2007-09-06, 12:26 | Link #61 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||||
2007-09-06, 19:09 | Link #62 | |
Ancient Member
Join Date: Apr 2002
|
Quote:
Anyway, technology is overrated when discussing animation quality. Cartoons from the 1950's, before cost-cutting techniques were introduced, were better animated than any anime today. Animation techniques, however, improve over time, and that's the problem with most TV shows from the First Gundam era. Even so, some of the battle scenes that were done especially for the First Gundam movies were very well animated. However, none of the Gundam vs. Red Zaku fights belong in that category.
__________________
|
|
2007-09-07, 01:10 | Link #64 |
Defeater of Robot Masters
Artist
|
You know, I think this might be a set of trends that go along with the times... It's kind of far-fetched theory... but in the original few series', the Gundams were rare, had a distinct advantage over average suits, but were by no means invincible, and were damaged often. By the early 90's, with the OVA's, the MS were more realistic, and suits in 0080 and 08th MS were almost identical, leaving the results of a battle solely up to skill and chance. G Gundam and the series afterward in the 90's and 00's made Gundams more special and superpowered, which lead into the SEED times, which bring in Gundams which are incredibly powerful and could devastate an army of mobile suits with practically a flick of the finger.
It all seems to be a matter of trends, and maybe at some point, the super-powered Gundams of today will be brought back into more realistic dimensions, and the strenth of the SEED's will be noted as a kind of trademark, like it was for Wing. Now, as far as G Gundam goes, I don't think it enters into the godly discussion, as the story and setting of G is so out of context with all the other series' that it bears no real similarity apart from mobile suits, space colonies, and the Gundams themselves. There's my opinion. Hope it's worth a damn.
__________________
|
2007-09-07, 03:39 | Link #65 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
2007-09-07, 04:23 | Link #66 |
Defeater of Robot Masters
Artist
|
Actually, in one of the earlier fights in MSG (at least in the movie trilogy), the Zaku's heat hawk sliced right through the Gundam's shield, which should logically be made of the same armor as the Gundam, if not much denser and sturdy than the armor itself. The Gundam's foot was also sliced off by a Gouf's heat rod. The Zaku rifle obviously had no effect, as clearly shown in the first fight, but melee weapons and heavier weapons like bazookas and beams can do the job. A skilled Zaku pilot can destroy the Gundam, it's just really, really, REALLY frikkin' hard to do.
__________________
|
2007-09-07, 05:09 | Link #67 | |||
Ancient Member
Join Date: Apr 2002
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||
2007-09-07, 05:38 | Link #68 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
|
Quote:
The thing about the older Gundams is that when the main protagonist does have certain superiority, it's not cheesy over the top. Usually they fight in small numbers, MS are powerful weapons and there are only some hundreds of them during the whole war, and the most uneven fight is like about 5 vs. 15 which is still believeable, and the main protagonist has to struggle very hard to win. But since W, it becomes 3 vs. 100 easily, and in SEED Destiny it's like 3 vs. 1000 with no sweat. Of course starting from W it seems the enemies get the ability to mass produce thousands upon thousands of MS to be slaughtered by the main protagonists It's necessary to give the main protagonists some advantage for them to be heroes of the show, but there's a line where it becomes totally surreal. Last edited by hipeach; 2007-09-07 at 07:54. |
|
2007-09-07, 05:46 | Link #69 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Mass producing suits is really stupid when your opponent has Weapons of Mass Destruction all over their MS. It was still acceptable in Gundam X where charging the Satellite cannon requires some time but in W the twin buster rifle is simply ludicrous. |
|||
2007-09-07, 08:06 | Link #70 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
|
Quote:
numbers by themselves don't mean much, but numbers coupled with the way how the fight goes on do mean a lot 1: one MS with superior technology fights two enemies headon and defeats them, that's believable 2: one MS fights enemies 1 vs 10, and after a hard fight uses tricks and skills to defeat them, that's also believable 3: one MS fights enemies 1 vs 50 by leading them into a trap that destroys them, again believable 4: one MS fights enemies 1 vs 50 headon and defeats them no sweat, that's... "godly" MS when the older shows tend to have situations like 1, 2, and 3, the newer shows have more and more type 4 encounters. Not to mention Akatsuki which can basically stand there and let the grunts shoot themselves up |
|
2007-09-07, 09:17 | Link #71 | |||||||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
And what is claiming that it's impossible to compare the animation from different eras supposed to prove? That it's impossible for older works to look as good as newer ones? Or that it's unfair to compare works which are given different budgets? You and I may not care all that much about animation quality, but it's foolish to claim that other people can't think otherwise. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
The main difference between this and Gundam shows is that the historical accounts are far more entertaining than the animated shows. Then again, I'm not very fond of Gundam combat choreography in general. Off-topic: Quote:
__________________
|
|||||||||||||||
2007-09-07, 10:09 | Link #72 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
|
well it was actually more like a 4 vs 12 fight, and he did use tricks and maneuvers to run and hide from enemy sight and go around to the behind. And it was regarded as a miraculous victory. While in GSD, even Shin in the lame Impulse consistently slaughter dozens of enemy MS on his own without doing much manuever except shooting and charging forward, which was regarded normal
Quote:
Another thing is, while it is possible for someone to have some "godly" superweapons like nukes and such, it's more fun to watch the main protagonists fight against those superweapons than watch the main protagonists using them to slaughter enemies. Guess that's why we have lots of movies showing heroes racing against time to disarm nukes, instead of heroes throwing nukes around to wipe out their enemies Guess that's also why many people want to see more Gundam shows where the main protagonsts don't have "godly" Gundams And the newer shows indeed have more of those type-4 "godly" Gundam while the older shows are mostly of type 1, 2, and 3 (for the main protagonist side that is, and usually they need to fight some enemy "godly" superweapon) |
|
2007-09-07, 11:20 | Link #73 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
As an aside, there seem to be two very distinct ideas in this topic: the question of whether the combats in Gundam shows are realistic, and the question of whether they're entertaining. I think that it's safe to say that the answer to the former is "no", while the latter is a matter of personal preference. Quote:
Off-topic: Quote:
In fact, it was likely this very tactic that got Wittman killed as he was in the process of attacking a British column when his tank was knocked out (likely by said Firefly). The Sherman Firefly's 17-pdr was one of the very few Western guns that could penetrate a Tiger (and only if it was firing APDS ammunition).
__________________
|
|||
2007-09-07, 11:25 | Link #74 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||
2007-09-07, 11:58 | Link #75 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||
2007-09-07, 13:41 | Link #76 | |||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Besides, how does it make any difference what technique is used in the coloring process? Do you really think that digital color is superior to hand painting to such a degree that there's no way to compare the two? Quote:
By the way, what's your point referring to? If it's about the question of realism, then a "godly" Gundam is much more realistic than a "godly" pilot. Heck, since you been complaining about the Cosmic Era shows, Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||||||
2007-09-07, 19:22 | Link #77 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
|
Anybody think that its a little weird that ZAFT was able to equal the Earth Alliance?
I know that ZAFT has as many resources as the Earth Alliance does,but this is another reason of why I like UC over CE. ZAFT should not have been able to go on as long as it did for the simple fact that they didn't have the man power(Compared to their being over a billion people on Earth).In Mobile Suit Gundam and CCA,Zeon/Neo-Zeon does well,but eventually they end up losing simply because they didn't have enough manpower. It's crazy that there can be two wars in two years,and ZAFT still functions basically the same. |
2007-09-07, 20:12 | Link #78 | |
Ancient Member
Join Date: Apr 2002
|
Quote:
But that's just the thing. In CE, manpower don't mean jack. One person can defeat thousands of people, and technology rules all. ZAFT can match EA because of technology, and Orb can match them both with its own technology. This isn't necessarily unrealistic though, as better technology has pretty much always equaled victory prior to the 20th century, though nowadays it doesn't mean jacked. But anyway, neither Neo Zeons lost due to lack of manpower... They were both defeated by squads much smaller than themselves actually. And the One Year War has heavy WWII influences, so its not like the whole idea of Zeon losing due to lack of manpower was particularly original.
__________________
|
|
2007-09-07, 21:51 | Link #79 |
Junior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
|
Actually I was not thinking about ORB,though now that you mention it they are a powerful nation(And I guess its only natural that everybody wants a piece because they maintain their neutrality).
Yes I got the OYW WWII references with the Nazi's and whatnot(That might have been one of the more obvious references that I can think of). Amuro stopped Char's plan in CCA,but with or without him Zeon IMO would have eventually fallen.It's just not reasonable that a Nation with limited Manpower could control Earth for long(Though with Char's plan...). But its an awesome point that Technology>Grutns in CE(Kira beam spammage) I personally still don't see how a Nation with what was it,10-100 million residents could successfully fight two major Wars within two years,and basically show mo signs of suffering at all.It's not like they even gave the Earth Alliance a chance |
|
|