Rate That Signature!

[Takeru]

Radiosity~ haha, love it. 8.9/10
bl4xb0x~ nice effects 8/10

[Cyz]

@ Raiju32: reading time hm? 7/10

[darkjester]

bl4xb0x: i like the whole effect... nicely done... 8/10
Cyz: more than meets the eye, me thinks... it speaks to me, though, i feel somethings missing... 7.1/10

mmmkay....

[guiltygearxt]

darkjester:
ava: 7.5/10
sig: 8/10

Cyz:
ava: 8/10 (kawaii)
sig: 8/10 (1 of better sigs ive seen from u, skill wise ofc)

Raiju32
ava: 7.5/10 (sry not a fan of Lucky Star)
sig: 7/10 (same reason above )

[KeiKei-chan]

gulitygearxt :
avatar : ~Nice^_^~8/10
signature : ~Cool~^_^8/10

Raiju32 :
avatar : Kawaii Ne 8/10
signature : 7/10 ... wonderful

Cyz :
avatar : Cute ... 8/10
signature : Looks Good! 8/10

[Tatsumiko]

Why are you guys rating the avatars also?....you know there's a seperate "Rate that avatar" topic also ....T.T"

Keikei-chan : very small....6/10

[Cyz]

@ guiltygearxt: Another Matsuri sig! Very nice indeed. Hm, she's a little too bright though 8/10

[felix]

* Braces self for Mass-Deletion

Remmeber kids.. Rate Or Die is the name of the game. For Example: Raiju 11 - 9

Looking @ KeiKei-chan...

Mmm.. I think your sig is over the limits. It will get deleted if a mod sees it, I'm afraid.

[felix]

	Didn't that get deleted last time?!.. It's too big as well. If you right click on the image you'll see that the main image is 144 px heigh. You have text so the maximum allowed is 120 px. It's actually not only that... but well that's enough to make it illegal. By the way, double posting is not allowed unless you're posting on something like 10minute intervals.
	-------------------------------------------
	You can try to ask one of the forum Moderators/Super Moderators/Admins that is currently online over pm if it's good or not. ...here's a list with them.
	Also, like I said in my last post.. You have to rate someone for EVERY post you make in this thread, regardless of context, or they will be deleted.

-----
Cyz -- I'll give it a 8.9 for a starting siggy.

[~Tsukuyomi]

@Cats
The most simple and one of the best work I've seen!!! Great arrangement and meaning... 9/10

@deathreape
Cropped image with text... 4/10

@Radiosity
Quite basic... Image, background, text, borders, nothing much to it...


Not anime, but who cares...

[Cyz]

@ Cats: It's the 2nd sig I used here (3rd sig I made actually, 2nd one hasn't been use yet). Just an FYI

@ Tsukuyomi: Not one of your bests. 4/10



-> My 4th sig that I made. I love Spider Man and I've been waiting for the 3rd movie for quite some tme now. So..I made a little sig of Spider Man in his black suit. I know, the color is a little dark but I have myself a little fun making this one. Heh, went wild with the Photoshop

[darkjester]

srsly though.... whats with all the deleted posts..... rules are easy as pie.... rate a sig or post gets deleted..... simple... and yea, there's a seperate thread for avatar rating... gg though....


guiltygearxt: mmmm, its ok, it just doesn't "do it" for me though... 6/10
~Tsukuyomi: agree with cyz... but u get an extra point cuz jack sparrow is cool 5.1/10
Cyz's spidy sig: i like it, it blends well... 7.9/10

k thxs

[Wandy]

darkjester - 6/10 the image looks like you duplicated it and took the other half and combined it with the original..try blending it a little bit more XD and there are choppy parts of Rin that needs fixing


Stellar~

Spoiler:

[KiNA]

Hahha.. monir on rampage

@ Raiju.. Simplicity at its best ^^b

@ Cyz .. Cute =3 froggy mikuru with lemon! Whats with the sudden butterfly BG tho .. too weird and dont match lol.
=- For you spidey sig, the font dont match. AT ALL . Nice crop angle tho ^^

@ Tsukoyomi~ .. Borders!!!!

@ Cats .. I lolled a the big meanie pic

@ dakjester the blending dont work too well.. you cant see a line in the mid that separate the right and the left =/ . Rin also have a jaggy edge on the right.

@ Azami .. Stellar never wear red blouse .. It do feel empty, thus dont really match her face expression IMO .. unlike your current sig, which the emptyness of the sig matched her face expression .. that being said .. demanding your current sig source I'm enchanted by her bew.. I mean beauty

@ KiNA .. There something not right with this, yet I cant pinpoint it myself due to my eyes keep getting distracted over some huge matters .. requiring assistance

[Aoie_Emesai]

Cyz - that's the frog outfit correct? Very cute.

darkjester - how stoic she looks. But I do believe that's her personality. (careful, your sig is ???x160 with text, you better shrink it down to ???x120 for text too.

Azami - it's rather bright. Maybe a layer of curve could be good for it.

KiNa - who is that girl you always use for your signature and avvy? Reminds me of Aya from Chrono Trigger ^_^.

also this sig of your, is it really Fate Teta...... (nanoha girl)

Spoiler:

ps: Finally finished it. Hope ya like it. She's so pretty too ^_^. Random Hiro Suzuhira artwork.

[darkjester]

OMG... u guys are gonna make me /cry... srsly...

rofl nah, not really... but omg, i didn't split the image in half or seperate or whatever... it's abstract... i took a different path this time and combined several images as well as a couple added effects, and one of the images was a garden with a pond in it, if u had noticed... there wasn't just ONE line.. there' were several... those lines were the "reeds" in the pond...

yes, i noticed it, but i kept it, cuz i thought it looked kinda cool, giving the tree a sorta crying feeling... but then u all come to think that i'm duplicatiing and spliting original images... rofl... n e wayz... i "fixed" it, so now it doesn't look like there's a "blending problem",(basically just clone stamped over the reeds).... as for Rin... i think the problem was in the reducing it to meet the restrictions... i tried fixing it a bit... but wasn't too successful...

either way, thanks for the critisizm... i am still amatuer at best, but, remember though... i focus on abstract... gg no re...


Aoie_Emesai: it's definitly got pizazz! 8.2/10

k thxs

[Pellissier]

guiltygearxt: Matsuri! Bias rating, but it looks a bit confused.. 7,5/10

darkjester: A tad too long.. not much going on, on the left. Rin is a plus though ^^ 7/10

Cats: Love it, ditto already. 9,5/10

KiNA: The right pic looks a bit rough, perhaps the extraction or perhaps the contrast is too strong. Not fond of the line behind your name, it didn't need to be so long, where it is white it's distracting. However, a good "unlazy" work 8,5/10

Aoie_Emesai: Cute girl, cute pose and cute colors make a cute signature cuter ^_^ 8/10

--
As for me, I guess I've taken quite a sympathy for the Hiiragi twins ^^

[Cyz]

@ KiNa: I'm not very good at matching things I have to work on that one As for why there are butterflies on Mikuru....I want to make it "nature" like wise thingy since she's dressed up as a frog though. Anyway, your sig, I like the last one better but this one is okay too 8/10

@ Pellissier: The twins ne? Really nice! Go Tsukasa-chan! ^o^ 9/10

[Jamezterr]

7/10 I like it alot, very easy on the eyes, pleasant to look at, and I like the colors. =D

[KeiKei-chan]

Jamezterr - I like the colours!Not Bad!!!~ 89%