AnimeSuki Forums

Register Forum Rules FAQ Members List Social Groups Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Go Back   AnimeSuki Forum > Anime Related Topics > Reviews & Recommendations > Long-Form Reviews


Thread Tools
Old 2015-09-27, 21:24   Link #1
Impossibly Childlike
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: Location: Location
Send a message via AIM to iSuckAtWriting
I am here! (Koko ni Iru yo!)

The highlights
The characters: mostly work
Sumino: is too damn adorable
the artwork: a shoujo, right?

ďI am here!Ē is a manga I have conflicting feelings for. On one hand, a story about a girl, Sumino, whoís practically unnoticeable in real life and can only find solace with people on the Internet is a relatable story. On the other hand, said girl breaks out of her shell with everything falling into place almost perfectly. With that said, this is still a good manga, but itís held down by some hard to ignore flaws.

Near the top of the mangaís problemsóbut also one of its best strengthsóis Sumino. She wants to have friends in real life, but people hardly notice her. But, Suminoís personality shows through her thoughts and online blog, and itís clear nothing about her personality keeps people away from her; thereís no sarcasm in her words, no heaviness to her demeanor, and no doubt to her courage. Sheís a sweet girl who just canít get noticed despite her efforts, and this makes her a character worth cheering for.

But at the same time, while nothing about Sumino leaves a bad image, nothing about her rounds out her personality. Putting aside how unnoticeable she is, sheís practically flawless, having stayed the same from whatís shown in her early childhood to the storyís present time, as if her non-existent presence did almost no damage to her personality. But, this isnít to say Sumino is a bad character, itís just that what stands out about her amounts to being very likable and not much else.

Still, Suminoís likability is enough to make the story worth the personal involvement. Early on, itís hard not to feel sorry for her as she tries and fails to break out of her shell. But as more people notice her, the story becomes less about Suminoís want to change her life, and more about the love triangle with the two other leads in the playfully jaded Teru and the gently serious Hinata. But this isnít a bad thing at all, as the story believably ties in Suminoís development, her online blog, and Teru and Hinataís involvement to unify the whole story instead of the romance being an afterthought to a good premise.

Even then, some things about the story donít mesh as well as they should. Thereís a coincidence in the love triangle set-up thatís almost too good to be true, but even ignoring that, there are two moments in the story that are major turning points for Sumino that are unfortunately mishandled. The first scene solves a problem so quickly itís a wonder how it ever was a problem to begin with, and the second scene easily pushes Sumino from being a very likable and flawless character to an outright magnanimous saint. Thankfully, the rest of the story doesnít get close to being as eye-rolling as these three moments, and in the meantime carries itself well through pleasant artwork.

The artwork is easy on the eyes, good, but nothing outstanding. Well, except for Suminoís face. Look at it. Itís cute. Very cute. The kind of cuteness less seen in a shoujo manga and something more akin to a male-targeted series. A small part of the sides of her hair also stick out, like animal ears, and they extend and retract with her excitement and sadness. The art adds to her likability, which I know is a word Iíve been using a lot in this review, but I canít stress that enough.

And maybe thatís the big reason this manga is still good despite its problems. Despite Suminoís simplicity, she has a lot of likeability. Despite the story being heavy-handed at times, itís actually very focused and knows what it wants to say. Maybe Iím giving too much credit to Suminoís likeability, or maybe she has the kind of charm that can make someone enjoy a good if flawed story. Worth a read? Well, reading ďI am here!Ē is like growing a sunflower against a strong wind. The stem will sometimes bend, but those who can work through that might grow something beautiful.
Hellooo~Nobody thinks they're cuter than others
unless they're conceited
iSuckAtWriting is offline   Reply With Quote

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2023, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
We use Silk.