AnimeSuki Forums

Steffa · 2004-10-15, 07:22

there are many fansubbers doing destiny...which one is the best in your opinion?

Inuzuka · 2004-10-15, 08:18

A-Kingdom & Aone

ZGMF-X10A · 2004-10-15, 11:24

A-Kingdom & Aone... nice quility and translations too :P

avmoghe · 2004-10-15, 12:16

We've only seen one episode so its a bit hard to judge based on that.

But I've seen the first episodes of UKE, and A-kingdom-Aone. I have not seen Seed-Fansubs or Anime-Chounin versions, so I cannot judge them.

Out of those two I think A-k, Aone had a better first episode.

Regardless, I appreciate every group that tries to bring Destiny to us fans.

Kurono · 2004-10-15, 14:35

http://ultima.hafio.info/Fansubs/Gun...ed_Destiny.php

http://ultracarl.darkslyde.net/GSD/

Panon · 2004-10-15, 18:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steffa

there are many fansubbers doing destiny...which one is the best in your opinion?

Anime-Kingdom/Aone easily.

Gouryella · 2004-10-15, 18:41

Men i have downloaded all the subs and i like all of them!!!
they put hard afford to make the subs and i think you must have some RESPECT too that!!
I liked all of the subs!! they all have good quality!! and the subs i dont know because i cant understand japaneash!!!

I think you must have some respect and knwo that al the subs are GOOD!!!
thanks to all people who help us to get Gundam Seed Destiny THANKS!!!

Hyperion · 2004-10-15, 20:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZGMF-X10A

A-Kingdom & Aone... nice quility and translations too :P

Agreed. Now if they'd fix their sound where I don't have to cut my volume up real loud to hear the BMG music.........

iceyfw · 2004-10-16, 00:34

I checked most of the forums for Gundam Seed Destiny and i have concluded that these two groups are the best subbers for it.
Now i want to see which fansub wins the poll.

djIhcoro · 2004-10-16, 09:18

http://ultracarl.darkslyde.net/GSD/

Hooray for comparison screens. IMO, it's between AOne/A-Kingdom, Seed-Fansubs, and A-Keep. I really can't pick between the three of them unless we get some outside information. t/l comparison maybe?

Enragin_Angel · 2004-10-16, 13:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by IcExAlcHeMy

I checked most of the forums for Gundam Seed Destiny and i have concluded that these two groups are the best subbers for it.
Now i want to see which fansub wins the poll.

How about making your conclusions by WATCHING each fansub?

jpwong · 2004-10-16, 14:50

Quote:

Originally Posted by Enragin_Angel

How about making your conclusions by WATCHING each fansub?

I agree, between A-K/Aone and Keep the differences should be marginal, and for me, it's probably going to come down to speed and typsetting

djIhcoro · 2004-10-16, 16:15

Has anyone besides me watched the seed-fansubs version? I think it has a superior translation to aone/a-kingdom, but then again I don't know japanese. =X
I don't know, maybe the general concensus is bias from the latter half of seed done by a-kingdom. But who was reigning as the best sub for seed for the first half? Anime-Gundam/SI/Aoshi. And where can we find the seed-fansubs version of seed destiny 01? Anime-Gundam. I'l let you people think on that for a bit.

dew · 2004-10-17, 01:51

If SEED-Fansubs actually had the SI-Aoshi-AG name tag, it'd be more popular. But A-Kingdom did a good job, and for those of us who like to have one group for a whole series to burn would rather have the same 2 groups the whole way through then a few groups who disappeared halfway through. We don't have any reason to switch off A-Kingdom/AonE (and later more than likely Haro^2).

ViVi_bOi · 2004-10-17, 10:19

ANiME-Sannins & DeathSquad Screenshots Added

Naiji · 2004-10-17, 10:56

Honestly can you trade quality for lack of translating, Uke-Fansubs & YoumaOtakus has the best translation in my opinion, and the quality's not bad.

Wisely · 2004-10-17, 12:56

A-Kingdom & Aone, too bad the file size was quite big, good for collection though

If you go for speed, the fastest fansub would be popgo. The translated version is released like a few hours after the raw is aired.

Enragin_Angel · 2004-10-17, 13:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by Naiji

Honestly can you trade quality for lack of translating, Uke-Fansubs & YoumaOtakus has the best translation in my opinion, and the quality's not bad.

Well, if you go to this site: http://ultracarl.darkslyde.net/GSD/

you'll notice that in the 4th screenshot comparison, they put "Pilot to the stern deck" Whereas every GOOD group put Pilot to the Core Splendor...I dunno how you could say Uke-Fansubs and YoumaOtakus could have the best translation. I think that comparison is a good indicator of which groups that actually do research on the show. Uke and YO clearly do not.

Cellulax · 2004-10-17, 13:56

Aone/A-Kingdom from the versions I've seen. Can't tell how accurate the translations are though, so I'm judging on the encoding, typesetting... and stuff.

Just like to point out, Seed-Fansubs is not SI-Aoshi-AG. From my knowledge, both Si and Aoshi are long dead, and most of the original staff of AG that worked on Seed are gone too. AG might be continuing on with a new name, but it isn't the same team working on Destiny.

Naiji · 2004-10-17, 17:58

Sorry, I made a mistake I wanted to say AnimeOne, but I was looking at the wrong one for some odd reason :P

2004-10-15, 07:22	Link #1
Steffa Ninja Guru Join Date: Aug 2004	[GSD] Best Fansubber there are many fansubbers doing destiny...which one is the best in your opinion?

2004-10-16, 00:34	Link #9
iceyfw Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2004 Age: 35	anime-keep or A-K&Aone I checked most of the forums for Gundam Seed Destiny and i have concluded that these two groups are the best subbers for it. Now i want to see which fansub wins the poll. Last edited by NoSanninWa; 2004-10-16 at 00:58. Reason: Threads merged

2004-10-15, 08:18	Link #2
Inuzuka now with 20% more ego! Join Date: May 2004 Location: Singapore Age: 33	A-Kingdom & Aone

2004-10-15, 11:24	Link #3
ZGMF-X10A Tsukiyomi -Moon Phase- Join Date: Jun 2003	A-Kingdom & Aone... nice quility and translations too :P

2004-10-15, 12:16	Link #4
avmoghe Senior Member Join Date: Mar 2004	We've only seen one episode so its a bit hard to judge based on that. But I've seen the first episodes of UKE, and A-kingdom-Aone. I have not seen Seed-Fansubs or Anime-Chounin versions, so I cannot judge them. Out of those two I think A-k, Aone had a better first episode. Regardless, I appreciate every group that tries to bring Destiny to us fans.

2004-10-15, 14:35	Link #5
Kurono Jounin Join Date: May 2004 Location: Sweden Age: 40	http://ultima.hafio.info/Fansubs/Gun...ed_Destiny.php http://ultracarl.darkslyde.net/GSD/

2004-10-15, 18:41	Link #7
Gouryella Junior Member Join Date: Sep 2004	Men i have downloaded all the subs and i like all of them!!! they put hard afford to make the subs and i think you must have some RESPECT too that!! I liked all of the subs!! they all have good quality!! and the subs i dont know because i cant understand japaneash!!! I think you must have some respect and knwo that al the subs are GOOD!!! thanks to all people who help us to get Gundam Seed Destiny THANKS!!!

2004-10-16, 09:18	Link #10
djIhcoro Junior Member Join Date: Jun 2003	http://ultracarl.darkslyde.net/GSD/ Hooray for comparison screens. IMO, it's between AOne/A-Kingdom, Seed-Fansubs, and A-Keep. I really can't pick between the three of them unless we get some outside information. t/l comparison maybe?

2004-10-16, 16:15	Link #13
djIhcoro Junior Member Join Date: Jun 2003	Has anyone besides me watched the seed-fansubs version? I think it has a superior translation to aone/a-kingdom, but then again I don't know japanese. =X I don't know, maybe the general concensus is bias from the latter half of seed done by a-kingdom. But who was reigning as the best sub for seed for the first half? Anime-Gundam/SI/Aoshi. And where can we find the seed-fansubs version of seed destiny 01? Anime-Gundam. I'l let you people think on that for a bit.

2004-10-17, 01:51	Link #14
dew Member Join Date: Sep 2004	If SEED-Fansubs actually had the SI-Aoshi-AG name tag, it'd be more popular. But A-Kingdom did a good job, and for those of us who like to have one group for a whole series to burn would rather have the same 2 groups the whole way through then a few groups who disappeared halfway through. We don't have any reason to switch off A-Kingdom/AonE (and later more than likely Haro^2).

2004-10-17, 10:19	Link #15
ViVi_bOi Member Join Date: Jul 2004 Age: 37	ANiME-Sannins & DeathSquad Screenshots Added

2004-10-17, 10:56	Link #16
Naiji Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2004	Honestly can you trade quality for lack of translating, Uke-Fansubs & YoumaOtakus has the best translation in my opinion, and the quality's not bad.

2004-10-17, 12:56	Link #17
Wisely Member Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: The place where you believe I live Age: 38	A-Kingdom & Aone, too bad the file size was quite big, good for collection though If you go for speed, the fastest fansub would be popgo. The translated version is released like a few hours after the raw is aired.

2004-10-17, 13:56	Link #19
Cellulax Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2004	Aone/A-Kingdom from the versions I've seen. Can't tell how accurate the translations are though, so I'm judging on the encoding, typesetting... and stuff. Just like to point out, Seed-Fansubs is not SI-Aoshi-AG. From my knowledge, both Si and Aoshi are long dead, and most of the original staff of AG that worked on Seed are gone too. AG might be continuing on with a new name, but it isn't the same team working on Destiny.

2004-10-17, 17:58	Link #20
Naiji Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2004	Sorry, I made a mistake I wanted to say AnimeOne, but I was looking at the wrong one for some odd reason :P