|
View Poll Results: Fate/stay Night Episode 6 Rating | |||
Perfect 10 | 12 | 11.32% | |
9 out of 10 : Excellent | 16 | 15.09% | |
8 out of 10 : Very Good | 33 | 31.13% | |
7 out of 10 : Good | 26 | 24.53% | |
6 out of 10 : Average | 17 | 16.04% | |
5 out of 10 : Below Average | 1 | 0.94% | |
4 out of 10 : Poor | 0 | 0% | |
3 out of 10 : Bad | 1 | 0.94% | |
2 out of 10 : Very Bad | 0 | 0% | |
1 out of 10 : Painful | 0 | 0% | |
Voters: 106. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools |
2006-02-16, 13:19 | Link #101 | |
~Hi -mi- tsu des~
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Canada
Age: 38
|
Quote:
But most criticism I have seen about Shirou is more about the way he follows through with his ideal rather then the ideal itself. Take this ep for example, Riders attack on Rin while she was healing that girl. Shirou intercepted that attack and immediatly set out to find the perpetrator, very amirable yes, especially with a whole in his arm. However what if the attacker was to circle around him while he was stumbling around outside and got to Rin while she was still tending to the girl? Rin was the target of the first attack not him. My first response to that attack wound have been to slam the door shut ( after screaming bloody hell that theres a hole in my arm ) and strenghen it with my ability until Rin's done with treating the girl. I dont hate Shirou or his ideal of wanted to be a hero of justice, but his tendency of taking the most self sacrificing path in a situation is sometimes counter productive, its just hes been lucky so far |
|
2006-02-16, 16:42 | Link #102 |
I desire Tomorrow!
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: As far away from reality as possible
Age: 41
|
Well, all's said and done, I'm a bit late, but I'll add my opinion nonetheless.
I support everything Shirou has done up to this point. I would've been a lot more careful, sure, but I like his sheer determination to uphold his ideals to their fullest, no matter the personal cost. I like his unyielding style and his recklessness when his ideals are called forth. His pure devotion to his noble ideals to the point of seemingly stupidity is inspiring and touching. I cannot judge his character development, cause it's still the 6th episode. But I suppose he will have to make hard choices in the future, only made harder by his inability to stray from his absolute ideals. Admirable but painful. And I wouldn't call Shirou stupid, just an idealist, true idealists can appear stupid. I believe he understands what he's doing, he's thought about it and chose to act the way he did (shielding Saber, not summoning Saber, etc). I wouldn't mind if he sticks to that level of idealism, but his recklessness could cost him his life, obviously. I suppose even a blind idealist like Shirou should take the time to at least study magic and some form of martial combat. Then, by all means, rush to protect everyone. I believe that's the first thing Shirou must understand. While his intentions and his ideals are noble, he needs training. But I don't think he had much time to train. I also believe he really hasn't really grasped how serious the other Masters can be. But I suppose he'll be able to get those messages in the next episodes, or his life will be short. Having said all the above, even if Shirou, for some reason that escapes me, continues with his current choice of actions, I'll still support him but I want a good explanation of why he keeps surviving, if he is put in extreme danger again. A real person in Shirou's place would have most likely died by now, but I still wouldn't call him stupid. It's no small thing to put your life at risk with no apparent weapons against armed and vicious opponents because you want to protect someone else, against all odds. What strikes me is his father's words : "Saving one person means not being able to save another", and I'm sure Shirou will be forced to face that eventually, which would be really tragic for such an idealist. All in all, I think we have a lot of Shirou development to see, and I can't understand why he's condemned by so many people. Personally, I like him even as he is now. I think Shirou and Saber make a nice couple And don't compare Shirou with Rin (Shuffle). Rin's a huge ass who can't do anything right. Damn, even Takayuki (KGNE) is better than Rin
__________________
|
2006-02-16, 17:27 | Link #103 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
|
|
2006-02-16, 23:44 | Link #104 |
Senior Member
|
Someone posted about how foolish Shirou was going out after Rider and leaving Rin behind, and how Rider could have circled around him to get to Rin. What that person fails to remember from the episode, is Shirou says so himself, he can feel that the enemy was close, and felt them from behind the archery dojo and in the woods. So if they had gone around him, he would have followed them back to Rin. Lets not forget when Lancer attacked him the second time. He felt Lancer's presence above the rooftop. Have we seen any masters yet who are able to sense Servants? He's the only one so far. Just food for thought. Also about him not doing anything yet, and not trying to learn more magic and martial arts. If you look at the timeline in these 6 episodes, a maximum of 3-4 days has accured. Not very much chance considering all that's happened to him, to learn anything. Who's going to teach him? Rin and Saber are his only options, and well they haven't had an opportunity yet to teach him(which will be fixed soon enough).
As for Shirou's reasons for still being alive at this point... Lets just say there's a real good reason beyond him being the main character.
__________________
|
2006-02-17, 02:20 | Link #105 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
|
|
2006-02-17, 03:12 | Link #106 | |
~Hi -mi- tsu des~
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Canada
Age: 38
|
@justinstrife
Well I believe that someone said Quote:
Sure he sensed Rider, but then proceeded to drop his guard because he thought he saw, heard and/or felt a familiar presense (Shinji). If Rider wanted Rin dead are you sure she couldn't have went around Shirou while he was lured into the woods calling out to Shinji? I didnt deny Shirou's ability, he holds up pretty well against servants. I just felt that from my point of view that running out headlong into an unknown enemy while injured and leaving behind the target of the first attack from said enemy while she was tending to a victim of the enemy didnt make much sense. In my opinion making sure that Rin was alright by guarding her while her attention was focused on reviving the girl was better then running into an unknown enemy's possible ambush. |
|
2006-02-17, 07:35 | Link #107 |
Level 5 Haruhiist
|
IMO, Shirou is a kid. What would you do in the situation? Assuming running away is not an option, and you had ideals which basically forced you to do stupid stuff like this. Shirou isn't one to sit around forming battle plans, or going around taking the course of action that makes the most sense. This has been made clear from the beginning. He's not Rin, he's not Saber, he is himself and the things he does fit his personality type perfectly.
|
2006-02-17, 12:03 | Link #108 | |
Senior Member
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2006-02-17, 12:30 | Link #109 |
Waiting for more taiyuki!
Join Date: Jan 2004
|
Personally, I think that the deleting of the spoilers which may be game-related is alittle too much. These type of spoilers do add another layer to understanding the anime. Besides, there are loads of sites that discuss the game. To think that the people watching the anime are existing in a vacuum is erroneus imo. Besides, no-translation notes-on-the-DVD Geneon has this title. so the only way that Region 1 DVD buyers who don't understand Japanese can get a better understanding may be from the game players.
( Not meaning to offend anyone. It's just my opinion.) I really liked ep.6 and gave it a 10, mostly for Rider's fight scene and finding out that Spoiler:
Spoiler:
I thougt it was pretty obvious from the get go that Rin likes Shirou. She also seems to act similarly (sense of justice) like Shirou. From what Rin's dad was saying, it's a family duty to be in the Grail War, so Rin has to find a stronger reason imo.
__________________
|
2006-02-17, 12:42 | Link #110 |
"Show it to me"
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: In solitude, where we are least alone
|
rider's voice is so sexy. it makes my hair stand up anyway, archer seems to be distraught that rin doesn't attack shirou seriously....could it be that she's....
Spoiler:
__________________
|
2006-02-17, 13:01 | Link #111 | |
~Hi -mi- tsu des~
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Canada
Age: 38
|
*response to justinstrife's post*
I know what you said you missed my meaning, first of all I didnt say he couldnt sense Rider, he certainly sensed SOMEONE thats why hes in the woods. BUT he dropped his guard when he thought he saw Shinji and Rider got the jump on him correct? In the he managed to block the next attack because then he was focused and could sense the attack, when he was yelling for Shinji to come out he was not and couldn't react to Rider's attack in time. Without having to make referances to the game and just by judging the other servants that he has seen, most of them are quite agile and fast most likely more so then Shirou. Also Shirou was only getting a general Idea of were Rider was, he might have realized it if Rider was to circle back and attack Rin but most likely too late. Not to mention that as I said before Rider jumped him he was distracted by Shinji. Quote:
Also I think you missed the point in my post, I might not have been all that clear though. I was saying I can UNDERSTAND the criticism people have of Shirou and the actions he takes. I gave a recent example and followed with what I would have done in that situation. I think most if the the criticisms against Shirou's actions have to do with the fact that he does not react in what we would consider a normal manner. I simply used an example of one of those situations and provided an example of what a more normal response would have been. I used myself because I cant predict how anyone else would have acted in the same situation, but if you think what I'd have done to be to be unlogical in that situation feel free to say so. Also I never said that Shirou should have reacted more like my example, I know what kind of character he is and he has differant prioities then I do. I'd do everything I could to help but I would also be keeping my self preservation instincts active, Shirou doesn't care about that as long as he can do something which resulted in HIS reaction. However this differance is the main reason people get fustrated with his character is because he seems to chooses to react in a way with the lowest chances of survival, very differant from what most of us, including me, would have reacted. I think in your fervor to defend Shirou you misunderstood what I meant in my post. This is turning into a rant so im going to stop typing and have breakfast |
|
2006-02-17, 18:18 | Link #112 |
Tsuruya Cultist
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: San Francisco, CA
|
I think I know how I would react as well. I'd act like any dead person would after being run through with a lance. I'd probably stay dead, because I don't think I'm Rin's type. But let's say I was. Let's say I was killed, punted through the air and into the side of a house, bludgeoned by a giant, chased through the school by girl maniacally shooting at me from her finger, and then pierced by a large pointy object on a chain. If I were in my late teens, I might subconsciously feel I was invincible. But I'm not in my late teens. I'm at an age where a heart attack would most likely be the appropriate response.
Young men often act without regarding the consequences -- on principle, for love, for kicks, you name it. Shirou has been killed and pulverized and stabbed and it only seems to make him stronger. Subconsciously or not, that has to have an effect on his decision making process. We all might act like supermen if we had reason to believe we were. |
2006-02-17, 19:21 | Link #114 | |
Tsuruya Cultist
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: San Francisco, CA
|
Quote:
|
|
|
|