2013-07-30, 16:36 | Link #32601 | ||||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2013
|
Quote:
Quote:
I mean, I understand Ryukishi was aiming for it.(The names Shannon and Kanon gave that out), but other than that the foreshadowing was poor and when you look at it really, Shannon and Kanon and Beatrice have absolutely nothing in common. Beatrice herself called herself fickle. Is there anything remotely fickle about Shannon? Or Kanon for that matter? No. But I can present Rosa as being fickle. At certain times, Rosa would act like a terrible monster towards Maria. While at the same time, Rosa would also be in Maria's eyes the world best mother. Fickle? Quite . Quote:
I mean, we know George's pretty much a mother's boy(except when it comes to her refusal of Shannon of course) and we know Eva can be that vindictive and that low. Quote:
While Krauss did express regret about the way he treated the other siblings in the 3rd game, I suspect he thinks much more highly of his immediate family than siblings with which he really no longer has a relationship with(They're all adults now). For that same financial security and future that you spoke of, for his more immediate family he'd be capable of pulling this off. Quote:
There are only 17 people on Rokkenjima If Yasu ever existed at all, he/she/it fell off a freaking cliff(at that, at an infant age). I'm sorry but my belief can't be suspended. I'll sooner believe that Zepar and Furfur exist on the island than Yasu's story. If Yasu survived, she should've suffered extensive brain damage or something! Quote:
If, however a character is disguising himself to shroud his identity, how can we possibly foreshadow that? My type of disguise should theoretically bypass Knox's 10th. Quote:
But keep Kanon out of it, that's about as likely as a shooting star being responsible for the deaths of Rokkenjima. Kanon only has one identity(as proven at the end of the Fourth game). Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
-Furudo Erika had no influence on any of Beato's games before now. -She does not exist in the worlds before this one, nor does she influence them. Furudo Erika doesn't exist, she isn't Michael Phelps, she died ashore in 1986. And her existence in the games is merely as Bernkastel's piece, or alternatively from a RL perspective, as an interpretation of Eva's specific malice towards Natsuhi. Erika believed that she had free will over her body and actions but that doesn't mean it was an actual fact. Artificial life, by it's very nature cannot comprehend the complexities of life. Such as Erika not being able to feel love. Quote:
Quote:
|
||||||||||||
2013-07-30, 16:41 | Link #32602 |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
Fair enough. But it doesn't necessarily imply murder/homicide, correct? It's a vague description in an otherwise precise sentence; we know he died, and we know exactly when he died, but exactly what happened to him is something we don't know (and will never know, as the game suspends before anyone finds his body). All we know is there's an implication that someone else may have been responsible, but the red is noncommittal otherwise.
__________________
|
2013-07-30, 17:04 | Link #32603 | |||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
This is the biggest problem with you, you make up your own truth, which makes it frustrating to argue with you. Last edited by haguruma; 2013-07-30 at 17:18. |
|||
2013-07-30, 17:34 | Link #32604 | |
"Senior" "Member"
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
@α-B.
This is becoming boring... you simply write anything that comes into your mind and hope it will somehow not be shot down, instead of focusing on 2-3 HQ arguments that you are sure cannot be denied. So, how about going for Quality over Quantity once in a while, hm? I won't even begin to address the appearance of the people... You are seriously basing your theory on a bunch of pixels? Battler's and Ange's red hair must be an indication that they are demons! Half-brother and half-sister are the real culprits! Anyway... you said that 17 people exist on Rokkenjima. That is not completely correct. That red truth only applies to EP6 and it INCLUDES Erika. For EP1-4 the rule "No more than 17 humans exist on Rokkenjima" applies and for EP5 it is: "Furudo Erika only increases it by one person. Besides her, the number of people on this island is exactly the same as it was in the previous games." You said that Kanon only has one identity. That was never said. I am sure you are referring to Lambda's red truth from the EP4 ???-TP. That red truth is worded like this: "The only one who can claim Kanon's name is the person himself! A different person cannot claim his name! " and in EP6 there is actually an even stricter rule introduced: "All people can only use their own names!!" So then what is the flaw of your argument? I can tell you that: All the red truth states, is that a name is always bound to EXACTLY one person. You however claim, without any basis, that people are bound to their one name, which is not true. I even had made an example using mathematics in the EP6 thread: Quote:
And about "Yasu never appeard": "Yasu" is Beato's "old" name that she doesn't use anymore. Her present name is "Beatrice". She does appear as a character from early on. For one she does so in the disguise of Shannon and Kanon, secondly she is being mentioned in a lot of discussions (e.g. as the 2nd master of the mansion), and there is a portrait in the entrance hall. But even if you disregard that: Beatrice does appear early on before Maria and gives her the letter. That was done by an actual character. Of course you can claim that "Maria's statement is unrealiable because Detective Battler didn't see it himself". That is no problem though, as Maria's statement gets confirmed at the end of the first game, as Battler sees someone next to Maria at 23:59, that looks like Beatrice.
__________________
|
|
2013-07-30, 18:06 | Link #32605 | ||||||||||
The True Culprit
|
Quote:
Quote:
The Love Duel, and all other conflicts between Shannon, Kanon, and Beatrice, symbolize Yasu's indecision when it comes to important choices. This reflects Beato's magic style, where she doesn't care how the dice rolls because she'll be satisfied with any outcome. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Deny it in red! The Man on the Phone never dirties his hands with murder! Unless you can deny that statement, you have no ability to deny it was Battler! Quote:
This means that Erika, who increases the human count by one, brings the total to 17, remove her and there are 16 humans. Quote:
Quote:
Only Kanon can use his name. If Shannon and Kanon are the same person, then Shannon can use Kanon's name. Also, If Shannon dies, Kanon disappears forever. You lose. Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||||||||||
2013-07-30, 21:47 | Link #32606 | |||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2013
|
Quote:
What gain would Battler possibly get out of it? Is 'Yasu' the conspirator he's working in tandem with? Why would Shannon and Kanon betray the very household that's employing them? Isn't it easier to simply employ an Eva-George "culprit" theory for the man for 19 years ago? In the game, Lambadelta-sama is seen on the other line. Isn't it possible to fake or alter one's voice slightly to sound different? Quote:
While Kanon wants to 'feel love', he utterly rejects the concept in all games. Acknowledging his role as furniture. This is different from Shannon, who openly pursues her relationship with George and Beatrice who begrudgingly comes to accept Battler on a platonic level. Yasu doesn't suffer from "multiple personality disorder" and any sane person would have eventually chosen a person to fall in love with. If you believe in Yasu, he/she/it is a single entity! There's only one reason the love battle exists, and that's because at the end of the day you can only choose one person. If multiple existences or personalities were true, then theoretically the battle is unnecessary. 'Shannon' can be with George, 'Kanon' can be with Jessica and Beatrice can be with Battler. Quote:
By comparison, we know that Rosa herself has never actually experienced love. Having been abandoned by Maria's father, and subconsciously pushing away any male that did like her. We see Beatrice's plain disgust for men when she tells Shannon that George will eventually lust after her. And Kanon himself never expressed that Love was the Single Element. Beatrice first proclaimed that, and Shannon swallowed it up(like any young girl her age would). The fact that Beatrice needed to explain that, proves that Beatrice is either a different person or a different consciousness but at the very least, neither are the same person. In fact, Shannon later regrets breaking the mirror and releasing Beatrice because it began the games which led to the killings. Instead of the happy days between the cousins.. I'm sure you'll explain that conflict as a part of Yasu's multiple personality disorder, oh well. Quote:
So, it's Precisely what it means! Of course Beatrice is never abusive towards Maria, that's the whole point. She's the alternative personality of Rosa, whose Maria's mother. If Shannon/Kanon=Yasu whose Beatrice, then why couldn't Kanon simply give Maria a new bar of candy? Kanon bemoaned the fact that all he could do was brush it off. Shannon was demonstrably with the other cousins in the guesthouse! Quote:
So now, in order to trap me with this blue, you're going to have to deny at the least that Yasu(Beatrice) wasn't the one on the phone. But there's more. To have the kind of information that the man of 19 years ago had, he would have to had been intimate with the family, to have knowledge of it. Yasu was kept in secret by Genji and Kuwasawa. You can argue that they filled in the blanks, but doubtful. And I'm sorry, Battler was away for 6 freaking years!(Six). My Eva-George theory for the man for 19 years ago, makes much more plausible sense than Yasu/Battler and entirely fits your blue. All the moreso if George in fact is a culprit! Quote:
Quote:
It's a clear statement, Erika doesn't exist. Kinzo doesn't exist. Santa Claus doesn't exist. The Easter Bunny doesn't exist. The only ones at the Ushiromiya's during the Family Conference are all relatives except for Kinzo(who doesn't exist) and the servants. Quote:
Quote:
So in other words, when Kanon was pronounced dead in the 3rd game we can be absolutely sure it was Kanon! Lady Lambda-sama said with absolute certainty that no one can take Kanon's identity. I already expressed my doubts about Kanon being Shannon, but let's flip it the other way around: How the hell are you going to make Shannon Kanon? Better yet: Whom among the males could remotely disguise themselves as Kanon? You could argue "breast reconstruction surgery." Except Nanjo is a physician, not necessarily a surgeon. That and I doubt they'd have the tools And as far as the other guys? None of them are as short in stature, or anywhere close to Kanon's personality. If there's anyone in the Umineko series you can't be deceived with, it's Kanon. Kanon is as much of a personified figure as Kinzo himself Quote:
My arguments are logically consistent with the truth They're just not the arguments you want to hear. Quote:
If I'm guilty of anything, it's surrendering my theories and postulating new ones to counter any weaknesses in my original thesis. If you want to call that moving the posts, I'm guilty as charged. All I'm asking, is what's to gain from some fake murder game? Attention? That's a pretty sick way to get attention if you ask me. |
|||||||||||
2013-07-30, 22:07 | Link #32607 | |
"Senior" "Member"
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
Someone who is pretending to be dead is not a corpse
Quote:
Umineko is a work of fiction and the "gameboards" are fictions within fiction. Battler is "fake", Beatrice is "fake", Eva is "fake", Erika is "fake", Rokkenjima is "fake", everything is "fake"!
__________________
|
|
2013-07-30, 22:46 | Link #32608 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2013
|
I don't see how this refutes my notion that Yasu doesn't exist, or that Shannon and Kanon being one and the same is as plausible as humanity defying the law of gravity.
But okay, I'll accept it. Just add a little bit more detail so I can understand why you use this particular red against me. Quote:
Quote:
The terminology of fake, was only used in conjunction with the world of Rokkenjima. While obviously, the series itself is fake. We as viewers are able to view the world of Rokkenjima, unbiased and to see the reality of their world. Just because I deny Furudo Erika existing in Prime(or as confirmed in red, that she didn't exist on any of the boards), doesn't necessarily mean I reject the story itself or even want to. I'm a big Umineko fan. I just want to find the truth, and only with love can I see it.I can feel Rosa's pain. The pain of not being acknowledged, the pain of being burdened with guilt for feeling responsible for Kuwadorian Beatrice's death. The pain of not even being able to love Maria, her own daughter. I can see it, because I have love. |
||
2013-07-30, 23:36 | Link #32609 | ||
"Senior" "Member"
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
Quote:
Also: Someone who is pretending to be dead is not a corpse. Do you get it? Playing dead = being alive = NOT a(n unidentified) corpse. Quote:
FOR THE 3RD TIME! one body can have up to infinite amount of names, but one name belongs to EXACTLY one body. After I already wrote it for 2 times, was it SO hard to understand? Does it not fit into your 50 byte memory? I am losing interest in this "fight" because in the last days I destroyed most of your theories by simply repeating myself, which makes this really boring. Maybe you are actually thinking you are a "troll" and just have fun at flame baiting. Or wait... are you.... a.... HIPSTER?
__________________
|
||
2013-07-30, 23:43 | Link #32610 | |||||||||||||||||||||
The True Culprit
|
Quote:
Battler loves Yasu, and wants to help her. Yasu, wanting out of this situation (All three entities that are part of her express a desire to escape Rokkenjima) cannot leave with good conscience without dispelling all the lies and hurts of the family she's been a part of, such as covering up Kinzo's death. She's trying to motivate Natsuhi to come clean on her own instead of pushing her into the fire, so to speak. As for the Lambdadelta comment, Lambdadelta = 34. Sayo can be read in Japanese characters as 34. Beatrice is supported by Lambdadelta... Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Also, Erika isn't nine, you dolt, she's two years younger than Jessica. That aside, her existence in Rokkenjima Prime is utterly irrelevant because in the Gameboard of End and Dawn, she exists for the narrative. The red says she has a body, is capable of killing people, doing things, and taping doors. She exists as much as any other character on those Gameboards are. Quote:
Also, You misquoted Battler's red. He never says the word 'still' in that line. This utterly changes the meaning of the line. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Your arguments aren't even logically consistent with each other, btw. Quote:
Babies have survived cliff falls in real life. Those babies grow up, and can be as dumb or as smart as anyone else in the world, and it's fairly easy to coerce people into a fake game where no one is actually hurt if you have several tons of gold and they all need money. Your arguments aren't even new; go back about 600 pages or so. Quote:
But as for why...The game happens because Battler returns to the island. Battler is Yasu's/Shannon's first love, and they bonded over mystery novels. Yasu/Shannon worried for years that he forgot her. The game is a test; she is replicating one of his favorite mysteries, hoping that he sees through the illusion and remembers her. She's childishly trying to use the one thing they bonded over because she's too scared to say it upfront, just like she was too scared years ago to call him on the phone and ask. Quote:
You do not have love. Not the love you're being asked to find.
__________________
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
2013-07-31, 00:12 | Link #32611 | ||||||||||||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
From the beginning it is made clear that Natsuhi and Krauss have reason to believe that the servants are working against them, which is why they hired Gohda. From the very start on both Shannon and Kanon make it clear that they work for the "master of the house". Quote:
Yasu was clearly raised as female, having an original Shannon as a rolemodel, hanging out with female servants, wearing dresses. Isn't it more likely that 'he' simply does not know how to love as a 'male'? Even more, what is the promise that Beatrice wants Battler to remember, which she in EP4 claims was not done to her but in EP5 goes insane over when she says that she can never trust one of Battler's promises again? What is it if not the one promise mentioned during the early stage of the game, the promise to Shannon? Quote:
They are more than personalities, they are different paths given a voice due to a way too overactive imagination. As soon as one path is chosen the other can no longer be pursued. That is why Yasu thinks the Golden Land is necessary, because if everybody exists in an imaginary space, wiped from existence without a trace, then they can be with as many people as they want. Quote:
Also, where is it implied that she subconsciously pushes men away? Quote:
What does the mirror in the shrine stand for and why would Shannon have to smash it? How was Rosa able to sneak onto the island and meet Shannon on several occasions? What would Rosa gain by having these conversations with Shannon and Kanon? How is Rosa the granddaughter of Beatrice Castiglioni? Current Beatrice=granddaughter of original Beatrice is something stated in EP8. Why would Rosa allow her daughter and herself to be killed in EP2? If Shannon/Kanon=Yasu whose Beatrice, then why couldn't Kanon simply give Maria a new bar of candy? Kanon bemoaned the fact that all he could do was brush it off. Shannon was demonstrably with the other cousins in the guesthouse! Because Kanon is not the one performing magic. Beatrice is the one wielding magic. By that logic your idea of Rosa=Beatrice breaks down as Beatrice wouldn't crush Maria's candy. And where was Shannon demonstrably in the guesthouse? Do we have a "while this happened" scene? Quote:
Quote:
EP8 (at least the manga) makes it clear that the information on Natsuhi and the baby's fate was given to 'Beatrice' by her trusted head furniture (Ronove=Genji). And since Beatrice swore to hand everything to the one who solves the epitaph, it is not unlikely that Battler gained knowledge of this element as well. Quote:
Quote:
1) Like GreyZone already said, someone who is pretending to be dead is not a corpse. 2) Kanon was clearly identitifiable, his face was intact, the only thing that happened to him was that he apparently had a wound on his chest. Apart from maybe Kinzo there was no unidentified corpse in EP3. I go even further, Kanon or Shannon where never among the corpses that had their respective identity drawn into question. Quote:
Kanon becoming Shannon? Put on a wig, pad out the bra and speak a little more feminine. Hell, I pulled it off to confuse my classmates when I crossplayed at the last costume party so far that three of my friends actually hit on me. Shannon becoming Kanon? Loose the padding, act a little more gloomy and don't draw too much attention to yourself. But this draws into question if Shannon and Kanon as distinct roles ever existed in the first place. We only know that Kanon was seen with Jessica on one culture festival at her school and while one survivor refuses to talk, the other is actively trying to conceal stuff and the last person who was ever on the island frequently is unable to even remember how her grandfather acted around her. Quote:
Quote:
The chain of events that led up to the reality we see depicted from EP3 onwards, 1998, is more or less fixed but only to the people who were actually there and only they can lock it down. |
||||||||||||
2013-07-31, 04:27 | Link #32612 | ||
Eaten by goats
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Rokkenjima
|
Quote:
In that case, how do you explain the fact that each of them lacks a complete soul, and their dreams (and Beatrice's) are mutually exclusive because they contradict each other, meaning that only one of them can succeed? How do you explain the lines in Episode's 8 manga which say Quote:
Canon is explicit there in saying that the reason their dreams are contradictory is because their body is one and the same. Beatrice's dream is also contradictory to Shannon and Kanon's dreams in the same way. Only one of the three can have their dream come true. |
||
2013-07-31, 06:32 | Link #32613 | |||||||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2013
|
Quote:
**Still, the male witch drank tea and hoped to construct an argument that would fit all four's viewpoint and hope to move the post at least a little.** According to Virgilia, Beatrice loses nothing whether the epitath is solved or not. In other words, we can make the proposition that the gold never belonged to Kanon, Shannon, Yasu, Beatrice in the first place. Rather than there being a fake murder game, what if the events on Rookenjima themselves were Kinzo's will? The only reason there wasn't a game in 1985 was that Battler didn't return until a year later, to raise the number up to 17 people on Rokkenjima. Quote:
But basically the entire family remarks on how reliable and trustworthy Genji is. Even Kanon seems to be held in regard. About the only character with which for example Natsuhi showed clear disgust for was Shannon, on the account of her clumsiness as a servant. Quote:
Prime exists, it has to exist! The entire story is based off the "real" events that occurred in the Umineko world. We're just not shown which, if any of the worlds is actually Rokkenjima Prime. But I've stated a hypothesis several pages earlier: All of the worlds reflect a part of Prime. I'm even willing to go as far as episode 5, namely the part of Kinzo being dead long before the events of 1986. But outside of that, the episode was clearly a sham. Quote:
Because if he did actually solve it, Will wouldn't have been necessary and Clair(Yasu/Beatrice) states as such, saying that it wasn't the one(Battler) she wanted but that there was an excellent observer. Quote:
**sips some more tea** If Yasu only exists as one body, then how can Kanon and Shannon exist in front of the cousins at the same time? As they are shown to do so in multiple occasions! How can they successfully change their clothing from male to female and vice versa seemingly within minutes, all without the cousins noticin a thing? If Yasu exists, she does so outside of the mansion, never to be seen or acknowledged by the other 17 humans. In other words, she's the 18th human on Rokkenjima. If she orders Genji and Kuwasawa, she does so strictly from Kuwadorian. It wouldn't be farfetched to imagine a private line that only connects the mansion and Kuwadorian that the three of them have access to. Quote:
Then she goes on a nonsensical rampage about how the man doesn't care for her because of Maria(not true at all and the man tries to interject many times) before finally, Rosa rejects him herself. Quote:
According to the episodes, the mirror sealed the spirit that is Beatrice, the witch who rules over Rokkenjima in the night. It's entirely possible that it's a roleplay between Rosa and Shannon(as well as the other servants) and breaking the mirror is a precursor to the "spirit" that is Beatrice.. As I hypotheize for the first question, I believe Rosa may have been roleplaying with Shannon and Kanon. Keep in mind that Rosa lived on the mansion longer than any of the other siblings and was partially responsible for the death of Kuwadorian Beatrice. She might believe in the epitath basically more than anybody. I postulate that Rosa is Yasu, IE: The child from 19 years ago. We know that Kinzo is Rosa's father, but we don't know who her mother is. She could be the result of incest from the Kuwadorian Beatrice. Quote:
Besides What's the likelihood of Shannon or Kanon possessing the same kind of candy? Quote:
Quote:
When Battler solves the epitath, he becomes the ruler of Rokkenjima, no? So why does he feel obligated in any way to play along with Yasu's game? Knowing Battler's personality, he'd ask Yasu to play a game that doesn't involve framing Natsuhi.(or for that matter, any of the siblings/cousins). Quote:
Which was later denied by both Beatrice and Battler in the meta world. Which means obviously Kinzo doesn't exist. Neither does Erika. She didn't swim ashore from some tragic ship wreck and made it to the island. Or even if she did, she wouldn't have the strength to make it to the mansion on her own power. Quote:
Ronove countered this by stating that even if a corpse couldn't lead to a mistaken autopsy, it doesn't matter if it wasn't a corpse to begin with. Here, I'll expand with another fact: Dr. Nanjo wouldn't deliberately mistake a real corpse for a fake. Unless of course if he was Yasu's accomplice. So it goes back to what you believe. Do you believe the entire Ushiromiya family is delusional and saw a body(either Shannon or Kanon's) that doesn't exist? Particularly in the 1st game we saw Shannon and Kanon together when the family first makes it there) It only makes sense for Nanjo to be Yasu's accomplice if Rosa is Yasu=Beatrice. Quote:
You can argue that's their definition of being called furniture. But I regress, I actually have multiple personalities myself. On the inside, I'm a person who can be rather lazy and content. On the outside, I'm an alpha male with lavish goals. Where's the crucial philosophical agreement? Pleasure. To the lazy, contented part of me and the overly ambitious part, a sense of fulfillment is the meaning of my existence as a human being. Quote:
We don't have that level of detail with Yasu, but a cliff is higher, the infant is probably younger and less developed. From the time you come out of your womb until maybe 5-6 years old, your bones are still forming and you're as soft as tissue. So is it possible? I surrender to you that it's possible. Probable? Eh, that's a tougher sell. Quote:
The only thing we cannot do, seemingly is come to a consensus on what happened. I'll surrender as far as this: Aura is right, I don't have love for Yasu. But aren't I reserved to my right to have "love" for Rosatrice? Just as you are reserved to your right to have "love" for Shakanontrice? |
|||||||||||||||
2013-07-31, 07:20 | Link #32614 | ||||
Eaten by goats
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Rokkenjima
|
Quote:
Also, we do know who Rosa's mother is: Kinzo's wife, the same as the mother of Krauss, Eva, and Rudolf. Of course, we don't have it in red for any of them. Nonetheless... Knox's 8th. It is forbidden for the case to be resolved with clues that are not presented. Have you got any clues to support Rosa being 19 years old and not Mrs Ushiromiya's child? And when, exactly, would Rosa have been roleplaying with Kanon and Shannon? Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Last edited by GoldenLand; 2013-07-31 at 08:03. |
||||
2013-07-31, 08:11 | Link #32616 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2013
|
Quote:
But it's clear Rosa had often access to the mansion, and it's clear that Shannon had been serving there for a while. But I think this argument I've had with everyone has allowed me to reach the Truth of all Truths. Yes, without love it can't be seen. Shannon is the culprit of the Umineko games. I'm not supporting "Shakanontrice", I'm saying Shannon and Shannon alone is the culprit. I present the theory that Kanon, like Yasu is a figment of Shannon's imagination. This is my list for working out the "17 people riddle."(Which implied there's only 16 people) I'll order the lists in Red to Blue to "Gold" Original List of people on the Island. Kinzo 1 Krauss 2 Natsuhi 3 Hideyoshi 4 George 5 Rudolf 6 Kyrie 7 Rosa 8 Maria 9 Genji 10 Shannon 11 Kanon 12 Gohda 13 Kumasawa 14 Nanjo 15 Battler 16 Eva 17 Jessica 18] Let's make a list that includes Yasu, takes out "Shannon" and "Kanon" and includes Erika. Kinzo 1 Krauss 2 Natsuhi 3 Hideyoshi 4 George 5 Rudolf 6 Kyrie 7 Rosa 8 Maria 9 Genji 10 Yasu 11 Erika 12 Gohda 13 Kumasawa 14 Nanjo 15 Battler 16 Eva 17 Jessica 18 To accomplish this, we'd have to take Kinzo off the island. New List: Krauss 1 Natsuhi 2 Hideyoshi 3 George 4 Rudolf 5 Kyrie 6 Rosa 7 Maria 8 Genji 9 Yasu 10 Erika 11 Gohda 12 Kumasawa 13 Nanjo 14 Battler 15 Eva 16 Jessica 17 However, it says "if" you join us there's 17. Implying that originally, there was only 16 people. The Shkanontrice solution would be to eliminate Erika. Sorry, but you can't do that and claim Erika "exists". This is the Answer:Real List of people who attended the family conference: Krauss 1 Natsuhi 2 Hideyoshi 3 George 4 Rudolf 5 Kyrie 6 Rosa 7 Maria 8 Genji 9 Shannon 10 Gohda 11 Kumasawa 12 Nanjo 13 Battler 14 Eva 15 Jessica 16 I'll settle Knox's 8th and present evidence that Kanon never existed. Primarily, the 3rd game. In Jessica's room, Kanon's "corpse" disappeared. And in that same game, a "alien" Kanon appeared and only Shannon seemingly knew this alien's weakness or for that matter its existence. It was also mentioned that Yasu had a conversation with Rosa, with Rosa having guaranteed "Yasu"(Shannon) that Battler would return. and that she was devastated when Battler in fact didn't return. In concurrence with the "multiple personalities" theory, Beatrice was created to represent the fact that 6 years later, Shannon still hadn't let go of all her feelings for Battler. The hole in my revision might seem to be the fact that Kanon and Jessica had a connection, but what if Jessica acknowledged Kanon as an imaginary friend? Shannon created her "Kanon" persona for Jessica's sake, who is her best friend who also hasn't experienced love. |
|
2013-07-31, 08:34 | Link #32618 | ||
"Senior" "Member"
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||
2013-07-31, 08:42 | Link #32619 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2013
|
Quote:
In short, this is a mystery. Whereas if there actually were "real", alternative peoples it would be a fantasy. |
|
2013-07-31, 08:50 | Link #32620 |
BUY MY BOOK!!!
Join Date: May 2009
|
By the way... Erika does exist. There was a person named Erika Furudo. What happened to her is as unknown as anyone else in that area on that weekend; hence, since it is not impossible to imagine Erika could be present in the catbox, it is possible to put her there as a valid living human. How she is characterized is probably an invention of Bernkastel. But her TIP assuredly suggests she did exist at some point. It's very unlikely she survived to even reach Rokkenjima in the "Prime" universe, but we really don't know. That aside, speculating on whether Erika exists IRL misses the entire point of Erika's introduction to the series. I don't much like her as a character, but there's a purpose to her existence that has nothing whatsoever to do with how plausible it is that she's real.
Also: "Shannon" was never a real human being. "Shannon" is a pseudonym for a human being who works for the family. It isn't her real name. None of the Fukuin servant names are real names. There has always been a person "behind" Shannon or Kanon, because that's the very definition of the role that they play. Whether you believe them to be separate or the same, their root identity isn't "Shannon the servant" or "Kanon the servant." There's a human being with a normal name in there. Bear in mind "Yasu" is also a nickname; we never actually learn her full name with absolute certainty... although you'd think people in the future would know. I mean, Ange should know.
__________________
|
|
|