2011-08-23, 13:21 | Link #1101 |
The True Culprit
|
Yasu loves all three of them, but seems to love Battler > George > Jessica in pretty much that order. She is indeed the daughter of the Kuwadorian Beatrice. We're still not 100% sure she's the culprit, but if she were, she would've apparently committed the murders because she's so fucked up in the head and feels she and everyone else deserves to die, or something.
__________________
|
2011-08-23, 14:29 | Link #1104 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Rokkenjima
Age: 27
|
than what is episode 8? so ryukushi left us with that? I'm disappointed. but this way
it's more interesting probably.... sorry to ask this in ep 8 discussion but will chiru anime ever come out? i'm dyeing to watch it. |
2011-08-23, 15:02 | Link #1107 | ||
The True Culprit
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||
2011-08-23, 16:52 | Link #1108 | |
別にいいけど
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
|
Quote:
He said that a solution to all the mysteries exists and that it can be found, but that one must find it by himself. Personally I think he's either overestimating the readers or his ability to create a story with enough and clear enough hints to reach the only reasonable conclusion. There is no confirmation whatsoever of a chiru anime adaption, there doesn't seem to be a big chance of that happening and most novel fans believe it's better that way. The PS3 conversion of chiru, however, was already announced, so at least you'll have a voice acting of all the chiru characters.
__________________
|
|
2011-08-23, 17:13 | Link #1109 | ||||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Quote:
He definitely overestimated his own ability to write a proper mystery. In Higurashi he basically threw it into our faces (except the over the top conspiracy plot of course) and in Umineko he veiled some aspects so far that nobody can bloody guess those elements without using guessing as a major element of "reasoning". It's no wonder because he's basically still new in the mystery department...he effectively only wrote 2 or 3 stories before Umineko only that one of them was so damn big that it counts for some authors whole resumé. Maybe if he had actually went for the more difficult mysteries that he said he had prepared for Episodes 3 and beyond...maybe that would have made better clues. I bet the "everybody is locked up in one room and still people die" would have been a pretty decent scenario full of hints... But he rather went for the "I'm going to mash the basics into your head over and over again until I see enough people on the internet getting it". I'm really with him on his metaphor about how he became like a curry shop with extremely spicy curry which became famous and stopped serving the trademark because new trendy costumers complained... Quote:
Maybe Lion really was a boy and he adapted Shannon as a personality BECAUSE he was into dudes...so he essentially dressed up as a girl and Jessica was more or less only an option because it seemed "healthier" if he should uncover his true identity. Though with his genitalia destroyed it doesn't really matter what s/he is...does it? The only other hint we have is Ryûkishi always talking about her (彼女). Quote:
|
||||
2011-08-23, 17:39 | Link #1110 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2010
|
Quote:
Ryuukishi's lack of a competent detective up until episode 7 made us pretty much guess how he intended us to see the world. He makes it clear in interviews he is surprised that people didn't see things the way he intended them to, but that's only because it requires too much guessing. For example, he makes a point in that interview that rain only matters if the author calls attention to it... Well, that's a very specific way of seeing the problem. And one that doesn't work if we don't have a good conductor along the story. I think he had a few good ideas, but there were two major problems with his approach. 1)The lack of a detective was simply too much. There are authors who can do so and still provide a good mystery, but the fact he wanted you to pretty much telepathically understand the way he saw the genre without a specific conductor made it hard to assume. 2)Like you said, he gave up going to deep into his own approach(which could have helped problem #1) and instead focus on the basic concepts of his own series. I have a feeling it could have been much better if he didn't try to cater to his fanbase so much... ...but to be fair, the man makes a living out of those novels. If he alienated his fanbase too much, he wouldn't sell any novels. And with a small fanbase like he has... .That's one argument against self-publishing I suppose. |
|
2011-08-23, 18:12 | Link #1111 | |
The True Culprit
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2011-08-23, 18:56 | Link #1112 |
Blick Winkel
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Gobbled up by Promathia
|
I dunno, I started reading when EP5 came out, but I thought the hints were well shown. However, there were so many red herrings that it made it difficult to find -which- hints led to the actual solution.
For most of us, solving the Epitaph was a lost cause. There is no getting around this. It required knowledge about both languages and about the history of Taiwanese railways; I guess Ryukishi's idea of "making it fair for both audiences" was making it so difficult no one could solve it. There was a lot of foreshadowing for the Shkannon solution, though. I'd say that, for me, it was obvious that the whole "without love, it cannot be seen" theme was a part of the solution. That being said, this is not a conventional mystery (starting from EP2). For a story of this scope, I doubt he'd do something as stupid as "GOHDA LOVES KUMASAWA BUT DOESN'T KNOW HOW TO TELL HER BECAUSE SHE LOVES GENJI BUT GENJI LOVES KINZO AND KINZO WANTS TO HAVE A NECROPHILIC ORGY WITH EVERYONE". The solution had to be meaningful to the theme. Considering the opening of EP2, the fact that Beatrice is related to Kanon and Shannon was established early on. I was aware of Shkannon by EP5, and the fact that it was the solution was pretty evident by the Love Trials part of EP6. It was superobvious by EP7's BSOD scene (though the rest of it practically handed us the answer). I know it's a silly answer, but I think EP7 cleared it up and at least made it feasible. I can see why a lot of people are pissed off by it, but I don't think that's justification for saying that he's a bad author. I'm not trying to sound like a mindless fanboy here, but when I consider the series as a whole, I consider it brilliant. EDIT: I will concede that his way of presenting the stories is "less than fair", but once again, if you consider the whole series, he clears up this with EP5 and Knox's Decalogue. |
2011-08-23, 20:58 | Link #1113 | ||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Was it actually just Eva who found the gold? Maybe. Did Natsuhi confess her crime against "Lion"? Probable. Was it Kyrie and Rudolph who decided "what the hell, let's just kill them all and take what we can carry"? Not unlikely. Was Yasu killed very early on and did the occult murders never start or did s/he survive and just decide to rather help her true love Battler? Who knows. We all know that one of the messages was that truth is subjective and so on. But what bugged me in the end was, that everybody and his dog knew what the one truth was in the end...even Ange (our perspective for EP8) knew it...but we were never told because "we don't have to be told so bluntly". It's not that it's a bad message or anything...but the build up was too huge to let it end on that note. It's like telling a one-hour joke always promising that it will blow your mind and then ending with a "guess what the pun is". Hadn't he included the story about Ange being so persistend in finding the truth...okay, I might have bought it without being annoyed. But the fact that knowing the truth became so important to the characters we associated and identified with and then letting them change because they gain knowlegde that we don't gain...it just alienated most of the readers instead of drawing them in. If it had just happened with Battler, okay...but it happened with Ange AGAIN. Quote:
The lack of an actuall trustworthy detective made it very hard to focus and as I said above, the fact that 2 of our 3 conducting main characters (Battler, Ange and finally Will) changed oppinion along the way without us knowing why made it very hard to follow the concept. I think as well, that Ryûkishi actually created a competent mystery, he just didn't know how to guide us through that mystery. He through hints left and right and when we didn't catch them (or better, if the majority didn't catch them) right away, then he changed his Episodes to an easier format. I don't even know if he would have lost so many of his fans if he had went another way...I know he lost some readers by being way to lenient with his riddles and mysteries, at least some people in Japan I know stopped reading after the 4 core arcs because they thought that it was a pretty shallow pop-mystery like most mystery manga. I still think it would have been better if he had included Virgilius from EP3 on. I mean, an Erika-type cold and calculating detective who basically destroys love in order to reach the truth...that would have actually helped even if he had thrown around exagerated theories. |
||
2011-08-23, 22:39 | Link #1115 |
The True Culprit
|
....*points rogerpepitone to the post I was responding to*
We're refering to the idea of Female-Lion, and that Kinzo wouldn't care because Lion is Beatrice's child. The question, then, would be why no one else raises the question of Lion's heirship. No one does, which implies that Lion isn't a normal female.
__________________
|
2011-08-24, 00:18 | Link #1116 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
So yes...this plot was either a bit lazy in the explanation department OR I can understand Kyrie for going on a psychotic rampage in this world as well. "You're cheating me out of my heritage because of this? HONESTLY?! Now f**k it you're all dead meat!" Don't get me wrong (especially everybody just joining in)...I love Umineko, but sometimes it's pretty easy to ridicule... |
|
2011-08-24, 01:07 | Link #1119 | |||
The True Culprit
|
Quote:
Quote:
I don't think you're thinking things through, here. Quote:
__________________
|
|||
2011-08-24, 02:26 | Link #1120 | ||
Senior Member
|
Quote:
Okay...but androgynous, looking like a woman and a dude at once...that's quite rare I'd say. Even among Japanese guys I haven't encountered that this often. Quote:
I can live with those two not being commented on their nationality. But Lion? Honestly? When Kinzô says how much s/he looks like his/her mother?! What is inconsistent about this...I'm just saying that Ryûkishi might have underestimated that factor and that it is slightly odd. |
||
|
|