2008-09-15, 11:48 | Link #461 |
魔女狩り続行中
Join Date: Dec 2007
|
Just to make sure, is the fan mystery done?
If so, will anyone be interested if I post more speculation/things I noticed in EP 03? I did write a lot... probably too much as I think I need to split it in 3+ posts b/c I seem to hit the limit how much a single post can take, multiple times ^^;;;;; I may take some more time and post it tomorrow to reduce the text. |
2008-09-15, 18:10 | Link #467 |
魔女狩り続行中
Join Date: Dec 2007
|
Pasrt 2
First disclaimer:
1) I apologize for the ridiculous amount I wrote. 2) I'm sure I have many grammatical errors. I apologize for this. 3) I do have many contradicting theories. This because I was trying to keep open different possibilities even the unlikely ones. If you want a blunt answer: Spoiler for In short what I believe:
Now for the long winded theory... Spoiler:
Last edited by nagare; 2008-09-15 at 21:02. |
2008-09-15, 18:17 | Link #472 | |
魔女狩り続行中
Join Date: Dec 2007
|
Fin.
Quote:
I had the ideas down but I had to write them out. I was lazy so I didn't finish part 4~5 until sometime last week. When I came back to this forum, I saw that there was a fan mystery going on, so I just waited. Not like I'm in a rush since the next episode is so many months away. |
|
2008-09-16, 05:05 | Link #475 |
Philosopher of theories
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Portugal
Age: 31
|
this is kinda ... amazing O_o I would not be able to write so much text, but your theories are very well conceived...
Spoiler:
Also, as for the number, could it be a combination for some safe? Dunno, just trying to make it simple. |
2008-09-16, 09:05 | Link #476 | |
Guitar Man
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Brazil
|
Spoiler for 戴冠式:
More of my stupid thoughts () My guess is (a)+(b). We are prone to take Rosa as stupid, after all, during the solving of the riddle she did not have much participation. But I guess she is just not that much I guess she is just not so greedy (she just wants to solve her money problems) and is kind of frigging scared of her siblings, taking as basis the short flashback we had of her childhood in the tea party of episode 2. I think she already knew about where the 'golden village' was and feared that she alone would not be able to secure her share of the gold and 'slipped' some hints to Eva to have an 'ally', as Eva is known to be very sly. With this setting she would have Eva as her ally or, in the worst case scenario, Krauss and Rudolf, if Eva tried anything funny. If she came up alone claiming: "I found the gold, I'm the next head and I'll have 62,5% of the gold", it could induce a conspiracy of the other 3 together against her (it's better to share among 3 than among 4), as she doesn't have the 'poisonous nature' of the other 3. The strategy is to split the other 3. Part 12: We are strongly suggested that while Eva-b was playing with Rosa (that is, the criminal was killing Rosa), Eva was having a nightmare about the very same scene. Well, with information we get later, it seems to be more likely that eva went nuts (2 personalities) and when she kills, she thinks it was not her but Eva-b, who is 'other person'. That is, if it was realy Eva who killed the two. In spite everything points to that... Part 14: If we are to believe all that talk about Asumu, jealousy and Rudolf+Kyrie's love story, even Kyrie can have a killer instinct inside her in this story. In my 'game impression' post, I said the criminal could be one or more people, but they could be different in each game because many, if not all, of them could have a killer instinct inside that just needed something to trigger it. And Beatrice would be the personification of this, as it seems the criminal(s) want to give the impression the Witch does exist. About the calculations: To be honest, at the time I read it, I thought it to be a typo from Ryuukishi (the part of 168 and 188, it's just a 8 instead a 6) But this part: Quote:
It says: 'It is more than 845 times Leviathan's speed' And 938 is more than 845. However, this calculation needs 168 to work, and not 188. That's why I thought it to be a typo... but, who knows... And I do not remember if it's mentioned that Kyrie shot leviathan in the chest... I think... Just re-read it and did not find it... whatever... Spoiler:
It's magic Spoiler:
The stakes had to be used starting from 4th night. It might be to just take advantage of the 'ritual' and make it look more witch-like. Strange is that there's not letter this time to indicate the 3rd night. Spoiler:
I think it hints to Ria's suggestion about Nanjo's murder. Someone who was thought to be dead (Hideyoshi, anyone...?) was still alive and killed Nanjo, only to die later and create Eva-b's trick to deceive Battler's with all those red texts. Part 16 Spoiler:
It makes sense But, it's interesting to note tha the 'corpses' of Rudolf, Kyrie and Hideyoshi are found on the same place later, in the hall. This is becoming quite a playacting Spoiler:
Could it be for the sake of forcing the blame onto Eva? Like a revenge for something? -------- 腹と言うのは、何とも致死性に欠ける。 他の方法で無難に殺し、死体に杭を刺してもOKなのでは? This Kyrie's TIP is indeed extremely suggesting. This might be pointing Kyrie wrote those numbers. Could it be that her 'hatred' fro Battler had something to do with it, since Battler recognized his birthday date there? Well, quite unlikely But it suggests Kyrie might have done something with her last strenght. And in fact, it's hard for Hideyoshi to have killed Nanjo as well as Rudolf and Kyrie. But Hideyoshi's TIP bugs me: 油断した。まだ生きていたなんて……。 If one of the dead is the criminal, he'd have to go back to the exact same place he/she died because of the scene where Beato is rummaging the corpses and finds Kyrie's stuff. It would be strange if they were not in the same place, (meta)Battler should notice it. Unless the 'living-dead', knowing he/she would die soon, for some reason, did not want anyone to know that they were alive and committed a crime and returned to the place of death. It's hard, but not impossible. Can't be discarded. Could it be that there are people taking Claymore's supressing pills around here? Other point; We do not know how Battler finds Eva is the killer in the real world. We just see him crying and Eva shooting him. This has to be related to Nanjo's killer. I'm sure about this.
__________________
|
|
2008-09-17, 00:48 | Link #477 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2003
|
Lots of intresting and very promising theories but peroyasha and ace, but alot of stuff to read...I'm just gonna comment/speculate/theorize on some of the points, but do excuse me if I've brought up points that you guys have brought up/solved already:
Spoiler for 07151129:
However, thinking on that route, Spoiler for Real/Fake Battler?:
Spoiler for 6 "closed" room. Not "How?", but "Why?":
__________________
|
2008-09-17, 04:28 | Link #478 |
Guitar Man
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Brazil
|
It is mentioned something like this when Beatrice and Eva-b are discussing how to put the humans to believe in Witches.
Spoiler:
That's why the 'not-so-cruel' murders look even more strange. Someone is not very interested in look like a Witch.
__________________
|
2008-09-17, 07:43 | Link #479 |
霊夢→デレ
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: NYC, NY
Age: 46
|
You know... if this is true wouldn't it make Meta-Battler actions weird? as Meta-Battler is EP 1's Battler.
EDIT: Though whoever EP2's "Beatrice" is she would have had to of known Battler to justify the last chapters
__________________
Last edited by Sterling01; 2008-09-17 at 08:00. |
Thread Tools | |
|
|