Rate That Signature!

[ganbaru]

Dist 8,9/10 better now
Namiey 8,5/10 not liking the inside rectangle
Delorean2200 8,7/10 good picture

@ Everyone this version of my sig is ''monochrome'' because I experimented with gradiant map.

[Hooves]

Delorean2200: 9.3/10 (Interesting picture)

[The Chaos]

Hooves..not sure if I rated yours before ..look very good..9/10

[Dist]

Hooves : Lovely Shana signature once again. 9/10
The Chaos : You still have no signature ... ??/10

[ganbaru]

Hooves 8,8/10 Like The Chaos, I don't remember if I rated this one before

[Wolley]

Ganbaru: 5/10 it's not the worst signature ever, but not the best either. It seems like very little was done to the background. The use of monochrome doesn't seem to work with the smokey attempt at blending. Also, the text is very boring and placement isn't that great either. Certainly not the worst signature around, but not all too interesting either.

[Haladflire65]

Wolly: I'm not sure how well the use of two renders works for this, and it could be better blended. 8.5/10

[Butter Fly]

Wolly : 8.6 Nice sig, try using a border

[JRendell]

Wolly: Nice background effects. I think the two looks very well blended however. I prefer borders on my sigs, but I know some people don't. A bit small for my tastes. 8/10
Halad: It's a strange size. I like the effect you've gone for too. 8/10

[Wolley]

I prefer borders as well. I just made this signature for a website with a dark blue bg, so it's a white border

anywho JRendell: I really like the contrast as well as the glow, however the typography could use work, 9/10

[ganbaru]

Wolley 8,7/10 just a reminder than on this site, signature are supposed to be under 50000 bytes

[Wolley]

ganbaru: I'm sure you understand that I'm new to this site, and that I'm trying to adjust, being that I'm accustomed to forums where it's common knowledge that .png is the best format for a signature, and that's accepted.
Regardless your signature is improved from the other one, shows a little more effect. However, I'm not a fan of the vignette sort of deal around the edges, and it looks as though your stock has been made transparent. Also, your typography is incredibly boring and ill-placed. 6/10

[Dist]

JRendell : Who's that cutie ? Even with lack of colors it's quite good, only the text could use some improvement. 8/10

[Haladflire65]

ganbaru: I'm not that fond of the dullness of the render. 8.6/10
Wolly: Pretty good, a bit small though. 8.7/10

[Hooves]

Halad: 9.4/10 (Like the effects with the blue on his hand)

[Namiey]

ganbaru: 8/10 , nice lighting...the colour blend well too...
JR: 9/10, great colours

[ganbaru]

Namiey 8,8/10 good picture

[Haladflire65]

Namiey: Seconding ganbaru, 8.7/10

[ganbaru]

Haladfflire65 9/10 grest effects

[Kagayaki]

Ganbaru: 8.7/10 I love the way it looks like she's being enclosed/sheltered by the outer, lighter part near the border. Personal preference, but you might try increasing the saturation or contrast or something. (I agree with Halad)