AnimeSuki Forums

Kohane · 2017-09-30, 18:36

Spoiler for about Vol 9:

I was wondering about that from a long time ... (u don't have to read it if u don't want xD) my opinion about this anime.

Spoiler for what i think:

Why this author put the good things happening with Sistina (first heroine) ( i mean she's smart, have a good family, she's strong in magic, beauty, good in cooking, nothing bad target her life like Rumia and she will get the MC to like her in the end and happy ending

)

When Rumia (second heroine) get the bad things ( she's the princess who's drive out from her family she loved, she have a special power that not like the other ppl who have the same power as her like Glen said her power "Making impossible things possible" we still don't know much about her power which make ppl target her life until now and in the future since her power not temporary thing but with her all life, since she's the second daughter that mean the priority will go to Sistina who hold her family blood ( it seem in the old times ppl who're rich or famous they give the business of the family and priority to get marry and stuff like that for first child and the kids after first child should make there own life outside the family like in what happening in anime Kuroshitsuji if anyone know about it) there's some chara who appeared and saying stuff like she hate her the most, she give up about her love for Glen to Sistina , not good in cooking (tho she's start to get better in cooking in this Vol.9) not good in fighting which seem made some ppl don't like her because she's weak and just standing behind, well she's more like White mage (healing) and Sistina Black mage (fighting) like in the games and we still don't know what Rumia have to do in the future and in the past like what Namenlose said - i have a bad feeling about it lol

)

huh it seem things happening in here unfair lol

it'll be good if the author give some stuff to Sistina that have to do with her and not just that she's resemble to White Dog lol
it feel like the main chara here is Rumia since most Stuff happening
involved her and some for Glen and Sistina more like supporting chara :/
i feel sorry for Rumia for real lol

i don't think that the author have any attention to make Rumia fight since if she's able to fight then Sistina will have no role in this anime or more like a side chara because Rumia will have her rare power and fighting healing skill which will make her a strong heroine haha

if anyone get mad about what i said i'll just say this's my opinion and u don't have to agree with me if u don't like it, i'm just saying what i think and not that i said something bad about the chara but just the author way to write this story kind of strange lol and sorry for my bad Eng

Looking forward for Novel 10 ^^

syzorst · 2017-09-30, 19:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kohane

Spoiler for about Vol 9:

I was wondering about that from a long time ... (u don't have to read it if u don't want xD) my opinion about this anime.

Spoiler for what i think:

Why this author put the good things happening with Sistina (first heroine) ( i mean she's smart, have a good family, she's strong in magic, beauty, good in cooking, nothing bad target her life like Rumia and she will get the MC to like her in the end and happy ending

)

When Rumia (second heroine) get the bad things ( she's the princess who's drive out from her family she loved, she have a special power that not like the other ppl who have the same power as her like Glen said her power "Making impossible things possible" we still don't know much about her power which make ppl target her life until now and in the future since her power not temporary thing but with her all life, since she's the second daughter that mean the priority will go to Sistina who hold her family blood ( it seem in the old times ppl who're rich or famous they give the business of the family and priority to get marry and stuff like that for first child and the kids after first child should make there own life outside the family like in what happening in anime Kuroshitsuji if anyone know about it) there's some chara who appeared and saying stuff like she hate her the most, she give up about her love for Glen to Sistina , not good in cooking (tho she's start to get better in cooking in this Vol.9) not good in fighting which seem made some ppl don't like her because she's weak and just standing behind, well she's more like White mage (healing) and Sistina Black mage (fighting) like in the games and we still don't know what Rumia have to do in the future and in the past like what Namenlose said - i have a bad feeling about it lol

)

huh it seem things happening in here unfair lol

it'll be good if the author give some stuff to Sistina that have to do with her and not just that she's resemble to White Dog lol
it feel like the main chara here is Rumia since most Stuff happening
involved her and some for Glen and Sistina more like supporting chara :/
i feel sorry for Rumia for real lol

i don't think that the author have any attention to make Rumia fight since if she's able to fight then Sistina will have no role in this anime or more like a side chara because Rumia will have her rare power and fighting healing skill which will make her a strong heroine haha

if anyone get mad about what i said i'll just say this's my opinion and u don't have to agree with me if u don't like it, i'm just saying what i think and not that i said something bad about the chara but just the author way to write this story kind of strange lol and sorry for my bad Eng

Looking forward for Novel 10 ^^

I can understand what you're saying and it's true. Considering most of the bad stuff revolves around Rumia it does seem like she's the main Heroine. But I think that's why the story is written this way between Sistina and Rumia because they both balance out. Now let's look at both girls.

Yes everything you say about Sistina is true but there are things that you forgot to mention. Sistina is smart but she's also naive. She's strong but also can get too overconfident and arrogant. She's also not honest with herself which is the typical tsudere which is one of the reason she argues alot with Glenn.

Then you have Rumia. She's not as smart as Sistina is academically but she's sharp and can read people very well and understand the situations. Something that Sistina lacks because she's naive. Rumia was not meant to be a frontline fighter like Sistina which is why her power is best as support. Her healing magic is the best among any magician. Also unlike Sistina, Rumia is honest and is not afraid to speak her mind and what she feels. One of the main reasons Glenn treats Rumia better is Rumia accepts Glenn for who he is. She doesn't try to change Glenn like Sistina do by making him more professional and constantly nag about every little thing. Not to mention her will power is amazing and doesn't fear even in dire situation like in Volume 6.

Kohane · 2017-09-30, 20:50

Quote:

Originally Posted by syzorst

I can understand what you're saying and it's true. Considering most of the bad stuff revolves around Rumia it does seem like she's the main Heroine. But I think that's why the story is written this way between Sistina and Rumia because they both balance out. Now let's look at both girls.

Yes everything you say about Sistina is true but there are things that you forgot to mention. Sistina is smart but she's also naive. She's strong but also can get too overconfident and arrogant. She's also not honest with herself which is the typical tsudere which is one of the reason she argues alot with Glenn.

Then you have Rumia. She's not as smart as Sistina is academically but she's sharp and can read people very well and understand the situations. Something that Sistina lacks because she's naive. Rumia was not meant to be a frontline fighter like Sistina which is why her power is best as support. Her healing magic is the best among any magician. Also unlike Sistina, Rumia is honest and is not afraid to speak her mind and what she feels. One of the main reasons Glenn treats Rumia better is Rumia accepts Glenn for who he is. She doesn't try to change Glenn like Sistina do by making him more professional and constantly nag about every little thing. Not to mention her will power is amazing and doesn't fear even in dire situation like in Volume 6.

Spoiler for more:

well ... ur right about that, haha sorry in my opinion before i didn't say the bad side in Sistina nor the good side from Rumia but the opposite... so about what u said is exactly what i think about in both of them.

tho both of them main Heroine but it seem Sistina who get in the front most the time in covers LN, magazine, side story and Anime ( i'm really sad and upset about the anime... it feel like the director for this anime was in Sistina side, many things i noticed they removed about Rumia and the other Chara ... some line from Rumia they give it to Sistina .. it feel more like the anime for route sistina lol i don't think this anime will get second season since they really missed in first season and removed a lot ( fighting , about chara and some explanation... i don't know but i start to hate sistina when i watched the anime, i didn't hate her at all when i read manga and novel tho she's not my type but in the anime they let me hate her...i don't know why tho) that's why i was a little upset and said unfair lol
if Sistina will win in the end, why they didn't just make the anime like in the novel lol
for me i wanted to see all the novel as anime but after i saw what they did, i don't want season 2 anymore lol

for me i think each chara here have her way to help Glen:

Sistina with her power magic and knowledge like in Vol 1, 4 and 5 and later.

Rumia she helped with her magic healing like in Vol.1 ( i think she's the one who healed him since he was covered in blood since sistina couldn't heal him fully and it's pretty low chance that she carried him to the school in that stat) and helped in healing other time Glen Celica and Re=l in vol 6 or with other time since she helped all of them in vol 6 with her will power or her rare power and she always helping Glen morally in a lot of time or when he want to make decision or hesitation about something.

Celica helped Glen too by taking care of him for like 9 years and she's saved him like in Vol6 and 9 too.

Re=L helped Glen in vol 4 when he was close to die and she helped Glen, Rumia and Sistina many times after that like vol 6,7 and 9.

that's why i respect each girl here and each one of them have her way to help Glen when he close to die or making wrong decision.
that's what i think.

Haruka Haruka · 2017-10-01, 11:34

Omg really? So this Light novel going to the end?

Nooooooo

Just now that things are getting interesting!! I was hoping this novel would continue for another ten volumes xD

However, I agree with your opinion and I respect it, each one has its own preferences and opinion about it!
At first I hated Sistine because I hate the character "tsundere", while I prefer characters like Rumia, sweet, cute, kawaii xD
So at first I liked Rumia for her character, for her kindness ... I fell sorry for her because she was disowned by her family and almost killed. It's true that only bad things happen to Rumia ... !!
After some episode (i saw the anime first and then I read the light novel) I started to love Sistina, for her determination and her (implicit ahah) goodness. She loves Rumia and considers her like a sister, moreover she wants to become stronger to protect her! She is always ready to help others. That's why I like her character.

Don't get me wrong, I like Rumia, but EVERYTHING revolves around her, everything!
Rumia and Sistine are the female protagonists at the same level, but nevertheless every event concerns mainly Rumia (except volume 5 and 6).

I would like that the author deepen Glen's past (i want know more about Sara) the life and relationship with the other characters, but it seems always the same story: someone tries to kidnap Rumia and Glen saves her.
I hope that the author will continue the novel and he could give each one proper attention

(Sorry for my bad english)

BladeMancer · 2017-10-01, 13:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by Haruka Haruka

Omg really? So this Light novel going to the end?

Nooooooo

Just now that things are getting interesting!! I was hoping this novel would continue for another ten volumes xD

However, I agree with your opinion and I respect it, each one has its own preferences and opinion about it!
At first I hated Sistine because I hate the character "tsundere", while I prefer characters like Rumia, sweet, cute, kawaii xD
So at first I liked Rumia for her character, for her kindness ... I fell sorry for her because she was disowned by her family and almost killed. It's true that only bad things happen to Rumia ... !!
After some episode (i saw the anime first and then I read the light novel) I started to love Sistina, for her determination and her (implicit ahah) goodness. She loves Rumia and considers her like a sister, moreover she wants to become stronger to protect her! She is always ready to help others. That's why I like her character.

Don't get me wrong, I like Rumia, but EVERYTHING revolves around her, everything!
Rumia and Sistine are the female protagonists at the same level, but nevertheless every event concerns mainly Rumia (except volume 5 and 6).

I would like that the author deepen Glen's past (i want know more about Sara) the life and relationship with the other characters, but it seems always the same story: someone tries to kidnap Rumia and Glen saves her.
I hope that the author will continue the novel and he could give each one proper attention

(Sorry for my bad english)

Why would Rokuden end this early when it has fantastical sales? I cannot believe in the validity of this statement until proven otherwise, there are still many other subplots needing to be fixed up and as mentioned before it sells really good.

Haruka Haruka · 2017-10-01, 13:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by BladeMancer

Why would Rokuden end this early when it has fantastical sales? I cannot believe in the validity of this statement until proven otherwise, there are still many other subplots needing to be fixed up and as mentioned before it sells really good.

I think exaclty the same! There are many outstanding issues
Anyway i didn't write that but the other user

Kohane · 2017-10-01, 15:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by BladeMancer

Why would Rokuden end this early when it has fantastical sales? I cannot believe in the validity of this statement until proven otherwise, there are still many other subplots needing to be fixed up and as mentioned before it sells really good.

well i said the author said the story finally start "The Beginning of the End"
but is not like it'll end with 1 to 2 Volumes

maybe it'll take 10 Volumes maybe more or maybe less so maybe around 3 yeah or something like that maybe less it'll finish so it's not like it'll end in one year or so lol that's why don't worry because i don't think the author planing to finish the story until he complete everything in the story :3

Roxanne · 2017-10-01, 18:00

Rumia is cute, clever and honest but I doesn't still like her. I don't know why cant Rumia fight? She has fucking perfect power but she cant still fight. If she can't fight, then why did she enter a magical academy?

That is why I prefer Sistine. She is cute, tsundere and strong. Unlike Rumia She can fight.... Also, she is first heroine. if Lumia was first heroine, then I would drop the LN lol

blitz1/2 · 2017-10-01, 19:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by Emilia

Rumia is cute, clever and honest but I doesn't still like her. I don't know why cant Rumia fight? She has fucking perfect power but she cant still fight. If she can't fight, then why did she enter a magical academy?

That is why I prefer Sistine. She is cute, tsundere and strong. Unlike Rumia She can fight.... Also, she is first heroine. if Lumia was first heroine, then I would drop the LN lol

But that's why I DON'T like her.

You don't need to be a offensive mage user just to be "useful", that's exactly WHY Glen pretty much said Magic is ONLY good for killing. That is what reinforces that ideal.

Well, to me Rumia should have been the imouto and TRUE heroine.

Tenzen12 · 2017-10-03, 08:55

Tsundere or not even you should be able see Sisto is usually right and deliver punishment Glenn deserves and maybe she can even straight him up eventually!

It worked well with her parents at least.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BladeMancer

Why would Rokuden end this early when it has fantastical sales? I cannot believe in the validity of this statement until proven otherwise, there are still many other subplots needing to be fixed up and as mentioned before it sells really good.

Even if Rokuden ends, it doesn't mean it's about sales or anything. Maybe it simply ends because author has it planed out. It might actually hurt whole work if it were dragging out. Being able ends in to right time is great talent on it's own.

dragon213 · 2017-10-11, 17:45

when did Rumia admit that she loves Glen? Also I now understand why Sistine is crying when Glen is leaning over the blushing Rumia in the colored illustration in volume 7. Rumia had managed to convince Sistine to ask Glen to the dance party only for him to ask Rumia (to protect her of course, however does he show any attraction towards either her or sistine at this time?) and Rumia agrees, of course sistine would be sad in that case. Also anyone can see that she's jealous when she sees Rumia clinging to Glen's arm at the party

Iroha Isshiki · 2017-10-12, 07:15

Guys did Celica really die in volume 9?

dragon213 · 2017-10-12, 08:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Iroha Isshiki

Guys did Celica really die in volume 9?

Huh? What are you talking about?

hibiki3190 · 2017-10-12, 10:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by Iroha Isshiki

Guys did Celica really die in volume 9?

Nope, that is trash-bait on facebook, Celica still alive, better than ever.

wuhugm · 2017-10-12, 10:39

Lumia End Confirmed

blitz1/2 · 2017-10-12, 11:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by wuhugm

Lumia End Confirmed

Just the way I want it.

dragon213 · 2017-10-12, 14:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by wuhugm

Lumia End Confirmed

How is it confirmed?

Iroha Isshiki · 2017-10-12, 22:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by hibiki3190

Nope, that is trash-bait on facebook, Celica still alive, better than ever.

Goodness! As I thought she's not dead, When I see that trash bait post I seriously doubt my Japanese reading capability because for a second I thought I missed some sentences or any lines about Celica being dead. Thankfully she's not.

hibiki3190 · 2017-10-13, 08:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by Iroha Isshiki

Goodness! As I thought she's not dead, When I see that trash bait post I seriously doubt my Japanese reading capability because for a second I thought I missed some sentences or any lines about Celica being dead. Thankfully she's not.

You have probably forgotten, but Celica is immortal, she can't die, whether she wants.

Haruka Haruka · 2017-10-20, 14:42

Quote:

Originally Posted by wuhugm

Lumia End Confirmed

Where did you read it?

2017-09-30, 18:36	Link #421
Kohane Junior Member Join Date: Mar 2017	Spoiler for about Vol 9: It seem half Novel 9 about Sistina with Glen and the other half Rumia with Glen lol Interesting things happening in this volume and finally the story start to move as the author said "The Beginning of the End", things become finally good :3 I don't think it'll finish in next volume since the story about this anime finally start, i bet the next novel for sure will be about Glen and Rumia. The most important thing that the castle in the sky start to move ( i don't know much about what Glen and Rumia did to make it move ) this's what read, i don't understand much about jap so i don't know if i read it right or wrong I was wondering about that from a long time ... (u don't have to read it if u don't want xD) my opinion about this anime. Spoiler for what i think: Why this author put the good things happening with Sistina (first heroine) ( i mean she's smart, have a good family, she's strong in magic, beauty, good in cooking, nothing bad target her life like Rumia and she will get the MC to like her in the end and happy ending ) When Rumia (second heroine) get the bad things ( she's the princess who's drive out from her family she loved, she have a special power that not like the other ppl who have the same power as her like Glen said her power "Making impossible things possible" we still don't know much about her power which make ppl target her life until now and in the future since her power not temporary thing but with her all life, since she's the second daughter that mean the priority will go to Sistina who hold her family blood ( it seem in the old times ppl who're rich or famous they give the business of the family and priority to get marry and stuff like that for first child and the kids after first child should make there own life outside the family like in what happening in anime Kuroshitsuji if anyone know about it) there's some chara who appeared and saying stuff like she hate her the most, she give up about her love for Glen to Sistina , not good in cooking (tho she's start to get better in cooking in this Vol.9) not good in fighting which seem made some ppl don't like her because she's weak and just standing behind, well she's more like White mage (healing) and Sistina Black mage (fighting) like in the games and we still don't know what Rumia have to do in the future and in the past like what Namenlose said - i have a bad feeling about it lol ) huh it seem things happening in here unfair lol it'll be good if the author give some stuff to Sistina that have to do with her and not just that she's resemble to White Dog lol it feel like the main chara here is Rumia since most Stuff happening involved her and some for Glen and Sistina more like supporting chara :/ i feel sorry for Rumia for real lol i don't think that the author have any attention to make Rumia fight since if she's able to fight then Sistina will have no role in this anime or more like a side chara because Rumia will have her rare power and fighting healing skill which will make her a strong heroine haha if anyone get mad about what i said i'll just say this's my opinion and u don't have to agree with me if u don't like it, i'm just saying what i think and not that i said something bad about the chara but just the author way to write this story kind of strange lol and sorry for my bad Eng Looking forward for Novel 10 ^^

2017-10-01, 18:00	Link #428
Roxanne メンバー Join Date: Nov 2016	Rumia is cute, clever and honest but I doesn't still like her. I don't know why cant Rumia fight? She has fucking perfect power but she cant still fight. If she can't fight, then why did she enter a magical academy? That is why I prefer Sistine. She is cute, tsundere and strong. Unlike Rumia She can fight.... Also, she is first heroine. if Lumia was first heroine, then I would drop the LN lol Last edited by Roxanne; 2017-10-01 at 18:39.

2017-10-11, 17:45	Link #431
dragon213 Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2014	when did Rumia admit that she loves Glen? Also I now understand why Sistine is crying when Glen is leaning over the blushing Rumia in the colored illustration in volume 7. Rumia had managed to convince Sistine to ask Glen to the dance party only for him to ask Rumia (to protect her of course, however does he show any attraction towards either her or sistine at this time?) and Rumia agrees, of course sistine would be sad in that case. Also anyone can see that she's jealous when she sees Rumia clinging to Glen's arm at the party Last edited by dragon213; 2017-10-12 at 02:48.

2017-10-12, 10:39	Link #435
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	Lumia End Confirmed __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2017-10-01, 11:34	Link #424
Haruka Haruka Junior Member Join Date: Sep 2017 Location: Italy	Omg really? So this Light novel going to the end? Nooooooo Just now that things are getting interesting!! I was hoping this novel would continue for another ten volumes xD However, I agree with your opinion and I respect it, each one has its own preferences and opinion about it! At first I hated Sistine because I hate the character "tsundere", while I prefer characters like Rumia, sweet, cute, kawaii xD So at first I liked Rumia for her character, for her kindness ... I fell sorry for her because she was disowned by her family and almost killed. It's true that only bad things happen to Rumia ... !! After some episode (i saw the anime first and then I read the light novel) I started to love Sistina, for her determination and her (implicit ahah) goodness. She loves Rumia and considers her like a sister, moreover she wants to become stronger to protect her! She is always ready to help others. That's why I like her character. Don't get me wrong, I like Rumia, but EVERYTHING revolves around her, everything! Rumia and Sistine are the female protagonists at the same level, but nevertheless every event concerns mainly Rumia (except volume 5 and 6). I would like that the author deepen Glen's past (i want know more about Sara) the life and relationship with the other characters, but it seems always the same story: someone tries to kidnap Rumia and Glen saves her. I hope that the author will continue the novel and he could give each one proper attention (Sorry for my bad english)

2017-10-12, 07:15	Link #432
Iroha Isshiki Member Join Date: Jul 2017	Guys did Celica really die in volume 9?