Rate That Signature!

[ganbaru]

delorean2200 8,4/10 funny picture

[MogMoogle1]

ganbaru 9/10 - It is always interesting to see your stuff.

[HasuMasu]

MogMoogle1: Something wrong with the edges? - 8/10

[ganbaru]

MogMoogle1 8,3/10 a two frames animation ?

Originally Posted by Hasumi

MogMoogle1: Something wrong with the edges? - 8/10

Probably the result of using .gif , or at least it isn't helping.

[MogMoogle1]

Originally Posted by Hasumi

MogMoogle1: Something wrong with the edges? - 8/10

If you mean the character sprites... yeah... I'm a noob who doesn't know how to clean up pics very well. Mostly learning from experimentation, so I suck at it. Imma have to look for tips on how to do a better job at it.

As for yours, 9/10. She is only the best girl in the series.

Originally Posted by ganbaru

MogMoogle1 8,3/10 a two frames animation ?

Yeah, the ED sequence of the series has it as a 2 frame animation sequence, but even if there is more, AS's size restriction would probably not like it much.

[Krytonis]

Everyone on this page: 10/10 I love them all!

[delorean2200]

ganbaru: 8.4/10 nice but feels a bit to light.
MogMoogle1: 9.8/10 love it it would be a perfect ten if not for the edges.
Hasumi: 8.2/10 feels a bit empty and could use a border.
Krytonis: 9/10 nice maybe a bit saturated on the render but nice overall.

[ganbaru]

delorean2200 8,4/10 nice looking girl

[milan kyuubi]

ganbaru 8/10 I think the colors behind the girl are just to bright.

Btv can I get ratings for a sig I did some time ago?

[ganbaru]

Milan kyuubi 8,4/10 it's interesting but it eel like a god deal of the detail of the focus had been lost on the process.

Originally Posted by milan kyuubi

ganbaru 8/10 I think the colors behind the girl are just to bright.

There's many reason it's like that, not only for my bias toward bright colors and white, but also because of a attempt for a rough or unrefined look, fitting with the Vieux Chaos/ Old Chaos of the quote.

[Frailty]

gotta keep this thread alive.

Originally Posted by milan kyuubi

Btv can I get ratings for a sig I did some time ago?

of course!
can't see the image though. Can you reupload it elsewhere?

@topic

ganbaru
7/10
-The colors are a mess IMO, you can't see the focal of the renders. The text has improved here. It's more visible now. Your previous ones had text that were pretty difficult to read. You should keep this style from now on

milan kyuubi
-I've already rated yours before iirc

delorean2200
7/10
- simple. You should work on the sig's canvass if you want your text below to be seen.

Krytonis
- I believe I've rated yours before as well.

MogMoogle1
7/10
- Good job on rendering Noire. The background does not do well for the renders though. It's the colors, I think.

[ganbaru]

delorean2200 8,4/10 the background's sky look nice.
Frailty 8,8/10 I remember this signature but I don't think than I rated it yet.

Originally Posted by Frailty

gotta keep this thread alive.

Rather hard to do it when there's much new signatures to rate.

[Ichuki]

10/10- The colours fits perfectly and it is pretty overall.

[Sumeragi]

Ichuki: 8/10 A bit blurry.

[Frailty]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

Rather hard to do it when there's much new signatures to rate.

I think it's the other way around. It's the same forumers that are posting here. And most of us rarely change signatures.

@topic

Ichuki
8/10
-it's too dark. There are light sources in both left and right sides but it's dark on those sides. I feel like the sig was burned too much or it's probably because of the small black gradient at the sides. Adjusting the brightness and contrast or dodging some of the parts should do the trick.

Sumeragi
-I'm pretty sure I've rated yours before

[Akito Kinomoto]

Frailty--Solid monochrome. 8.3/10
Sumeragi--Background has clear outlines despite the similar colors. The character looks slightly pixelated though. 8.23/10 Is that a list of your party members?
Ichuki--The moon is dominating the picture more than it should be. 8/10
Ganbaru--Maybe not knowing what the text reads adds to it. 8.29/10
milan kyuubi--Downsize the text and shift it to the bottom-right. The border and effects make nostalgia. 8.25/10
delorean2200--Simple, cropped, but effective. 8.2/10
Krytonis--8.19/10
MogMoogle1--Nice background, nice sprites, perfectly placed text, corners get an "A" for effort. 8.6/10
Masuzu--8.2/10
Crashmaking Zoomatic--Points for originality. 8.4/10

[ganbaru]

Ichuki 8,3/10 Suigintou is a bit too blurred
Akito Kinomoto 8,6/10 very nice smile here.

[UltimaWolf]

Akito Kinomoto: Very upbeat and cheerful, makes me want to smile too. Good choices! 9/10
ganbaru: I've always liked your sigs. Touching picture and sad words to go with it. Nice colors and effects. Blends well which could be a good or bad thing I suppose 8.5/10

[Triple_R]

Ichuki: 8.4/10 I agree with the criticisms on the darkness/bluriness of the sig, but it does still have an enchanting gothic look to it. Try to make it a bit more clear and/or bright, and it could be excellent!
Sumeragi: 8.8/10 Lovely and highly informative. Saten with glasses is a rare treat too.
Frailty: 8.6/10 Good character pose. Well-drawn. Very eye-catching.
ganbaru: 8.8/10 Elegant visual style. As usual, I like how it matches your avatar.
UltimaWolf: 8.8/10 I like the little touches - Your name on the white leggings and how the blinking eyes are the only things that are moving. Good style.

Akito, for some reason, I can't see your sig right now, so I can't grade it.

[ganbaru]

Triple R 8,4/10 I can't remember if I rated this one before.