Quote:
Originally Posted by Charred Knight
Here's the thing, yes what happened to Louise is a tragedy, it was really well conceived, and Alle killing all those children where tragic, Neil's death, and Kinue's death where really sad as well, but the problem was that all the good tragedies where in season 1, the "tragedies" from season 2 come off as stupid and forced.
Setsuna's "God" betrays him would be interesting if his god wasn't a giant robot
Tieria's tale of humanity was interesting but the whole Veda is a complete narm. Its like if Nina had an actual relationship with the table from Season 1.
Marina being a wayward princess would be interesting but she's a crappy character and the series would have been better off if she had been in Azadistan when it burned down.
Honestly I hoped it would be different, I hoped that the staff would look at what worked and what didn't work and change it. I hoped that the intelligence seen in the first season continued.
The thing is that for the first 10 episodes it did, the Marie subplot was great the fact that the A-Laws where holding their own against Celestial being was great.
Then all of a sudden Kuroda and the Director thinks that Gundam needs Magic, and the whole thing falls apart.
|
Okay, here is what we are going to do since you seem so keen on ignoring everything I and anybody else says:
You are going to hold onto those thoughts about the series that you imagine that you wanted but doesn't exist and to me utterly conflict with the themes that have been building for the past ever in this series which does exist. Just keep it to yourself, Nutype and 4Tran and it is yours to have. I will keep my thoughts on this episode and then.....then we will all be really happy and chill on this board. Okay? Okay.....and really I've gotta be level with you though, I don't actually care about what you want for the series since you see.....lol.....you are not the writer and never have been. And really why should I care about what you think worked and didn't work in your own head when it is just completely flies in the face of the internal logic the series has presented?
Here is what I care about
:
What the series has built itself as and what works within that context and by my judgement it has so it's time for you to just accept that I like where this has gone and stop trying to convince me otherwise.
Oh and in case you are wondering, don't bother replying to this as I don't care what you have to say anymore. In fact don't bother quoting or replying to me ever again at this point since you've completely lost me with this episode and your posts make no sense to me anymore. The only reason I've read them up until now is for the lulz, but among other things that has worn thing for me. Chill with Nutype and 4Tran for all I care as they seem to be down with your point of view. There's also T.H.A.T Animeblog which you can visit and which is full of people who complain about this series on a level you can't even begin to imagine. You can hone your art by hanging out with them and ripping this series a new one for stuff that I would probably find superficial, irrelevant or manufactured if I bothered to care anymore. So yeah, that's is for us. Bye.
And I just noticed Monir's warning so I am going to go to bed and get back on topic tomorrow.
Moderator
) which I believe cause her vegetative state ever watch zeta? Saji crying. GN particle spreading and Tieria/regene/veda boot up. Oh it magically healed? 
