Hayate no Gotoku manga (raw discussion only)

[Utkarsh Ray]

Spoiler for Chapter 551:

I didn't think Hayate and co would be back to mansion so soon. Still confused. Nice to see Violet Mansion and Ayumu, Chiharu and others though. About time Hinagiku got involved.

Great to see a chapter focused on Athena after so much time.
Enjoy the fanservice! (^_<)b

[grecefar]

that was a really good fanservice

[aldw]

Hayate with best girl together is automatic win, as always.

[Hamazura_Shiage]

The ship has sailed again my friends

[Ruki0089]

Hayate x Nagi? No! Hayate x Athena? Hell Yes!!

[Diluc]

I wish the author aren't that subtle and will let Nagi and Maria more relevancy to the plot by let them known the last night situation. This remind back to Athenna arc where Maria and Nagi being clueless the whole nexus happened to Hayate in greece.
That Athenna part really an awkward part lol, next chapter going to be interesting haha.

[Hamazura_Shiage]

Well, in Athena's arc Nagi wasn't involved or affected and she wouldn't have played an useful rol against unnatural powers. I do agree that Nagi and Maria must play an active rol on this one, not just leave them aside while the strong characters fight.

[xSauriaNx]

we're still on the opening part on this arc... they'll be involve on it soon enough... xD
we're talking about the inheritance and the Royal Garden afterall... xD

[~Yami~]

Heil A-tan... she just overthrow all her rivals in one chapter...
now let her meet with Nagi once again

[xSauriaNx]

this chapter just proves that A-tan and Hayate loves to cause misunderstandings albeit indirectly and unknowingly... xD

[~Yami~]

I wonder how A-tan will introduce herself..

"Let me introduce myself again.. My name is Tennousu Athena, chairman of Hakuou. I'm Hayate's ex, but I still don't intend to let him go so please consider me as your rivals.. Nice to meet you"

[Ulin]

That sounds like her yes

[AstroNerdBoy]

Maria has some connection with Athena, but we just don't know what that is. So I suspect that Maria's role will grow.

As to Nagi, I still think she opens the path. And I think Papa makes a return.

[Utkarsh Ray]

Hata-sensei pushing Nagi end so forcefully

Spoiler for Chapter 552:

The last I remember, Hayate still preferred Athena over others and now he has Nagi in her eyes.

I am still hoping (against increasing odds) for Athena end

[xSauriaNx]

^ please no....
I want more A-tan than Nagi...

EDIT: Just read the latest chap... f***... why am I crying so much inside... why A-tan... why... why are you killing your own self... T_T

Originally Posted by AstroNerdBoy

Maria has some connection with Athena, but we just don't know what that is. So I suspect that Maria's role will grow.

As to Nagi, I still think she opens the path. And I think Papa makes a return.

The thing about Maria being connected to Athena... wasn't that kinda solved itself already?
It's about the Phyrgian language and the power of Royalty... if Maria did somehow solved that, won't the very first heroine be Maria and not Athena? I'd ship that too... xD

[Hamazura_Shiage]

This is so frustrating... Unfortunately it seems Hata is forcing his way to the Nagi ending... The ship is compromised, I repeat, the ship has been compromised.

[grecefar]

Is ayumu a masochist?, I was so sure she was going to give a-tan the same speech of not giving up hayate and become another love rival, that way to far that being nice, seriously and I'm glad that a-tan is mature enough to not fall for that or not hear it, too bad the ship sink but I don't want ayumu be the one to put a-tan in te fight for hayate.

[Hamazura_Shiage]

This hurt, but if it's true what A-tan is saying, my ship has changed to Hina or Ayumu.

[Ddale7]

After reading this most recent chapter, I feel like Hata is a genius for making that whole "Alice arc". Even if we as the reader wanted more "real Athena" back then, Athena getting to be Alice for several months gave her the proper closer she needed as a character. If she returned as Athena she would have just joined the harem as another rival, which wouldn't feel right. But by getting to be Alice with everyone for several months she was able to transition to being friends with the Hayate cast. And now I think she'll be genuinely happy despite not being romantic with Hayate.

[zibi88]

I just dont get Hata... everyone wants Athena to win as she has so freaking huge fan base... but he still tries to push Nagi into the face by force... seriously this will not work... nagi for me is kinda at the bottom of wanting to win Hayate


Anyway I hope there will be a reset button later on so we can get back in time.. like now Hina has a bilion cash on that card so she could be the girl to pick up Hayate and with that have her Win becouse this is how it works it seems... Nagi bought him...he got enslaved to Nagi as buttler and this is supposed to give birth to romance, he stayed becouse he felt indepted and now he cant leave becouse he feels "sorry" for her, becouse she would be all alone.

But isnt Athena even more alone !! she lost her parents, had a ilness that was about to kill her off so she "had" to use that stone to wish for a cure but was locked in that castle for a long time all alone with no one to talk to. Hayate was the only person she "EVER" had and now she is just going to disappaer...f...k she should just confess her feelings to him and it will work since he belives that she rejected him back there but in reality she did not.


Not many people want a Nagi ending becouse its freaking boring...as usual the main girl wins...woah what a surprise didnt see that coming, what an amazing twist, something that never happened in any other series. I just hope that Hina or Ayumu will talk to Hayate about Athena and so he decides to go after her the end.