water. |
|
2010-04-10, 23:13 | Link #7903 | |
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
Quote:
What's interesting is that it seems that Jessica is surprised that nobody greets them at the guesthouse, because she immediately asks if there was a schedule change. |
|
2010-04-11, 01:41 | Link #7905 |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Kanon is, generally speaking, AWOL for much of the 4th, from about the early afternoon when he's encountered in the garden until well into the evening. If you favor Shkanon, you have an easy enough explanation for that (since Shannon's position is known during this time), but if you don't... just what was he up to?
|
2010-04-11, 02:46 | Link #7906 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Buffer overflow
|
Okay, finally found the quote I've been looking for. This is from the post-EP5 Ryuukishi interview, but it looks a lot more interesting after EP6 and possible Shkanontrice:
Quote:
__________________
Last edited by chronotrig; 2010-04-11 at 02:57. |
|
2010-04-11, 02:51 | Link #7907 |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Beatrice has been portrayed as the black queen multiple times. I don't recall her ever being described as the king piece. In fact, ep6 more or less reinforces that she can be (or has been) every piece but the king, and it doesn't seem like this is changing.
By contrast, I think Battler has been described as the king piece. And there's the whole Maria's crown thing. Other than that, little has been said as to which pieces are important in chess, or indeed if the game is even chess to begin with (given some of the anti-chess analogies, like the drawing-on-the-chessboard example or the Shogi thing). |
2010-04-11, 07:36 | Link #7908 |
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Battler has been called white king in Ep4 and black king in Ep6
Beatrice has always been compared to the black queen. In any case the King must be a piece that once cornered (you can't remove the king no matter what you can only checkmate it) the game ends. Ryukishi says that Beatrice calls this king "her heart" and it still remains on the gameboard. What's Beatrice's heart? It might be her original personality. I really doubt that it's Maria anyway.
__________________
|
2010-04-11, 07:39 | Link #7909 | |
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
Quote:
|
|
2010-04-11, 08:05 | Link #7910 |
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
One more good reason the Kinzo phantom conspiracy can exist regardless of the financial pressure.
Krauss or Natsuhi have discovered the gold. However, gold is not currency according to law, it's a commodity and therefore, it's property! According to Japanese law, up until 2003, the tax rate on the property valued at 20 billion yen would reach 70%, which is impossible to pay, and would result in the gold going to the government. Even if the gold was not discovered but was known to exist, this fate would befall the island land itself, which could eventually result in a chance that someone else would discover the gold! Machinations required to bypass inheritance tax can take an extended period of time and could not be performed while Kinzo, dissatisfied with his heirs, was alive, and gift tax is nothing to sneeze at either. |
2010-04-11, 08:24 | Link #7911 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
|
I've been rereading episode one a little and I found something very strange. Right after lunch, after the scene where Battler asks Shannon about the sour sauce the family is having for dessert, Shannon and Kumasawa talk in the hallway. Kumasawa tells Shannon that Shannon is free until the evening, even though she later tells the kids at the beach that she has to hurry back to work after spending some time with them. I'm not sure how much time she spends helping Kumasawa cleaning the rooms, but there is a clear contradiction here.
|
2010-04-11, 08:32 | Link #7912 |
Mystery buff
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Gone Fishin!
|
I don't know how you could get Shkanon from that interview. I guess the word "personality" is important. Although I think it's suggesting that all the episodes are stages in a single game board. It could be chess or chinese checkers and it wouldn't make a difference.
Of course Beatrice is inactive we already knew that. The way I see it is if I look at it like chess is that she escaped "check" in episode 3, went "on the attack" to the human side in 4, and lost authority over her own piece at the end of 4 when Battler killed her.
__________________
|
2010-04-11, 08:35 | Link #7913 | |
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
Quote:
|
|
2010-04-11, 11:48 | Link #7914 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Buffer overflow
|
Quote:
I didn't say it supports Shkanon specifically, but it does support some kind of Kanontrice/Shannontrice/Shkanontrice. The queen would literally represent the Beatrice personality, whereas the king would represent Kanon/Shannon/Sayo herself. In the answer arcs, the Beatrice personality never takes action, so Sayo is no longer the murderer. The secret of "who does the Beatrice personality belong to?" must be solved before the game can be. Also, this would seem to imply that an entirely different culprit takes action in the core arcs, unless Sayo has yet another personality.
__________________
|
|
2010-04-11, 12:26 | Link #7915 |
Mystery buff
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Gone Fishin!
|
I think what's constantly hinted is that Beatrice is made to look like she's the culprit. She's a superstition or a cover story. An actual person dressing up as Beatrice and killing all but 5 people just isn't humanly possible without well "her Furniture" or accomplices ( if you want to beleive she actually controls anyone). I think that's where we disconnect.
__________________
Last edited by Judoh; 2010-04-11 at 12:45. |
2010-04-11, 12:30 | Link #7916 | |
Back off, I'm a scientist
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: In a badly written story.
|
Quote:
But speaking of cheap tricks, I've stumbled on something interesting in Ep1. Eva and Hideyoshi leave for their guest room, saying that nobody should follow them. The next unreliable scene implies it is the same guest room that they stayed in prior to construction of the guest house. If it is, anyone except Battler should be well aware which one it is exactly. Later on, Genji and Kanon come to fetch them and find the sound of TV inside, lights on, and a letter by the door, with nobody answering. Genji picks up the letter, then orders Kanon to fetch the cutter, then goes with him. It is never said what did he do to the letter afterwards. Then, Kanon and Kumasawa come back. The door now contains a drawing that could not possibly be completed while Kanon was away and narration remarks on that. And the letter is there again. Either Genji dropped it or someone added a new one, but if someone did, the one Genji took apparently vanishes for no good reason, so he probably dropped it in his haste. It's easy to assume that the narration is lying and the pantacle was there already, because this helps solving the closed room by implicating Kanon and Kumasawa. But what if it's just a different room? The rooms are all very similar, "hotel rooms" the text says, but it is never mentioned they're marked or numbered. They're probably identical internally and externally. Multiple rooms on the same floor had to have been prepared for the adults -- at least three, one more for Kyrie and Rudolf, and one for Rosa and Maria. They're probably adjacent. It is in Eva and Hideyoshi's interest, if they want to avoid being targeted, to pick a different one to their usual one from years ago. Only Battler doesn't know which one it is. If Eva really mistrusts the servants so much it's quite sensible. Can they? Probably, they had multiple opportunities to acquire keys or master keys, and it is never mentioned how did they acquire the key to the one they planned to go to. Possibly, they were given an opportunity to just take one from a set, and they could take two. The remark that they don't want to be followed would be a hint that they want to go to a different room in this case. For safety, they turn on the lights and the TV in the other room, so that a murderer would not be able to determine which room they are in by looking from outside, and actually reside in a room further down the corridor than they would normally take. Alternatively, the lights and TV are turned on in their old room because a murderer is hiding in there. Genji, assuming out of habit that they took their usual one, tries the door, but nobody answers, obviously. He finds a letter, fears the worst, drops everything and runs to the kitchen. The murderer killed Eva and Hideyoshi already, but they were in a different room - the one painted up, which Genji and Kanon did not notice being painted up because it's further down the corridor - from three meters away sideways, the paint can't be that apparent on a dark wooden door. The murderer was probably caught painting and needed to quickly hide. Once Genji and Kanon leave, the murderer emerges from one of the three possible guest rooms, turns off the TV and lights if that was the room Genji and Kanon tried first, and leaves or hides again, moving the letter to the correct room door. When everyone returns, the room with the letter next to it is obviously The One, reinforced by the seal on the door, so nobody notices they were one room off. I suspect that this is the loophole that allows to solve this locked room in a natural way, one that does not involve deliberately creating it by fixing the chain or magneting it closed. People should be doing something we can imagine them doing if they don't explicitly want to create a mystery that results in creating one anyway. Unfortunately, I fail to find how this could help as the nature of the wounds seems to rule out the most obvious 'Hideyoshi was killed first, Eva was killed, murderer left the room and the dying Eva locked it'. You don't do that with a hole in your head and you don't make a hole in your head to play dead - certainly you can't stick a stake into it so that it remains upright, so even if stakes are added by Kanon or Kumasawa later, holes must exist. Any ideas? |
|
2010-04-11, 12:45 | Link #7917 |
Dea ex Kakera
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Sea of Fragments
|
Wow, I definitely need to reread EP1. I totally missed that letter discrepancy.
I need to think about the room switching trick more before I decide if it's plausible in this case or not, but it does strongly remind me of a trick that was used in the manga Kira Kira Labyrinth. It might be worth reading that for a better idea of how the trick might play out. |
2010-04-11, 12:48 | Link #7918 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Buffer overflow
|
Quote:
Also, there probably isn't a limit to the number of personalities a single person can "see". After all, Ange had about 9 of them in her arc.
__________________
|
|
2010-04-11, 12:56 | Link #7920 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Buffer overflow
|
Just to be clear, it only explicitly says that he pulled it out from the crack under the door, supposedly to check the wax seal on it. It never mentions that he actually picked it up and took it anywhere. Still, an interesting point.
__________________
|
|
|