2009-01-21, 06:57 | Link #1841 |
~ Your Smile ~
Author
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: 346Pro
Age: 38
|
tl;dr, you guys remember that the TSAB presence on Midchilda were being made lame due to the schemes of the High Council deshou? Had it been any other day, all the proper protocol would've been followed...
...and don't give me anything about how this would've never gotten through in a proper democracy. Prior to mid-StrikerS, TSAB really is a militaristic totalitarian government in disguise. Oh and don't be so confident about democracies either. Remember our credit crisis? Madoff? Sometimes, it's just humans being stupid.
__________________
|
2009-01-21, 07:02 | Link #1842 |
Adeptus Animus
Author
Join Date: Jan 2007
Age: 36
|
By all means, do explain what our current credit crisis, which was caused by banks, has anything to do with democracy?
But no, democracies aren't all powerful either. Our current prime minister is not the most shining example, and yet he managed to get himself elected as such. Also, a democracy is a form of government elected by the people, something which StrikerS obviously does not have. What it being ruled by the military and all. Last edited by Keroko; 2009-01-21 at 07:28. |
2009-01-21, 09:08 | Link #1843 | ||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
|
Quote:
Quote:
The biggest part in whether a loss or an un-necessarily hard win is acceptable is whether you can sell your audience into believing that there was nothing that can be done. They didn't manage to do it for Ep16 and Ep21. I'll have skipped your last example because that last one was quite controversial in its own right with its stupid "touching" save and all. It might have passed muster in a pure Magical Girl show but people's mood changed due to its military setting and the fact Fate is now 19, not 9 - now she just looks weak. But they DID manage to do it for the examples you showed. In fact, the first example in particular was almost written by a lawyer trying to exonerate Fate from any such accusation. We show her doing reasonably against Vita. Then we see Signum being so tough she just stands there and takes direct hits without effect and being able to blast Fate into walls. As if all this wasn't enough, 3 episodes later, Fate gets a rematch armed with cartridges and a toughened device and draws even. Lotte was pure surprise. Surprise is good. It not only exonerates the hero for the failure, it makes the villain look more villanous. I still have worse vibes of Aria and Lotte than Regius, Graham, Scarlietti and only a bit better than Precia. And they even wrote a lawyer's statement for that one too, about Aria and Lotte hiding so well even ship's scanners can't find them - the implications are obvious. Chrono's victory was paved carefully too. He's a skilled hero in his own right (he hadn't been sidelined yet). They show him at a higher rank. The teacher they decided to invert the Show, not Tell rule. This is the final defence. In a situation where you can't plausibly show your characters losing, but it is vital that they do, just SAY they did and make all as murky as possible, and let your readers plot their best rationalization. It is better than drawing it out and f*cking up. If they did half as well in handling the losses in Ep16 as they did in your examples, it might have escaped such criticisms. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||||
2009-01-21, 09:46 | Link #1844 |
Truth Martyr
Author
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Doing Anzu's paperwork.
Age: 38
|
Money and time, arky-baby, money and time. That, and most of the relevant internet details are in English - and if these things are already incomprehensible to a casual English speaker, how hard do you think it'll be for a non-native speaker?
Let's not forget that the creative team makes the final call; the Metal Gear Solid series has over the last 5 installments used the services of a military advisor (Paratrooper & SWAT trainer), but Kojima has admitted that when he needs a cool & awesome boss fight, he'll go with cool & awesome, realism taking a back seat. The swordfights in MGS, plus Raiden fighting off a Harrier II Plus, are proof of that. And this is a series that hired a military advisor. Look, give it a rest - why should you two bang your heads against the walls of each other? Just sit, and wait for the bell to ring. (Bonus points to whoever who can figure out which poem I'm quoting.)
__________________
|
2009-01-21, 09:50 | Link #1845 |
~ Your Smile ~
Author
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: 346Pro
Age: 38
|
@Keroko: I somehow mixed capitalism for democracy, and both aren't very good examples.
My main idea is to propose human stupidity for it happening as it is. On hindsight things look stupid yes, but at that point in time, either no one noticed, those who noticed didn't open their mouths, or were silenced in one way or another. Then the problem builds, then breaks. That's how crisis happens nowadays I think, and Midchilda isn't exactly immune...
__________________
|
2009-01-21, 10:28 | Link #1846 | ||||
Adeptus Animus
Author
Join Date: Jan 2007
Age: 36
|
Quote:
Quote:
Ah, I'm sorry. Backtracking my posts I realize I'm confusing theories with facts here, I was assuming that, with Belka dominating the dimensions for milenia, their loss also meant the loss of dimensional travel. I have no canon evidence for this theory though. Regardless, this not being the case makes Mid's progress even more admirable. Had they been the first to re-discover dimensional travel, they would be able to spread their influence much faster then any other world. However, if this is not the case, then Mid being both the most dominating magic style and the biggest fish in the pond becomes far more admirable. Quote:
Quote:
It takes time, and time equals money in more ways then just hourly pay. |
||||
2009-01-21, 11:17 | Link #1847 |
Truth Martyr
Author
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Doing Anzu's paperwork.
Age: 38
|
If it can be accepted that the writers are idiots and did not do the research, it also stands to reason that it can also be accepted the animators did not do a full on job. Hell, compare the animation quality between StrikerS and Macross Frontier. Even with a bigger budget, the animators on Frontier still screwed up a few times (like vapor trails from wingtip vortices forming in space. And no, official schematics rule out coolant being ejected from the wingtips.
__________________
|
2009-01-21, 13:10 | Link #1848 | |||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
To say that was some kind of redemption is like saying a good landing is one that you walk away from (even if the plane collapses on its landing gear). Quote:
Quote:
Besides, as I said, it is all relative competence. If the Orusians are no smarter at the game, then with an adequate commitment of numbers, the TSAB can probably maintain order. |
|||||||
2009-01-23, 06:24 | Link #1851 | |||||
Adeptus Animus
Author
Join Date: Jan 2007
Age: 36
|
Quote:
Quote:
Suddenly the panic attacks of the mages present become a lot easier to understand. Quote:
Remember what I said about nitpicking? You're doing it again. I could sit here and nitpick any of the melee casts victories and throw in the same analogy, but the end result is simple: They won. They held of and defeated an enemy that had trampled them before. Sure, if you nitpick you can say 'but it wasn't perfect!' but they won nonetheles. Why is it that everything else is reasonable, and excusable, but military tactics must be ground into the dust? Quote:
The simple fact is that the TSAB still has conflicts to deal with. That's why the Navy draws in all the elites. Not to have them roam around on a ship with nothing to do, but because they're needed. If the TSAB fails to be a competent military organization, how do you explain its existence for 150 years? Quote:
Or they could simply not control it out of diplomatic reasons. The country is embroiled in a civil war after all. The TSAB as it stands needs not necisarily be a dictatorship that conquers all who opose. |
|||||
2009-01-23, 09:05 | Link #1852 | |||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
|
Quote:
Quote:
Anything else is fanciful wishing. Double the points taken off for this being the battalion assigned to guard HQ, thus presumably an elite battalion (at least among GF), which means most of the GF units are below on the scale. As an elite battalion, what we SHOULD have been seeing is some moral fibre even AFTER the (nonexistent) first attacks don't work. What we should have been seeing, at the very least, are them trying stuff similar to what the Forwards did when they did. Commanders should be taking charge, and if they can't think of something imaginative they can at least try concentrating a squad's fire onto one. What we certainly shouldn't be seeing, even from a bunch of complete military ignoramuses, is them running without a fight, unless the intent is indeed to make them look like d*umb*sses. At least the air mages actively closed, but there is a point in "rapid defeat by the enemy" where what people think is no longer "Man, the enemies are strong", but "Man, the good guys are weak." And before you blame the budget or the timeframes (as you tend to do when what is seen start going against you), do note that things do change when you add the military - you have to show them trying, or at least NOT show them wimping out so blatantly. And don't say 7Arcs is too dumb for this. While the attempt was crude, they were smart enough to do something like that for Ep23. And while you are right that RF6 isn't sure whether it'll be Jail, but if anything, Jail's guys coming would be something of a morale booster to them because they'll be fighting what they've fought and practiced against for months. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Idea 2: The Arcenciel idea. Idea 3: Leave such worlds as non-management. Quote:
Quote:
Most likely, after so many years of war, they got so sick of it that they were willing to have peace, and eventually, an intricate web of economic and other mutual interests makes war an unsavory prospect. Quote:
Quote:
|
|||||||||
2009-01-23, 10:12 | Link #1853 |
Grumpy Russian bear
|
Ehm... TSAB is 75 years old in Strikers. And have usual "3rd generation" problems. Revolutioners of 1st and builders of 2nd generation are out of play mostly and it's 3rd generation who are bureaucrats and/or careerist are in play which is highly visible... It's actually entirely possible that TSAB would selfdestruct as many other countries/cultures/organizations which didn't overcame 70years barrier - most visible example in modern times was USSR...
|
2009-01-23, 14:29 | Link #1854 |
Once and Current Subber
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Well, the TSAB has the advantage of having at least some of the founding members still around, even if they're not on active duty anymore. More parallels to Meiji Japan?
It's obvious that the show is grooming Nanoha/Fate/Hayate to eventually step into that role - not so much governance as providing moral direction, military inspiration, and a panic button. (Okay, they're already the panic button.) So reasonably speaking, no, they'll do all right, because they got really lucky and recruited the right people. But you're correct, it's obvious that the "modern" TSAB has not been in a prolonged combat situation. I still like the British Imperial model - strong navy, which draws a high proportion of the elites, leaving an army that's not particularly effective, and which gets neglected because it just doesn't have much to do and when it is in action, it's often against under-armed natives from "overseas"... Let's give them this much credit - the cartridge system went from "rare historical oddity" to "in general, if not universal, use" between A's and Strikers. Without the spur of a war, a lot of militaries wouldn't have made that jump. |
2009-01-31, 06:05 | Link #1856 |
Adeptus Animus
Author
Join Date: Jan 2007
Age: 36
|
New information from SSX throws yet another light on past observations. In track 16 of disc 2, Subaru is hit by what is blatantly labeled an 'artillery' style cannon with 'live ammunition' that could 'destroy a tank in one shot'
And Subaru? Without any active defense being thrown up, she comes out with even less damage then after her fight with Nove and Cinque. This means that the blows being exchanged during the fight between Nove, Cinque and Subaru exceeded the power of an artillery cannon during their fight in episode 17. With no active defenses being thrown up, that means her only defense was her Barrier Jacket and her Cyborg body. Cinque's and Subaru's blows had to go through an active Barrier as well, further increasing their power. It also deals another blow to the 'measured speed is always an accurate display of power' and 'Mid buildings are made of foam' theories. |
2009-01-31, 06:26 | Link #1857 | |
Sword Wielding Penguin
|
Quote:
Generally, that's how most modern firepower against tanks works. Either you blow the tank up in one shot, or you're toast. It's just the way the armor works. Either you reach the fail point, or you don't. Now the question is. What kind of tank? If they had a japanese tank in mind, the artillery round might be smaller. Seriously. Not all tanks are created equal. We're talking 'What is the difference between a T-72, an Abrams, a Challenger II, and a Greopard.' (And if Mid-Childa tanks are being thought of in the comparison, then it must be a lousy artillery shell. Remember how horribly poor those tank designs are. ^_^; You can probably take those things out with confetti popers.) |
|
2009-01-31, 06:32 | Link #1858 |
Adeptus Animus
Author
Join Date: Jan 2007
Age: 36
|
Mariages were created during a time when mass-weaponry was common usage, so the Mid-type (which we haven't even seen in action once, so we can't exactly call them 'poor' especially in light of this new knowledge) is probably not a correct standard.
Considering no tank type is mentioned (just 'a tank') we can't say it was a heavy tank. Though by the same logic we can't say it was a light tank either. Why don't we take the middle ground in this? A medium tank (if that's the correct term <_<) so to say. |
2009-01-31, 07:03 | Link #1859 | |
Sword Wielding Penguin
|
Quote:
I think one could adapt that to tanks. There are two types of tanks on the battlefield. Tanks, and scrap metal. Guess where mid-childan 'tanks' go... |
|
|
|