Rate That Avatar!

[delorean2200]

Ganbaru: 8.4/10 overall its more about liking the concept of the avatar and the choice to shape it rather then the content since the render doesn't seem to mix well with it all imho, neither in style nor theme.
ArabianLuffy 8.2/10 good quality.
SOGESNAKE: 8.5/10 to bad there's no loop but otherwise nice idea.
iSuckAtWriting: 8/10 its not bad but unfortunately theimage quality isn't very good.

[ganbaru]

iSuckAtWriting 8,3/10 I do prefer the sig over the avatar as it show a bit more of her hair.
delorean2200 8,2/10 the focus might be a little too close

[Frailty]

it's been a while!
anyway
less talking, more rating!

ganbaru
9/10
Quality is pretty high. I love how smooth the image is and the head popping of the border is pretty cool too.

delorean2200
7/10
I'm not really a fan of using logos as avatars. But I'd give you an 8 if you made it yourself cause it's still a nice looking logo

iSuckAtWriting
6/10
I agree with ganbaru. Seeing how the hair flows in the sig and all, it looks weird if you don't see it in the avatar with that kind of focus. IMO, zoom in to the focal point more up to the point where you only see a portion of the character's neck. I think it'd look better that way.
props to you if you drew the character in both your avatar and signature

SOGESNAKE
7/10
not the smoothest of frame by frame transitions of a gif avatar, but it's still good. I don't have the right to say this, I can't even make a gif avatar that's longer than 10 frames lololol.

ArabianLuffy
7.5/10
Loop is pretty good.

YISUG
7/10
same reason as SOGESNAKE's

[ganbaru]

Frailty 8,6/10 good focus. Her yellow eyes aren't much of my taste but its nothing more.

[Houreki]

^ ganbaru 8.0 I like the colors and the border, it's original

[Kirito]

Been awhile since I've been here. None the less, let's get started.

Ahem:

Auxilism 9/10 - The shading and others efforts are really unique and neat. I really like it.
ganbaru 8.5/10 - Even with your avatars you're not going for the dark and cryptic look. Are you going for a complete makeover? The imagery looks pretty with a tinge of sadness coming from it. I do like it though.
delorean2200 8/10 - Is it something out of Muv Luv? Looks really cool.
Jmaster49 8.5/10 - Catgirl lovers get high scores from me. Really cute. Nice pick.
BotchkosVertigo 6/10 - Not really feeling it but nice attempt though.
grylsyjaeger 9.5/10 - Really enjoyed Onani Master Kurosawa so this definitely gets a really give score from me. This series really needs an anime or OAV etc.
Libros 8.8/10 - Really cute and mystical. I really like it! Nice!
RRW 8.6/10 - Love the blinking effects. I find it to be really cute and endearing for some reason.
iSuckAtWriting 9/10 - Really liked Bungako Shoujo so this gets a big score. The background and coloring look really pretty to look at. Still need to pick up the novels though.
YISUG 6.5/10 - Little weird but unique in its own right.
ArabianLuffy 8/10 - Haven't seen much of One Piece, but I really like the pic though. Is that Zolo with a really bad hairdo? Or is it someone different?
SOGESNAKE 8.8/10 - Really liked Ultimate Muscle. Waking up Saturday mornings to watch it... fun times.
Frailty 9.5/10 - Pretty colorful and cool. Really impressive and I really like how lightning was added in there.
Houreki 10/10 - The imagery and the background looks like I'm starting into the deep blue beautiful sea. I really like how the hair of the heroine sways in the background. Perfect score dude. Congrats!

[ganbaru]

Kirito 8,4/10 a good loop but the focus is a bit odd.

[BlankVoid]

5/10

my angus is peppered

[iSuckAtWriting]

BlankVoid ...It's unique. 7,1/10
ganbaru peekaboo~ 8,2/10
Kirito Nice loop, I can't stop starring. 8,3/10
Houreki I'm unsure if this needs a border or not. 8/10
Frailty It looks a TV monitor. A small one. 8,1/10
delorean2200 That's actually p kewl 8,3/10
SOGESNAKE Make the loop a bit moar fluid IYKWIM. 8,2/10

[ganbaru]

iSuckAtWriting 8,4/10 good focus

[mangatron]

@ganbaru

Hey, I like transparent avatars, though I could hardly do it as well as that. 10/10

[Krytonis]

mangatron: 9/10 great loop and quality

Just bringing this back to life

[ganbaru]

mangatron 8,6/10 good loop
Krytonis 8,5/10 good focus

[RRW]

Krytonis 8/10 pretty
ganbaru 7/10 neato, thought feel outdated

[Krytonis]

RRW: 8.6/10 good loop

[ganbaru]

RRW 8,4/10 feel kind of bland but the loop is very good.

[Kotohono]

RRW: cute loop 8/10.
ganbaru: Great looking image and looks nice with that shaping for transparency 9/10.

[Rikimtasu]

Konakaga 8/10 Light effect are pretty good.
ganbaru 9/10 crop is the best part of it,really.

[Krytonis]

Konakaga: 8.6/10 good quality
Rikimtasu: 8/10 not sure if it's the image but it looks like the quality is slightly off

[ganbaru]

Konakaga 8,5/10 good artwork
Rikimtasu 8,4/10 the background is kind of bland