Rate That Signature!

[Rennir]

matty- 7.5/10 agree with halad

[ganbaru]

matty543 8,3/10 I also have to agree with Haladflire65's comment

[Hooves]

Rennir: 9.7/10 (Amazing effects and background . I just wonder who he is)

[Om Nerabdator]

7/10 a bit plain

damn guys so much hate for my sig >_> srry i cant do sigs like the one rennir has

[Arbitres]

damn guys so much hate for my sig >_> srry i cant do sigs like the one rennir has

Nii-san really is amazing with signatures, huh? Don't worry though! Just use the tutorials on here and steal get some tips from Rennir.

Matty543 - 8.1/10: It is indeed plain but it's better then what I could do. The lighting feels abit awkward and the render feels abit jagged around some parts. You could do better, but I stress it: Better then what I could do. ( Sorry fort he lame condolence bud.)

[Luna91]

Rennir - 8.5/10, hot guy , love the background
ganbaru - 10/10, can't remember if i rated this or not but that is just beautiful
matty543 - 8/10, nice but yeah a bit jagged
Hooves - 9/10, Shana! flashing names!
Arbitres - 9/10, really nice, though i think it would be better without the text.

[Afternoon Tea]

Luna91: 10/10 that is one cool looking siggy not gonna lie!

[Luna91]

Thanks
9/10, very nice, Yui! Though i have to ask, what are those 2 blobs just above the parkbence? can't figure it out

[Hiroi Sekai]

It kind of looks like a female with a dog.

Also:

Luna91 - Good composition and lighting. 9/10
CaptnAwesomee - Already rated I think, but still so awesome. 9/10
Arbitres - Well made, and your username included too, nice. 8.5/10
matty543 - I see no reason for hate: One Piece = awesome. 9/10
Hooves - Improved signature?! Shana looks even better now! 9.5/10

[Dragonar Fan]

10/10 I love & own all those games

[delorean2200]

Rennir 9/10 not on my taste so it could deserve more.
Ganbaru 9/10 nice another scenic one like you said though i'll be honest imho the previous one had more going :P.
Hooves 8.5/10 -the quality... then again it could be the gif limitation.... maybe could deserve more points though, again not quite my cup of tea the effect combination :P.
matty543 8/10 - interesting concept quality though could be better :P.
CaptnAwesomee 9/10 made me giggle.
Arbitres: 8.7/10 - overall nice but seems kind of jaggy in the left side.
Luna91 9.5/10 - nice concept and blending there.

[JRendell]

delorean: *ahem* Noel is looking good there. 9/10

[ganbaru]

Dragonar Fan 8,3/10 low quality
delorea2200 8,6/10 good looking girl

[Kelisidina]

ganbaru: 6/10 nice stock image used but the text looks out of place cause of the colour D:

[Mute]

Kelisidina: Just a picture with a box of the image with a gradient and a bunch of text. Though, it is more creative than most others here. 6/10

[JRendell]

Kelisidina: Nice lighting. Looks a little too sharp around her eyes. 8.5/10

[Kelisidina]

JRendell: 7/10 I like how you used the rule of thirds, but I think tags need more effects =3 and thanks for the warning, before I got an infraction @_@

@Mute: Actually, I had to recolour the entire original stock photo, I had to get a copy from the photographer (: Took me literally a day

[Haladflire65]

Kelisidina: 8.7/10
Delorean: 8.7/10

[Hooves]

Kelisidina: 9.6/10 (Pretty )

[Rennir]

@matty: It's not hate, we're merely just suggesting things that you can work it aka constructive criticism. After all, it is called the Rate that Signature thread.

Kelisidina- 8.7/10 Nice lighting, seems kind of blurry though.