AnimeSuki Forums

Shinji103 · 2013-04-14, 12:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by jasonhan416

dang.. what volume/chapter was episode 2?

Apparently it was one of the drama CDs.

***relentlessflame*** · 2013-04-14, 14:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shinji103

Apparently it was one of the drama CDs.

Not only that, but the actual anime script for it was penned by the light novel author himself. So I think it can probably be considered canon, even if it didn't make it in the printed novels.

jasonhan416 · 2013-04-14, 21:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by relentlessflame

Not only that, but the actual anime script for it was penned by the light novel author himself. So I think it can probably be considered canon, even if it didn't make it in the printed novels.

Wow -_-... Cause I read the light novel from 1 to 11 and I double checked volume 6 like 4 times and none of them matched lol

Yye1 · 2013-04-14, 22:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by relentlessflame

Not only that, but the actual anime script for it was penned by the light novel author himself. So I think it can probably be considered canon, even if it didn't make it in the printed novels.

Isnt it the reason that

Spoiler for Ayase plot spoiler:

***relentlessflame*** · 2013-04-15, 00:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yye1

Isnt it the reason that

Spoiler for Ayase plot spoiler:

Do you mean phone numbers? If so, I think that already happened (in the anime anyway) earlier (he was already blacklisted in episode 15 last season).

icebreaker · 2013-04-15, 03:41

Quote:

Originally Posted by relentlessflame

Do you mean phone numbers? If so, I think that already happened (in the anime anyway) earlier (he was already blacklisted in episode 15 last season).

Yes, in the original Drama CD plot, this is the reason Ayase blacklisted Kyousuke.
Also Fushimi's name in the "script" of this episode might refer to him writing the plot for the drama CD, not for this episode in particular.

bakAnki · 2013-04-15, 05:46

Was just thinking, isn't the wedding dress chapter will be great for 'TV end'/eps 13? The premise of the show is the relationship between big brother and his little sister that becomes distant for the past few years and due to the brother find out the little sister hobby they can get closer. And the wedding chapter is perfect to be the conclusion. It involves Kyousuke who put lot of effort to take Kirino to a anime concert she really want to see, Kirino also become honest to her feeling (when on the bike and when they arrive at the concert albeit Kyousuke didn't really hear what she said), and of course that wedding dress. That's like the best Kyousuke x Kirino end we can get (so far) without they crossing the line

But of course this is impossible due to the timeline (how can you fit 3 remaining novels just in 3 ONA/Blu-Ray episodes

), unless they change the order of the events

kentasaiba · 2013-04-15, 15:38

What about the scene when Kyousuke and Akagi goes to that sex-shop? Will it be cutted because its too much? I mean it should be between episode 1 and 3.

Mystic_Vegetto · 2013-04-15, 15:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by bakAnki

Was just thinking, isn't the wedding dress chapter will be great for 'TV end'/eps 13? The premise of the show is the relationship between big brother and his little sister that becomes distant for the past few years and due to the brother find out the little sister hobby they can get closer. And the wedding chapter is perfect to be the conclusion. It involves Kyousuke who put lot of effort to take Kirino to a anime concert she really want to see, Kirino also become honest to her feeling (when on the bike and when they arrive at the concert albeit Kyousuke didn't really hear what she said), and of course that wedding dress. That's like the best Kyousuke x Kirino end we can get (so far) without they crossing the line

But of course this is impossible due to the timeline (how can you fit 3 remaining novels just in 3 ONA/Blu-Ray episodes

), unless they change the order of the events

I think for episode 13, the best place to end it would be the end of Volume 11, where Kyousuke has finally decided on who he would confess to. It would be a good way to build up to the OVA Episodes to be aired at a later date.

Quote:

What about the scene when Kyousuke and Akagi goes to that sex-shop? Will it be cutted because its too much? I mean it should be between episode 1 and 3.

More than likely it's going to get cut since I don't really think the Akagi siblings play any vital roles in the story.

Flying Dagger · 2013-04-15, 17:17

....as long as they keep the "who has the cuter imouto" race.

jasonhan416 · 2013-04-15, 17:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flying Dagger

....as long as they keep the "who has the cuter imouto" race.

second that.

GVN.Chaos · 2013-04-15, 19:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flying Dagger

....as long as they keep the "who has the cuter imouto" race.

Me third. I was laughing so hard when reading that one =)

***relentlessflame*** · 2013-04-15, 19:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by icebreaker

Also Fushimi's name in the "script" of this episode might refer to him writing the plot for the drama CD, not for this episode in particular.

Well that doesn't make any sense, though, because in that sense he wrote the "script" for the entire novel too. The person who gets that credit is the one who wrote the script for the anime episode. If he also wrote the script for the drama CD, then it sort of double-proves my point that people shouldn't consider it out-of-canon (or "filler") just because it wasn't in the printed book.

icebreaker · 2013-04-15, 22:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by relentlessflame

Well that doesn't make any sense, though, because in that sense he wrote the "script" for the entire novel too. The person who gets that credit is the one who wrote the script for the anime episode. If he also wrote the script for the drama CD, then it sort of double-proves my point that people shouldn't consider it out-of-canon (or "filler") just because it wasn't in the printed book.

When they mean script then mean dialogues and scenes on what is going to happen. You can't use the light novel as script, but you sure can reuse the Drama CD script on the anime.
By the way, the timeline is different from the Drama CD, that's why people are arguing about it. -- Is this really the reason Ayase blocked Kyousuke's number or not?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mystic_Vegetto

I think for episode 13, the best place to end it would be the end of Volume 11, where Kyousuke has finally decided on who he would confess to. It would be a good way to build up to the OVA Episodes to be aired at a later date.

Yes, alternatively I think it's a way to do it chronologically. From what it seems he rejected either Kuroneko or Ayase (Rejects Ayase straight away/Putting Ayase on hold and apologizes to Kuroneko) in the time between Volume 10 and 11 and well, the tension will be gone for the OVAs.

***relentlessflame*** · 2013-04-16, 23:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by icebreaker

When they mean script then mean dialogues and scenes on what is going to happen. You can't use the light novel as script, but you sure can reuse the Drama CD script on the anime.

Well, in the end, it doesn't really matter at all, since it'd written by the novel author either way.

icebreaker · 2013-04-17, 07:27

Next episode preview out. Seems like Saori's story from Volume 9.

kentasaiba · 2013-04-20, 16:28

Vol 9, really? Well... lets hope they animate the kirino/kyousuke "wedding" scene also

Flying Dagger · 2013-04-20, 16:52

They merged two stories: the visit to Saori's home takes place earlier. In v9 the group ran into Kaori which is the setting of the other half of ep3.

Not as hyped for ep4, only really wanted to hear Kyosuke scream how he is not a lolicon but a siscon. I guess they can justify keeping in that episode as it is one of the first moments where the character's inner thoughts are revealed.

Micromancer · 2013-04-21, 00:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mystic_Vegetto

I think for episode 13, the best place to end it would be the end of Volume 11, where Kyousuke has finally decided on who he would confess to. It would be a good way to build up to the OVA Episodes to be aired at a later date.

will those eps enough to cover all of the story until vol 11 ending ? except there's some scene from LN being cut, like stories from vol 9 which are way too much :S (imo, idk)

***relentlessflame*** · 2013-04-21, 01:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by Micromancer

will those eps enough to cover all of the story until vol 11 ending ? except there's some scene from LN being cut, like stories from vol 9 which are way too much :S (imo, idk)

There are some theories about that earlier in the thread, though these may need to be revised somewhat.

In the end, they basically already said that they'd get to the end of the novels, so they'll get there somehow. I'm sure everyone will have opinions about what they end up keeping and what they end up cutting, or the exact way they do it (or what gets emphasized), but in the end the novels will always end up being the more complete and comprehensive version of the story no matter what. I try to look at it as an alternate retelling, and try to appreciate the way the director and anime writer (with the help of the original author and editorial staff) interpreted the story for this medium.

2013-04-15, 05:46	Link #127
bakAnki あやせたんの剣 Join Date: Aug 2011 Location: bakanki.blogspot.com	Was just thinking, isn't the wedding dress chapter will be great for 'TV end'/eps 13? The premise of the show is the relationship between big brother and his little sister that becomes distant for the past few years and due to the brother find out the little sister hobby they can get closer. And the wedding chapter is perfect to be the conclusion. It involves Kyousuke who put lot of effort to take Kirino to a anime concert she really want to see, Kirino also become honest to her feeling (when on the bike and when they arrive at the concert albeit Kyousuke didn't really hear what she said), and of course that wedding dress. That's like the best Kyousuke x Kirino end we can get (so far) without they crossing the line But of course this is impossible due to the timeline (how can you fit 3 remaining novels just in 3 ONA/Blu-Ray episodes ), unless they change the order of the events __________________ Tumblr \| MyFigureCollection \| Blogspot

2013-04-15, 15:38	Link #128
kentasaiba Member Join Date: Apr 2013	What about the scene when Kyousuke and Akagi goes to that sex-shop? Will it be cutted because its too much? I mean it should be between episode 1 and 3.

2013-04-15, 17:17	Link #130
Flying Dagger 大巧不工 Join Date: Dec 2003	....as long as they keep the "who has the cuter imouto" race.

2013-04-17, 07:27	Link #136
icebreaker Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2013	Next episode preview out. Seems like Saori's story from Volume 9.

2013-04-20, 16:28	Link #137
kentasaiba Member Join Date: Apr 2013	Vol 9, really? Well... lets hope they animate the kirino/kyousuke "wedding" scene also

2013-04-20, 16:52	Link #138
Flying Dagger 大巧不工 Join Date: Dec 2003	They merged two stories: the visit to Saori's home takes place earlier. In v9 the group ran into Kaori which is the setting of the other half of ep3. Not as hyped for ep4, only really wanted to hear Kyosuke scream how he is not a lolicon but a siscon. I guess they can justify keeping in that episode as it is one of the first moments where the character's inner thoughts are revealed.