AnimeSuki Forums

KoroshiyaX · 2006-08-21, 23:21

spoiler for the last volume of the manga... man it's depressing. (might not be the last volume after all)

Spoiler:

don't read this unless you're sure you want to know how it ends (anime fans beware lol cuz it's the summary of the entire last volume)

Spoiler:

I'd have never expected this kind of ending based on the lovey lovey theme throughout the story.
Correction: IT HAS NOT YET ENDED AND IS ON-GOING! hehe.

musouka · 2006-08-22, 00:16

Uh, are you sure that's the last volume and not just the latest volume? Because the series is listed on the BetsuComi site for next month's issue, which would seem odd if the series had already ended.

Fury · 2006-08-22, 01:04

maybe thats the latest volume and not the last casue that would so suck if it was and how it ended that way >.< i want a reunion

KoroshiyaX · 2006-08-22, 01:11

You may be right.. i may jumped the gun a bit lol, but it did look like an ending.

Spoiler:

Mr.Minou · 2006-08-22, 05:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by KoroshiyaX

spoiler for the last volume of the manga... man it's depressing. Yano needs to be shot

by saying that you are already spoiling so please be careful...(I just began watching the anime and fortunately, it seems that you are wrong it is not really the end. but you did spoil me anyway, even though I didn't read the spoiler)

KoroshiyaX · 2006-08-22, 15:53

Sorry Minou, I moved that line to the spoiler box heh, I got too jumpy.

It would be good if it was on-going, I will check tonight to make sure.

Spoiler:

Ya, it's not done.. one more volume was released after that.

Fury · 2006-08-22, 22:07

so can u tell us what goes in the next volume then dont keep us waiting when you gave off a preview like that T_T i want happy end T_T

KoroshiyaX · 2006-08-22, 22:40

lol, I'll spoil further as I read on... haven't gotten there quite yet.

I think the anime will only cover volumes 1-7.

ymseiran · 2006-08-23, 23:44

Spoiler:

Onibaba · 2006-08-26, 16:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by ymseiran

Spoiler:

Put these kinds of things in SPOILERS, please! I never got around to getting the manga and this really implies what's going to happen down the line in the anime.

Edit: Thanks, NightWish.

ombie · 2006-08-27, 23:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by KoroshiyaX

I made a torrent and am seeding raw volumes 1-10 for Bokura ga Ita. You can get it here http://www.datorrents.com/torrents-details.asp?id=13402

First let me thank you for this, I so want the manga released in English soon. From what I can see and not read this is a very complicated story.....

I'd ask for spoilers, but as of now I can't figure out how to use the hide spoiler function. *somebody give me a clue please*

Vexx · 2006-08-27, 23:53

It actually explains how to use tags in the forum usage guides and FAQs.

Briefly, type the tagword "["spoiler"]" without the quotes ... and then when you're done with the spoilage, finish it with "["/spoiler"]" again without the quotes.

Just like an HTML tag. If you QUOTE someone using the quote button... the quote will show up in your entry box with quote tags -- a nice example of tags.

KoroshiyaX · 2006-09-05, 19:52

Volumes 9 and 10...

Spoiler:

Eurys · 2006-09-06, 04:35

Thanks for the summaries (and the cute chart

).
Ah, shoujo is bad for my health, I always despise the heroine and get angry over the plot...
But I like poor Yuri.

cyw1988 · 2006-09-06, 05:53

I thought this series was quite dramatic... Yano and Nana are like so near yet so far... After one obstacle is crossed another pops out... its like a never ending battle to stay together. But i think this tokyo part would probably be the final test of their relationship and I am betting on a happy ending... *prays*

Barbka · 2006-09-07, 04:16

is manga 11 allready out? How many mangas will be released? I would really like someone to tell me if this manga/anime has a happy ending for Nana and Yano. I like them to much and they look so good together - love is in the ear

I couldn't take a different ending, it would hurt to much.

Barbka · 2006-09-08, 03:38

Because I don't read japanese...I need some help -

Spoiler:

KoroshiyaX · 2006-09-16, 12:37

Spoiler:

Eurys · 2006-09-16, 13:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by KoroshiyaX

Spoiler:

Why are women judged so harsher than men? It's unbelievable (Reminds me of Suzuka). I think the point is that all the characters are flawed, broken and weak.

Spoiler:

KoroshiyaX · 2006-09-17, 06:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eurys

Spoiler:

Why are women judged so harsher than men? It's unbelievable (Reminds me of Suzuka). I think the point is that all the characters are flawed, broken and weak.

Spoiler:

People will probably dislike Yuri even more so for events after ep 11 then... she will basically go all out to get what she wants (Yano), hurting everyone else in the process.

The problem with both Yano and Nana2 throughout the majority of the manga is that they are stuck in his past. For Yano, he still loves Nana1 even though he knew she cheated on him, so it's tormenting him. Yuri did not help this case by confirming that the cheating was true in order to hurt both Yano and Nana2. For Nana2, she's inexperienced and cares too much about stuff that happened before they went out together, being immature. But dont worry, she will get over it

Sure, all the characters are weak and flawed, and I'm not calling Yuri a whore. But she does indeed have a very selfish personality that only cares about herself. It was as much Yano's fault as Yuri's that they slept together.

As for Nana1's cheating, she likely did it because she is a weak person that is always dependant on others. So she always needs someone to be there for her.

As for Yano, his distrust and paranoia to confide in his loved ones is his undoing (caused by experience with Nana1). I don't buy into the sacrificing for others sake/not wanting to hurt loved ones BS. Loved ones are there for a reason. His choice not to contact Nana for 4-5 years is one big mistake.

I look forward to his reaction when he finds out Nana2 is now Takeuchi's girlfriend. If he accepts it like man, I'll truly be impressed and might even root for them to get back together, but if he acts like a whining bitter bitch like in the early years, I hope Nana2 stays with Takeuchi. We'll see what happens I guess...

You should wait until all the eps air, or read all the manga and then give your opinion on the characters. I think the author really went all out to make the readers dislike the Yamamoto sisters... At least in Suzuka we see Suzuka's good sides, I do not recall one good deed that Yuri does to this point, the bad ones keep piling up. And they're now 20-21 years old

2006-08-21, 23:21	Link #1
KoroshiyaX X Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Toronto	Bokura ga Ita Manga spoiler for the last volume of the manga... man it's depressing. (might not be the last volume after all) Spoiler: don't read this unless you're sure you want to know how it ends (anime fans beware lol cuz it's the summary of the entire last volume) Spoiler: Yano needs to be shot - So Yano's parents are getting divorced. His mum is moving away from the town they're in. Yano is debating whther or not to go with her or to stay with Nana. - They tell each other that they really love each other. Yano really doesn't want to leave her. But she tells him that no matter what his decision is, she'll be okay with it. - And that he should choose whatever is most important for him. - Also deals with the univs they want to get into and them working hard to raise their grades. - - But despite what he's told her, he plans to leave with his mom. He can't let her be on her own. She needs him. He figures that Nana is strong enough to cope with it. - His friend tells him that he's treating Nana unfairly and that he should tell her. 'Or are you going to pretend that you can't hear Nana's silent "Please don't go"?' Or is it that you're trying to give her time? - He doesn't really explain. - They have a few very painful scenes between them. With 'what if I...' kinda conversations. What if we run off together kinda thing. - They hug and realize that both wish for the same thing. "I wish for Yano's wishes to come true. and Yano wishes for my wishes to come true. So let's entrust the future with our futures.' - He tells her he's going to Tokyo with his mom. They go on a farewell trip together for a night to a ryokan. - At the end of the trip they promise to meet at the end of the year in Tokyo. - She turns down Takeuchi. - At the train station when he's leaving: Wherever you are... however lonely you are... however painful it is... Don't forget that I'm here for you. Don't forget that you'll never be alone. - He whispers something in her ear. : The plus/minuses were not equal to zero. They equalled a plus. - Train goes off. She runs down the platform crying and he looks out of the window like he wants to go back. His mother calls him to sit next to her. - They show a flashback of all their scenes together. Epilogue - Exact narr spoken by Nana: Please God, protect him. Give him strength so that no matter what, he does not lose. He does not get crushed. Give him the strenght to stand up again no matter how many times he cries and how many hurdles he runs into. May the people he meet be warm. Please protect him. that is my wish. My prayer. I met him when we were 15. I pursued him. Was rejected. Ran after him some more. We separated at 17. The realities that he had to face were bigger than him. Could anyone truly blame him for the choices he made? Today I turn 21. I continue to hope for the impossible. That someday he'll come to take me away. Because that was the last day I ever saw him. - The End - I'd have never expected this kind of ending based on the lovey lovey theme throughout the story. Correction: IT HAS NOT YET ENDED AND IS ON-GOING! hehe. Last edited by xris; 2007-11-18 at 17:48. Reason: Please do not post links to raws (as per forum rules)

2006-08-22, 01:11	Link #4
KoroshiyaX X Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Toronto	You may be right.. i may jumped the gun a bit lol, but it did look like an ending. Spoiler: it would actually be pretty interesting if it went on, since they've had no contact for 4-5 years. More drama. Maybe he found another chick in tokyo already.

2006-08-22, 15:53	Link #6
KoroshiyaX X Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Toronto	Sorry Minou, I moved that line to the spoiler box heh, I got too jumpy. It would be good if it was on-going, I will check tonight to make sure. Spoiler: I think I read somewhere that in an upcoming storyline, we find out that Takeuchi had actually met Yano 3 years ago, so a year or two after he left, but did not tell Nana about it. And then we also find out something important is going on with Yano in Tokyo. (new gf perhaps?) hehe Ya, it's not done.. one more volume was released after that. Last edited by KoroshiyaX; 2006-08-22 at 19:41.

2006-08-23, 23:44	Link #9
ymseiran Junior Member Join Date: Aug 2006	Spoiler: i downloaded the manga and everything but just wanted to know did she end up with takeuchi or yano , and is yano with another girl cause vol 10 is kinda weird, or is it a side story... Last edited by NightWish; 2006-08-26 at 22:02.

2006-08-27, 23:53	Link #12
Vexx Obey the Darkly Cute ... Author Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: On the whole, I'd rather be in Kyoto ... Age: 66	It actually explains how to use tags in the forum usage guides and FAQs. Briefly, type the tagword "["spoiler"]" without the quotes ... and then when you're done with the spoilage, finish it with "["/spoiler"]" again without the quotes. Just like an HTML tag. If you QUOTE someone using the quote button... the quote will show up in your entry box with quote tags -- a nice example of tags. __________________ "It Really IS Rocket Science", Novel series rough drafts; vol. 1 thru vol. 3 complete Volume 4 in work, Visit the thread for short stories!

2006-08-22, 00:16	Link #2
musouka Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2003	Uh, are you sure that's the last volume and not just the latest volume? Because the series is listed on the BetsuComi site for next month's issue, which would seem odd if the series had already ended.

2006-08-22, 01:04	Link #3
Fury Member Join Date: Apr 2006	maybe thats the latest volume and not the last casue that would so suck if it was and how it ended that way >.< i want a reunion

2006-08-22, 22:07	Link #7
Fury Member Join Date: Apr 2006	so can u tell us what goes in the next volume then dont keep us waiting when you gave off a preview like that T_T i want happy end T_T

2006-08-22, 22:40	Link #8
KoroshiyaX X Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Toronto	lol, I'll spoil further as I read on... haven't gotten there quite yet. I think the anime will only cover volumes 1-7.

2006-09-05, 19:52	Link #13
KoroshiyaX X Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Toronto	Volumes 9 and 10... Spoiler: Just a short summary of previous volumes first... we discover a few things. 1) Yano slept with Yuri in the classroom that one year (likely just that he wanted to be comforted). So he did lie to Nana when she asked him if anything happened. 2) We never find out (yet) why Nana was in her ex-bf's car when they died. I suspect Nana was cheating on him on a regular basis. It seems Yuri knows something, but they still haven't addressed that even by Volume 10. (Unless I missed it in earlier volumes hehe) 3) Takeuchi has loved Nana for a long time. Volume 9 and 10 summaries: - Takeuchi has been in touch with Yano over the past 4-5 years. But Yano told him not to tell Nana that they've been keeping in touch. - Takeuchi once again attempts to ask Nana out, but she refuses him again. - Takeuchi keeps on being persistent and eventually Nana gives in, thinking that Takeuchi has been the person that has been there for her and comforting her these past 4-5 years. - Takeuchi and Nana are now officially going out. - In Tokyo, Yano has a friend (girl) who does seem to be interested in him. - We find out he has had a hard life in Tokyo, and that is the main reason he has not contacted Nana. Part of the reason is that Yano's mom has cancer and will die within 5 months. - Yuri travels to Tokyo in pursuit of Yano, and is acting pretty desperate at this point. He refuses her again, but she's persistent and she ends up staying in Tokyo. (Hopefully we will find out in the next volume if Yuri knew anything about why Nana was in her exbf's car at the time of death). - Yuri thinks Yano slept with her that one year because he pitied her, and not because he wanted revenge on Nana. - Regardless, she's going full out to "acquire" Yano now. - Yano does still love Nana a lot, but likely is prioritizing getting his life in order in Tokyo. Anyway... this is how the relationship chart looks like now, school rumble anyone? haha Last edited by KoroshiyaX; 2006-09-05 at 20:09.

2006-09-06, 04:35	Link #14
Eurys Crush me. ~Ringo Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Tropical France	Thanks for the summaries (and the cute chart ). Ah, shoujo is bad for my health, I always despise the heroine and get angry over the plot... But I like poor Yuri. __________________ Leerin icon by ree_rhea

2006-09-06, 05:53	Link #15
cyw1988 Japaholic Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: I don't know... T_T	I thought this series was quite dramatic... Yano and Nana are like so near yet so far... After one obstacle is crossed another pops out... its like a never ending battle to stay together. But i think this tokyo part would probably be the final test of their relationship and I am betting on a happy ending... prays

2006-09-07, 04:16	Link #16
Barbka Member Join Date: May 2006	is manga 11 allready out? How many mangas will be released? I would really like someone to tell me if this manga/anime has a happy ending for Nana and Yano. I like them to much and they look so good together - love is in the ear I couldn't take a different ending, it would hurt to much.

2006-09-08, 03:38	Link #17
Barbka Member Join Date: May 2006	Because I don't read japanese...I need some help - Spoiler: can someone tell me who is the girl that kisses Yano in volume 10/189? Is this still the part of the story or what? I really wish for Yano and Nana to come together at the end...

2006-09-16, 12:37	Link #18
KoroshiyaX X Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Toronto	Spoiler: Looks like I did read too fast... We actually do find out the reason Nana1 was in her ex-bf's car the day of their deaths. She had a fight with Yano earlier that day, and it was also her birthday. Her ex-bf called her up and wished her a happy bday and she went along with him. They've actually been keeping in touch throughout her relationship with Yano... oh well. Yuri and Nana1 are nasty sisters w/ rotten personalities. No wonder Yano is so paranoid lol. What's worse, this was all revealed by Yuri to Yano after Yano had already starting going out with Nana2. It's like a double-wam on Yano.