Rate That Signature!

[Haladflire65]

CM: Simple but nice 8.7/10

Spoiler for @ the people involved:

It's ok, Pat-sama, honoured to have been picked as an example Awesome sigs you've posted here, by the way, too bad they're not for rating

On another note, I don't understand how having a fixed style makes the signature itself 'bad'. You're rating the style then, not the individual signature, and that's not what we're doing here. It's like saying a bunch of Van Gough paintings are the same because they're all in the same style, the artist's style. And using the same subject or render again and again is what I've been doing for a while but that doesn't make all the sigs the same! As Patchy mentioned, I've used different styles and elements like fractals, splatter brushing, grunge, blending with stocks, smudging, etc. Perhaps when you're more versed in the ways of gfx, you'll be able to see that?

I think I'll try to finish here, since people will get annoyed and the mods will come... If I manage to stay restrained, that is

[Rennir]

Halad-8.7/10 Blending is good, at the same time the neck part could use some work

[Str@wberryHeart]

Awesome sigs! The transparency is wonderful!

[Dist]

Your signature is WAY too big for the forum .. See rules. Hell, it should even show a box where your signature must fit inside when you are choosing a signature ... + Bad quality, awful rainbow borders and weird text. 3/10

[OgodItsKanon]

Originally Posted by Haladflire65

OgodItsKanon: Nice. Is it by rikkikai? 8.7/10

Yup. o;

Originally Posted by Dist

OgodItsKanon : Pretty .. please don't tell me that's a trap, though ? With Hetalia being what it is, I find it hard to believe it would have cute girl(s) in it :x. 8/10

Haha, nope. Vietnam is a girl.

Dist: Very pretty. 9.2/10

[delirium]

Str@wberryHeart: 10/10 Gazing upon your signature gives me the same feeling I would probably get from looking at a Picasso!

[bigdave]

@Dist 7/8/7/9 so around 8 overall
nice placement for your render. I like the light source and the color it is.
I like what you did with the bg, but it would look even nicer with more depth and atmosphere.

@delirium
6/7/6/7/ so around 6.5
I like that you made unit1 all black cuz with that red the purple would have clashed. I like the eyes and bg being same in color. Good job with it. Bg could use a little more work. In which i mean try making something using different sources of pictures and such.

[delorean2200]

bigdave: 9/10 nice, though wings appear to be to disproportional, one's a lot wider then the other and its not just cause of the angle, also could use imho a subtle border.

[delirium]

Originally Posted by bigdave

@Dist 7/8/7/9 so around 8 overall
nice placement for your render. I like the light source and the color it is.
I like what you did with the bg, but it would look even nicer with more depth and atmosphere.

@delirium
6/7/6/7/ so around 6.5
I like that you made unit1 all black cuz with that red the purple would have clashed. I like the eyes and bg being same in color. Good job with it. Bg could use a little more work. In which i mean try making something using different sources of pictures and such.

bigdave: 8/10 I really like the colors in your signature. They mesh well and I like the atmosphere of it.

As far as my signature is concerned, you are right. I could probably put something else in with the background, but I liked how it was at that point so that's what I used. Thank you for the suggestions. They are actually very much so appreciated.

[ganbaru]

CMHerrera 8,8/10 did you used this one before ?
JRendell 8,7/10 interesting focus
OgodItsKanon 9/10 simply great
delirium 8,4/10 adding more render, especialy if not ''working with each other'', disperse the focus of the sig

[delorean2200]

Delirium: 8.4/10 from me as well, i think it would look better without the thing on the right.

[Haladflire65]

delirium: Agreeing w/ the others, also, the render(s) should be better blended. 8.4/10
bigdave: Nice. 8.8/10

[JRendell]

bigdave: It's a nice concept, but I've got mixed views on the colours. The orange cloud seems really out of place, but I think it's supposed to be an explosion caused by her? 8/10
delirium: Lurvely work. I like the font. 8.8/10

[ganbaru]

JRendell 9,1/10 looking great.

[Haladflire65]

JR: Nice work! Who is it? 9/10

[ganbaru]

Haladflire65 8,8/10 interesting one

[Butter Fly]

ganbaru : 8.5/10 good colours.
Halad : 9.4/10 Awesome!

[delorean2200]

Halad: 10/10 love it!, btw didn't you had one with a similar main render before ?
JRendell: 9.5/10 interesting.

[Haladflire65]

@delorean: I think I might've, since this isn't my first guitar sig. I especially like this particular Les Paul, so... (next one might be a Flying V!)

ganbaru: Nice one, but the sig looks a bit low-q and the reflection not necessary. 8.6/10

[Rikimtasu]

Haladflire65 9/10 Da Guitar! It's a fresh one.
delorean2200 8/10 Haven't finshed SEED yet...
Butter Fly 7/10 Can be better.