Rate That Signature!

[KiNA]

@ Xello .. NIIIIIIIIIIIICE pic selection.. Now be a good bro and SEND ME THE SOURCE PIC for the New year's gift .. Learn to put you name on your sig .. It keeps thief from stealing ^^

@ Zaris .. hmm, combo girls sig.. Nice.. but Eruruu kinda feel a bit out of place =/ (couldn't finger the main problem there).. Also, snuck your name closer to the border a bit IMO.

btw, how dare you say I didnt cut my render correctly .. Its the outer glow style

jk

[Cyz]

KiNa: Faye! 8/10
kayos: nice one. The whiteness really does suit it. 8/10
Xellos: another ecchi sig hm? 7/10

[Deathkillz]

Xellos ~ ho ho...dont get yourself too worn out 8/10

zaris ~ nice but imo the BG seems a bit plain and the characters at the front should be blended in imo ^_^ 8.5/10

kiNa ~ wow...just love the effects but why that font? and i dont really like it glowing black and white...how bout black and gold? 8.5/10

[Radiosity]

Deathkillz - DROOL. Seriously, I can find no fault with your current sig. Fate + HAWT pose = WIN for a 10/10

[~Tsukuyomi]

Wow, haven't been here for some time now...

@Cyz
Love the grudge/abstract work... Not liking the texts... 7/10

@Deathkillz
Faded borders and choppy animation makes is not likable... 5/10

@Radiosity
Borders, stock image, text... 3/10

Now, here are mine...

Spoiler for ~Tsu Siggy:

Archer
Version 1:
Version 2:

Confused
Version 1:
Version 2:

[kaito-kid]

@~Tsukuyomi: the first one is nice

[SweetHoney]

Lommm: Both sigs are fairly nice 8.5/10

Cyz : A bi to bright 7.5/10

KiNa: lol shiny 10/10

kaito-kid: There's something not right but I can't pick it up 7/10

~Tsukuyomi: I like the Ichigo one way better ^^ 9/10

*ahem* Mine is of course Maaka Karin or Karin Maaka. I spent about nearly 1hr on it the wings really hate me T-T. Oh and a side note if you don't like it don't rate it or say anything rude please ^^

[Renvi]

@SweetHoney : Nice, i love the border! Image seems a little stretched out, though.
- 8/10

@Lommm : I like them both! = 8.5/10

@kaito-kid : Nice! I like the border and the background. 8.5/10

[Synth]

Renvi: Good kanjis <__< 7/10

[Cyz]

SweetHoney: The img seems a little stretched out no? The font and text is hard to read with all those red BG colors. 6/10
Renvi: I like the gloomy feeling around it. 7/10
Synth: Chibi Roy Mustang I see 7/10

--> New sig. This is Feena from Yoake Mae Yori Ruri Iro Na.

[SweetHoney]

Cyz: don't really like this one 6/10

Synth: lol cute 7/10

[Xellos-_^]

Tsukuyomi: 7.5/10 good effect.

[Cyz]

Xellos: Too ecchi IMO. 7/10

[Deathkillz]

Renvi ~ nice but the words are blocking most of the BG pic O.o 8/10

Synth ~ chibi roy ^__^ need to blend the front roy better and reposition the text...8/10

sweetHoney ~ lol karin moments i see imo shes a bit squashed down which isnt good >.< and the sides are a bit plain...7.5/10

cyz ~ feena...imo the colours are a bit dull...brighten it up a bit and it will be good ~ 8.5/10

[Kvikveg]

Cyz: very nice, harmonic one: 9/10

[Klashikari]

heh... it has been a while that i didn't rate (sorry, was kinda not really in the mood for this recently XD)

let's see...

@zaris : while i liked how you tried to put a peaceful mood with the BG, it feels somewhat wrongs with the contrast/luminosity of the 3 girls. there are also some problem with the hair edges of the 3 girls, but it is easier said than done. 8.5/10

@KiNa : *refrains himself to do a complete analysis *
well, the golden BG is really strong and well balanced. however, slight problems with Faye edge. 8.5/10

@Cyz : impressive BG and texts, it has the perfect impact for its meaning. but too bad that the right edge of the picture is not really well blended/cut 9/10

@Deathkillz : i guess several persons said it already : the animation is kinda choppy. also, i'm not really fond of the think gradiant white border of the sig, while i understand it is done to add some light/sweet effect. good picture choice. 8/10

@Sweethoney : the blood stains are interesting. sadly, kairin picture suffers a lot of that squeechy format, along with some weird edge effect on her + the text. 6/10 (this might be a low rate, but cheers, you are improving a lot recently !)

@Renvi : i love the ratio. too bad that the main picture colours are a bit flat, and the kanji edge are kinda weird. 8.5/10

@Synth : finally a roy mustang sig ^^. nice comedic focus, but i feel the font text and lightning effects are a bit offtopic with roy... meh. 7.5/10

@Xellos : errr... i'm not really fond with eechi things but meh XD.
the ratio is somewhat unbalanced, and i'm not really fond to the thick border. 7/10

@kvikveg : too bad you cropped alucard's head... maybe you should cut slightly the left side? (it's rather empty). meh : 7/10

[Kvikveg]

Originally Posted by Klashikari

...
@kvikveg : too bad you cropped alucard's head... maybe you should cut slightly the left side? (it's rather empty). meh : 7/10

Yes, it was originally an amv.org banner but they did not vote it. The size comes from there and the logo was on the left size.
Will fix it. Once...

SweetHoney: horrible, 4/10. She is distorted vertically and the border is not smooth, etc. Ok maybe 5/10 it is not very bad. I have seen several worse ones on the net. XD At least te general impression is ok for the first sight.

Xellos-_^ nice one, but too ecchi for me... should be 7/10, but 0/10 because I don't like watching tits as you probably don't like watching nice beach-boys half-naked. (No offense, I bet the mods would have told you if that was a problem here. I am new here. ) Once I put this signature image in in the other forum I am visiting because many of them used signatures like that. Only bigger ones.

~Tsukuyomi: nice, I really like that. 8/10 same for kaito-kid.

[SweetHoney]

@Kvikveg: If I remeber I said if you don't like it and say it's horrible keep it to your self! read back a page or so I rate 6.5/10

Klashikari: Oh Rena really kawaii no? 10/10

Deathkillz: MWhha kawaii again 9.5/10

[Radiosity]

SweetHoney - reminds me very much of Rikers sigs in the past (in particular his 'Oh no, Riker's in love with Ohno!' sig.) Which is no bad thing at all 9.5/10. I'd give it a 10 but there's some nasty artifacting on Yuuji's face that kinda detracts from the overall whole. The animation of Shana is nice though, which makes up for it

[Kvikveg]

Originally Posted by SweetHoney

@Kvikveg: If I remeber I said if you don't like it and say it's horrible keep it to your self! read back a page or so I rate 6.5/10
...

Emm, I see. Did not mean to hurt you.
The new one is really nice, the animated part is really good. 8/10