Oda Nobuna no Yabou [Light Novel]

[XxSleepyxX]

Originally Posted by Akumasama

In the anime, yes. In the novel, yes. But, no it has not translated to that part.

If you want to read summaries, just go to the social group: http://forums.animesuki.com/group.php?groupid=802
For everything else, there's a mastercard.

Spoiler:

Jk, thought to make the occasional joke every once in a while.

He needs those tips to fulfil his urges....

Nene why you not have anymore roles? :/.

[aigomorla]

Originally Posted by Akumasama

In the anime, yes. In the novel, yes. But, no it has not translated to that part.

If you want to read summaries, just go to the social group: http://forums.animesuki.com/group.php?groupid=802
For everything else, there's a mastercard. Jk, thought to make the occasional joke every once in a while.

waaaah?

what do you mean no in the novel?

im pretty sure this picture comes from vol.1

Spoiler:

now correct me if im wrong, but the only Nene hideyoshi knew is this nene?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nene_%28aristocrat%29

however, i dont think history accounted for the MC to be able to marry one of the generals or Oda herself.

Anyhow, i still predict Mistuhide goes full blown yandere and ends up killing everyone in a glorious Yuno moment.

[Undertaker]

Originally Posted by aigomorla

waaaah?

what do you mean no in the novel?

im pretty sure this picture comes from vol.1

Spoiler:

now correct me if im wrong, but the only Nene hideyoshi knew is this nene?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nene_%28aristocrat%29

however, i dont think history accounted for the MC to be able to marry one of the generals or Oda herself.

Anyhow, i still predict Mistuhide goes full blown yandere and ends up killing everyone in a glorious Yuno moment.

I think you misunderstood Akumasama's reply.

Originally Posted by Akumasama

In the anime, yes.

In the novel, yes.

But, no it has not translated to that part.

That probably just means that he hasn't translated the LN to English to that part yet, in which Nene's appearance was toward the end on V1,if I remember correctly.

[Mechatrill]

Originally Posted by ReaperxKingx

I believe so, Oda Nobuna no Yabou follows the timeline of events. Judging from the events, I expect Asakura to appear around vol 6 to 7.

Um... The Asakura showed up by the end of vol 3, had a good showing in vol 4, and was prominently featured in vol 5 ch 5 (which, admittedly, I haven't summarized yet).

Spoiler:

Nobuna went to attack the Asakura at the end of vol 3, and Nagamasa's father decided to help Asakura despite the alliance the Azai had with Oda against Nagamasa's wishes. Vol 4 was Sagara securing the retreat against the Asakura forces (we also see Asakura Yoshikage there, he's... rather obsessed with Nobuna, and not in a good way either. You'll see more on that when I summarize the rest of vol 5). Vol 5, ch 5 is mostly Nobuna and Sagara fighting the Battle of Anegawa, which is against the Azai-Asakura, where the Asakura do feature quite a bit...

I have read a good chunk of vol 6 and very little of vol 7 (again, Chinese translations), and Asakura are pretty much done as an active threat by then, and Nobuna and Yoshiharu were busy taking care of other stuff.

[ReaperxKingx]

Originally Posted by Mechatrill

Um... The Asakura showed up by the end of vol 3, had a good showing in vol 4, and was prominently featured in vol 5 ch 5 (which, admittedly, I haven't summarized yet).

Spoiler:

Nobuna went to attack the Asakura at the end of vol 3, and Nagamasa's father decided to help Asakura despite the alliance the Azai had with Oda against Nagamasa's wishes. Vol 4 was Sagara securing the retreat against the Asakura forces (we also see Asakura Yoshikage there, he's... rather obsessed with Nobuna, and not in a good way either. You'll see more on that when I summarize the rest of vol 5). Vol 5, ch 5 is mostly Nobuna and Sagara fighting the Battle of Anegawa, which is against the Azai-Asakura, where the Asakura do feature quite a bit...

I have read a good chunk of vol 6 and very little of vol 7 (again, Chinese translations), and Asakura are pretty much done as an active threat by then, and Nobuna and Yoshiharu were busy taking care of other stuff.

Thank you for the correction. I must have skipped it.

[Athena]

BTW, just me or the pacing for the adaptation of this series is quick, considering the studio in charge?

[ReaperxKingx]

Originally Posted by Athena

BTW, just me or the pacing for the adaptation of this series is quick, considering the studio in charge?

It really does seem that way, but at least it is not horrible pacing like Campione! Almost every anime adaptation is like that, especially ones where the main characters is having too many thoughts in his head in the course of the Light Novel like Sagara. Oda Nobuna no Yabou deserves praise for pulling it off, even I am satisfied of the pacing and I am very critical on Light Novel adaptations too.

[aigomorla]

Originally Posted by Athena

BTW, just me or the pacing for the adaptation of this series is quick, considering the studio in charge?

12 episodes to work with...
i wouldnt blame them..

This series and hagure is starting to get good / better then campione and SAO.
However maybe its because ive read the later 2, and came to the conclusion that they butchered 2 of my favorate LN's in 3 episodes!

[larethian]

Seriously, you guys don't understand what the word 'butcher' means until you've really watched thoroughly butchered LN adaptations *shakes head*

And this a GA publication we are talking about, I seriously doubt that there will be any of the important girls dying (I could be wrong though).

[Avrorrange]

Originally Posted by ReaperxKingx

It really does seem that way, but at least it is not horrible pacing like Campione! Almost every anime adaptation is like that, especially ones where the main characters is having too many thoughts in his head in the course of the Light Novel like Sagara. Oda Nobuna no Yabou deserves praise for pulling it off, even I am satisfied of the pacing and I am very critical on Light Novel adaptations too.

Actually, the studio changed a number of things in oda Nobuna no Yabou. For example, Juubei doesn't join the crew until they Yoshiteru Ashikaga flees Kyoto. More importantly, if I remember correctly, Saru and co. infiltrated Castle Inabayama to capture it instead of defeating and capturing Dosan's son on open field to defeat the Saito clan.

[NoirX]

Originally Posted by ReaperxKingx

It really does seem that way, but at least it is not horrible pacing like Campione! Almost every anime adaptation is like that, especially ones where the main characters is having too many thoughts in his head in the course of the Light Novel like Sagara. Oda Nobuna no Yabou deserves praise for pulling it off, even I am satisfied of the pacing and I am very critical on Light Novel adaptations too.

Also if you see it from anime-only viewers point of view, the pacing is quite nice as it doesn't omitted the important details that first-time viewers needed. All in all, the pacing and detail managing is good.

[ReaperxKingx]

Originally Posted by darthfanta

Actually, the studio changed a number of things in oda Nobuna no Yabou. For example, Juubei doesn't join the crew until they Yoshiteru Ashikaga flees Kyoto. More importantly, if I remember correctly, Saru and co. infiltrated Castle Inabayama to capture it instead of defeating and capturing Dosan's son on open field to defeat the Saito clan.

Those events alone would take a number of episodes, the adaptation is limited to 12 episodes. They got to work what they got, but they are doing a good job at making it very appealing to watch despite anime these days working on budgets entirely.

[aigomorla]

Originally Posted by ReaperxKingx

Those events alone would take a number of episodes, the adaptation is limited to 12 episodes. They got to work what they got, but they are doing a good job at making it very appealing to watch despite anime these days working on budgets.

yeah but there also isnt enough in translation for us to do an accurate comparison.

i mean just reading the first 2 chapters, makes me want to wait for the anime to finish b4 i start reading.

Because I KNOW the moment i start reading the chapters, im gonna be like

WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHY DID THEY SKIP THAT!!!!!!

[ReaperxKingx]

I already read both the chapters, Akuma done excellent work and I enjoyed at. Normally I criticize anime adaptions of Light Novel because it feels off with the Light Novel like a separate entity. With Oda Nobuna no Yabou, sure there are notable differences but the plot and story line still feels like the Light Novel.

[relentlessflame]

I deleted about 20 posts that were going too far off-topic talking about other franchises for irrelevant off-topic reasons and a translation poll on another website. Please try to use this thread to talk about this light novel proper. If you want to relevant on-topic comparisons, please use spoiler tags that clearly indicate the show/franchise you are comparing to. Quasi-related conversations can occur on the Social Group, if you wish. Thanks for your understanding.

[larethian]

If my memory serves me right, through my quick scan, a number of events were changed and reordered. Like Hanbei didn't join Saru initially. It was later after the one-night castle thing. There were also quite a number of things. But since I scanned it in under an hour and it was more than 2 days ago, I don't quite remember shit about it.

And did that diversion take place? I really can't remember, but I thought Nobuna's reinforcements were an unexpected thing? No matter, since I only scanned it.

[ReaperxKingx]

Originally Posted by larethian

If my memory serves me right, through my quick scan, a number of events were changed and reordered. Like Hanbei didn't join Saru initially. It was later after the one-night castle thing. There were also quite a number of things. But since I scanned it in under an hour and it was more than 2 days ago, I don't quite remember shit about it.

And did that diversion take place? I really can't remember, but I thought Nobuna's reinforcements were an unexpected thing? No matter, since I only scanned it.

Some stuff are changed and not added due to the limit of 12 episodes. Wonder why 12 is the norm these days for anime? It is quite a shame some of the Light Novel parts didn't go in. I would love to watch the introduction of Nobuna and Sagara from the Light Novel version. It was....... I don't use this phrase often but incredible.

[NoirX]

Originally Posted by larethian

If my memory serves me right, through my quick scan, a number of events were changed and reordered. Like Hanbei didn't join Saru initially. It was later after the one-night castle thing. There were also quite a number of things. But since I scanned it in under an hour and it was more than 2 days ago, I don't quite remember shit about it.

And did that diversion take place? I really can't remember, but I thought Nobuna's reinforcements were an unexpected thing? No matter, since I only scanned it.

Yes the diversion thing took place

Originally Posted by ReaperXKing

Some stuff are changed and not added due to the limit of 12 episodes. Wonder why 12 is the norm these days for anime? It is quite a shame some of the Light Novel parts didn't go in. I would love to watch the introduction of Nobuna and Sagara from the Light Novel version. It was....... I don't use this phrase often but incredible.

It's because it's an anime adaptation. If it's an original anime or manga based one it mostly span 25 episodes

[ReaperxKingx]

Originally Posted by NoirX

Yes the diversion thing took place



It's because it's an anime adaptation. If it's an original anime or manga based one it mostly span 25 episodes

Would that be so bad, I mean other anime gotten that amount but many did not really showcase what the Light Novel is capable of. I say Oda Nobuna no Yabou deserves it, its story and plot is one of the best I ever read and I am usually modest.

[Kirito]

Make sense considering that we're building more into the story and there's still some things that can be explored if given the proper time and care. I know it's based on production value but anime with a great story such as this one deserves more chances to expand the story and at the same time keep the pace of the original media in check.