Rate That Signature!

[HasuMasu]

Tacoshuriken: SAAABBBBEEERRRRRR!!!!!!! - 8/10
ganbaru: Nice purple. - 9/10

[Krytonis]

Akito Kinomoto 8/10 Lovely colours <3

[ganbaru]

Koominator 8,6/10 good pop-out signature, why not ptting a border also at the bottom ?

[HasuMasu]

Koominator: Why no border for bottom? - 9/10

[Krytonis]

ganbaru (Fixed my sig ) 10/10 I love the wings. The text colour is nice as well

[Tomotanke]

ganbaru 10/10 I love it!
Detective-san 9/10 good animation
Koominator 10/10 I love the style!

[Dist]

ganbaru : The wings and colors are nice, and text kinda works when you place it there since the wings are so colorful. However, the text color should be lighter and be blended more into the effects. Also I still don't get why add wall of text into a signature, in a language that 99% of the forum users don't even understand :x

8/10 for sig tho, if text blended in better, could raise points.

[Beryl Black]

Tomotanke 8.1 / 10. Like the background
Dist 8.8 / 10. Neat flame effect, lovely font.

[Krytonis]

Originally Posted by Dist

ganbaru : The wings and colors are nice, and text kinda works when you place it there since the wings are so colorful. However, the text color should be lighter and be blended more into the effects. Also I still don't get why add wall of text into a signature, in a language that 99% of the forum users don't even understand :x

8/10 for sig tho, if text blended in better, could raise points.

I guess that is how ganbaru likes it to make it unique?

[ganbaru]

Koominator 8,7/10 look better now

Originally Posted by Dist

ganbaru : The wings and colors are nice, and text kinda works when you place it there since the wings are so colorful. However, the text color should be lighter and be blended more into the effects. Also I still don't get why add wall of text into a signature, in a language that 99% of the forum users don't even understand :x

THe text isn't in a lighter color or more blended because it would make it harder to read in any language. And about language, the reason I keep using text on a language that 99% of the forum users don't even understand is because the said text was writed first in the said language. Of course the fact than 99% of the forum users don't even understand it is the reason than I also make a second version of the signature, with a translated quote, than I use shortly after the other version.

@Koominator it isn't about making my signature unique, you don't make a serie of signature if you want them to be unique .

[Rennir]

Koominator-8.5/10 Change the font and position of your name...try integrating it into the main text.

[Krytonis]

Rennir 10/10 C.C. FTW

[ganbaru]

Rennir 8,9/10 I can't remember if I rated this one before.

[CMSensei]

Koominator - 8.3/10 Nice transparency on top

[ganbaru]

CMHerrera 8,6/10 simple but nice

[Rennir]

CMHerrera- I think you overdid the glow effect around the render a bit and it looks kind of LQ as a result. Try sharpening the focal a bit and lessening the opacity of that layer (I'm guessing you did gaussian blur + overlay?). Or instead of sharpen (cause PS's default sharpen function is kinda meh...) you can try: New layer>Apply Image>Filter>Other>High Pass and set it to ~10px and the mode to soft light @ 50% opacity.

[HasuMasu]

CMHerrera: Nice effect. - 8/10
ganbaru: Like the artwork. - 9/10

[Vena]

Since I've not done this before and it looks like a good-fun time waster, and who doesn't enjoy looking at art?

Detective-san: I really enjoy the show of expressions (the color (and the angle to a lesser degree) changes help to keep the flow from being repetitive and give it a lot of life) and it compliments the avatar you have perfectly. The fact that its a simple colorless with a simple smile is a perfect foil to the more expressive emotions and the richer colors that come with them. (Though that's probably just me looking a little too deeply into things.)

I give the whole set a 9.5/10, can't give a ten on my first go and it could be longer.

[ganbaru]

Vena 8,8/10 good artwork but JPEG would give better quality than .gif

[Krytonis]

ganbaru 9/10 lovely artwork!
CMHerrera 8/10 simple yet so good
Vena 7/10 not bad but quality could be better