Syosetsuka ni Narou Discussion Thread

[Avrorrange]

Originally Posted by dragon1412

I'd say that how do you even gauge tax for adventurers in the first place, confirm their earning is pretty hard

The Adventurer’s guild will probably keep part of the adventurer’s pay as tax.

[wuhugm]

Originally Posted by dragon1412

I'd say that how do you even gauge tax for adventurers in the first place, confirm their earning is pretty hard

Super Easy, Barely an Inconvenience
Quest Assignments, Selling Monster Parts, Dungeon License all done through the guild

People earn money so fast as adventurer, like 1 day worth can easily cover 1 month expenses
In CN it's even crazier, like that jade slip / interspatial ring worth of billions of gold is frequently traded

[dragon1412]

Isn't that limited to what in the guild, quest is obvious, but most of the other stuff, such as monster part, treasure, earning, etc... are pretty much depend on the adventurers voluntary goes to the guild for the transactions. For example monster part, it is far easier to sells to any others vendor instead of going through the guild.

And this is not counting the type that hop between city to city. keeping track of them is even harder then.

[wuhugm]

^Yea, well...
Kinda obnoxious but you can place inspection team in every dungeon and settlement entrances
And force adventurers to deal only with them
Need to coordinate with government to
Byebye Freedom

[Tenzen12]

Originally Posted by dragon1412

Isn't that limited to what in the guild, quest is obvious, but most of the other stuff, such as monster part, treasure, earning, etc... are pretty much depend on the adventurers voluntary goes to the guild for the transactions. For example monster part, it is far easier to sells to any others vendor instead of going through the guild.

And this is not counting the type that hop between city to city. keeping track of them is even harder then.

Guild have usually pretty good communication channels. Eitherway even with taxes included doing stuff through guild would most likely still got you better price then trying sell stuff on your own, especially as you have no guarantee some "other vendor" is willing or capable buy your goods.

[wuhugm]

^Indeed

Btw, it's often now that MC is going to Isekai with his MMORPG character
Usually at MAX level
But don't these authors realize how broken MAX lvl character in MMORPG is?
Especially compared to lvl 1 or civilians
They are 10.000x stronger
And don't get me started with those event paid items
These people getting into isekai will just cause power inflation

[XFire]

The whole MMORPG system is overdone anyway. I get that it makes it easy to create a frame for the power system, but it's so common everything just feels copy paste.

It's gotten to the point that any isekai that doesnt use it get automatically elevated for me lol

[Tenzen12]

Originally Posted by wuhugm

^Indeed

Btw, it's often now that MC is going to Isekai with his MMORPG character
Usually at MAX level
But don't these authors realize how broken MAX lvl character in MMORPG is?
Especially compared to lvl 1 or civilians
They are 10.000x stronger
And don't get me started with those event paid items
These people getting into isekai will just cause power inflation

Is that any differrent to any other cheats abilities? They are often walking nukes eitherway.

[Rasty]

^ I don't like that because the lvl MAX means there is almost no space for growth and I like when the character grows in strength. Ideally also in reasonable (slow) pace from weak, but that is asking a bit too much.

[wuhugm]

^Indeed

^^The difference would be :
- The ability is cheat
* The existence is cheat
A MAX level support character still has monstrous stats, so even 1 of his punch would probably enough to kill anyone,
not to mention humongous HP and MP, so cheat existence
Cheat ability like Copy Magic can still be limited like by having him not have enough mana to cast

And usually more players appear (also MAX level) in that world either as friend or foe
And to present threat to these characters, enemies of equal level must appear
Then it becomes Dragon Ball

[Tenzen12]

I don't know man. Sounds like Potayo, potato to me. Especially as if there are limitation worth to be talked about then it's not cheat, just unusual ability. If anything max levels might be bit tamer as there is at least potential for similarly strong characters appear.

[Ruki0089]

Speaking of MMORPG character went to Isekai.
Is there story with MC literally become their MMORPG characters?
Not OP, as they start from very beginning.

[wuhugm]

^ゲームキャラってアリですか？

^^Just kinda dislike crazy upper limit thing
Especially those which ending has the MC becomes literal God

[Avrorrange]

Originally Posted by wuhugm

^Indeed

Btw, it's often now that MC is going to Isekai with his MMORPG character
Usually at MAX level
But don't these authors realize how broken MAX lvl character in MMORPG is?
Especially compared to lvl 1 or civilians
They are 10.000x stronger
And don't get me started with those event paid items
These people getting into isekai will just cause power inflation

Max level generally means nothing.A max lvl boss can always solo an entire party of max lvl players if they either play poorly or simply just unlucky.

[wuhugm]

^........ Not talking about the game

[Tenzen12]

Yes you are talking about world that follows practically same rules as game.

[wuhugm]

^No
Normal isekai but the MC and some others from MMORPG

[wuhugm]

『彼女』：主人公の子爵家令嬢・次女。13歳。黒目黒髪の美少女。

『姉』：子爵家令嬢・長女。16歳。侯爵・辺境伯の次男三男との婚約模索中。

『令息』：ニース辺境伯の三男。優しげな雰囲気イケメン・怜悧な頭脳の文官。

『薄赤野伏』：冷静かつ計算高いが意外と優しい。薬師の心得もある。

『薄赤戦士』：30代半ばのベテラン戦士。足に障害がややある。

『薄黄剣士』：軽戦士で20代前半。ちょっとヘタレ。

『伯姪』：辺境伯の母方の従弟の娘。

『騎士団長次男』：辺境伯の次男で独身、辺境伯騎士団を率いる。薄青レベル。

『前伯』：ジジマッチョ。濃青等級並現役最強の辺境伯騎士

OMIGOD, I really hate stories where the characters don't have name, and only referred by their role

It's confusing and unnatural
Using citizen number is still better

I blame Maoyuu and Goblin Slayer

GET REKT

[Rasty]

^ And Re:Monster, don't forget that one (though some characters got names in the short SS that was the only one written in pretty nice literary format).

Also in Maoyuu the Maou at least had a name. Though I agree with this nameless format being hard to read.

[Amelgar]

Also severely limits the number of characters. What if two characters have the same role?