Rate That Signature!

[Chaho-Chi]

JRendell: 9.5/10 I find v2 better
ganbaru: 8.9/10 Hmmm Didn't you have the sig before?

[ganbaru]

ayu-smepai 8.6/10 at first I did read '' Reading you '' insted of ''Reaching you ''

Originally Posted by ayu-smepai

ganbaru: 8.9/10 Hmmm Didn't you have the sig before?

Not exactly,You are remembering a sig than I used 2 month ago:

Spoiler for saving space:

Honestly, I made both about the same time and kept the one than I am using for a week than I wouldn't have anything ready, as I am working on 2 sigs (by coincidence one of them is reusing this Tooko's render ) than need work on the text.

[katiemirmo]

ayu-sempai - the blood in the border kinda bites me off..8.6/10
Jrendell - it's Minorin!, but the color is kinda..dull.. otherwise, it receives a 8.4/10
ganbaru - I like this one! although what the white on the girls left braid? 8.7/10

[grylsyjaeger]

Originally Posted by katiemirmo

ganbaru - I like this one! although what the white on the girls left braid? 8.7/10

They're Sakura. Cherry Blossoms.

But I do like this one too, ganburu but the text is a bit strange. 8.5/10

[Haladflire65]

ayu-smepai: I don't really like the top and bottom borders, but it's real nice. 8.7/10
ganbaru: I really like it. 8.7/10
katiemirmo: Nice artwork. 8.5/10
fallschirmjager: lol. 8.5/10

[CMSensei]

Haladflire65 - 8.1/10 Pretty good..

[RadiantBeam]

@CMHerrera: 9/10 - Very nice, but having it to the side like that makes my eyes hurt for some reason.

[katiemirmo]

RadiantBeam - nice effects, although the lower part has too much 8.6/10
CMHerrera - sharp..O.o 8.4/10

[ganbaru]

Haladflire65 8,4/10 interesting
CMHerrera 8,6/10 good effect

Originally Posted by fallschirmjager

But I do like this one too, ganburu but the text is a bit strange. 8.5/10

Strange ? in which way? it's not the first time I quoted poetry on my sig.

[grylsyjaeger]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

Haladflire65 8,4/10 interesting
CMHerrera 8,6/10 good effect


Strange ? in which way? it's not the first time I quoted poetry on my sig.

Well as in the sense that it doesn't actually make sense...

katiemirmo: Very blue but I like the overall dark theme to it. 9/10

[JRendell]

@CMHerrera decrease the sharpeness of the render, and it'll be great. Nice work on the text aswell. 8/10

Originally Posted by fallschirmjager

Well as in the sense that it doesn't actually make sense...

It makes sense. It's just that it's a poem from the 1800's, making the references, lexis and syntax a bit strange to modern eyes

[Miko Miko]

JRendell- 10/10 Kawaiii

[Nobodyman9]

Radiant Beam: Hmm, don't know who that character is, but nice sig, 8.0
katiemirmo: Sweet graphics and shading effects, 9.0
ganbaru: Didn't understand a damn thing about that poem, but still cute 8.0
fallschirmjager: Yes it is awesome 9.5
JRendell: Cute girl, 8.5
Miko Miko: Pretty cool, 8.0

[ganbaru]

Miko Miko 8.3/10 a bit too black
Nobodyman9 8.7/10 I like it

Originally Posted by JRendell

It makes sense. It's just that it's a poem from the 1800's, making the references, lexis and syntax a bit strange to modern eyes

...And knowing the story might also help to see how the text fit with the visual.

[Endrance]

fallschirmjager-Mudkip huh -8/10
Haladflire65-is that alucard i see?-9/10
CMHerrera-very nice-9/10
RadiantBeam-nicely blended-9/10
katiemirmo-love it simple because its BRS-9/10
ganbaru-another good one from ya-9/10
JRendell-cute-9/10
Miko Miko-I like the dark colors-9/10
Nobodyman9-not my fav character(shirley) but i like it since lulu is there-8/10

[katiemirmo]

Endrance - 9.5/10 it rocks just like all your other sigs and I envy you cause I don't know how to do animated fire >.<
Nobodyman9 - SHIRLULU!9/10!!

[Jze0]

Endrance - Cool flame effect, wish I knew how to do that 9.5/10
katiemirmo - Hmmm... looks kind of blurry don't you think? Still nice needtheless 8/10

[ganbaru]

Endrance 9/10 good animation
Jze0 8,3/10 from Tjaard, no ?

May I ask for C/C and rating for those 2 work in progress as well:

[katiemirmo]

jze0 - put the blur blame on the effects not me..XD, and about ur sig 8.6/10 cause it's LuluxCC
ganbaru - 1st POSTED: I like the softness of the colors it fits all together and it deserves a second viewing 8.9/10
2nd: it's creepy!it gives an eerie feeling O.o 8.6/10

[Kelisidina]

ganbaru: 1st: Light source is way too bright, and the positioning of the render painfully cries for depth... It also looks like a texture... Flow is very hard to notice at first glance. 5/10
2nd: Much better. Nice depth... Sharpen the focal more though. Also, since the render has a "glow", a light source for that is needed, but overall much better. 7/10