|
View Poll Results: Code Geass Episode 21 Rating | |||
Perfect 10 | 35 | 29.41% | |
9 out of 10 : Excellent | 40 | 33.61% | |
8 out of 10 : Very Good | 21 | 17.65% | |
7 out of 10 : Good | 10 | 8.40% | |
6 out of 10 : Average | 8 | 6.72% | |
5 out of 10 : Below Average | 2 | 1.68% | |
4 out of 10 : Poor | 2 | 1.68% | |
3 out of 10 : Bad | 1 | 0.84% | |
2 out of 10 : Very Bad | 0 | 0% | |
1 out of 10 : Painful | 0 | 0% | |
Voters: 119. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools |
2007-03-16, 00:58 | Link #121 | ||||||||
Mahjong Triple Pro
Join Date: Sep 2006
|
[death] NOTE: I just noticed this post has nothing to do with Code Geass. Sorry! I'll make amends shortly. :P
Quote:
Consider this; we're here to discuss anime, right? What's to discuss if we all love it? Discussion isn't possible if arguments are lop-sided, and for the past couple weeks when I've been in silent dissent the vast majority of arguments flowed one way. The other dissenters who have anted up arguments couldn' t sustain them, so like the meddler that I am I decided to interfere. It's not about imposing my views on other people, it's about having people develop their own thoughts, rather than simply grow around seeds of ideas implanted by other people. If I've got to do the same, so be it; we'll raise a diverse forest instead of a homogenous one. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I guess this forum needs a lot more work than I thought. *equips gloves* Think for a moment; why is crack-cocaine illegal? I mean, the people most likely to use it are "dead weight" from a cost-benefit analysis point of view anyway; a political 'realist' would claim them to be better off dead! The reason is: political constituencies don't like them. It's not a rational reason at all, but merely a personal preference, so they come up with excuses like "it's for the best of the drug abusers" to justify their action, when really it's just an instance of taste. My personal preference is that all people think critically and use rationality appropriately, with the pretense being a difference of views. As in the analogy earlier, its not rational (do I really want to make people who could potentially be my rivals in the future smarter?!) but I still want it to happen. One could call it a "devil's advocate" position, but in this case I actually agree with the position I'm assuming. I always get a smile when people see someone take an aggresive stance on something and go, "LOL E-PEEN STROKING LOL". If you're too lazy to attack my arguments directly, you might as well not reduce yourself to being so crude with your reservations! Afterall, I'm stepping up to plate so there's no reason for you lot to risk your "street credit" here; there's a world to lose, but nothing to gain. :| Quote:
Lelouch needs to pluck out that seed before it takes root. He's alreadly lost Ougi in that regard. Quote:
Spoiler:
With Schneizel at the helm, I doubt Lelouch will gain support after this. Quote:
Id est off of the top of my head: Genkai from Yu Yu Hakusho. She was basically a one-arc character who suddenly came back for more later in the story. Sort of follows Orange-kun's plot path, actually. Quote:
Bonus points for the reference. ^O^; Last edited by Malintex_Terek; 2007-03-16 at 01:40. Reason: Now it's on-topic. Sort-of. Also, less inflammatory; harm isn't meant. |
||||||||
2007-03-16, 01:24 | Link #125 | |||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: California
Age: 36
|
@Malintex: I suppose Code Geass sold out all the extreme "experienced" viewers that had high expectations of the show. I'm not much of a critic to assess every factor to which an anime can/should be judged. If the series is decent enough for me to make analysis of the ongoing events and characters, then I suppose it'll keep me occupied. I guess, sorry you couldn't "enjoy" the show more?
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
... I won't quote specifics in your last argument, but I'll say this as my own recent-developing opinion. I don't believe the whole series alltogether was intended to focus solely on Lelouch's character, but to use his perspective to develop the plot, though I have no doubt in my mind that focusing primarily on Lelouch would have been interesting (though it hasn't lost all of its interest yet, even if it is tanking). |
|||||
2007-03-16, 01:53 | Link #127 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: California
Age: 36
|
Quote:
|
|
2007-03-16, 02:15 | Link #130 |
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Blue Raider Nation
Age: 38
|
Finally saw the episode, looks like Geass is back on track with another excellent episode. We got to see everything from multiple cheese-kuns, to a zombie Karen.(side note: When Karen does discover that Lelouch is Zero, I expect there to be some very funny moments maybe with her dragging this up) We even got to see Cornelia getting embarrassed by her big brother. I also enjoyed the girl that makes sketches on the wall dressed up and still being geassed.
Yuffie, what a completely foolish thing that you have done. This will without a doubt, bring dissension within the black knights, cause chaos throughout Area 11 and the other areas, and extremely piss Lelouch off. Suzaku will no doubt be overjoyed with this idea because he's an idiotic idealist like Yuffie. I wonder if if Nunnally could feel Lelouch's anger at the end because he was still holding her hand. |
2007-03-16, 02:25 | Link #131 | ||||||||
Mahjong Triple Pro
Join Date: Sep 2006
|
Well, when I read those spoilers I got the impression Lelouch's mistake was GEASS-ing Shirley instead of outright killing her. I mean, she's bit him in the arse a lot in this series, hasn't she? If there's any Shaa that could potentially be a knife in Lelouch's heart, it's Shirley's very meaningless life.
Of course, I do not mean to rat on her without justification; I liked her a lot and thought episode fourteen was bitter-sweet and awesome (such that I listened to the raw something like eight times) but she's really been a burden since. Quote:
Quote:
I could not complain if I didn't have some sort of standard to contrast Geass with, and in this case it's GITS: SAC. A huge part of GITS could have been re-oriented toward low-brow fanservice but the show kept it tasteful, and when not tasteful intellectual. GITS isn't exactly a mecha show but there are mechs in it and Bandai was involved; as far as I'm concerned, it's a bar that has yet to be jumped by another show and it's still being maintained with each new installment. I might not have liked GIG II as much as the first season, but the quality hasn't dipped at all. It's still one of the most epic shows I have ever seen. I've never seen more than a couple minutes of E7 but I've heard it's a comparable "standard-setting" show to GITS (though the dub is poor). When I first saw Geass, I immediately recognized it had enough potential to surpass GITS; as of right now, I've lost that faith, and now I'm holding onto the hope that it'll have a believable ending and not "putter out" like so many promising shows have in the past. One of my friends drew a Saikano parallel but I've never seen the show; maybe you lot could elaborate. Quote:
Quote:
Now, CG would be nothing without Lelouch. He's so pivotal to the story it's scary what could happen if he dies or fudges up royally somewhere. Quote:
However, the episode ends at the end of the speech so we never see what happens. Nor do we see Katase escaping from the center of a mountain, when all logic would tell us that he's stuck in there due to the avalanche, which should have collapsed any escape routes. Or, how did Lelouch get the bomb to blow up Katase's ship? There's also the subject of "threats" to; when Lelouch threatens to kill himself in front of C.C., she takes him seriously when there's no benefit of him doing that. The same applies to Kirihara Taizou's hostage situation. If people stopped being so hot-headed and were more rational, they'd realize how foolish they are in falling prey to Lelouch's drama. Quote:
I'd like to see evolution beyond "revisions", though; instead of, "how can we improve this character" I'd love to see characters that are totally original, who serve as archetypes. One of the reasons I like The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya is because it's got one such character - Kyon. There isn't another person in anime/manga I can think of who is like him; there are simmilar characters like, say, the "laconic genuis" sterotype a la Shikamaru of Naruto, but there's no one exactly older and simmilar enough to Kyon to call him a "revision". In spite of a lot of stuff I dislike in Haruhi, the existence of Kyon makes the whole show worth it. Even if "archetype" characters aren't possible, slight revision of all stereotypes is also welcome. The problem is, Euphemia and Suzaku aren't revised at all; they're still hard-headed stock characters. :| C.C. is largely a mystery, but her spunk is original, I'll say that. It's too early to tell if she's really a new archetype or a revision. Quote:
Quote:
Or a perspective from a commoner's point of view, like how they view Zero and the royalty. Heck, even focusing on Mao would have been an improvement over watching Suzaku and Euphemia walk around without brains for the past eight or so episodes (not including the Mao Arc). |
||||||||
2007-03-16, 02:37 | Link #132 | |
( ಠ_ಠ)
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Somewhere, between the sacred silence and sleep
|
Quote:
I probably have at least 20 years more "experience" viewing anime than 90% of the people here, and I don't care for any of the so-called "problems" mentioned by him. Some people simply want to "justify" the reasoning why certain shows don't fit "their taste", and try to convince others of the same. Which is totally silly, IMO. It's a freakin cartoon for god's sake. Watch it for what it is, not what it isn't. It's there to entertain, and if it doesn't entertain you... then you're simply watching the wrong show. There are tons of anime I find uninteresting or crappy. But I'm not gonna go to every single one of those community, and tell people who are enjoying the show how crappy their show is, and try to convince them to feel the same. That's not "educated" like he claims, that's simply "immature". What's even more, looking at posts on both here and spoiler thread, many doesn't even seem to understand everything said in the said episode. How the heck do you criticise something before you even know what took place? If you're unsure, wait for the subs before jumping the gun.
__________________
|
|
2007-03-16, 02:47 | Link #133 |
Logician and Romantic
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Within my mind
Age: 43
|
Okay, this is a continuation from my previous post about how Euphie's actions will end in fire...
I need to make it very clear. What Euphie want to achieve, a zone within Area 11 where Numbers get more rights, is not impossible. I frequent the spoiler thread, and when I first heard of Euphie's plan there, my response wasn't "she is doomed!" but of "she is doing something about her desires at last!". You see, what I hoped was that Euphie might be intelligent enough to realise her dream needed far more than royal order to occur. Something along the lines of secret meetings with government groups, consulting lawyers, make deals with people from Kyoto and even Zero, pay money to those who would be disadvantaged by this, thrash out rudimentary treaties and new laws within the special zone, have Cornelia's silent consent (her approval is impossible to get), and otherwise make preparations for when things go horribly wrong... ...THEN Euphie could declare her plan to a live audience. But instead, Euphie performed the Code Geass equivalent of "let them eat cake!". Now, this isn't a bad thing for the show. I was merely expecting some sort of metamorphosis from Euphie, and indeed she did change. It's just that I wasn't expecting her to be that much of a Meer Campbell. My previous hypothesis concerning Euphie and Suzaku, was that Euphie would take Suzaku as her inspiration and single-handedly try to make both their dreams come true. Sadly, now I know Suzaku is completely and utterly doomed. He hedge his bets on a Britannia princess who couldn't negotiate herself out of a paper bag. This ought to teach Suzaku not to judge political savy by hair colour ; now as I said, he is stuck with Meer Campbell MK-II. And we all know what happens when the blind leads the blind... p.s. I am loving the way the show is going, so this isn't a complaint in any way. It wasn't what I expected, but why should it be?
__________________
Last edited by Vallen Chaos Valiant; 2007-03-16 at 05:56. |
2007-03-16, 03:08 | Link #134 |
キズランダム
Join Date: Apr 2003
|
Uhh.... so how exactly has Code Geass "Sold out" per se? With Ep20: Suzaku has always had his own agenda, so how he acts is not surprising at all, and Lelouch was also acting within his own agenda for WHY he was "helping" Britannia beat the Chinese forces.
Ep21 is also a very standard storytelling device -- I knew from the start of the episode that this lightheartedness would follow with shit hitting the fan at the end of the episode, and thats exactly what happened. If I had to make a major gripe about the show at this point, it would be the copout with Shirley. That along with having all these people with double lives crossing paths makes things extremely complicated and you hang your head at how they don't all get discovered. So I just hope they don't do that again. What is an "experienced" viewer anyways? The fact that the character designs are by CLAMP should tell you that they were going for a wide appeal with Code Geass. So sorry if you were expecting another GITS. That said, I think they've done a decent job with it so far. Theres some cheesecake with the CC cosplay and Pizza Hut, etc. but it's all in good fun, and I think fans have gotten a lot of laughs out of the pizza jokes. Heck -- my friends are planning to have like 5 people walk around in Pizza Hut uniforms at Acen to take pictures with other Code Geass cosplayers |
2007-03-16, 03:29 | Link #135 |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Manchester, England
|
Cheese man, Suzaku has tried to kill and capture Zero several times and has made it clear that Zero is wrong in the way he does things and Suzaku would never agree with his actions.... Lelouch forgives him and saves him every couple of episodes(maybe thats what Suzaku really doesn't like about Zero with his death/punishment wish).
Anyway Euphemia wants to help Lelouch, Zero, Nunally and everybody else. And it seems Lelouch wants to wrangle her neck. One can't blame him, but I feel sorry for her especially since Lelouch is even more upset that she has kept Suzaku from Nunnally. I actually really liked the Ogi x Viletta. Their interactions went right into heavy soap opera style. I found their last scene amusing. I think Schneizel is like Zero in that they use and discard pawns as they see fit. I don't think he's going to be evil. In this show royalty pretty much do what they do for their own image and power. Its going to be interesting to see if Zero will actually be the one to covertly instigate the Britannian act which FUBARs Euphemia's plans. Lelouch - "Not only have you ruined my original plans you naive princess, but you also dare to take the man Nunnally and I had chosen as her future companion and protector! (Glare intensifies) For that alone you die! Bitch!" ALso has their been any other person so far who has such long pink hair in this show. Hats and glasses really must have some powerful stealth properties. Sci fi artists must really like to emphasize the sci fi aspect in everything. |
2007-03-16, 06:14 | Link #137 |
^.^
Join Date: May 2006
|
well i guess Euphie is really impulsive this is so much like her love confession to Suzaku but at least she consulted with Schneizel or was that a bad thing because Schneizel is or imo is the mid boss in the series while the final boss is the king he could have easily manipulated Euphie rather than say it was bad idea he said it was good one then he can just easily sit back and watch as sh*t hits the fan
i really dread Violeta regaining her memory cause i really like the VioletaXOugi pairing oh and Shirley is so funny even if she can't remember Lulu she still gets jealous easily
__________________
|
2007-03-16, 06:27 | Link #138 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2007
|
Quote:
Plus, when did Diethard meet Nunnally?
__________________
|
|
2007-03-16, 10:04 | Link #140 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: California
Age: 36
|
Quote:
I refer to him as extreme because everyone else seems to be ok with harem-like cast and what not. Though that was not what I expected, it doesn't 'destroy' the whole series for me or even disappoint me really, is what I'm trying to say. Quote:
... Spoiler:
Last edited by Juvyniled; 2007-03-16 at 10:29. Reason: Added extra comment |
||
|
|