Code Geass R2 - Episode 13 Discussion / Poll

[Freya]

Originally Posted by orangejuicetang

The problem I see with this scenario is, Shirley saw Rolo's mask fall off, meaning that he probably reverted to his original personality. If Rolo did have second thoughts and stopped himself and parted ways, Shirley would have no longer geassed and would have been able to move. So why is she in the same room? Did she just stand there after she and Rolo parted ways? She could have left along with Rolo. Unless Rolo abandoned her and left the room, and in that five seconds before Rolo's geass wore out someone snuck in and killed her, and Rolo did not hear the gunshot in a room he was in five seconds before.

yes yes anyone else who wants to debate on this pathetic issue? Me and orange would be glad to prove you wrong.

[Captain Zechs]

Originally Posted by Aquaman OS

The suggestion was that he activated his Geass and moved in to kill her but then had second thoughts and stopped himself. They then parted ways and Shirley was killed by someone else a few minutes later. That does make a little bit of sense.

However now I think he really did it.

One question.

Why on Earth would some random person kill her? Most people don't go arround murdering innocent school girls. V.V. maybe, but eh, doubtful.

[Freya]

Originally Posted by Captain Zechs

One question.

Why on Earth would some random person kill her? Most people don't go arround murdering innocent school girls. V.V. maybe, but eh, doubtful.

Okay you guys say that but would he even kill Shirley? She's a nobody to him. Plus I'm sure he has to take care of Cornelia first which he does as it appears in ep 14.

[Captain Zechs]

Originally Posted by NarutoFreak1

Okay you guys say that but would he even kill Shirley? She's a nobody to him. Plus I'm sure he has to take care of Cornelia first which he does as it appears in ep 14.

Please use logic. Let's think here for a moment, who else would have done it? Please tell me. And they had the mask drop, why on Earth would they do that if not to point us in the correct direction?

[Var]

Originally Posted by Captain Zechs

Please use logic. Let's think here for a moment, who else would have done it? Please tell me. And they had the mask drop, why on Earth would they do that if not to point us in the correct direction?

I shot Shirley, the Sheriff, the Deputy, and his wee doggy too!

Are we seriously still arguing about this? If there has been no agreement reached by now, there won't be until they shove the answer in our face to digest.

[Diedrupo]

edit: whoops, misread the post i was quoting

[Stargaze]

Originally Posted by Var

I shot Shirley, the Sheriff, the Deputy, and his wee doggy too!

Are we seriously still arguing about this? If there has been no agreement reached by now, there won't be until they shove the answer in our face to digest.

Indeed, lets just leave it as it MAY be Rolo. I mean, even though all signs show that it is LIKELY to be Rolo, there is no concrete proof.

I know, I know, use your logic, blah, blah. But one thing is for certain: there is no proof.

[miroku2192]

Originally Posted by Captain Zechs

Please use logic. Let's think here for a moment, who else would have done it? Please tell me. And they had the mask drop, why on Earth would they do that if not to point us in the correct direction?

how about you use some logic of your own first before you start attacking others...the "he" in that sentence is referring to v.v., not rolo, so unless you're saying v.v. has to be the one to shoot shirley...well you're wrong, you misread his post

[Captain Zechs]

Originally Posted by miroku2192

how about you use some logic of your own first before you start attacking others...the "he" in that sentence is referring to v.v., not rolo, so unless you're saying v.v. has to be the one to shoot shirley...well you're wrong, you misread his post

Because he made it sooooo clear as to whom he was talking about.

But regardless, I was just saying to defend both sides. I think it was 100% Rolo myself.

[miroku2192]

Originally Posted by Captain Zechs

Because he made it sooooo clear as to whom he was talking about.

But regardless, I was just saying to defend both sides. I think it was 100% Rolo myself.

yeah he actually DID make it clear...last sentence said "Plus I'm sure he has to take care of Cornelia first which he does as it appears in ep 14."

really, does rolo fit the "he" in this sentence? please...

edit:
it's not like iwant to bash you, just don't want to see others getting bashed for nonsense...and then having that guy not admitting his mistake

[Jeffry2009]

ok, i've had it with this. Since episode 14 will be aired soon, we'll settle this in a new turn 14 discussion, shall we guys?

[Captain Zechs]

Originally Posted by miroku2192

yeah he actually DID make it clear...last sentence said "Plus I'm sure he has to take care of Cornelia first which he does as it appears in ep 14."

really, does rolo fit the "he" in this sentence? please...

edit:
it's not like iwant to bash you, just don't want to see others getting bashed for nonsense...and then having that guy not admitting his mistake

I'll admit I may have misunderstood, but he could have definately made it clearer. But I shall apologize.

[Freya]

Originally Posted by miroku2192

yeah he actually DID make it clear...last sentence said "Plus I'm sure he has to take care of Cornelia first which he does as it appears in ep 14."

really, does rolo fit the "he" in this sentence? please...

edit:
it's not like iwant to bash you, just don't want to see others getting bashed for nonsense...and then having that guy not admitting his mistake

Lol thanks for backing me up and stuff.

Originally Posted by Captain Zechs

I'll admit I may have misunderstood, but he could have definately made it clearer. But I shall apologize.

Yeah sorry man I could have made it more clear. But I thought if I referred to the last post people would have got I was talking about V.V. I don't even think V.V. knows who the hell Shirley is. So hes canceled.

Rolo killed Shirley.

[miroku2192]

Originally Posted by NarutoFreak1

Lol thanks for backing me up and stuff.



Yeah sorry man I could have made it more clear. But I thought if I referred to the last post people would have got I was talking about V.V. I don't even think V.V. knows who the hell Shirley is. So hes canceled.

Rolo killed Shirley.

haha let's put this thread/topic to a rest...and wait a few hours for the real deal...we'll find out soon enough

now hush, no more talking, i need to sleeep

[Freya]

Originally Posted by miroku2192

haha let's put this thread/topic to a rest...and wait a few hours for the real deal...we'll find out soon enough

now hush, no more talking, i need to sleeep

Haha. Its usually out by now.....

[miroku2192]

Originally Posted by NarutoFreak1

Haha. Its usually out by now.....

really? thought it doesn't come out in japan until like 5 ior 6?

[Freya]

Originally Posted by miroku2192

really? thought it doesn't come out in japan until like 5 ior 6?

Oh I meant the topic thread.

[mougrim]

BTW, hope Lelou will kill Rolo by nail-sticked yaoi broomstick... Poor Shirley...

[molitar]

This episode is making me hate this anime.. I am really hating this one.. every time we turn around someone dies that is totally innocent and cared for by him.. the author of this one is one twisted mine almost as bad as Stephen King! First Euphy now Shirley! I really hate authors like this.

[Dream_Traveller]

Uh...Taniguchi isn't twisted, and Shirley's death was seen coming from a mile away. He's done stuff like this before.