Rate That Avatar!

[delorean2200]

RRW: 9.5/10 cute and nice loop.
Krytonis: 9/10 nice quality, for a moment there though i thought there was some dirt on my monitor (i mean the crumbs at her mouth lol).
Konaga: 8.5/10 as ganbaru said nice artwork.
Rikimtasu: 8.4/10 agreeing with Krytonis and ganbaru.

[risingstar3110]

@ganbaru: the avatar shape is master class so 9/10 for me
@delorean2200: looks simple and fit the purpose, but i deducted 1 point as you changed his scarf colour!! 8/10


Fishing opinions for this new avatar actually. The animation sequence was so long so the quality seriously nose dived, but i want to keep the whole thing. If it does not work, will pick a shorter loop next time

[Cruachan]

Originally Posted by risingstar3110

@ganbaru: the avatar shape is master class so 9/10 for me
@delorean2200: looks simple and fit the purpose, but i deducted 1 point as you changed his scarf colour!! 8/10


Fishing opinions for this new avatar actually. The animation sequence was so long so the quality seriously nose dived, but i want to keep the whole thing. If it does not work, will pick a shorter loop next time

I like the color scheme a lot. It looks a little off to me when it switches angles. Not mechanically just personally. What's it from?

I wouldn't know what to rate it but it's the only avatar I've seen that caught my eye.

[delorean2200]

^Its probably from a MMD clip that has Kantai collection characters by the looks of it but i'm not 100% sure.

@risingstar3110: 8.8/10 personally i'd love it more if it was just a vertical dance/sway but giving the animation i'm seeing it would probably be a bit hard to pull in to a proper loop that way so i get why the change, it certainly interesting and nice though, thankfully due to the motion the lower quality settings don't affect it that much.
As for my avatar its a good thing you didn't noticed i swapped some of his other colors otherwise you would have deducted to many points , on a more serious side the reason i did it was because: i like blue, i wanted it better synced with my sig, and wanted to merge Tenzou's look with my look a tad when i did the vector/trace.

@Cruachan: 8/10 rotfl at that kramer avatar, made me laugh pretty good when i first saw it, though it could use a subtle 1 px black border imho.

[ganbaru]

risingstar3110 8,6/10 good animation
Cruachan 8,5/10 interesting, could use a border
delorean2200 8,2/10 not bad

[ArabianLuffy]

ganbaru: 9\10
deloran2200: 8\10
Cruachan: 5\10

[inisipis]

@Rikimtasu - Crisp and clean. Nice work in the transparencies. 8.5/10

@Krytonis - Nice framing and the cool tone makes it stands out. 8/10

@delorean2200 - Like the design of the character but the thick uniform line-work makes it flat. 6.5/10

@risingstar3110 - I like the loop of the animation but the sudden shift of angle makes it jarring. 7/10

@Cruachan - What The F....., still I kinda like it. 7/10

@ArabianLuffy - Nice loop and the framing of the character is quite right. 9/10

[delorean2200]

ArabianLuffy: 9/10 nice loop.
Inisipis: 9.5/10 good quality for such a long loop.

[ganbaru]

Inisipis 8.7/10 I have to agree with delorean2200 on this one.
delorean2200 8,4/10 not bad
ArabianLuffy 8,5!0 good loop.

[Kotohono]

ganbaru: 9/10 well shaped for the hairstyle
delorean2200: 8/10 seems on small size

[ArabianLuffy]

Konakaga: 10\10
ganbaru: 9\10
delorean2200: 7\10
inisipis: 10\10

[Triple_R]

risingstar3110 8.7/10 Good, slightly mesmerizing loop. Visual equivalent of "catchy tune".
Cruachan 8.5/10 Amusing avatar, and I honestly kind of like how it's not an anime character. Good for greater board variety.
delorean2200 8.4/10 I agree with Kona. A bit on the small size. Otherwise nice.
ganbaru 8.8/10 I love the oval shape. I like the soft green/grayish color palette.
inisipis 8.8/10 Excellent loop, especially for length and quality.
Konakaga - 9/10 Lovely Chibi-Kotori image. Good, simple border.
ArabianLuffy - 8.7/10 Clever gif. Good image quality.

[jaykowalski]

@up 8/10. It's cool.

[ganbaru]

Konakaga 8.5/10 that's transparency for the background, right?
ArabianLuffy 8,7/10 good animation.
Triple R 8,3/10 I would had used another color for the border.

[Kirito]

Certainly has been a long while since I've been on here. None the less, time to get this started...

Ahem:

ganbaru 10/10 - Been quite awhile since I've critiqued a avi or a sig that you use ganbaru, but sure is great to do so. For someone who's currently reading Bungaku Shoujo I really fell in love with Miho Takeoka's artwork/illustrations. I don't know how to put it, but her illustrations are really pretty and they really grip you. I could stare and admire them for hours. Weird I know but that's how I truly feel about them. Please don't judge!

But I digress! On a critiquing note I really like the coloring and the mirror like border. It's like looking at a beautiful portrait at a art museum that can peer into your soul and invoke emotions from you. As usual you never fail to make me feel emotions both cryptic and fascinating. "Claps" Truly well done, as always!
YISUG 6/10 - A weird one but it has its charm. Can't really comment sorry.
ArabianLuffy 8.5/10 - A tilting head Luffy is always fun to see. Nicely done. I really like it and the size and border look really good.
SOGESNAKE 8/10 - Interesting and unique. The loop is smooth and easy to follow so great job on that one!
iSuckAtWriting 9/10 - I think I reviewed this one already, but just in case. I'm really a fan of Bungaku Shoujo series and Miho Takeoka's illustrations. I'm on the 2nd volume and it's really engaging. Great series to use as your avi...nice! Plus the border looks really colorful and pretty, too.
Frailty 8/10 - The color and the zapping(?) look really cool. The border looks a little distorted though. Either it's intentional or not...still looks weird.
mangatron 10/10: You truly know how to capture the greatness and sexiness when it comes to anime girls avatars. Are you and Eroking eternal rivals in the art of ecchi or something? Anyways... um, yeah, Ellen sure has sexy legs that for sure and the looping oh my god. All I can say is "boner approved!"
Krytonis 9/10 - A little plain but the girl in the picture looks really cute and the border looks really nice. I like it, nice work.
Konokaga 9.5/10 - As a big Love Live fan you get a big score and plus Kotori is really funny and cute. Her interactions with Umi-sama are the best... and really full of heart. Still my Umi-sama is the best...enough said!
Rikimtasu 8.5/10 - As someone who love to play UNIEl I personally think that Vatista has the best theme in the game. It's really pretty and serene, plus the design of the avatar really screams cuteness for a stoic Automatic Nerve like her. Awesome work "thumbs up".
risingstar3110 9/10 - The avatar looks really cool and sexy to boot. The loop and transition is a bit weird, but the uniqueness and the border makes up for it. All and all I really like looking at it. Still looks sexy so high score on that one.
Cruachan 7/10 - This is well... Um. I'm sorry I just...I-I can't sorry.
inisipis 8.5/10 - Big Suzu fan here. And the loop and avatar really brings a smile to my face. Plus the border is simplistic which also accompanies the image well.
Triple_R 9.7/10 - As usual you sure love your idols Triple R. But one thing's for sure...Honoka really knows how to take the stage as a center really well. The pic used truly is pretty, the coloring is satisfying on the eyes and great to look at, and the border color also captures her bright and sunny personality. Nicely done dude "applause" even Honoka would truly be proud! But Umi-sama is better, but that's just me.

[Akito Kinomoto]

Kirito--Nice loop quality and focus. 8/10
ganbaru--Looks a little smaller than usual, like how detailed it still is though. 8.3/10
Triple_R--Can't tell if expression is inviting for smirking. 8.2/10
ArabianLuffy--Good focus and perfect loop. 8.6/10
Konakaga--I actually think it could do without the border, unless that background isn't clear and it just so happens to be the same color as the forums (but I'm using blue, so...) 8/10
insipis--What delorean2200 said. What hacks did you use to make that? /10, or 9/10
Cruachan--wat. 8.5/10
risingstar3110--A little stiff. 7.9/10
Krytonis--Nice focus. 8/10
Rikimatsu--Kind of a lot of pixelated. 7.9/10

[ganbaru]

Kirito 8,5/10 good loop
Akito Kiomoto 8,4/10 somehow, it feel like the focus should had bee moved a little

[Triple_R]

Kirito - 9/10 Excellent gif avatar. Lovely colors, great timing, stylish look.
Akuma Kinimoto - 8.8/10 Good purple border. Good job matching avatar with sig. Pretty topical avatar choice, reflecting your own view on a prominent recent anime movie.
ganbaru - 8.8/10 The circular avatar, as opposed to oval avatar, is a nice change of pace. Pretty as always. If I had to make a suggestion, maybe darken it a bit? Seems almost too bright.

[SOGESNAKE]

Akuma Kinomoto: 7/10 - A nice simple image, the focus is fine.
ganbaru: 8/10 - I'm... actually not sure how I feel about round avatars actually. Probably just a personal thing... but it looks great all together~
Triple_R: Border goes with the avatar nicely.

[Triple_R]

SOGESNAKE - 8.6/10 That's a very well-done gif. Good focus, and I like the colors.