Rate That Signature!

[Afternoon Tea]

^
Hooves: 10/10 i dont know theres something about that signature lol i really like for some reason

[Rennir]

abet- 8.6/10 Text needs work IMO

[grylsyjaeger]

CaptnAwesomee: Yui! 10/10 regardless of everything else.

Rennir: I like your effects, I just can't say I'm a fan of how that bloke looks. 8/10

[Dragonar Fan]

fallschirmjager 9/10 sounds dangerous

[ganbaru]

Haladflire65 8,5/10 interesting

[Haladflire65]

JR: awesome Halo sig, 8.8/10

[Hooves]

CMHerrera: 10/10 (Lovely Quality and Animation )

[CMSensei]

Rennir - 8.7/10 looks awesome

[bloppyblue]

Damn, this thread is SO intimidating.

Haladflire65 - 9/10 - love the way its placed
Hooves - 9/10 - so pretty :O
CMHerrera - 10/10 - it's really nice The darkness on the right and lack of anything on the left bothers me, but i dont know anything about art, haha

[Haladflire65]

bloppyblue: Interesting, but there's a lack of focus and the blue outline around the renders kind of bug me 8/10

[Star-Wing]

@Halad I prefer your last Masa one ^.^ Something in this seems off to me, I can't tell why 8/10
@CMHerrera Loved the animation! Wish I could do something like that. And the emptiness on both sides work well with the mood of sig 9.4/10
@Bloppyblue Your left side render seems too bluish to me (and the edges jagged...quality issue?) 7.4/10

[Mr. Wang]

Tragic as it is that I had to give up my previous signature, I decided for a change of pace and made this new one. Now then...

@CaptnAwesomee I think your signature is "awesomee" too. I can't help but laugh a little at Yui's facial expression, but the whole scene in the sig presents itself very nicely. Everything looks good, even the text below the actual image and the music notes augment it nicely. However, there are two... of something seemingly off in the just above the bench, something I can't really identify at the moment... Still, a 9.1/10.

@Rennir An amazing signature, it has great effects, a colorful and straight theme to it, and the guy comes off nicely. Just who the heck is he, anyway? 9.4/10

@fallschirmjager I've seen some of your paneled signatures like this one, and I must say that they do have an original, and lovely concept. It's odd, though nicely done how you can show the whole woman through the use of the smaller panels on either side of the signature. I think the coloring at the woman's waist in the middle image looks a bit... unnecessary, though it looks very nice. The quote at the bottom also seems to give this sig some story to it. 9.5/10

@Dragonar Fan Well, not much to say other than that it looks like a still taken from an episode of a show. It looks as though there was much more to the scene before it was cropped to the size it is now, perhaps that would have made the scene much more interesting and dynamic. 8.1/10

@ganbaru It's beautiful. The sunset, the ocean, the warm, colors and appearance of the whole scene... it's enough to get your eyes lost in (poetic much?). This however, is only offset by the rather fitting quote from Edgar Allen Poe's tragic short poem. Then rather than a sunset, I see a feeling of... reflection, almost. Reflection of life, not the sun. 10/10 because it made me think.

@Haladflire65 I'm not familiar with Fukuyama Masaharu, though the sig somehow... emanates the feeling of one man, in a large world, or stadium apparently (I'm thinking way to much and abstractly). Looks like it could use some work on the right side, though now I'm curious to look up Mr. Masaharu and see who he is. 8.5/10

@Hooves Aw, Shana is cute isn't she? A good theme, great effects, and the text goes well with said visuals. Facial expression, the colors, everything about this seems to just go together. Your quote below is cute. 9.4/10

@CMHerrera The facial expression of the man, and the smooth, nice looking animation of the rain falling beside him, and the emptiness on either side of him set the mood of this signature extremely well. It all just goes together well. My only complaint would be the apparent lack of cloudiness. I would have made everything perhaps darker or more saturated, not just because realistically speaking that where there's rain there's clouds, but also to reflect just how... well, down he looks. The picture does look oddly bright for a rainy day, though he could just be standing under a light. Great signature, 9.5/10

@bloppyblue The overall shape of the signature and use of transparency is quite out of the norm, and has an original look to it. The shape, your choice of anime characters which I assume are your favorites, and the name really strike off as a signature unique and representing you. The left render of Yui, and the blue around her could use some work though.0 8.9/10

@Star-Wing Jeez, I really need to get an entry in for this month... Great lighting, the effects are beautiful, and the coloring is fantastic. I can imagine an original image, and all the details you put in come off to me as either striking and eye-catching, or subtle and detailed. You really capture the essence of the holiday well. 9.4/10

[Hooves]

Originally Posted by Mr. Wang

@Hooves Aw, Shana is cute isn't she? A good theme, great effects, and the text goes well with said visuals. Facial expression, the colors, everything about this seems to just go together. Your quote below is cute. 9.4/10

Might want to edit this posted right when I made the switch

(Made a quick swap with Rikki's version of the signature to Star-Wing's version, to honor the work they both put into the request )

Mr. Wang: 9.7/10 (o.o..........)

[Haladflire65]

Originally Posted by Mr. Wang

@Rennir An amazing signature, it has great effects, a colorful and straight theme to it, and the guy comes off nicely. Just who the heck is he, anyway? 9.4/10

@Haladflire65 I'm not familiar with Fukuyama Masaharu, though the sig somehow... emanates the feeling of one man, in a large world, or stadium apparently (I'm thinking way to much and abstractly). Looks like it could use some work on the right side, though now I'm curious to look up Mr. Masaharu and see who he is. 8.5/10

Rennir's sig is Taeyang, the Korean singer (I'd know cause I made it on his request )

As for Fukuyama.... FIY Masaharu is his first name

Mr. Wang: Good transparency. 8.7/10
Hooves: Not bad, but the render could use more blending. 8.5/10

[ganbaru]

Hooves 8,5/10 too bad than all the sig have to be in .gif
bloppyblue 8/10 not much to say
Mr. Wang 8,8/10 good use of transparency.

@Mr. Wang, I thought than sunset would fit thoses happy day, while winter and night scenery would fit more the next strophes.

[Afternoon Tea]

ganbaru: Nice text and very artistic 9/10

Mr. Wang review rocks thanks, and good detailed write up

[Hooves]

bloppyblue: 9.4/10 (Good signature, nothing about it bothers me that much )

[Arbitres]

Mr. Wang - 9.3/10: Oh. My. God.

The render is just beautiful, as well as the use of transparency and lighting. You seem to have a thing for box + render sorte, and I like it myself. Good work.

I adore our shared bond of Kotonoha-ism, Mr. Wang.

[Om Nerabdator]

8/10

i dont recognise it but it looks great

[Haladflire65]

matty: Not bad, the renders all look all slapped in there though 8/10