Character Discussion - Shirley

[Roloko vi Britannia]

Of course he is a yandere after all it was her fault anyways she should have stayed out of the building and told Lelouch her feelings later unless she was that obsessed over him she couldn't wait any longer oh well thats what happens if you ignore the police officers warnings the whole thing could have been avoided so it just a bad decision on her part which led to a not so desirable consequence. Then again this is solely MY opinion and this thread needs opposing views every once in a while from the other side of the fence so it might as well be me

[Hsadman]

Originally Posted by Roloko vi Britannia

Of course he is a yandere after all it was her fault anyways she should have stayed out of the building and told Lelouch her feelings later unless she was that obsessed over him she couldn't wait any longer oh well thats what happens if you ignore the police officers warnings the whole thing could have been avoided so it just a bad decision on her part which led to a not so desirable consequence. Then again this is solely MY opinion and this thread needs opposing views every once in a while from the other side of the fence so it might as well be me

Rawr! It is someone with a opposing view from me who expresses it in a sensible and plausible way! I must troll him!

Just kidding, I don't hate people for their opinion's, its just childish

I do agree that Shirley should of stayed outside, but at this point she was concerned about Lelouch's safety against Jeremiah. And perhaps she is obsessed but Rolo wouldn't be much different in that sense

[Roloko vi Britannia]

Originally Posted by Hsadman

Rawr! It is someone with a opposing view from me who expresses it in a sensible and plausible way! I must troll him!

Just kidding, I don't hate people for their opinion's, its just childish

I do agree that Shirley should of stayed outside, but at this point she was concerned about Lelouch's safety against Jeremiah. And perhaps she is obsessed but Rolo wouldn't be much different in that sense

yeah I know he does, but at least he can protect Lelouch and I respect fans like you who don't get all butthurt for someone hating their favorite character or paring unlike this one Shirley fan (not on here btw) who kept on spamming me telling to die and burn in hell with Rolo I was like wtf?? Well anyways back on topic I just can't see Shirley with Lelouch or anyone I would go more into it, but it would involving severe bashing and flaming of Shirley so I will just leave it at that out of respect for you and her other fans or will I?? kufufufu

[Hsadman]

Originally Posted by Roloko vi Britannia

yeah I know he does, but at least he can protect Lelouch and I respect fans like you who don't get all butthurt for someone hating their favorite character or paring unlike this one Shirley fan (not on here btw) who kept on spamming me telling to die and burn in hell with Rolo I was like wtf?? Well anyways back on topic I just can't see Shirley with Lelouch or anyone I would go more into it, but it would involving severe bashing and flaming of Shirley so I will just leave it at that out of respect for you and her other fans or will I?? kufufufu

I don't understand bashing of any character, including Rolo. Its a waste of time, energy, and anger you need to argue with your girlfriend.

Wait what?

Anyhow, I'm not very sensitive (In most cases), and I respect anyone's opinion. There are an enormous amount of people on this Earth, it would be preposterous if I expect every one of them to hold my mentality. That would be a boring-ass world.

Offtopic.

By the way, even though I raged at Rolo when Shirley died, I can't picture him in hell. More like someone who disturbs Lelouch's threesomes with Shirley and Euphie in heaven.

Rolo - Onii-sama! I want to join too!

Lelouch - Oh fine! But I'm doing you last!

Alas, I believe I've pressed my point...kind of

[Roloko vi Britannia]

Originally Posted by Hsadman

I don't understand bashing of any character, including Rolo. Its a waste of time, energy, and anger you need to argue with your girlfriend.

Wait what?

Anyhow, I'm not very sensitive (In most cases), and I respect anyone's opinion. There are an enormous amount of people on this Earth, it would be preposterous if I expect every one of them to hold my mentality. That would be a boring-ass world.

Offtopic.

By the way, even though I raged at Rolo when Shirley died, I can't picture him in hell. More like someone who disturbs Lelouch's threesomes with Shirley and Euphie in heaven.

Rolo - Onii-sama! I want to join too!

Lelouch - Oh fine! But I'm doing you last!

Alas, I believe I've pressed my point...kind of

I can't picture him in hell either, but anyways before this derails too much this is supposed to be about Shirley. I find it strange as much as I dispise her her character song is beautiful I don't know it just gives me this weird feeling everytime I listen to it I love that kind of music and Shirley isn't using her annoying anime voice when she sings instead its soft and calm maybe thats why I like it as much as I do. I know I hate the character, but I like her song I'm weird like that.

[Hsadman]

Originally Posted by Roloko vi Britannia

I can't picture him in hell either, but anyways before this derails too much this is supposed to be about Shirley. I find it strange as much as I dispise her her character song is beautiful I don't know it just gives me this weird feeling everytime I listen to it I love that kind of music and Shirley isn't using her annoying anime voice when she sings instead its soft and calm maybe thats why I like it as much as I do. I know I hate the character, but I like her song I'm weird like that.

I know lots of people who despise a character but love their theme music (Cough Cough *Aizen* Cough Cough). I think Shirley's just has that harmonic soothing vibe to it, relaxes your soul

Its easy to hate a character, I myself don't because I well....can't really bring myself to it. But after generic replica's and 'annoyingness' I understand how people bring themselves against them. But still, I love Shirley, I just fall for the innocent types, and in my eyes she was somewhat unique in her case. Just my opinion.

[azul120]

It's not Shirley's fault for being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Rolo was at fault for killing her just because she mentioned the one person whose existence he wanted erased. And in the process, he also eliminated one of Lelouch's chances for stability. Nice job breaking it, anti-hero.

[Hooves]

Well it was neither Rolo or Shirley's fault. Shirley was just desperate that she wanted to find atleast one way to help be by Lelouch's side during all the crisis that was happening in the building. So she got her gun, and went into the building to find some way to find and help Lelouch with all his troubles.

Rolo saw Shirley with a gun, and when she said the one name "Lelouch" he instantly thought she was going to kill him after recovering her memories of Lelouch being Zero. Then thought that it would be best to protect his brother's identity by getting rid of her.. But the results leading to Lelouch's breakdown.

[Hsadman]

Originally Posted by Hooves

Well it was neither Rolo or Shirley's fault. Shirley was just desperate that she wanted to find atleast one way to help be by Lelouch's side during all the crisis that was happening in the building. So she got her gun, and went into the building to find some way to find and help Lelouch with all his troubles.

Rolo saw Shirley with a gun, and when she said the one name "Lelouch" he instantly thought she was going to kill him after recovering her memories of Lelouch being Zero. Then thought that it would be best to protect his brother's identity by getting rid of her.. But the results leading to Lelouch's breakdown.

You can easily find reason in his actions, just that they were very contradictory and consequential.

[Hooves]

Originally Posted by Hsadman

You can easily find reason in his actions, just that they were very contradictory and consequential.

One thing Rolo could have done when he saw Shirley with a gun was not kill her while using his Geass. But take the gun away from her, so she cannot do anything and would have to be turned away.. That could have been one thing...

[Hsadman]

Originally Posted by Hooves

One thing Rolo could have done when he saw Shirley with a gun was not kill her while using his Geass. But take the gun away from her, so she cannot do anything and would have to be turned away.. That could have been one thing...

Or, you know, let her finish her sentence

[Hooves]

Originally Posted by Hsadman

Or, you know, let her finish her sentence

Well Rolo probably thought she would have made a move when she finished her sentence

[azul120]

Rolo used the gun thing as an excuse. He killed her after she mentioned wanting to bring back Nunnally. That was it.

[Kittenlady]

If we're assuming Rolo has anything amounting to a brain, then I'm pretty sure he'd know that Shirley was inexperienced with a gun and, oh yeah, had nothing against Lelouch from the way she was talking. She was literally saying "Let's help him!".

It was only when she mentioned Nunnally that he killed her. It was jealousy, and a mention of her name resulted in a knee jerk reaction from Rolo.

[Hooves]

Makes a lot more sense in a way. If Nunnally was ever brought back, Lelouch would stop caring for Rolo as a little brother. Then would just throw him away and leave him to be alone.

[Roloko vi Britannia]

Well even if she didn't have the gun he still would have killed her regardless wither she mention Nunally or not. He would have slashed her neck killing her instantly which I would have preferred since I wouldn't have to hear that corny generic "I will still love you even if I am reborn" speech and it would have probably made her fans happier that way since she wouldn't have suffered.

[azul120]

Originally Posted by Roloko vi Britannia

Well even if she didn't have the gun he still would have killed her regardless wither she mention Nunally or not. He would have slashed her neck killing her instantly which I would have preferred since I wouldn't have to hear that corny generic "I will still love you even if I am reborn" speech and it would have probably made her fans happier that way since she wouldn't have suffered.

No he wouldn't have. It was only when she said Nunnally that he snapped.

Aside from that, it would have been worse had she been murdered as you described it. Besides, if her final words were corny and generic, I'd hate to consider what Villetta and Ohgi's unholy union would be considered.

[Roloko vi Britannia]

Originally Posted by azul120

No he wouldn't have. It was only when she said Nunnally that he snapped.

Aside from that, it would have been worse had she been murdered as you described it. Besides, if her final words were corny and generic, I'd hate to consider what Villetta and Ohgi's unholy union would be considered.

unique comes to mind there. I think he would have cause if she would have moved from that spot saying she wants to see Lelouch while waving that gun around he probably would have killed her to protect him then in that case.

[Hsadman]

I have to agree with Azul here, Rolo killed Shirley cause of her mentioning of Nunally. I highly doubt he would've killed her otherwise.

[Hooves]

There is many reasons why Rolo killed Shirley

1. Shirley mentioned "Lelouch" with a gun in her hand, and talk on non-sense in Rolo's PoV. Leading Rolo to believe that Shirley was going to kill Lelouch for killing her father.

2. Shirley mentioned "Nunnally" which meant that once Nunnally was saved, Rolo would easily be replaced from brother to sister. Then be left to die, because he betrayed the people he worked for, and has no one else to support him.