Rate That Signature!

[Patchy]

~_~ Just spending some time in my free time... decided to come back making some touhou sign...(though I knew it wouldn't last that long)

Obelisk-kun ~ brown border is kinda thick but still nice image, good
Koomi-chan ~ trying some new things eh? btw already done with what you wanted to me, but can't upload the files in here, I'll just PM it to you.. improving on your style Good
Ganbaru-sempai ~ Color Blast??? ^^ Good
Halad-sempai ~ when it comes to those sig of him, you're always doing some really nice works. V.Good
Silvance-kun ~ cool tech like sign ~ V.Good
E.Rick ~ own drawing... ~_~ envy some artists like you .... good



Mine Non-as safe sig again.... guhhh... >_< fake signature ftw lol...

__________________

My Workshop ----------------------------- Featured Character Black Rock Shooter ----------------------------- EMDAS : Searching! ----------------------------- Currently Doing: <3 bye bye minna!

[Rennir]

Patchy-8.9/10 Better than your last one IMO. Nice job with the flow, lighting is good. Focus is a little bit weird since the sword's kinda drawing my eyes, but that's normal I guess I only see two things that could use improvement; The grass in the bottom half of the sig looks topazed (not sure ). But whatever effect it is, I'd lessen the opacity just a bit. Also, I think it'd look better if not all 4 corners were burned/shaded. After all, there shouldn't be shadows when the light source is coming from the top left corner. Great job with the rest though!

PS: For effects other than drop shadow, maybe think about doing a reflection on the bottom instead? I've always thought that those sigs look pretty cool

[Yurichan]

^ sig 7/10

[Krytonis]

Yurichan: 8.3/10 could use a border

[Obelisk ze Tormentor]

Ok, so I took all the advices and change things a bit. The border is thinner now .

Oh, there're more sigs ^^.
@Patchy Kun 9.5/10 the image is super and the shadow is cool, maybe a little bit too far but it's ok.
@Yurichan 9.0/10 nice pic. Beautiful and crisp.
@Evil Rick: Yup, she is written Ishizu Ishtaru (more or less) in Japanese. But the mangaka meant her name to be a combination of two goddesses who's husband & lover met tragic fates (Isis & Ishtar). So, I use the correct spelling .

[DarkyPwnz]

@Obelisk

9.5/10 very nice,and first one ruled them all. Seriously,I just saw a picture about this new Yugioh Zexal thingie and now I need to wash my eyes with acid.

[Haladflire65]

Patchy: I agree that the drop shadow can be a bit closer to the sig. Also seconding Renn-kun about the four corners being dark - but the sig's very lovely as always 8.9/10
Yurichan: Agreeing with Koo, 8.5/10

[delorean2200]

Obelisk ze Tormentor: 8.9/10 everything fits in nicely border maybe a bit big for my tastes. Also love the character in your avatar please share the name if you know it.
Koominator: 9/10 not my tastes but well done, you really got good at this in quite a short time.
ganbaru: 8.4/10 feels to saturated to me.
Silvance: 9.7/10 cool mech sig ^^.
Haladflire65: 9/10- nice blue theme.
Patchy: 10/10 i love it.
Yurichan: 8.2/10 agreeing with Koo as well.

[Obelisk ze Tormentor]

Originally Posted by delorean2200

Obelisk ze Tormentor: 8.9/10 everything fits in nicely border maybe a bit big for my tastes. Also love the character in your avatar please share the name if you know it.

Thanx. My avatar is Malik Ishtar. The antagonist from Yu-Gi-Oh! and Isis Ishtar’s (sign) younger brother.

Edit: Nice sig, btw. It's creeeepy. Still, it can use some more pixel : 9.0/10

[ganbaru]

Patchy 9,3/10 great work as always
Yurichan 8,3/10 could use a border
Obelisk ze Tormentor 8.8/10 better this way
delorean2200 8,8/10 very interesting

[Krytonis]

Patchy: 9.6/10 amazing job!!
delorean2200: Rosario + Vampire is FTW 8.5/10

[Rennir]

Koominator-8.3/10 Big Bang Logo and the text is too distracting/disparate here. Try making the logo plus TOP and your name into one square or crest, if you may, that's 2/3 or 1/2 the size of the current logo. It'd be a nice addition to the sig and wouldn't draw attention away from the focal that way. Nice job with the rest though! Personally, I like Taeyang better

[ganbaru]

Koominator 8,7/10 to be honest, I prefered your previous one.

[delorean2200]

Koominator: 8.6/10 nice bg and also nice render choice, but the blending of the render is a bit off around the headband and the left side imho.

[Krytonis]

I don't think I had a chance to say this yet, but I will now. Thank you guys for saying I am improving! Well, to be honest, I am just amazing. Haha, joking! I am not there yet. Probably not even close! I am getting better because of you guys! Your rating and feedback really helps on what I need to improve!

Thanks again!

[Haladflire65]

Koominator: Yeah, it's good to have people giving you feedback on your work constantly I agree about the blending issue, perhaps you can try looking into techniques that helps blending, such as C4Ds or clipping masks. 8.4/10
Delorean: I quite like it, the colour scheme is nice and the size works well 8.8/10

[Dragonar Fan]

@ Halad 9/10 ....oddly reminds me of the theme in Portlandia

[ganbaru]

Dragonar Fan 8,2/10 blood or dirt?

[Dragonar Fan]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

Dragonar Fan 8,2/10 blood or dirt?

Blood , His own blood . though I believe he used mud once ...but thats not mud or dirt.

9/10....I'm sort of rough translating it.

[Krytonis]

Dragonar Fan: 7.5/10 he looks serious ._.