AnimeSuki Forums

Drkz · 2013-03-20, 18:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by sky black swordman

^ Cecily, she looks like a wife....A HOUSEWIFE!! And is it just me or does she look a bit like she is may be expecting ?

Just you. SB S2 WHERE?! I wanna see siegfried's ass get kicked.

Stufu · 2013-03-21, 01:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by sky black swordman

^ Cecily, she looks like a wife....A HOUSEWIFE!! And is it just me or does she look a bit like she is may be expecting ?

cuz she married Luke haha so she become more woman-like or so

MAX_COLA_POWER! · 2013-03-21, 01:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by sky black swordman

^ Cecily, she looks like a wife....A HOUSEWIFE!! And is it just me or does she look a bit like she is may be expecting ?

Well, if she is, a plentiful bounty awaits that newborn.

Kazu-kun · 2013-06-16, 10:28

So, the LN ended in volume 15.

Some bits I heard

Spoiler for spoiler volume 15:

Stufu · 2013-06-16, 10:33

good end! now I wanna read it in full

Bern-san · 2013-06-16, 16:40

To me...

Spoiler for about spoilers of vol. 15:

demonking79 · 2014-02-10, 06:08

i agree seigs an ass. however based on a discussion in chapter 30 something wear it talks about how the first housman performed terrible experiments with demons and even force mating with humans and that the children that came out of the matting had no reproductive organs i believe that seig is one of these children in wicth case i caan kinda see why he such an ass. i mean if you can onisly tell me that if you were the cild from some force mating between a human and a demon and were pronely kept in a cage for most of your life and tormented by the first housemen you would't be like and want revenge on the city that did that to you than congas you are most limey a saint or an egotistic bastered. another reason i believe seigs is a child from these experiments is cause in anoth captor 30 somthin one of his demon cals him seig housemen so you big hint there not to mechen that he isn't capable of sex as previously stated.

demonking79 · 2014-02-10, 06:24

hey any one know were i can read an english LN I've been looking but i can't find one.

amtro · 2014-03-10, 22:14

Let me see if I got this right.

Spoiler for vol 16:

Also whatever happened to the sacrifice required to use the purifying flame, why did Luke's eye suddenly turn red?

wuhugm · 2017-03-16, 22:19

Cecil rape

Also Cecil is the protagonist (MC coz Japan generally has only 1 MC), as it's using her POV
So in this case, Luke is a main guy lol

dark44 · 2017-03-17, 13:36

didnt they remove the rape ?
or there is two ending light novel and manga have different end?

Sacredus · 2017-03-17, 13:38

There never was any rape to begin with. That rumor about "rape scene and magical 1st edition of LN that had it" was born in western community for some reason ffs.

ImperialFlameGod8190 · 2017-03-17, 13:41

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sacredus

There never was any rape to begin with. That was just rumor that "rape scene and magical 1st edition of LN that had it" was born in western community for some reason ffs.

so it's like the famous chapter 16.5 for SAO

Sacredus · 2017-03-17, 13:43

No... 16.5 actually exist...

Edit: But really, do people really believe that publisher of teen novel would ever allow to release something like this? /facepalm

Edit2: It really pisses me off. That dumb rumor is like boomerang. You say it's completely fake, but it will return after some time.

wuhugm · 2017-03-17, 13:58

^But in ch23 of manga, Cecil said her body has been defiled by Siegfried
Before she danced with Luke

Y Ddraig Goch · 2017-03-17, 14:41

She only got groped and Siegfried implied he was impotent.

I actually want to see the proof there was a real "rape" chapter to begin with. People argued the controversy for months, but no source was ever linked to even support this claim.

AB079 · 2017-03-17, 15:46

Back in the day a lot of people was saying that never happend and others that it was 100% true, it is 50/50 so nobody can be sure. The "rape" issue started for something, why someone would lie about it when you have stories like Gosick with similar situations and nobody say anything?

Nobody knows the truth, in the end this isn't like Kannagi where the rage of the japanese fans was 100% real.

PS: don't misunderstand the example of Gosick, I'm talking about what father did to her.

Sacredus · 2017-03-17, 16:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by wuhugm

^But in ch23 of manga, Cecil said her body has been defiled by Siegfried
Before she danced with Luke

Quote:

Originally Posted by Y Ddraig Goch

She only got groped and Siegfried implied he was impotent.

I actually want to see the proof there was a real "rape" chapter to begin with. People argued the controversy for months, but no source was ever linked to even support this claim.

He was eunuch from what I remember but well... we can say he was impotent

Quote:

Originally Posted by AB079

Back in the day a lot of people was saying that never happend and others that it was 100% true, it is 50/50 so nobody can be sure. The "rape" issue started for something, why someone would lie about it when you have stories like Gosick with similar situations and nobody say anything?

Nobody knows the truth, in the end this isn't like Kannagi where the rage of the japanese fans was 100% real.

PS: don't misunderstand the example of Gosick, I'm talking about what father did to her.

Isn't her father was giving her drugs or something? I remember she's still recovering from this (in new books).

As for this. This 100% fake. People from Baka-Tsuki for some time searched for any evidence of this rumor and found nothing. Not a single mention in Japan/Asia internet side and remember drama that could force publisher to publish 2nd print of book with changed contented should be HUGE and yet there's compliantly nothing about something like this ever happening.

It's really just fake. Someone must saw manga raws of that chapter and misinterpreted everything. And that was not a first time that something like this happened.

El Rue · 2017-03-17, 17:55

Hahaha, there should always be a disclaimer for all of erotora's posts, something like its often 60-70% lies & his half truths most of the time are not even 50% true.

felc57 · 2017-06-20, 15:27

Is there any difference in the light novel vs the manga? Or is the manga a pretty good adaptation of the light novels?

I just finished up with the anime (was okay), and about to jump into the manga. As the final volume will be released in English next month, I wanted to know if the manga is complete and good by itself. It sucks that the light novel never got translated to English, and probably never will, but I don't mind if the manga is good enough for the story.

2013-06-16, 10:28	Link #144
Kazu-kun Senior Member Join Date: Apr 2006	So, the LN ended in volume 15. Some bits I heard Spoiler for spoiler volume 15: 1 - As it turns out, the sacred sword was Aria all along (or at least she became the sacred sword after being reforged). 2 - Cecily had to use Aria to seal Vaalbanil, but that meant that Aria became the seal in the volcano. Cecily promised to Aria that she and Luke would forge a new sacred sword to replace Aria as the seal, so that Aria could be free, even if it took many years. 3 - It took like 300 years. Lisa (who is immortal since she's not human) finally forged a proper sacred sword, and went to the volcano along with two kids who are Cecily and Luke's descendants, to finally replace Aria with the sword she created. Aria was finally free. The end. Kind of a bittersweet ending, I think, since Cecily and Aria couldn't be together during Cecily's lifetime. And when Aria was finally free, Cecily was long dead. But it sounds like a good ending nonetheless. __________________ Last edited by Kazu-kun; 2013-06-16 at 16:49.

2013-06-16, 16:40	Link #146
Bern-san Senior Member Join Date: Sep 2009	To me... Spoiler for about spoilers of vol. 15: It would be sad to know that Lisa has watched Cecily and Luke's deaths as well as their descendants... I'm sure they managed to keep her company but I think it's really good for her that at least she has Aria now. Really a sort of happy ending with bittersweet feelings. __________________

2014-03-10, 22:14	Link #149
amtro Distro Join Date: Jun 2009	Let me see if I got this right. Spoiler for vol 16: The baby seen in vol 16 is Luke and Cecily's child. Vol 16 as a whole is an epilogue and short story volume. Vol 15 is the actual ending? Also whatever happened to the sacrifice required to use the purifying flame, why did Luke's eye suddenly turn red?

2017-03-16, 22:19	Link #150
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	Cecil rape Also Cecil is the protagonist (MC coz Japan generally has only 1 MC), as it's using her POV So in this case, Luke is a main guy lol __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2017-03-17, 13:58	Link #155
wuhugm Confused Shark Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Atlantis	^But in ch23 of manga, Cecil said her body has been defiled by Siegfried Before she danced with Luke __________________ ------------------------------------------ [SPOILER] Manga, Anime, & LN Where The Girl MC Ended Up With Is Not The Main Heroine All My Threads

2013-06-16, 10:33	Link #145
Stufu Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2012 Location: Condo...	good end! now I wanna read it in full

2014-02-10, 06:08	Link #147
demonking79 Junior Member Join Date: Sep 2013 Location: USA	i agree seigs an ass. however based on a discussion in chapter 30 something wear it talks about how the first housman performed terrible experiments with demons and even force mating with humans and that the children that came out of the matting had no reproductive organs i believe that seig is one of these children in wicth case i caan kinda see why he such an ass. i mean if you can onisly tell me that if you were the cild from some force mating between a human and a demon and were pronely kept in a cage for most of your life and tormented by the first housemen you would't be like and want revenge on the city that did that to you than congas you are most limey a saint or an egotistic bastered. another reason i believe seigs is a child from these experiments is cause in anoth captor 30 somthin one of his demon cals him seig housemen so you big hint there not to mechen that he isn't capable of sex as previously stated.

2014-02-10, 06:24	Link #148
demonking79 Junior Member Join Date: Sep 2013 Location: USA	hey any one know were i can read an english LN I've been looking but i can't find one.

2017-03-17, 13:36	Link #151
dark44 Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2010	didnt they remove the rape ? or there is two ending light novel and manga have different end?

2017-03-17, 13:38	Link #152
Sacredus Senior Member Join Date: May 2009 Location: Valhalla	There never was any rape to begin with. That rumor about "rape scene and magical 1st edition of LN that had it" was born in western community for some reason ffs.

2017-03-17, 13:43	Link #154
Sacredus Senior Member Join Date: May 2009 Location: Valhalla	No... 16.5 actually exist... Edit: But really, do people really believe that publisher of teen novel would ever allow to release something like this? /facepalm Edit2: It really pisses me off. That dumb rumor is like boomerang. You say it's completely fake, but it will return after some time.

2017-03-17, 14:41	Link #156
Y Ddraig Goch Chasing Echoes Join Date: Jul 2014	She only got groped and Siegfried implied he was impotent. I actually want to see the proof there was a real "rape" chapter to begin with. People argued the controversy for months, but no source was ever linked to even support this claim.

2017-03-17, 15:46	Link #157
AB079 Banned Join Date: Apr 2016	Back in the day a lot of people was saying that never happend and others that it was 100% true, it is 50/50 so nobody can be sure. The "rape" issue started for something, why someone would lie about it when you have stories like Gosick with similar situations and nobody say anything? Nobody knows the truth, in the end this isn't like Kannagi where the rage of the japanese fans was 100% real. PS: don't misunderstand the example of Gosick, I'm talking about what father did to her.

2017-03-17, 17:55	Link #159
El Rue Otherworld Wanderer Join Date: Aug 2014 Location: Internet Limbo	Hahaha, there should always be a disclaimer for all of erotora's posts, something like its often 60-70% lies & his half truths most of the time are not even 50% true. __________________ *I hate <Past Me>* and <Future Me>. <Past Me> is an idiot. <Future Me> is a know-it-all. <Present Me> though is quite alright.**

2017-06-20, 15:27	Link #160
felc57 Junior Member Join Date: Sep 2015	Is there any difference in the light novel vs the manga? Or is the manga a pretty good adaptation of the light novels? I just finished up with the anime (was okay), and about to jump into the manga. As the final volume will be released in English next month, I wanted to know if the manga is complete and good by itself. It sucks that the light novel never got translated to English, and probably never will, but I don't mind if the manga is good enough for the story.