Magia Record: Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica Gaiden- Episode 13 END S1 Discussion / Poll

[Cosmic Eagle]

Oh, looks like her wish to live is quite effective then. Come to think of it, what if someone simply wishes to never become a Witch? Quite a dumb wish though and is self-contradicting, but say, purely as part of some way to attempt to game the system....


Anyway the ED here, whoever シト is her voice is really good. Have to look into her

[Liddo-kun]

Originally Posted by Cosmic Eagle

How old is Yachiyo supposed to be? Come to think of it, there isn't a 20+ year old Mahou Shoujo before

it is often a joke in the official Magia Report manga that she's in college. So probably almost 20.

[GDB]

Originally Posted by Infinite Zenith

If memory serves, she's 19.

Correct. She's also a first year University student.

Originally Posted by Cosmic Eagle

Oh, looks like her wish to live is quite effective then. Come to think of it, what if someone simply wishes to never become a Witch? Quite a dumb wish though and is self-contradicting, but say, purely as part of some way to attempt to game the system....

I'd assume this is where karmic debt from season 1 would come into play. That or Kyubei would just say it's not possible, regardless of whether or not it is. He decides whether you get the contract or not, after all.

Only reason Madoka got her wish was likely because Kyubei was so desperate for her karma/anti-entropy that he granted it regardless of the risk. That and he wasn't sure if she'd become a god or not.

[maximilianjenus]

Originally Posted by Cosmic Eagle

How old is Yachiyo supposed to be? Come to think of it, there isn't a 20+ year old Mahou Shoujo before

One of the witches in the first season was a late twenties magical girl; societal expecations about career and marriage are what ended up making her turn. rumours back then were that said mahou shoujo was madoka's teacher too. I think the latest was wrong as she should be in her early thirties (being madoka's mom kouhai from college) and she adapted well relyign to whoreism and alcoholism to avoid despair.

But still the 25+ years old ahou shoujo exists since the first series; there should be some older ones in the janne of arc spin off too.

[GDB]

Originally Posted by maximilianjenus

One of the witches in the first season was a late twenties magical girl; societal expecations about career and marriage are what ended up making her turn. rumours back then were that said mahou shoujo was madoka's teacher too. I think the latest was wrong as she should be in her early thirties (being madoka's mom kouhai from college) and she adapted well relyign to whoreism and alcoholism to avoid despair.

You're going to have to source this, because I can't find anything about basically any witch's past from the original series outside of Charlotte, Oktavia, and Kremheild (or whatever Madoka's was called).

And the teacher being a magical girl is a bunch of nonsense. Further, trying to find love is not "whoreism".