(CR) Planet With

[wuhugm]

Originally Posted by Kanon

As much as I love Planet With, I think it's the weakest of his main works.

THIS!

Originally Posted by Dengar

So all girls in anime ever have to cater to your specific preferences?

Do you think Nozomi figurines will sell?

[Guardian Enzo]

Who the fuck cares?

[4th Dimension]

Originally Posted by Gan_HOPE326

I think they'll wake up anyway, even after planet-wide sealing. It's just, when they wake up, they've lost all will to fight. You've seen it happen with the chuuni guy.

I think this sealing was a bit different given that even the planet changed color. Which is why I'm assuming they basically conserved/froze the planet.

But then again the moment was short.

--------------------

Also really? We are still arguing how a character is bad because she is not beautiful? Really? That's the crux of the issue?!?

IMO, she is meant to be a bit homely. Not to be Anime pretty or beautiful. She is just some nerd, and she looks it. And her looks are perfectly fine. She is average looking to me. Her actual draw fro Soya is that she is there for him and understands him.

Although I would agree that she probably got the least amount of development compared to her amount of screentime. She is kinda just there to be THE GIRL, and unfortunately isn't let be much more than that in most of the episodes.

[wuhugm]

Originally Posted by 4th Dimension

Although I would agree that she probably got the least amount of development compared to her amount of screentime. She is kinda just there to be THE GIRL

Well, basically this

[Solace]

Originally Posted by wuhugm

Do you think Nozomi figurines will sell?

Who the fuck cares? I'd buy those mechs. The cat and dog mechs are pretty sweet. Not everyone rates anime by how fuckable the girls are.

Nozomi is fine. She doesn't need to be anything more than she is.

[RDNexus]

Why can't people see each character for what he/she/it is instead of what they want them to be?

[4th Dimension]

Because they want them to be something they consider better, and are dissapointed by reality compared to the dream?

[RDNexus]

Well, given that tend to do it even in real life...

[orion]

Originally Posted by xrick

Why can't people see each character for what he/she/it is instead of what they want them to be?

Well....if you're self-inserting into the title which the makers want, that means that your preferences are also affected by the MCs. Nozomi is okay, but she wasn't developed enough to compensate for people who are into "girls with glasses". Ginko got more development, looks better after time skip, and is in a maid outfit. Maids are better imo.

[RDNexus]

Well, I don't tend to self-insert myself, I prefer to see things unfold in a 3rd-Person View, so maybe that's why I don't see things the way others do.

[wuhugm]

Yo, it's over~

Great anime. Especially the later half after entering the subspace was epic.

I'm so glad the end didn't show Soya and Nozo happily ever after

Should totally just went Ginko route

Desperately giving Nozo achievements, to the point of disregarding the entire telepath squads (Just kept zooming to her face)
Giving her random Deus Ex Machina power of remote dimensional tracking to locate Soya
So obnoxious

Writing her off the script would make this anime whole lot better

[Stark700]

This was one of the strangest, most ambiguous, and creative show I've seen this year. It's a hell of an experience that got me confused in the beginning but the more I watched, the more I went with the flow and enjoyed it.

Kinda wish there was more of an aftermath though as the very final scenes felt a bit lackluster. Other than that, I hope more of Mizukami's works gets adapted in the future (this technically isn't an adaptatation as it's an original show)

[Kanon]

That was really, really good (loved the scene with Ginko and Soya respectively thanking and forgiving the dragon), but the lack of epilogue hurts. I'm very disappointed there wasn't any. One may argue everything after the timeskip was the epilogue, but I wanted more.

Still a really strong show overall, one of the best this season. The finale didn't change my mind about this being Mizukami's weakest main work, if anything, it cemented it. Still happy I got to enjoy a brand new story by him. Here's hoping this is just the beginning and we'll get more Mizukami anime, adaptations or originals!

[Dop]

Brilliant show, started watching for the maid and the weird cat thing, kept watching for the story an the action. Put more into twelve episodes than some shows put into 24, but never with a feeling that it was being rushed or things were being cut, the show just had no fat, all lean.

Never heard of Mizukami before this show, but I'm getting into his manga now.

Can we have Spirit Circle next, please?

[4th Dimension]

While I'm not entirely sure the ending with the dragon landed 100% right, this was still a great ride. And I'll definitely be there to lap up anything Mr Writter-san makes in Anime-land, if he ever gets another chance.

I want to again be taken on Mizukami's wild ride

[Dengar]

Feels Good Man

[zeando]

Originally Posted by Dop

Can we have Spirit Circle next, please?

That would be a great pick to get animated, or maybe it would be best to have an other work being animated first, since spirit circle is so good anything coming after would hardly stand the comparison.

It's still to see though, how Planet With was received in Japan, before talking about any other adaptation.
Anyone has news or stats?

[4th Dimension]

There is no edge lord antagonist to swoon over, no heapings of despair to call it "art" and no lolis. So they probably hate it

[Wandering Soul]

Hard to believe that they could cram so much story into 12 episodes, but in the end they did it. This was definitely one of the most ambitious and strangest anime I have seen this year. Overall one of the best shows of this season. I'm also disappointed by the lack of an epilogue though.

[Psyco Diver]

Good show, I wasn't sure what to expect going in but I'm glad i did