AnimeSuki Forums

Asakura_Y0h · 2004-04-08, 23:51

You see another reason why I said that Ed would die was because it would make a good ending... my opinions are that good endings are the ones that leave the most memorable impression... in my case if Ed did die heroically in the end... I'd feel really sad to the point of crying, angry because there was no other way but happy as well because he died for a good cause... Any ending to an anime that can make you feel this much emotion would be great.... and I think if Ed does die, the impact would be really great because for us FMA watchers, we take it for granted that Ed is and always will be alive and well..

jonli · 2004-04-09, 02:09

I think Ed will die as well.

And probably Roy as well.....

JubeiYamazaki · 2004-04-09, 03:05

The new ending isn't to foreshadow Windy's death... but...

Spoiler:

Scrumhalf · 2004-04-09, 03:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by JubeiYamazaki

The new ending isn't to foreshadow Windy's death... but...

Spoiler:

kamij0 · 2004-04-09, 07:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scrumhalf

Spoiler:

Fei-san · 2004-04-12, 18:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by kamij0

Spoiler:

Mizuki · 2004-04-12, 19:14

i would say al dies protecting his brother.
roy will probably die and hawkeye will take over him .

loki9x · 2004-04-12, 20:04

There's no reason for there to be a giant climactic battle versus all seven sins plus their creator in the last few episodes...sins can be temporarily debilitated (eg Lust with a knife in her head) and indefinitely contained and controlled (eg Greed, presumably through alchemist sealing wards), and presumably they can be killed as well.

So the question is, which will be the first sin to go? Sloth hasn't had any face time yet, so the question might be, will they develop her or quickly kill her off (and by quickly I mean in the next seven to ten episodes)? Lust is the worst fighter, but Gluttony would be so helpless without her that either he'll die or she'll die and he'll really go off the deep end. Wrath and Greed seem too important to kill, for plot reasons, and Envy really has one of the most enviable and useful abilities that so far has been sorely underutilized. I don't think she'll go until she's done something awful, like killed Windy, taken over her body, infiltrated the Club Elric, messed with Ed for a few episodes, seduced him, and then revealed herself and driven him into despair and insanity.

So my predictions: Envy assumes the personality of someone important, and Gluttony dies, although the first is doubly awful because we'll lose someone else we like in the process, and the second sucks because he is the funniest and cutest characters, in his own special way. Or else Envy will be the one who dies, which might actually make more sense, because she will have fulfilled her plot purpose at that point.

Oh, and can we get an authoritative answer: what gender is Envy?

Yebyosh · 2004-04-12, 21:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by loki9x

Oh, and can we get an authoritative answer: what gender is Envy?

It.

Or "I'm not sure... lemme check... uh I dunno"

Seriously even he doesn't know since he forgotten his original form. The reason his gender is classified as male at the moment is that he prefers the teenage boy form that we see him in.

Interesting possibility. Envy's the earliest protoype of homunculi. Because if he is not, the other Sins would have known what was his original form and would have reminded him of it. But none have done so.

Zauren · 2004-04-12, 21:20

My question is, if this is not Envy's original form, why did he choose it? And is he older then Greed in such a case, or is Greed just too pimpish to say?

Fighter Volk · 2004-04-12, 21:47

It may also be possible that Greed was locked away before Envy was 'created', hence he would not know Envy's original form; hence, we cannot deduce that Envy was the first Sin created. And still, we do not know much about Sloth, Wrath, Greed, or Pride...

Kurama no Miko2003 · 2004-04-13, 15:24

I dunno if killing off Winry is the best option they have right now . . . if anything, it's probably going to be Mustang and Co. The Sins are more interested in killing off anyone who tries to figure out the truth OTHER than Ed 'n Al. After all, if the results will end up disastrous, the Sins won't want ANYONE warning Ed 'n Al of that. Look at what happened to the last one who figured it out. (Side note: I forgot how to make spoiler tags, so the identity of that particular character will remain hidden. Anyone who's seen far enough will know who I'm talking about.) Now, while Winry dying is a viable option, I think she hasn't completely served her purpose to the plot of the story just yet. Therefore, she's probably safe from getting killed off . . . for the time being. That doesn't mean she can't die later on. She's just . . . temporarily safe.

~ Kurama no Miko2003

Nagare Ryouma · 2004-04-13, 15:57

Well anybody but not Hawkeye and Winry PLS! Ahem... Anyways, since the military is somehow corrupted, and Mustang vowed he's gonna find out the so-called truth behind Hughes death and what he was searching for before his death; it quickly put's Mustang and his team into danger practically. I guess the Elric bro's we'll be busy fending off those Ex-state alchemist troops we see in the new OP.... I wonder what's gonna happen to Scar now? Found a new path in his life? Dunno if he's gonna end up dying or not....

Yoshi31 · 2004-04-14, 13:07

if Winry was to die....

Spoiler:

jakkz · 2004-04-14, 13:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yoshi31

if Winry was to die....

Spoiler:

i would do same thing too

dragonz20 · 2004-04-14, 13:45

Why are u all using tags when it's all speculation!?...

but I'll play along...

Spoiler:

WabukiSensei · 2004-04-14, 19:42

Speaking of the Fuhrer, is he really a King or something? I mean his name is King Bradley. He must've earned the title of King if he was of Royal Blood.

Spoiler for Anime viewers who don't wanna be spoiled shouldn't open this:

inv4zn · 2004-04-14, 20:29

i want everyone to die!

Yebyosh · 2004-04-14, 21:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by WabukiSensei

Speaking of the Fuhrer, is he really a King or something? I mean his name is King Bradley. He must've earned the title of King if he was of Royal Blood.

"King" is just a name and not a title.

Sorta like how now we have people named "River", "Aqua", "Leaf", "Princess" etc...

Avi · 2004-04-14, 22:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by dragonz20

Why are u all using tags when it's all speculation!?...

but I'll play along...

Spoiler:

Ya, im wondering about that as well.. we kno he isnt a dumbass for sure

2004-04-09, 03:05	Link #43
JubeiYamazaki Senior Member Join Date: Mar 2003	The new ending isn't to foreshadow Windy's death... but... Spoiler: THE DEATH OF THEIR DOG~! BERNARD(?)~!

2004-04-14, 13:07	Link #54
Yoshi31 Resident Dinosaur Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Good ol' California Age: 41	if Winry was to die.... Spoiler: I would cry..

2004-04-14, 13:45	Link #56
dragonz20 Cantonese Dimples Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: North Jersey (near NY city) Age: 46	Why are u all using tags when it's all speculation!?... but I'll play along... Spoiler: Since we're speculating about death, I think the Flame Alchemist will die sometime during the series (probably close to the end). And since we're into speculation, I have this weird suspicious feeling that the Fuhrer (the top guy in the militiary ~ forgot how it was spelled) isn't as clueless as the anime has made him out to be. I think he's hiding something and may actually be behind some of the things that are going on. He didn't get into his position by being a complete dumbass u know.. But then again, this is all speculation.

2004-04-14, 19:42	Link #57
WabukiSensei Chillin out Join Date: Mar 2004	Speaking of the Fuhrer, is he really a King or something? I mean his name is King Bradley. He must've earned the title of King if he was of Royal Blood. Spoiler for Anime viewers who don't wanna be spoiled shouldn't open this: Wouldn't make sense since he's a homunculus...

2004-04-08, 23:51	Link #41
Asakura_Y0h little black butterfly Join Date: Nov 2003 Age: 42	You see another reason why I said that Ed would die was because it would make a good ending... my opinions are that good endings are the ones that leave the most memorable impression... in my case if Ed did die heroically in the end... I'd feel really sad to the point of crying, angry because there was no other way but happy as well because he died for a good cause... Any ending to an anime that can make you feel this much emotion would be great.... and I think if Ed does die, the impact would be really great because for us FMA watchers, we take it for granted that Ed is and always will be alive and well..

2004-04-09, 02:09	Link #42
jonli JONLIの憂' Join Date: Apr 2004	I think Ed will die as well. And probably Roy as well.....

2004-04-12, 19:14	Link #47
Mizuki Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Australia	i would say al dies protecting his brother. roy will probably die and hawkeye will take over him .

2004-04-12, 20:04	Link #48
loki9x 大魔王 Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Providence, RI Age: 41	There's no reason for there to be a giant climactic battle versus all seven sins plus their creator in the last few episodes...sins can be temporarily debilitated (eg Lust with a knife in her head) and indefinitely contained and controlled (eg Greed, presumably through alchemist sealing wards), and presumably they can be killed as well. So the question is, which will be the first sin to go? Sloth hasn't had any face time yet, so the question might be, will they develop her or quickly kill her off (and by quickly I mean in the next seven to ten episodes)? Lust is the worst fighter, but Gluttony would be so helpless without her that either he'll die or she'll die and he'll really go off the deep end. Wrath and Greed seem too important to kill, for plot reasons, and Envy really has one of the most enviable and useful abilities that so far has been sorely underutilized. I don't think she'll go until she's done something awful, like killed Windy, taken over her body, infiltrated the Club Elric, messed with Ed for a few episodes, seduced him, and then revealed herself and driven him into despair and insanity. So my predictions: Envy assumes the personality of someone important, and Gluttony dies, although the first is doubly awful because we'll lose someone else we like in the process, and the second sucks because he is the funniest and cutest characters, in his own special way. Or else Envy will be the one who dies, which might actually make more sense, because she will have fulfilled her plot purpose at that point. Oh, and can we get an authoritative answer: what gender is Envy?

2004-04-12, 21:20	Link #50
Zauren Master of Pimpage Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: Salem, OR	My question is, if this is not Envy's original form, why did he choose it? And is he older then Greed in such a case, or is Greed just too pimpish to say?

2004-04-12, 21:47	Link #51
Fighter Volk Thanks sakurabatou @ LJ Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: NYC	It may also be possible that Greed was locked away before Envy was 'created', hence he would not know Envy's original form; hence, we cannot deduce that Envy was the first Sin created. And still, we do not know much about Sloth, Wrath, Greed, or Pride...

2004-04-13, 15:24	Link #52
Kurama no Miko2003 Twirly! Twirly~!! Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Wherever my favorite guy in the whole wide world is	I dunno if killing off Winry is the best option they have right now . . . if anything, it's probably going to be Mustang and Co. The Sins are more interested in killing off anyone who tries to figure out the truth OTHER than Ed 'n Al. After all, if the results will end up disastrous, the Sins won't want ANYONE warning Ed 'n Al of that. Look at what happened to the last one who figured it out. (Side note: I forgot how to make spoiler tags, so the identity of that particular character will remain hidden. Anyone who's seen far enough will know who I'm talking about.) Now, while Winry dying is a viable option, I think she hasn't completely served her purpose to the plot of the story just yet. Therefore, she's probably safe from getting killed off . . . for the time being. That doesn't mean she can't die later on. She's just . . . temporarily safe. ~ Kurama no Miko2003

2004-04-13, 15:57	Link #53
Nagare Ryouma Warrior Of Eternity Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Saotome Research Institute	Well anybody but not Hawkeye and Winry PLS! Ahem... Anyways, since the military is somehow corrupted, and Mustang vowed he's gonna find out the so-called truth behind Hughes death and what he was searching for before his death; it quickly put's Mustang and his team into danger practically. I guess the Elric bro's we'll be busy fending off those Ex-state alchemist troops we see in the new OP.... I wonder what's gonna happen to Scar now? Found a new path in his life? Dunno if he's gonna end up dying or not....

2004-04-14, 20:29	Link #58
inv4zn Dog of the Military Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Sydney Age: 35	i want everyone to die!