The Legend of Maian

[Syokool]

Originally Posted by noone

I might just read the LN when it's done so you can warn me guys if there's goin to be alot of dissappointments also, please tell what parts that has NTR/beating ruby in it so I can avoid it lels

anyways, can you recommend me some manga/manhwa similar to this but has good ending, I prefer it to be short

again any hints that Felix and Felicia will be reunited, I highly doubt that Felicia just let herself be NTR'd like that. I mean, she loved Felix so much, I bet she's up to something

Maian wasn't a Light Novel (as Phantom King) but a Novel, so it was really "dark" for young people.

And I'm not sure if someone is working on it as a project, but as I can remember, the last part really disappointed a lot of people.

The actual novel has the worst ending possible, so we are now expecting manhwa to be a lot better.

----

I'd like to recommend you Id (korean), but it's on hiatus as well. Or LMS (korean novel), one amazing novel.

[Avrorrange]

Originally Posted by Syokool

Maian wasn't a Light Novel (as Phantom King) but a Novel, so it was really "dark" for young people.

And I'm not sure if someone is working on it as a project, but as I can remember, the last part really disappointed a lot of people.

The actual novel has the worst ending possible, so we are now expecting manhwa to be a lot better.

----

I'd like to recommend you Id (korean), but it's on hiatus as well. Or LMS (korean novel), one amazing novel.

Is IDY also the author of the novel?

[Syokool]

Yeah.

I do remember him as a writer first. Maian and Phantom King were written by him.


Phantom King was "canceled" as well, so we only got part 1 in manhwa and 1 volume for part 2 (volume 5 LN). I'm not that sure, but I heard it was canceled because he was accused of some kind of plagiarism.

[noone]

ehh did felix and felicia get reunited in the novel?
I hope the manhwa follows the novel except the ending

[Syokool]

Originally Posted by noone

ehh did felix and felicia get reunited in the novel?
I hope the manhwa follows the novel except the ending

Yep, but

Spoiler for worst ending:

After being reunited with their son, and Felicia'd gained back her memories, everything blows up (literally).

and the novel was depressing. It reminds me Chaos;head as how Felix were driven insane.

[noone]

Originally Posted by Syokool

Yep, but

Spoiler for worst ending:

After being reunited with their son, and Felicia'd gained back her memories, everything blows up (literally).

and the novel was depressing. It reminds me Chaos;head as how Felix were driven insane.

well, atleast....I was relieved and so much happy that they were reunited. Saving grace for me.
however, I have questions:
1. Was their reunion somehow eased the pain from all the ntr they've been through?
2. Did they find the other regis knights? what happened to the four knights?
3. Did the "light and dark felicia" became one again?

do any of you knows how to contact IDY? lololol might we bombard his email to get his act together? JK that would be immature(though I would if I wanted to XD)
I really hope IDY knows the criticisms thrown at him
about that "Id" that you had suggested, was that a manhwa too? is it good?
and that LMS is there a manga/manhwa version of it? I like the ones that has both LN and manga/manhwa...

[Syokool]

Originally Posted by noone

1. Was their reunion somehow eased the pain from all the ntr they've been through?
2. Did they find the other regis knights? what happened to the four knights?
3. Did the "light and dark felicia" became one again?

Spoiler for answers:

1. The whole thing was so messed up that, in the end, you can't feel it as a happy ending at all.
It was like Steins Gate with Rintarou trying to save Mayuri, but after being reunited there is a nuclear attack that destroys everything.

Being Felix is suffering indeed.

2. As Felix travels in time, he met everyone, and lost everyone as well. More suffering.

3. I don't really remember the "dark" Felicia thing at all. What I do remember is that she lost her memories.

Spoiler for the end:

Well, they got together the last part, and then the world is being attacked from space.

Felicia can't do anything, and dies together embracing Felix and their son.

Originally Posted by noone

do any of you knows how to contact IDY? lololol might we bombard his email to get his act together? JK that would be immature(though I would if I wanted to XD)
I really hope IDY knows the criticisms thrown at him
about that "Id" that you had suggested, was that a manhwa too? is it good?
and that LMS is there a manga/manhwa version of it? I like the ones that has both LN and manga/manhwa...

I remember him posting in Seed Novel some times, but can't really recall having some kind of contact page or so.

Id is both, novel and manhwa, and has a lot of chapters (manhwa) so you can find it fun if you are fine with an OP character (Id, the MC, is nice).

LMS is a novel, but it is really good. Give it a try at least ch.1 (Legendary Moonlight Sculptor).

[anonfr]

Originally Posted by Syokool

Spoiler for answers:

1. The whole thing was so messed up that, in the end, you can't feel it as a happy ending at all.
It was like Steins Gate with Rintarou trying to save Mayuri, but after being reunited there is a nuclear attack that destroys everything.

Being Felix is suffering indeed.

2. As Felix travels in time, he met everyone, and lost everyone as well. More suffering.

3. I don't really remember the "dark" Felicia thing at all. What I do remember is that she lost her memories.

Spoiler for the end:

Well, they got together the last part, and then the world is being attacked from space.

Felicia can't do anything, and dies together embracing Felix and their son.

I remember him posting in Seed Novel some times, but can really recall having some kind of contact page or so.

Id is both, novel and manhwa, and has a lot of chapters (manhwa) so you can find it fun if you are fine with an OP character (Id, the MC, is nice).

LMS is a novel, but it is really good. Give it a try at least ch.1 (Legendary Moonlight Sculptor).

Ahh thanks for posting this. When I read over the thread I got confused.

Spoiler for cause:

I distinctly remember reading some post saying that Aliens attack and the world gets destroyed, and the whole story basically got rendered pointless in retrospect.

Thanks for adding some context to that.

[Syokool]

You are talking about the nyura race.

Yeah, they are like.. gods? Something as Stars Gate with aliens being the rulers of universe.

Maian is a novel with technology, so there are a lot of things like that. And the nukes are real as well.

[Avrorrange]

Originally Posted by Syokool

Spoiler for answers:

1. The whole thing was so messed up that, in the end, you can't feel it as a happy ending at all.
It was like Steins Gate with Rintarou trying to save Mayuri, but after being reunited there is a nuclear attack that destroys everything.

Being Felix is suffering indeed.

2. As Felix travels in time, he met everyone, and lost everyone as well. More suffering.

3. I don't really remember the "dark" Felicia thing at all. What I do remember is that she lost her memories.

Spoiler for the end:

Well, they got together the last part, and then the world is being attacked from space.

Felicia can't do anything, and dies together embracing Felix and their son.

I remember him posting in Seed Novel some times, but can really recall having some kind of contact page or so.

Id is both, novel and manhwa, and has a lot of chapters (manhwa) so you can find it fun if you are fine with an OP character (Id, the MC, is nice).

LMS is a novel, but it is really good. Give it a try at least ch.1 (Legendary Moonlight Sculptor).

WTF?!My opinion of IDY as an author just dropped dramatically, not that it was good to begin with.

[noone]

hahah well....still i'm happy they got reunited
about that #3, it has been said that felicia has been split into two person, the one being with Diha and the other, the dancer..
and that's what I'm asking, did the two characters merged as one in the end? or only one of them is real and got her memories back?

[noone]

@moe collection...yeah most of his works started out really good but it's just like he can't concentrate on a single project. It's like he has the need to work for like 10 projects at a time
and most of it just ends with a cliffhanger ending or in hiatus..I don't really understand...he makes good stories(IMO) but halfway through,it's like he loses his interest and starts making another manhwa/manga....or is it about the budget that his series gets axed? who knows
IF YOU STARTED SOMETHING YOU BETTER FINISH IT WELL
sorry for the rage XD

[Syokool]

Originally Posted by Moe Connection

WTF?!My opinion of IDY as an author just dropped dramatically, not that it was good to begin with.

There was not rage, but RAGE.

You can't really expect the best ending of him, though OnihimeVS was pretty good.

Originally Posted by noone

hahah well....still i'm happy they got reunited
about that #3, it has been said that felicia has been split into two person, the one being with Diha and the other, the dancer..
and that's what I'm asking, did the two characters merged as one in the end? or only one of them is real and got her memories back?

Ehm, no. I can't really remember the 2 Felicias thing at all. There was only one all the time.

Might be wrong as well since I haven't read it for years, but I'm pretty sure it was a manhwa thing.

[Avrorrange]

Originally Posted by noone

@moe collection...yeah most of his works started out really good but it's just like he can't concentrate on a single project. It's like he has the need to work for like 10 projects at a time
and most of it just ends with a cliffhanger ending or in hiatus..I don't really understand...he makes good stories(IMO) but halfway through,it's like he loses his interest and starts making another manhwa/manga....or is it about the budget that his series gets axed? who knows
IF YOU STARTED SOMETHING YOU BETTER FINISH IT WELL
sorry for the rage XD

Which is why I stopped reading anything produced by IDY, including FREEZING!!!!

[noone]

plus the part with the technology thingy
in the novel there was some sci-fi stuffs going on. But in the manhwa, it wasn't really implied, let alone, established. If this gets introduced later on in the manhwa(which takes forever to update), I think it's too late, it's gonna be way too off.. however If it really get into manhwa, they better put up a good fight against those nuclear thingys, hell they have to defeat it because if not " the whole story basically got rendered pointless in retrospect." like anonfr said

[Syokool]

Originally Posted by noone

plus the part with the technology thingy
in the novel there was some sci-fi stuffs going on. But in the manhwa, it wasn't really implied, let alone, established. If this gets introduced later on in the manhwa(which takes forever to update), I think it's too late, it's gonna be way too off.. however If it really get into manhwa, they better put up a good fight against those nuclear thingys, hell they have to defeat it because if not " the whole story basically got rendered pointless in retrospect." like anonfr said

Well, there is Nebriam (satellite attack), and that submarine though.

There was some kind of androids too, but they disappeared in the manhwa version.

[noone]

we can just hope that the Manhwa doesn't follow the Novel...or just hope that it would be updated lol

[chancs]

Spoiler:

*reads the spoiler messages*
*rejoices about the renioun*
*reads about the alien(?) nuke attack*
......
*goes WTF*

How does this nuke come into picture. Why are his endings always dramatic and stupid?

[noone]

Originally Posted by chancs

Spoiler:

*reads the spoiler messages*
*rejoices about the renioun*
*reads about the alien(?) nuke attack*
......
*goes WTF*

How does this nuke come into picture. Why are his endings always dramatic and stupid?

apparently, it's his thing
I'm curious too, there's so much potential in his works but then.....y'know what'll happen next...I just hope he doesn't do the same with freezing

[Avrorrange]

So the Aliens doesn't show up except at the end?!